Ever have 16 friends wanting pizza and no one has a car?!? Yah, me too! I called Carleo's, ordered…read morea bunch of pizzas for delivery at a certain time. They totally delivered on time and with all the things, plates, napkins and packets of cheese/spices. The pizza was spot on perfect. The delivery was on time and all of my 16 friends, loved the pizza party. I have also had their pastas... which I totally recommend:) When you go inside there are maybe 3 2-tops, and a super busy shop. I like to order and take it to wherever I am.

My daughter and I were visiting friends in Emmitsburg. We stopped in for some pizza at the…read moresuggestion of our friend Dale. The pizza was amazing. The gentleman who took our order at the counter was very friendly. The place itself is small, but I found it charming and welcoming. If you stop in this beautiful historical town , you must put this on your list. Well worth the visit.

YUM!! Loved that it is a family-owned business, two brothers!…read more We stopped after mass and tour of St. Elizabeth Ann Seton's Basilica and Shrine. A spiritual haven! We were fortunate to come upon this wonderful pizza place on the main street in Emmitsburg! They have parking in the back and we witnessed people walking out carrying two-three boxes of pizza to their cars. They said it was the best! Well, they were right!! We ordered a large pie with mushrooms and onion. Fresh mushrooms (not canned) and plentiful. The sauce and cheese were delish! Nice thin crust (they also have Sicilian and other dishes and subs). The service by Justin was top notch and very friendly. We will DEFINITELY be back as we travel from PA back and forth to visit our family. Sorry we forgot to take a picture, it smelled so delicious, we dove right in!!

The pizza here was very good but there was just way too much grease. Each slice you had to hold up…read morestraight down to let the grease drip off. The service here was great though I only saw two guys, assuming there was more in the back kitchen though. The server was taking care of many different tables all at once while also maintaining the food orders and being the hostess. I liked the vibe of here but it wasn't anything crazy. A good quick spot to stop in for a bite to eat in Emittsburg

This review is based mainly on decor and a great staff. And a promising appetizer. I was in this…read morearea briefly over a weekend and learned about this place on the Roadside America app because there is a taxidermied lion (!!) in the dining room. We didn't have time to have a meal, but we had to stop in and admire the Lion-themed interior. But the small wafting from the kitchen made us get garlic knots for the drive home. So the decor is a 10/10...and so are those knots. They were amazing - great dough, amazing amount of garlic and a phenomenal garlic knot all around. We were a far distance away before we ate them and were disappointed we didn't get more. Next time for sure!

Well, I've only been driving by Pizza Leone for the past 12 years or so before trying it and I'm…read moresorry that I waited so long. We were in the area for work and the place at the top of the hill that I used to go to closed, however, the handy yelp app suggested Pizza Leone. When I pulled up, I remember having driven by many, many times but it never looked open -- and didn't today, either. But it was! This is a family-owned shop and two brothers and a sister, at least, were working. The young man who took our order was beyond friendly and we loved meeting him and having him take our order and then bring out our order. We got italian subs, an order of fries, and a small pizza. Everything was delicious! I promised I'd be back again but our work concluded so I may not be back for a while but I'll remember to visit when I am. Thanks for a great meal, prepared quickly, and especially for the wonderful service.

I can not tell you the last time I was here. However I just moved less than a mile from this place…read more Today I ordered a pizza steak sub. The value was good. And the flavor was above average. Service was friendly and cheerful. I would definitely recommend this place. Is the best in my driving range. Maybe not. But it beats some local competition.

Great please. Best pan pizza around. People that work there are always friendly and helpfulread more

The Slices & Portion Size The slices are notably small and…read morenarrow--a detail where the deal loses points. While $7.75 sounds decent on paper for two slices and a drink, the modest portion size leaves a lot to be desired if you're looking for a genuinely filling meal. The slices offer a classic, well-browned mozzarella top with visible caramelized spots and decent cheese pull. The crust has a firm, golden edge that supports the toppings well without flopping, though the thin, small footprint makes quick work of both slices. A straightforward, traditional combination of sweet tomato sauce and salty browned mozzarella--classic neighborhood slice flavor, just in a skimpy portion.

First night in Gettysburg and ordered pizza from here. Very good pizza, a bit greasy but not bad at…read moreall! Good flavor and did amazing with extra cheese. We did delivery and it was quick and easy! Definitely recommend. Will say Lg pizza was a little smaller than expected.

Ordered hamburger bacon and Jalapeno. Got home it was pepperoni and jalapeño. Charged me at the…read moreregister for the pizza I ordered, so the knew what I ordered. Not happy

Food and service excellent. Hunting season starts getting cheese stk with gravy fries twice a week .read more

What can be said about Brothers Pizza that has not already been stated…read more We enjoy stopping in here for lunch when we both have the time and the staff is just amazing, friendly and attentive . The food is always consistent and very much well prepared if you have specific requests . The inside is always clean. The tables are wiped clean and it's very presentable. .

As always, Brothers Pizza is our "go to" restaurant for lunch or dinner!!! I absolutely love…read moretheir tossed salad with house dressing, a simple salad, but it is so good with a slice of pizza! My husband loves Italian subs and always asks to have his "oven baked." The service is always great, always accommodating and the food is always freshly prepared and served promptly. Brothers is a casual restaurant, very comfortable with outstanding food!!!!

Food was reheated like Chucky cheese pizza. It looked like they had it stuck in a fridge for a…read morecouple of days and put that thing in the oven as if it was fresh. Thanks but no thanks. If I could get a refund I so would.

Wow, Infinitos Pizza has lost its touch, Took my family there today around 4:30ish, pizzas were…read moresitting in the bake lights so long it looked like jerky all dried up and nasty. When asked if they could make some new ones, staff acted like it was a chore to do. I remember when fresh pizzas were ready they would holler out what just came up. Today silence, Had to go up and check for ourselves. All I can say is don't waste your time and money at Infinitos anymore, you'll be disappointed .