Deceiving. Ordered a medium sundae. Says it includes 1 topping, cherry, whipped cream…read more Receipt shows 1.50 added for my topping of choice (hot fudge) Same thing with my boyfriend's sundae, charged 1.50 for rainbow jimmies That's an extra 3 dollars for our order alone, if this happens for every order, that ADDS UP

Since my last visit there have been only positive changes! They no longer have a minimum charge…read morefor credit cards and now they accept ApplePay too. Fellow Yelper Dee M and I decided that Ice Cream for Lunch is now a thing when you're on vacation, so we headed over there after a morning of shopping in downtown Cape May. She got a milkshake and I got the 'Smores Sundae. Both were delicious, generous portions, creamy and just the right bout of sweet. Staff were friendly and worked quickly. They were slightly amused at my sheer delight in being able to use Apple Pay. It's the little things, people. Love this old school ice cream parlor, and hope they have many more successful years.

I don't love pies or non-chocolate chip cookies but this ice cream sandwich was a winner for me. No…read moretraditional pies involved (I don't think!). I ordered one of their classics, the caramel + brownie. It was the perfect chocolate to vanilla ratio. The brownie chunks and caramel bits were perfectly placed. I really didn't think I was going to enjoy the vessel, but I did...very much. A chocolate chip cookie on both ends would have been too much here. Peace Pie's biscuit like cookie had a great snap and went very well with the filling. $8 well spent. P.s. peace pies are pre made and non-customizable but they have so many options, you surely will find one you like! Loved their cute mini store front on Carpenters!

A small ice cream shop located off the closed street mall in Cape May. Stopped here after dinner…read moreand tried three ice cream sandwiches. We tried the chocolate mint, peanut butter cookie dough, and coconut cream sandwiches. We then enjoyed them sitting in the mall and they were all very good. The shortbread cookie was great in the coconut cream. The service was quick, pretty sure they are pre made. If you're in the mall area these were great. Will be back to try other options.

My favorite soft serve ice cream at the beach! The line is…read moremoving quickly. Servers are expedient! Chocolate and vanilla swirl in a cake cone!

Okay the ice cream itself is good. But something I'm APPALLED by is the chocolate on top. It's not…read moresweet at all. It doesn't crunch when you bite it. It's just like weird candle wax and it's not appetizing. Don't get your ice cream dipped in chocolate..

I had Fine Fellows Creamery bookmarked for a few years now, well before I ever made any plans to…read morevisit Cape May. However, I always knew I would be back, and when I did I wanted to check this place out. I love ice cream, and while they can be a dime-a-dozen on the Jersey Shore, FFC stood out with their great Yelp reviews and the high visibility of its owners across social media. I had finished dinner and was looking for dessert, so I thought this was the perfect opportunity to stop in for some ice cream. FFC is located on Beach Ave, right in the heart of one of the main drags in Cape May (also, conveniently around the corner from where I was staying). The decor is super fun - the entire space is decked out in Pride decor, with colorful ice cream aesthetics on the walls and an overall upbeat vibe. FFC serves Bassetts Ice Cream, I'm not familiar with the brand but apparently their cream content is higher than average so how bad can that be? They have several flavors to choose from, as well as a number of toppings, sundae combinations, and milkshakes. I decided to go with Moose Tracks in a cone - I was able to choose the number of scoops I wanted (I got two), as well as the type of cone I wanted. The ice cream was really good - super creamy with lots of peanut butter cups and fudge; the moose were stampeding. Service was also great - I was taken care of promptly and everyone I interacted with was very friendly. Overall, this was a yes - with the plethora of ice cream spots in the area, FFC stands out by serving high quality product in a fun and inviting atmosphere. I would definitely return the next time I find myself in Cape May.

Fine Fellows used to be my favorite ice cream place in town. It had that personal feel with the…read moreowners often working behind the counter, but now it's like every other place. I'm not sure if it's because there are so many people working there or because it's so expensive. Two small cups of ice cream were $15+. I asked for a unique flavor and tried their matcha which was good, but overall it's lost its Cape May charm. There are a lot of places to get ice cream, but this place doesn't set itself apart anymore.

We stood in a long line, but it was worth it! An abundance of options, very clean establishment.read more

When there is a line out the door on a hot summer night for an ice cream spot you get on the line &…read morewait -- cause you know it's worth it! And we were right, a massive assortment of flavors & quite the substantial size cup -- all in all a perfect choice!

Very friendly staff, the ice cream was great. Been going here for years and hope other people can…read moreexperience the joy of coming here as much as me. The owner was fantastic and never takes a day off, has lots of jokes and very friendly with families.

The ice cream is amazing here and the owner is so nice. Right around the corner from our favorite…read moreItalian restaurant in Cape May. So after dinner we stroll on by have our dessert. Oh and they have gluten free ice cream cones. Great flavors.

Good ice cream not great ice cream. Ube flavor is…read moredifferent. Their methodology in serving and paying is very clunky. They need to keep one person at the register, and let the rest scoop ice cream. (Maybe 2 registers during peak season) This would cut down on lines and touching ice cream and money by the same person! (Cross contamination concerns!)

The Lavender Honey Ice cream was fresh and tasty. The lavender flavor was very refreshing…read more They will also let you sample flavors before ordering. The interior is a take on an old fashioned ice cream parlor. Service quick and efficient. Also samples the Barn flavor and it was definitely different.

I think about the mint/chocolate soft serve daily. Staff was friendly and location was great!read more

So good! My favorites are the orange/vanilla swirl and coffee (when they have it) with vanilla…read more It's expensive but so creamy and worth it !

It was a very hot day visiting Cape May in May…read more Ordered a Blendini with Chocolate Custard and Chocolate ice with almond toffee crunch. It was too sweet for me. But it was a nice refreshing dessert.

While I normally love bringing my kid to get Rita's closer to home, my experience at this franchise…read morewas the worst. The owner decided to decried my 5 yr old about the difference between gelato and gelati. He was scared to even finish his order!