I ordered a 16 inch pepperoni and was excited about trying a pie from Pizza Cafe. Not sure what happened but there was definitely something off with the cheese. It appeared to be congealed, kind of lumpy which should not happen to a pizza. Plus the pie was undercooked. I've read numerous reviews of Pizza Cafe and they were very mixed but we wanted to support a local business. Unfortunately, we will probably be taking our business elsewhere read more

Jean's Pizza Cafe with OPEN MIC NIGHT was lots of fun. Great Burrito too..... ;). The pizza is outstanding. The help & the crowd were lively. The desserts are a must try! read more

Loved the pizza here. parking was tough, but the food and service was awesome. We went on a Thursday night and it was "open Mic" night. Crowded and super loud. The staff bent over backwards to get us seated and comfortable, but I am to old for that. The other times we went, it was awesome. read more

Little gem in Howard City. Good food, with some experimental. They love blending flavors you wouldn't think would work, but here we are talking about them. read more

If you enjoy not knowing what you're going to get, then this place is for you! Sometimes it is great! Sometimes you'll get a completely raw pizza, or a pizza that has been dumped into a pile in the box. And they'll tell you they'll take care of you the next time you order, but they won't. More bad pizzas than good for us, but it's the best option in town. If you take a chance, def skip the bread sticks - they're absolutely terrible 100 percent of the time. read more

We ordered pizza from here the other night and it was ok. Not the best, not the worst. The cheesy breadsticks were not good. The dough didn't seem fully cooked and didn't taste the best. Definitely used to be so much better years ago. I think they are pretty comparable to BC Pizza with the quailty. read more

Place was great! Excellent handmade pizza, lovely staff, and very accommodating. I came through on a bike trip and was by far the best place to sit, relax and cool down in the shade. They even let us put the bikes inside! read more

Pizza Cafe - Pretty paintings, some on sale even! - Pizza Near Me - Howard City, Michigan

We ordered pizzas and cheese breadsticks last night for a large crowd while on vacation. It arrived earlier than they estimated, it was piping hot and delicious! Also, our delivery girl was so sweet I only wish I knew her name. Thanks for the amazing service!! read more

Great food, Sandwich and flatbread exceptional. Service was great. For a quick bite a must stop. read more

Ordered here a week or so back and it was great food, got half pepperoni and half sausage extra cheese and onion i will say the pepperoni side was just fine but the sausage ohhh my it took the pie to a whole different level and let's say i was impressed, it was a real good high quality sausage and the sweet onions just brought so much flavor, also had the bread sticks too which had a nice doughy taste to them would def recommend and would def come back if i was in the area again read more

Honestly torn. Service is so much better than BC, but their pizza tastes like chuckee cheese pizza :/ once again, their customer service is phenomenal and they truly are very kind. read more

One star is giving credit since they switches owners and I no longer work there. I could be harsh cuz I used to work there, but honestly I go to town and see people that used to come in when I worked there and tell me how bad it's gotten. N regulars of 10 years no longer order. I order here n there to see n it's not the quality it used to be with old owner nor when I still worked there. Sad to see a business that was well liked and loved with great food and people go so far down hill. It's not a good thing to hear people down this place because I used to represent it just glad I don't any more. Long wait time on a day that's not busy n then 30 min late on top of that. Pay 40$ for a small and one large n it's not great is dry n uncooked it's a waste. read more

Pizza Cafe - Ordered extra sauce n toppings were missing off the deluxe dough uncooked in middle. - Pizza Near Me - Howard City, Michigan

Ok tonight we ordered some subs off the menu and they were OK not as good as we've had in the past. First off they messed up the one my wife ordered, wrong toppings. Then none of them were cooked enough, I hope this was just a error due to new help or something, very disappointing. I really don't wanna have to do the Subway thing instead read more

Ordered pizza to go and were given an exact time for being ready...friendly staff... pizza was very tasty...pepperoni was tasty but not greasy...our toppings were plenty...crust was not burnt and not too much in proportion to the pizza...would definitely get it again! read more

See all

The Pizza Cafe has a lovely website and polite staff. Their specialty pizzas are impressive and well-made. Our household favorite is the Alfredo pizza. Their delivery time is normal for a pizza place if not a little longer, but their pizzas are fancier than normal pizza so it's understandable. I would highly recommend them over the other local pizza place - BC Pizza. Order Pizza Cafe instead. You won't regret it. read more

A family business for many years it recently changed owners but they kept all the same recipes just added a few of their own. Always friendly service the owner actually comes out and sits and talks to the cusomters to get to know them. Prices are competitve and the food is good. read more

This is the best pizza in the area. The new owner uses high quality ingredients. We mostly get take out but many nights they have live music and open mic which is fun to experience. read more

Edible, but just barely so. If the nice large lady isn't working, then get out. The kids nor the owner seem to care about continuous quality. Spotty and hit-or-miss. Menu is exactly what one expects in a small town restaurant called Pizza Time. I had a calzone that i customized with andouille, chicken, green peppers and you're choice of sauce on the side, i chose pesto. The andouille had a nice spicy taste, but the pesto was from a jar and lacked the freshness one associates with the olive oil based sauce. It was okay for five bucks, but nothing i couldn't live without. read more

Very delicious. Lots of cheeze...just how I like it. Had the deluxe and the toppings were very plentiful and tasty. Loved the homemade look and taste as compared to a "franchise" pizza. We will be back. read more

The food was amazing! My wife and I stopped in for lunch, the waitress, Deb, was the cook and she did an amazing job! Service was fast and friendly. Food is priced reasonably as well. read more

There are many pizza places in Howard City but this is the only one that's good and delivers. They never mess my order up witch trust me seems to be an impossible task around here, I've read other reviews and have to point out I've never had a problem with staff if you treat them with respect they respect you I always order a large pepperoni pizza with green peppers always perfect and the arcade games and pool are fun while waiting just beware the Friday rush! Long wait times bit its worth it. read more

Just like the pic shows Zero sauce Zero flavor. Sad the renovations look nice but this ship is taking on water before even getting out of dock! Canned mushrooms on pizza equals gross. The moisture soaks into the pie as it cooks out the saline. It's official you can't buy a decent pie in the 49329! Avoid and get a supermarket frozen pizza. read more