We order from here several times a month. With all the pizza places here in Sammamish, this is our favorite. The pizza is good and we like their Greek salad too. Their prices are a lot better than a lot of the other ones around here too. The wait has been longer now so add extra time when picking up your pizza. Also good to check your pizza- we've had a mistake once but not a big deal. When we make pizza at home, we buy their dough too. read more

One bite, everyone knows the rules. Came across this pizza joint and I heard a lot of great things. Ordered a Large Cheese with a side house salad. The pizza is okay, the salad actually was my favorite out of the two things I ordered. The pizza has some good flavor to it in the sauce, I just like my crust to be done a little bit more. Maybe I am just used to coal fired pizza a little bit more where the crust has a good char to it and has some crunch. read more

This was our first experience and it was disappointing. The order was wrong on one of the pizzas. They offered to remake the mistake, which had me waiting for another 20 minutes. Meanwhile, the other pizza got cold and the ice and ice cream in the car melted. I tipped prior to this experience and really wanted to take it back. Lesson learned... Pay after you verify the order is correct. Pizza was OK. Not great, not bad. The cold pizza was soggy. No idea if the crust is usually this limp or if it was due to the extra time in the box. Probably smart of them not to comp the pizza, add a free cookie, or offer a coupon. We're not likely coming back. read more

I am a bit torn about this review. I would rank different parts of their business anywhere from 0-5 stars. This review is from my second time getting their pizza take out. We called in around 5:20 and asked if the pizza two pizzas to be ready at 6pm. They assured us that they would be ready. When we showed up at 6, and were told 20-30 more minutes. We came back 30 minutes later, and still had to wait another 6 minutes. That all being said, their pizza is very good. read more

Great neighborhood pizza place. With not many dining options in Sammamish,and a choice of about 5 other pizza places, this is our go to for pizza night. The staff is always friendly,and while a lot of them are younger,I applaud a restaurant to hire at a younger age so teens can get a feel of being in the work place. Not only do they begin to learn the value of money, but also customer service, team work, duties and timelines,etc. My husband's go to pizza is the Meat Feast. It is packed full of meat. I'm less of a meat lover so I tend to go with the Margherita, and as a tip add some garlic baked into it. An item not on the menu is jalapeno cheese bread. So good! Their wings are mighty tasty as well. Dying to try the calzone,so maybe we will get that next. read more

We visited on a Tuesday at 6pm and it wasn't busy. The location is not meant for dine in. There's a couple chairs if you choose to sit and wait for your order. I was asked to wait 10 minutes so I walked around QFC. Service was friendly. I grew up in New York eating meatball calzones so I ordered the meat feast calzone. At $8.99 it's a decent value since it's about a foot long and can be shared for 2 light meals. If I could suggest some improvements, increase the cheeses and put the marinara sauce on the side. In New York, they didn't put it inside so that gooey cheese was the highlight of each bite. And also it was dripping the sauce all over, making it messy to eat. I noticed the hand out menus had cheaper prices so I guess they raised them recently? Overall, a decent calzone. Wish it was a little cheaper and more cheese, but oh well. I'd be curious to try a pizza next time. read more

See all

Extremely disappointed with the last couple pizzas from this pizzeria that used to be the best on the plateau. It's sad, that during this pandemic when we all want to support our local eateries, that Pine Lake Pizza just put a pizza that was clearly burnt (crust was black) in a box. This carry out order was 20 minutes late too which is typical for Pine Lake Pizza lately so I had to wait outside (trying to keep social distance). It was a busy Friday night and this pandemic has put a lot of pressure on small businesses like Pine Lake so you want to give them the benefit of the doubt but the quality of their pies is so noticeably worse each time that they've lost our business. read more

Hope you're not in a hurry or take the time to come pick up when they tell you ""it will be 20 minutes". How about 45 minutes?! Not happy with my experience. Pizza is so, so. read more

