Outstanding service Extremely helpful and friendly Expertly repaired watch Cannot say enough good things !! read more

They're the best! So sweet and smart and have given me the best prices for my gold and silver.

Everyone here is amazing, I worked with Rich on creating an engagement ring for my now fiancee and her and I were beyond stunned at how perfect and amazing the ring came out. The craftsmanship and care that went into it you will not find anywhere else! read more

I have ALOT of experience with many jewelers on Long Island and I am happy I found Nick, Rich ,Sal and Nicole. They all want to make you happy . They all are so knowledgeable and accommodating. Never an attitude. No job too small or large. They won't take advantage of you! They gave me beautiful flowers one day from their garden. Thank you for your kindness R &S Diamond Exchage Jeanette K read more

Look, many people are going to search for their jeweler. Speaking from my experience, the owner and his family are fantastic at what they do. I had a very pleasant and honest conversation with them. I was treated poorly by other jewelers in the past. So having a place to trust is extremely valuable to me and for the people I recommend places to. Is everyone perfect? Of course not, but certainly most of these negative reviews are not accurate to what is happening here. They are not pushy, in fact they're the opposite and extremely lenient. I purchased a beautiful diamond engagement ring for a fantastic price. My fiancée cannot stop looking it every day and I couldn't be more grateful. We are going back for our wedding bands soon and all my other future endeavors. This is a generational, professional establishment that I implore you to try out if you're interested. You will not regret it. read more

The gentlemen at R & S Diamond Exchange are wonderful. Every time I come here they are helpful and trustworthy.

We could not ask for better service, prices or care! thank you for everything! Customer service and products unmatched!

This family owned business has been my go to place for jewelry purchases, repairs and to sell no longer wanted items for over 30 years. They take the time needed to educate you thoroughly to ensure you make informed purchase decisions. I highly recommend this business. read more

Boyfriend needed his chain fixed- the owner saw that a small piece where the clasp is connected, just opened a little bit which caused it to break-- he fixed it up in 5 minutes and didn't charge a cent- we offered and he said "on me, merry christmas" no BS, no lies, no conning us into buying a new one or getting it fixed a different way. A+++++ I will be back! read more

I can't speak on what it's like as a buyer here but they offered me $60.00 to buy a white gold diamond engagement ring that was purchased by my ex at Michael Hill in 2016 for $3,000.00 (I have his receipt) and the owner stated he can't imagine anyone would pay that for that and if he did, that my ex got ripped off. He said the reason is the diamond is of poor quality. At another jewelry store that buys jewelry they offered me $40.00 with the reason given that with synthetic diamonds now, apparently real diamonds aren't worth anything anymore. Which is interesting because the same place bought diamond earrings I had off of me for $100.00. There seems to be some kind of script out there to scam people out of their money for selling their engagement rings because they know people are probably eager to get rid of them for emotional/personal reasons. Not cool or right. I can't imagine any alternate reality of anyone buying my engagement ring for anything less than $100.00, the truth is the jeweler would buy it and then turn around and sell it for way, way more, closer to what my ex paid for it 8 years ago ‍ read more

Never had issues until the 'son' spoke to me. Don't bother. Go elsewhere where you don't get treated like you are in a street fight over asking questions. Dealt with the father/owner for years. Never going back. These places are a dime a dozen. read more

Best most honest ever! Had my 35 year plus Diamond ring reset for 1/4 the cost of previous jewelers. Honest and professional! Was not nervous about leaving my Diamond! So so sooooo happy! Thank you for the best service ever! read more

My wife and family have been using Rich Olivo and his family for over 30 years. There will never be a better jeweler than, Richie! Now his sons have taken part in this family business. I have used Dan and he is awesome! Richie, has me on speed dial. I waited 25 years for the watch of my dreams to show up at his store. When he called I felt like a won Lotto! read more

