My friend who lives out this way suggested we stop here for dinner on our way back from NC to VA…read more I'm so glad we did. It's right off 58 and was great! It's kinda a little hole in the wall type of restaurant- not the nicest seats, old decor etc... but the food was yummy! We were told to sit anywhere, which we loved picking our spots. We had the manager as our server, and she was just lovely! She was clearly in a hurry, but she was super cool & funny. The food was great, but I feel like some shortcuts were taken- like the Greek salad & Greek spaghetti had sliced black olives, as opposed to Kalamata olives. I'm always disappointed when I get those, although I still really like them. The Gaelic bread looked bland and meh, but it was very tasty. Not a large beer selection, which made it easy to drink water. I will definitely return when making my way back to the 757 from the 910.

I came here with 28 others for dinner. They set up a large table for us along the back wall and a…read morefew had to sit in the booth nearby. Our waitress , "Jay" was AWESOME! So many people at once and she handed it like a pro. A smile never left her pretty face and she was so knowledgeable about the menu and handled some special orders. I had cannelloni and a side salad with the best homemade dressing !! I am picky about my Italian "gravy " and this place does it right!!! We all enjoyed our meal and the service. Would highly recommend!

Great customer service even greater Calzones nice atmosphere and dessert too eat ready to eat…read moreagain soon.

No funny business. "Get your pie and get going" was the vibe I felt and I'm here for it. Pizza gets…read morethe job done for a neighborhood pie. The guys who wore no clothing besides a pair of overalls...that's what small town pizza people are about. Quiet hole in the wall neighborhood favorite.

The service is amazing and the people are great my whole family is excited to go here every time…read moretheir food is always good and the dining experience is very warm and rustic. Will always return for more.

I have eaten here a few times and the pizza's are good with more toppings than some other places…read moreput on the pizza around the area. I have also had the Philly steak sub which is good. This is a family business and the owner is friendly and on site.

This establishment has closed it is now a Mexican restaurant, I was kinda of disappointed but this…read moreplace is just starting out so they are pouring heart and soul into the food and it shows

I ordered a ham and cheese Calzone - it was amazing. Probably the best I have had in a long time…read more Now, I am originally from the NY/NJ area so I have experienced good Italian food, and this was great. The sauce was excellent and I got a medium which was huge - easily enough for two people. I can't imaging how big the large it. I suspect that the pizza and other menu items are also good.

This location receives a lot of criticism. I have eaten here several times and not had a bad…read moreexperience. The restaurant is clean, the workers are busy doing their job and hate that people complain and start drama about things that contradict my experience.

I called to place an order for pick up at a later time at 1:18. Never had the opportunity to select…read morewhen I wanted to come pick up the order, they said it would be ready in 15 minutes then disconnected the call at 1:22. I immediately called back to try to speak with someone. Was left in hold for 25 mins, an entire commute time to my appointment. Never got anybody hung up the phone tried calling back to cancel the order and was IMMEDIATELY sent to someone. They didn't try to correct the problem, did not apologize for anything, just piss poor service. Will be getting pizzas else where for my organization in the future.

The food is not bad, and the service is always good; the ambiance is good. We do not go to the…read morerestaurant often, because they are a bit pricey for us. Many of the townspeople love Napoli's.

Fast service, they have mouth watering food that is more than plenty. It feels like a home cooked…read moremeal you don't have to cook.

I was craving a white pizza, so I decided to try Amici's. it was absolutely amazing. exactly what I…read morewanted. great taste and realy easy to place a pick up order

First time here at the pizza is amazing! We had three different pizzas:…read more Meat lovers- 8/10 Pepperoni- 9/10 Cheese- 9 Greek salad 8 We ordered to go but they nice over the phone. You can tell they were busy but they were really professional and let us know about their special

10/10 Service, food & environment! Some of the best pasta…read moreand garlic knots i've had since being in little italy back in new york!! Amazing restaurant!!!

(March 2026) During…read moreour Historic Triangle visit, my wife and I stopped here for dinner. It was close to our hotel, and we didn't want to drive far. We started out splitting the Caesar salad ($11 plus $3 extra for them to split it) and garlic knots. We didn't know we were going to also get garlic knots. After that, we split a 12" Margherita pizza ($18) and a side of meatballs (which comes in two for $8). My two complaints were (1) that the meatballs came out the same time as the pizza, so the meatballs were no longer hot. (2) the $1.95 additional service fee at the end. Otherwise, our dinner was good, and the service was great.

Gerry's is no longer its name. It has had a new owner for more than a year. Now called Froggies…read more Still good pizza.

TL;DR: Restaurants in Cape Charles do NOT do takeout, but Gerry's does…read more When a family wedding brought us to Cape Charles, we learned an extremely interesting lesson: it's near impossible to find takeout in the town. The restaurants just do not do it. After calling several places closer to us, we eventually landed on Gerry's. It was difficult to find their menu online (much like the rest of Cape Charles). Gerry's is located right outside of the main drag of Cape Charles (I think) and the location is definitely easy to miss if you are driving at night. The building really sits on its own. Using the to-go window only (apparently they don't allow people inside right now) we picked up two sandwiches and a pizza. We were honestly just so thrilled to find a place in Cape Charles to get dinner that didn't require us to dine-in, especially after a super long car ride. I really enjoyed our shrimp pizza, which we ordered with white sauce. It comes with fresh mozzarella and garlic and is a really different type of pizza to order. We had it in the fridge for leftovers for days. It heated up surprisingly well. The gals working at Gerry's were nice and helpful and I think for the people that live here this is a solid local watering hole for pizza.