This place used to have great pizzas with generous toppings and prompt delivery. I have been patronizing them for 20 years. Something changed. Meagre toppings. Tasteless sauce. Late delivery is also a pattern. Price point is the same. If you are looking for premium quality pizza for a little extra money, this is no longer a useful option. I am switching to a competitor. read more

Well we always use Zeeks and thought maybe I would try Pine Lake Pizzeria for a change. Unfortunately I shouldn't have. I asked for 6pm delivery for Christmas party and the pizza's showed up at 6:41pm. Personally I don't think that's acceptable. I am very easy going, but man sakes that is ridiculous. I can't grade it higher. No phone call or text just to say you are running late? I called the store 5 times and it goes straight to voicemail? Service needs to be better for 3 pizzas at $75....for that price you aren't Dominos... read more

Pleasantly surprised with how delicious the pizza was. I was a bit worried since they had a three star average review but they were excellent in handling my order and getting it on time. I ordered the Margherita and the chicken pesto and both were very tasty. The dough and ingredients were just right and they add a little bit of Italian herbs that give the pizza a great flavor. We are new to the area. Actually this was "move in" day pizza and I think we will be back for more soon read more

I was excited to see a pizza place so close to my kids' Tae Kwon do place. How convenient, right? Wrong! I did like the pizza. It was good. The staff- all polite high school kids. They were great. I have a huge problem with being charged to use my credit card. They had a sign taped to the register, but the boy rang me up on the other side so I didn't even see it. It says they will remove the charge if you ask. I asked what the charge was, because I didn't see the sign and the kid just said "yea it's one of our rules, unfortunately." He didn't offer to take it off. At that point my card already went through. I hope they enjoy the credit card fee they charged me, because they just lost the business of what could have been a weekly customer. read more

Forgettable food. Somewhat pricey. Only have take out or delivery. Our last pizza was super greasy ... probably won't return...

I feel like my taste buds must be paralyzed after reading the reviews of the great tasting crust. The crust texture was delightful but the flavor was similar to sucking on a cotton ball (yes, I did suck on a cotton ball for comparison). There was barely any sauce on my pizza so I had to scrounge around my refrigerator for something to add flavor. I will give this place another try being that the value and customer service is excellent and I am hoping it was an off night for this establishment. The medium pizzas are mammoth so unless you're feeding a tribe, I think a medium will fit your bill. If I don't alter my review then either my taste buds HAVE been irreparably damaged or the pizza still just fills a voided space in my stomach. read more

Sooo..... I'm not one for pizza. But I wanted something that I THOUGHT would be better than Papa Johns and Dominoes.. but unfortunately its all the same crap. This place is not great. The pizza is... ok. the prices suck and way to expensive for what it is.. but in Sammamish I guess a business can get away with that. The Alfredo sauce cheeese pizza was pretty good, but thats just cheese.. can't really mess that up. Sauce sucked, bread was not up to par. Did not at all compare to the pizzas I had in Italy and France.... BTW in France the pizza was wayyy better than Italy. Anyways, I will not be coming back. read more

I didn't like their pizza or cheesy breads. Only reason I am giving 5 stars is because they were generous enough to mail out free medium size pizza coupon without any purchase necessary. Pizza gravy was very bland, had no salt. I can't complain since it was free. I paid for cheesy bread and it wasn't good either. read more

I am surprised to be the first to write a review. This pizzeria is one of the better ones on the Eastside. I drive to the plateau from Issaquah to get their pie. Other than Tutta Bella, Issaquah does not have any good pizza. Flying Pizza seems to think that if they make their pizza weight a ton and add a lot of garlic the pizza will taste better. I know this pizza isn't the best. One gets this pizza because it is close by, reliable in quality, has tasty ingedients and the folks there are friendly. read more

This is legit some of the best pizza I've ever had. Their simple pies like the pepperoni and the plain cheese are infinitely better than any I've had, even Pagliacci which I also love. We have gotten the meats feast before which is great but tonight we got the chicken carbonara pizza and it was Incredible! Two thumbs up and props that it's a local business super close to my house! read more

