Since moving here, I have been searching for a decent cheesesteak in Kansas City. I am from Philadelphia and realize nothing compares to the real thing, but Philly Time wasn't too bad. I admire their efforts for authenticity.
I have two places on my list that import Amoroso rolls from Philadelphia (the essential ingredient for an authentic Philly cheesesteak). One is Philly Time, the other one is Grinders, which is talked about a lot more among locals. I decided to try Philly Time first, since it is not as well-known.
I got here on a weeknight around 5pm, and there was basically no one in there. It is located in a shopping/dining center with other retailers, not sure what else was around, but I did not see the sign when I was first pulling in. It actually looked closed, and I was mad for a second, as I drove ~25 minutes to get there. It was indeed open, just a bit dark in there.
Of course I ordered a cheesesteak with cheese whiz (another sign of authenticity) and fried onions (the "South Street" without green peppers). I got a side of fries, and my total was around 10 bucks. I sat and waited to get my cheesesteak to go, and it took about 10 minutes. The place has a decent amount of seating, seemed more like a lunch place. I grabbed my cheesesteak and made the ~40 minute trek home.
I was excited to have an Amoroso roll for the first time in a long time, and unwrapped my beautiful cheesesteak. I was really happy to see the cheesesteak did not get soggy. This place does know technique and correctly put the cheese in-between the meat and the roll. My cheesesteak got a little cold, so I do expect it to be better if eaten immediately after prepared. I also noticed the roll was a little stale, but that is somewhat expected if importing a roll halfway across the country. But seriously, a stale Amoroso roll is much better than a fresh "soft" roll that many restaurants serve. I look forward to trying this place again after finding out what day they get their shipments and eating in, rather than taking out.
I can completely understand the 3-star ratings from people who have not had an authentic Philly cheesesteak before. Philly Time certainly was not the best sandwich I've ever had, and it probably is a 3-star experience if comparing to sandwiches in general. However, I really appreciate the effort to bring in real Philadelphia Amoroso rolls and offering cheese whiz. If you want to experience a decent authentic Philly cheesesteak, try one at Philly Time. Thank you, Philly Time, keep it up!
PS: The fries were kind of crummy. They were crispy but tasted freezer burnt. I suggest skipping those! read more