Bennettsville doesn't have many dining options outside of fast food but Pizza Time is an option. It's a typical pizzeria by most standards. The pizza isn't great but it isn't bad either. You place your order at the counter, find yourself a table, and they bring your pizza out to you. They have other options as well such as sandwiches and salads. The people here are nice and for the most part quite efficient. The restaurant gets pretty busy during lunch hour so you might consider ordering ahead. read more

Pizza Time - Small Cheese (10") with sausage and mushrooms. Mediocre at best. - Italian Near Me - Bennettsville, South Carolina

Well for starters, the young lady were asking questions about the menu to, couldn't answer a thing! My friend joked " she just started working right before we walked in" The garlic knots were delicious. Some were fried too hard and had zero cheese in it, but they were very tasty. Not over powering with garlic so that was a plus The pizza (I ordered a house no green peppers, no Italian sausage, no mushrooms) had a good Italian taste. I know you're supposed to wait for your pizza to cool slightly but I couldn't and it was worth it! read more

See all

The owner treats her employees terribly. If customers don't pay for their food because they change their mind, she takes it out the employee's pockets. If a work week doesn't go as planned for her, she holds their pay till it rolls over next week as punishment. She makes the all employees split tips and the cooks make $3 more than the waiters, then keeps half the tips for herself after divided. She physically lays hands on her cooks. She may act sweet and cute to her customers, but this customer really saw her true character and she isn't what she makes herself out to be. read more

I love this place. This is a great lunch spot daily. The service was great the food was excellent and everyone was friendly in this comfortable environment. I would recommend this establishment to everyone. Thank you for your service. read more

Good food prices, restaurants right on the bypass easy in and out. Waitress are friendly

Food was great. Chicken Parm was enough for three people. Mrat sauce was amazing. Take out was fast. She was polite. Kitchen looks clean. Staff was friendly. read more

3/12/19 update Note to business owner. If you don't want bad reviews then provide good service instead of blaming your failures on your customers. I visited today and after a 10 minute wait time to have order taken I walked out. On the way out I asked the owner's son about my wait. "We who work in local businesses only have limited time and we can cannot afford to wait unreasonable amounts of time for service. " - the excuse was we are busy but the restaurant was 2/3 empty. The owner also said if I didn't want to wait 10 minutes to place my order not to come back. He did make a loud spectacle of himself. I'll gladly oblige him and not ever come back. If you don't mind the wait and bad attitude then by all means patronize Pizza Time. read more

See all

Amazing pizza. I ordered the medium House Special ( pepperoni, ground beef, green pepper, onion and mushroom) . Fresh, hot and had an excellent crust. Can't wait to have the second half tomorrow. Topped the dinner with a slice of pecan pie. They even brought it out to our car in the parking lot. Yelpers, there may be another chain pizza place in town but skip it. The real pizza is here with all the charm and personality of a family run restaurant. read more

Have gotten food to go(register was down and had to pay cash so WENT HOME WITH ICE COLD PIZZA) and following time went in to eat. Some nice flavors, little pricey but worth it. read more

Unassuming and bland from the outside, Pizza Time is anything but when it comes to their food. This is the type of place you hope to find when driving through a small town in the evening. Pizza was excellent with a great crust and abundant toppings, the Greek salad is really good; the homemade dressing being the highlight. My favorite by far though was the Super Steak Sub. No hyperbole, this may be the best steak sandwich I've had in years. Perfect crunch on the outside, the right amount of cheese, perfectly grilled veggies and the most flavorful steak you could ask for. If you find yourself in Bennetsville, SC make it a point to stop in and sample this local spot, you won't regret it! read more

Pizza Time - Pizza Time at sunset - Italian Near Me - Bennettsville, South Carolina

Completely changed my mind! Great food and lovely hosts. The prior review was about an uncharacteristically bad night several years ago.

My favorite is the chicken Fettuccine pizza "The Great White". Crispy crust and so beautiful! Yummy! read more

Pizza Time - Chicken Fettuccine "The Great White" Pizza - Italian Near Me - Bennettsville, South Carolina

I was a little hesitant at first but we stopped by on the way to FL and man was I wrong. I ordered the Greek Salad and it was incredible and I don't compliment often. read more

Pizza Time - people sitting at tables in a restaurant - Italian Near Me - Bennettsville, South Carolina

Very good dining choice in Bennettsville, SC. My wife enjoyed her Medierranean salad and I had a tasty chicken parmegan sandwich.

My wife and I eat here all the time. It is one of the better places to eat in town. They have the best pizza in Bennettsville. Definitely recommend this place read more

First time. Casual dining. Staff courteous. Waited approximately 15 minutes or so for meal. No fast food here. My husband got the Mediterranean salad and I got the Gyro... Nice experience. read more

Pizza Time - Inside dining area. - Italian Near Me - Bennettsville, South Carolina

This is the best Italian place around. It's locally owned and operated. Food is fantastic - best pizza I've ever eaten. Subs are right up there with the pizza. Service is good, friendly and prompt. Orders can take a minute or two because it's made to order but well worth the wait. read more

Good little pizza place, got calzone and pizza, which was pretty good. The service was very good and nice servers, went around lunch time place was pretty packed, always a good sign. The only thing was the tables were clean, watched her clean ours, they are jus permanently sticky. The tables need a new clearcoat. Also have take out. read more