See all

Needed a ring sized and very unhappy with how it came out, its not smooth, uneven and scratched. I've come here in the past and had a much better and helpful experience (from the owner) but never again after the way I was treated by the younger man at the store, making me out to be some liar that doesn't remember the conversation we had. Would never recommend this business to anyone again. ** and now one week later 2 diamonds fell out of my ring. read more

They are amazing! For my 30th Anniversary we had my wedding ring reset in a new setting. Rich sat down with me, gave me plenty of options and the finished product turned out better than invisioned! I would highly recommend them! read more

Very friendly and honest jewelers ! I have purchased and sold gold jewelry to watches with R&S and I am always treated like a family friend. Other Jewelry stores I have used in the past to purchase and sell items I was kinda of mis treated and so where customers in front and behind me . I wish I never used some places and only used R&S , they fixed my jewelry and did it right . Don't be bullied by other Jewelry Shops and told tales , Go to R&S and get quality service, plus I and others love have everyday conversation with their staff , not always business and fun life stories . read more

Great place. After another jewelry shop couldn't handle changing my watch battery, these guys did it no problem, fast and a great price, thanks! read more

These folks are top notch business owners! They were able to help us with some of my mom's jewelry - removing stones from settings in a ring and hand cleaning another ring. They gave their condolences on my mom's passing and wouldn't take a single dollar from us! A true class act. If you want quality products and quality service from local, long-time residents, go here!! You won't be sorry. Thank you R & S!!! read more

I recently sold a Rolex watch to R & S Diamond Exchange. I worked directly with Richard Olivo. What a great experience !! Once we agreed upon a price, Richard ensured the transaction was quick and seamless, and provided great communication throughout the entire process. I would definitely recommend R & S Diamond Exchange and hope to do business with Richard again. Thanks again Richard. read more

Purchased a new Rolex submariner from Rich. The transaction was excellent. No pressure, and Rich went out of his way to accommodate my schedule. The watch was accurately described. I drove from NYCity all the way out to Rocky Point Suffolk County to buy the watch. Took me over an hour each way to get out to him from the city, but the deal Rich gave me was worth the trip. NO disappointment. Everything was as described. Highly recommended. I would buy from him again any day, all good. read more

The guys over at R & S diamond exchange did an excellent job helping my fiancé and I design an engagement ring. They guided us through the process and were honest and just incredibly nice and helpful. The ring came out beautiful. After coming here, we knew we didn't need to look any further and that we were in great hands. read more

Have an Ebel ladies watch that I previously replaced a battery in elsewhere--$80 and took two weeks....went to R&S and they did it while I waited for $7.00 Need I say more?? read more

I have passed by here many times, but stopped in for the first time yesterday to replace a watch battery. The gentleman was very friendly and professional and quickly replaced my watched battery. They have a beautiful collection of cameos and other beautiful pieces. This is my new go to place for professional and friendly service. Highly recommended! read more

Very professional and quality service. Highly recommended! I had to wait a few minutes to have a watch battery replaced and they were very apologetic. I would return again. read more

Been to R & S Diamond Exchange a few times and will go back. Everyone there is always helpful, whether it was for resizing my mom's watch band or fixing other jewelry. Had my engagement ring sized as well & always a pleasant transaction while we're there. read more

overpriced ,old styles diamonds where low quality. pushy psychotic salesmen would never buy from a.place like that read more

My husband and I have been purchasing jewelry from R&S over the past five years for all occasions - Christmas, birthdays, anniversaries, Valentine's Day and most recently our wedding. The staff are all great and friendly, not pushy at all. We have always worked with Danny and highly recommend him. He is a pleasure to work with and will help you find exactly what you are looking for within your budget. He helped my husband pick out my engagement ring and we of course used him for our wedding bands, too (which we love!) read more

I had a unpleasant experience here with selling gold. Owner was rude with an attitude and tried to low ball me..shop around.

My Husband and I have been doing business with R & S for years, The owners are very friendly relilable and will take care of all of your jewelry needs like they have with us. We recommend R & S very highly, we had them resize my wedding rings and they came out perfect we couldn't be happier with the way they came out. R & S are the best!!!! read more