This looks like a crummy little store, but exterior looks are deceiving. The store has an…read moreincredible selection of craft beer! Fantastic place!

Plenty of varieties. Easy access on 22. Friendly staff…read more Bring your cans and bottles while you're at it to recycle. In and out type of place. Easy. That's it! Some rare and local beer selection available as well.

Lovely place and lovely family! Highly recommend! Best…read moreplace in Putnam County! Knowledge is fast

Always top of the line friendly service with a smile. Over the top knowledge of whatever your…read moretaste. Cut to the chase and do all your liquor shopping here it's the best!

done business here before; good selection of beer..but trying all day to call to place an order and…read morethe phone number always connects to a fax machine. No 'alternate' numbers to call are available, Too bad...was a large order

Went to Santo Stefano on Sunday for an afternoon with the family and to see The Instigators play…read more What a great setting. The wine is delicious. Try the Valentino, it's well worth it. They had a wine tasting and it was $10 for food. I was there with my husband and 10 family members. We bought alot of the wine and spent the afternoon eating and drinking and enjoying the great music and great weather. The wine has no added sulfites so it was great for my husband's stomach. Definately worth another trip back.

This is going to sound like I'm exaggerating but I can honestly say this was the best wine tasting…read moreexperience my wife & I have ever been to. The wine & food are delicious and we ended up taking a few bottles home as well. They don't add any sulfites to their wine so no headaches the next day (even after the amount we ended up drinking) =)

Good selection, fair prices, nice people. Fresh product. Will go out of their way to please.read more

My boyfriend is a huge cigar aficionado, so it was awesome to stumble upon Sterling Cellars, tucked…read moreinto a strip mall off Route 6, which has an amazing selection to choose from! First and foremost, it's a liquor store, but the term "liquor warehouse" is probably better suited for the ample selection of wines, spirits, and craft beers they carry. They even have a Walking Dead themed wine where the labels animate before your eyes if you scan it on the TV show's app! Pretty next level if you ask me! Of course, we were there for the cigars, and the inventory didn't disappoint. They also sell pipes and hookah if that's what you're into as well. Shoutout to Chris, the salesperson that helped us - very helpful, informative, and friendly customer service! Thanks again!

This is a terrific store. They really have a wide selection, no matter what style you like. I was…read morebuying for party and knew folks would have a variety of tastes and was able to find plenty. The staff is so helpful....if you have any questions or want more information they are more than willing to assist, guide and recommend. I wish I drank more beer just so I could come her more often. If you need beer, this is the place you should come.

Used to be a big fan of this store when they opened years ago. Really good quality selection and…read morefriendly staff (and adorable store pup). I just left there about 10 minutes ago, and the selection isn't what it used to be. Everything is IPA, weird craft flavors or fancy fruity style beers or your typical watered down beer that you used to drink in college on a budget. Or what you can find in grocery stores but with a higher price tag. I do appreciate the good cider selection, however, the prices are just out of control. They don't update the sticker prices on the six packs and when checking out, I was surprised that it was several dollars more than what I had anticipated on paying. When I asked the cashier if he would be willing to honor the price on the sticker, he flatly said no. I get times are tough right now, but a little customer service goes a long way. If you're not doing your end of the bargain to update your inventory and prices, then maybe don't mark the cans at all so that customers can confirm the price at the counter before buying.

A fantastic local spot with an impressive selection of wines, spirits, and unique finds you won't…read moresee anywhere else. The staff is very friendly, knowledgeable, and always ready to help with great recommendations. Store is just off 84 and easy access. Highly recommend!

They have a really great selection of wines and liquor. They have a small fridge section of already…read morechilled wines. They do wine and liquor tasting samples sometimes which I never do because who wants alcohol on their breath driving away from a liquor store. Wish they had better prices but it's manageable and easily accessible from the highway

Mid July 2026 - I'm not an expert on wines nor distilled beverages; that's why I really appreciate…read morethe knowledgable staff here. If you tell them what the wine is for or the liquor will be used in, they won't steer you wrong. They even have small bottles of wine and liquor that are bigger than the airline sizes. They also have a record of past purchases, so you don't have to remember what it was you picked up once upon a time. The high ticket liquors are now kept behind the customer service desk. Shoplifting.

Everyone was so helpful and pleasant. The prices weren't that bad either. The cashiers are so…read morethoughtful also .