Pizza Time - Sittin at a table - Italian Near Me - Bennettsville, South Carolina

See all

I'm giving Pizza Time 5 stars because of their outstanding customer service and there good quality food. I've always been a patron of this place since it opened and to me personally they have the best pizza that cost $5 in town. I've always felt that way. Recently a situation occurred when there was miscommunication invegards to my bank and their system having an issue. They were very calm, understanding, and they worked with me until we got the situation resolved. I want to thank the ladies that were there that day for their help and I would definitely say go to this place. They're very customer service oriented and you will not be disappointed if you were to eat there. read more

Pieces are too high. They have recently jacked their prices up and the food isn't even worth it

Great place for dinner, we had a party of 5 and everyone enjoyed their meal. My girlfriend and I split a large Greek salad, it was very good. I did the baked fettuccine and my girlfriend had the lasagna. One of the people in our party had the large spaghetti, it all he could do to finish it. You won't be disappointed. read more

The pizza is very good but it comes at high price sometimes and when you microwave it the cheese isn't cooked all the way

WOW!! You have got to stop and eat here!!!!!!!!!!!!! If your traveling and go through Bennettsville, SC its worth the time to stop and eat here. They have great Pizza, and Subs! House Dressing is Great! Do yourself and family a favor stop and have Lunch or Dinner with Stan, Dina, Manoli, and the staff at Pizza Time. Relax and enjoy a great meal on your way to the SC, and NC Beaches.......... Don't let the appearance fool you this place is the type you hope to find when traveling. Some of the best food I have ever had. Give them a try I promise you will add Pizza Time to your list of Go To Places. read more

On our way home from the beach, we were looking for a non - chain option for lunch. Thanks to the trusty yelp app, we stumbled upon pizza time. The menu was quite large including many Italian and some greek options. We opted for the lunch special. For $7 each, we got a side salad, drink and choice of personal pizza, 6 inch sub or spaghetti and meatballs. Our food did take a bit of time due to the restaurant being half full with only one server. However, our food was great and the price was unbeatable. A great option if you are in the area. read more

Had lunch with a couple of coworkers. Food is yummy, service not so much. Waited 5+ minutes before anyone even acknowledge us. After order was taken food came out fast and accurate. Waitress never checked on us or refilled our drinks. Noticed several tables around us waiting too long for service Maybe they need more servers. read more

Awesome place! We tried the fried mushrooms and fried ravioli. The mushrooms were slightly overcooked but still good, but the fried ravioli was awesome! The Italian sub was excellent and the turtle pie and Oreo pie were incredible. Definitely coming back to this place. Great experience and great food. read more

The food was ok. Typical cheap Amercan dining. Cheese steak was ok. What really got me was they couldn't add cheese to my kids side of fries. Greek plate had a salad that was about 4 bites and it was $40? No thanks. Glad I'm just passing through. read more

Came here with a coworker from out of town. Rode around for 15 minutes trying to find this place. We called several times and the phone just said busy. Found it next to the Marlboro Inn. Salad was great! Got the lunch special. Steak and cheese sub with curly fries, salad and lemonade for about $8.00! Great deal. It was great! Will definitely stop by again when in town. read more

Pizza Time - Philly cheese steak. - Italian Near Me - Bennettsville, South Carolina

The pizza is great! I regularly get the hamburger steak dinner, most of the time. Everything is good here, I have never had anything bad.

I was very hesitant to come here for many years until a few years ago after so many people telling me how good it is. My husband and I thought we would order a pizza to go since the place looked "just okay" on the outside. But when we picked up the pizza, the place was hoppin! And the aroma was fantastic and the place was packed! The pizza was delicious and, needless to say, we have been several times since that day!! The steak sub is awesome as well along with the pita and wrap sandwiches. The seasoned fries are great, too! The spaghetti with their homemade sauce is a big hit from what I have observed. My husband likes the chicken parmesan! The staff is very friendly! So, I highly recommend this place! Give it a try sometime!! read more

What a wonderful surprise! We stopped on the way to Myrtle Beach coming from Greensboro. The friends we were traveling with knew about this secret place. From the outside appearance and name of the place, you would never stop for a great salad. We are on our way back to Greensboro and have stopped again for the Mediterranean Chicken Salad...7.65....A bargain and not to be missed when traveling thru the area. There are not many good places to eat along the small roads to the beach. :-) We're here at lunch time and they are packed. Always a good sign. read more

We came in and there were hardly any customers in the restaurant. It took 15 minutes to get our drinks and when one of us got the drinks it was only carbonation. It took 10 more minutes to change it because the waitress was flirting with the police sitting at the table beside us. Would not go back. The food was also bad I had spaghetti and it was not good at all!! read more

Best pizza in town! Locally owned for over 20 years by the nicest family around and keeps getting better. Check out the calzone or pesto pizza! And don't forget your brownie sunday!!! read more

Got the 12" steak deluxe and the curly fries. They give a lot of food for the money. Everything was very good and the staff work very hard! Lunchtime is very busy! read more

Just moved back to the area and glad to see this place still here. The food is still as good as I remember.

Food is good unfortunately service is poor! Have been there approx 4 times got decent service once. On one occasion server took orders and did not return with drinks for over 10 minutes. Last visit this past week after waiting for 10 minutes with no service then the server came to table next to us that came in 5 minutes after us took there order and never acknowledged our group. We left at this point and went to Southern Delights on same street. Ordered and had drinks delivered in less than 5 minutes. Owner and staff are more focused on take out orders than customers in restaurant. read more