By far the best pizza place on the east side, everything was fresh from tomato's to green peppers.. love this place and my favorite take out pizza place read more

I have to say I am a little picky about pizza but this one was highly disappointing. The crust like a cracker and over done. There was hardly any sauce and was was on it was way too sweet. Toppings? They were fine when you could find them and if you like cheese... pass on this pizza. Also we were the only people at the truck and it somehow took 25 minutes. They did apologize and offer a Coke I will say that. read more

Great pizza for a decent price. Crust is very flavorful and toppings are fresh. Cheesey bread bread is also awesome! Best I have had. Also service was really fast. read more

Pine Lake Pizzeria - a sign for the restaurant - Italian Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

Long time customer; one or two pizza nights a month going back to the days it was called Tony Maroni's. Always loved it (obviously) until last night. The only taste was in the toppings; the pie itself was dry, seemingly devoid of sauce and cheese and without any flavor. Honestly, it was like eating toppings on the cardboard box the pie came in. Which, come to think of it, might have been better. I think the lowest blow came from my wife who said that a pie at a work party that came from Papa Johns was far superior. Ouch. I genuinely hope this was just a really bad, off night and not a real change in how things are done there. read more

I ordered my pizza two hours ago. It still hasn't arrived. I called and called and called and no one would answer so then I had to drive up there to check on my order. I told them that no one was answering their phones and they said they had to turn their phones off??!!?? Then they checked on my pizza and said it would be done in 8 minutes. No apology. Nothing. Now I'm sitting here waiting, starving and angry .Will not order from here again. read more

Best pizza on the plateau by far. The staff is friendly and it's convenient to the home.

May be the best "simple" pepperoni pizza in Washington. I will be a regular. Now yelp is making me write more because they say my review is too short. It feels like High School all over again read more

This place is so weird. The quality of ingredients from the 2 times we've ordered have been great. Fresh mushrooms, herby delicious pesto, fresh sauce, etc. The actual pizza crust however is just not good. It's bland & seriously lacking any flavor or pizazz. Even the cheese doesn't have that salty bite or ooey gooey goodness you usually get on a pizza. I want to like them. I want to support local business. But this is just bad. My kids actually said it was missing the salt & grease that they normally get with pizza. Yea, salt & grease is bad on the daily. But for the occasional pizza fix, they miss the mark. read more

I'm not particular about pizza so much but my girlfriend is, I asked her what in particular was the issue, she said It was a "hot circle of garbage" . I didn't think it was great or anything, was certainly expensive for what it was... meh, they employ people and its probably not poison, I don't have an issue with them. read more

We're a big fan of Pine Lake Pizzeria. Although I feel it's a bit on the pricey side for pizza, I have to say, it's our favorite pizza joint around here. The crust and sauce is really what makes this top notch. We live outside the delivery zone, so we drive up to the plateau from Issaquah. If you like Pagliacci Pizza, then you'll like Pine Lake. read more

We have just moved to the area and have tried every pizza place in town, trying to find our "go-to" pizza place. This place takes first place. I like my pizza to be balanced, not too much crust, not too many toppings, not too much sauce... Crust was on the thin side but not like cracker crusts. It was cooked thoroughly and had a nice crunch with a soft interior. The sauce was a tad sweet but not over powering. The toppings were fresh and plentiful. I placed the order to go and it was ready in 20 minutes. The service was good and the gentleman that took my order was friendly. We will be back! :) read more

A truly decent pizza, even with the scarcity of choices here in Sammamish. I can't stand the super doughy sweet Papa John's pizza so I figured almost anything would be better, but Pine Lake's pizzas way exceeded my expectations. The crust is chewy and somewhere between thick and thin, which is a nice compromise for me and my husband who would go for pan-fried if it weren't for me. The pizzas arrived hot and not soggy. The pepperoni pizza was about average, but the Gourmet Greek was awesome! A good distribution of toppings with no skimping on the artichoke hearts and Kalamata olives. Hallelujah, a pizza place that delivers and that I actually like! read more

