I could not be more pleased with my experience. Jake was considerate, kind and so patient with me. He honored my piercing journey in a way that was almost spiritual. This is the only place to get pierced in Toledo. read more

I went in for a full earlobe piercing because at 62 I figured my holes had closed being I hadn't worn an earring since 1980. She said " oh really? Let's try a reopen anyway. 3 seconds later I was wearing a stud earring and she only charged for the reopening saving me a bundle! I was very happy with her and ( forgive me, I forgot his name,)but he was great! ( cute, Kinda reminded me of Radar O'Reilly from MASH). read more

I booked my appointment two weeks before online. The process was easy and I appreciated the text & email reminders. I got my nose pierced I have it pierced before but every time it had gotten irritated and it was not a good experience. I have three other nostril piercings that healed just fine but that one was the worst. Caitlyn did a great job walking me through the process and making sure she didn't go over that scare tissue. It's been 7 months now and it's been perfectly healed with no issues. I had a tiny bump that went away in a week! I love it so much. I'm symmetrical now. Thanks for the great experience! read more

She did a great job with my daith piercing and has made sure I've kept it healthy and clean. She changes all my jewelry for me and always makes sure everything is don't properly and professionally. She's the best! read more

The front desk attendant handled a call from a grouchy customer with amazing patience. I was very impressed. I tipped on a non service purchase just because of this. You've got a great staff and no matter what service I need next, I'll be coming back here. read more

I walked into 4Nineteen Ink a few years ago looking to get a second lobe piercing. Caitlin was the artist I worked with and she was wonderful. She helped me pick a set of earrings that matched the ones I already had, and when marking my ears she went above and beyond by marking out where the third set would go, to make sure the second piercings would be evenly between the first and third. Her attention to detail and ability to plan ahead on the fly was astounding. The shop itself is beautiful and clean, and I'll actually be returning for a tattoo soon and can't wait. Caitlin is one of the best piercers in our area and I can't recommend her more. She's smart, funny, calming, and has a genuine love for her craft. read more

I wanted to get my nipples pierced and was told that the barbells they had to choose from were the best as they were longer than most barbells-It would facilitate in the healing process. They weren't actually that long and were a touch short for me. I trusted in what my piercer said and we went with the barbells she suggested-thankfully, they healed pretty well. I was also forced to buy solution and even though that is the case in many piercing studios, I already had some. So it was just frustrating especially after I told my piercer. When I was ready to check out, on the POS, it asked if I wanted to sign up for their newsletter and texts, in which I could get a bday discount. I had told my piercer that it was the day before my bday. She could even see that on my ID- She could care less. She was so unfriendly at that point. I still gave her a nice tip because she did take the time to explain the piercing to me and ensure that the piercing went smoothly. Shortly thereafter, I received a text from Caitlin Piercing to come in to receive a bday discount (past purchases not apply) lol For me, the takeaway points are not friendly staff (not just my piercer), high price points and misinformation (Jewelry and piercing solution) read more

Was a great experience. Clean and professional. Answered all my questions and explained the process. Would definitely recommend her if your looking for a piercing. Lots of jewelry to chose from and made in the USA. If I decide to get another piercing definitely going back. read more

Caitlin is amazing! Have been in on a few occasions and shes always on top of it! Takes customers as they come in and helps with everything you need answered. Got some new pieces and had old jewelry replaced with beautiful new gems. Would hands down recommend her for all of your needs! Very professional and easy to talk to. Also good with pointing out what would fit the placement. read more

I made an appointment At 12:45 unfortunately it was my fault but I was having issues getting ready due to recent surgery. When I walked in, Jake immediately said you are late and your appointment time it's pretty much over. I guess my appointment was only 15 minutes even though I got there at 12:54. All that I wanted was a new hoop and put in other piercings that I had to remove do the surgery and possibly shortening the post on a piercing that I had here a year ago. He told me over and over how I was late and how it was already past my appointment time and he didn't think he would have time to help me with most of it. I know I was late I understand I apologized it wasn't like I was a half an hour late I didn't realize the appointment was only for 15 minutes. People take longer than that just to pick out what they want for their piercing. I thought it was very rude the way he treated me. And I didn't appreciate it. I know I'm only one person but I will never go back to see him again. I work for a doctors office and we even give our patients 15 minutes sometimes 20 and we still see them and we are not rude!! He then said that if I just left because I was very angry that he would have to charge me anyhow! Great customer service. read more

Got my earlobes pierced for the first time (as an adult) with Caitlin via Amity Ink. Had a great experience with Caitlin. She was personable, warm, professional and her station was very clean. But-- same experience as other reviewer with checkout. The iPad is definitely set up to make you tip on the jewelry, which my more experienced friends later told me is not a legitimate thing. Though I definitely would have tipped Caitlin for her services, which were excellent, tipping on the expensive jewelry is quite a racket. I chose rose gold, which was in the 200 range, while actual piercing service fee was under 50. Since it was (clearly) my first time getting any piercings done and wasn't sure how tipping worked in that setting, I should have given closer attention to the screen, but I'm so autopiloted about the clover/touchscreen pay system these days and businesses must know that. Even so, it's hard to click "no tip" or do a lesser manual tip than the preset buttons when the person is standing right next to you. Would have appreciated if Caitlin had pointed it out, but who can blame her. Probably ended up tipping around $70 when I would have done 10-20. It colored the experience a bit and is the only reason this isn't a 5 star review. If you don't make the same mistake I did, I'm sure you'll come away with a better opinion of the place. Would still absolutely go to Caitlin as a piercer; I attribute this more to Amity procedures than her personally. read more

Kinda rude... Did a good job but wish I felt more comfortable. Cursed at me and just wanted to get me out of there as fast as she could. Don't understand how people bring their kids there smelled like marijuana heavily and was not kid friendly. Overpriced jewelry also. read more

Caitlin pierced my daughters' ears and was absolutely amazing! Caitlin took her time with my daughter, Maddy, and talked Maddy through everything, and even made it into a fun game! Caitlin was very very clean -- she cleaned everything and changed her gloves at least 3 times during our visit. Highly highly recommend Caitlin!!! :) read more

My 16 year old daughter had been wanting to get a second ear piercing but was nervous since her first ones were done when she was a baby. We were apprehensive to go to the mall and have it done after hearing some bad things about having it done with a piercing gun. We decided to see Caitlin after reading many great reviews of her including young children and kids. She was very professional and put my daughter at ease with her great sense of humor. Everything was extremely sterile and she explained what she was going to do every step of the way. She explained how to clean and care for the piercing. She also took her time to make sure my daughter felt OK afterwards. It was a great experience for us and I would highly recommend Caitlin for any piercings. read more