I'm a native of New York - lived there the first 21 years of my life -so I know good pizza. Pine Lake tries to be good pizza by saying it's "True Italian Pizza" (and it is the best pizza on the plateau, bar none, which is why I give it 3 stars), but it's lacking in several areas. The major issue I have with the place is the staff. Ordering for delivery is asking for trouble. I've had 2 hour waits when I've been promised only 1 hour, I've been double-charged on my credit card, and I've been told I didn't give a credit card number even though I most certainly did (and the pending list of charges on my account show they charged me). Their delivery pizza is almost always cold and requires reheating. It kind of defeats the purpose of ordering out. That being said, when I order pick up, I have never had long wait times, and I have always gotten a piping hot pizza. As for the actual product? I judge a pizzeria by their cheese pizza - if they can't get the cheese, sauce, and crust right, there's little sense in throwing toppings on it. Pine Lake has good sauce, but their crust is completely tasteless (seriously, it tastes like air), and their cheese tastes and looks like it's lower quality. One other thing - their pizza isn't "well done". If you're from the east you know what I mean - crust can be crispy or it can be chewy - it depends on how long they bake it. This place definitely falls on the chewier side, a tad chewier than I'd like. Overall? I think Pagliacci puts out the best pie in the area, but considering that Pine Lake is the only non-chain pizzeria on the plateau, it's not that bad. My favorite place from home is still Amedeo's in LaGrangeville, NY. read more

I can't understand the bad reviews? We had the combo pizza and it was one of the very best we've ever tried and we come from a very Italian area and we know our pizza. Service was quick and friendly! read more

Huge fan of Pine Lake Pizzeria. In my opinion its a cut above the standard fare at the likes of Dominos and Pizza Hut. The price is a bit higher but its worth it for me. Definitely recommended for those looking for a change of pace from the large pizza chains read more

Owner has no regard for comments by his customers loves to argue, such as when customer complains about pizza is under cooked. Will never return... read more

Pizza is ok at best. Over priced. I just ordered an "extra large" (which is really just a large because as all the other joints they seem to have done away with a small pizza and now call a small a medium and a medium a large and a regular large an extra large which is bs) and an order of garlic bread sticks. The pizza crust tasted like cardboard and the garlic sticks had so much garlic on them we couldnt even eat them. So I wound up paying $35 for a bland pizza and bread sticks that went straight in the garbage read more

Average pizza at best with high premium pricing. Recommend other options.

Great pizza... Andrew runs a great place in Sammamish. Very helpful and supportive of local schools - invovled in the community. Ask him sometime about the pictures of him and Jennifer Lawrence :) read more

We were in the area on several occasions, the girl at front counter was blah not the friendliest and pizza is rather on the expensive side. 6 pack of soda was almost $4. We don't plan on going back anytime soon....it wasn't horrible but it wasn't great. They could stand to brush their pizza crust with some flavor too. read more

Wasn't impressed. I was a walk in, and the kid at the counter told me there was a 10 minute wait, not bad I figured. Well, where he came up with that I have no idea..try 40 minutes later, I finally got my pizza, with no apologies, nothing. Come to find out the crust is horrible and tastes like cardboard. As I waited I watched a few other mess ups happening. The same kid accidently hung up on a guy and then also charged the wrong card for another lady that was on hold waiting to pay. I realize young high school kids need to make money at a job, but don't put them behind the counter without the proper training, much less some basic people and customer service skills! read more

Please PERMANENTLY expand delivery to the Highlands and I'll upgrade to five stars! You're better than Round Table, you're even better than Zeke's, and I can't stand Amante or Flying Pie. Not that my opinions are all that interesting, but if there are others in IH who feel like we do that our pizza delivery options are woefully limited, it might be worth your investment to add driver capacity and reliably provide some better products and service to us over here just to the south. As it is, it feels pretty awkward to call and place an order, only to find out you're doing us a favor by delivering to our home, which Yahoo Maps tells me is 2.08 miles from your shop. And that's when you agree to deliver at all, which you don't always do! read more