Pizza was delicious!! We tried the pickle pizza and it did not disappoint. We also tried a…read morepepperoni pizza, and still quite delicious!!

Great pizza! The Festus is a family favorite. We also ordered a Betty something with chicken and it…read morewas good. Medium is more like a small size, but the Large is ENORMOUS!

Awesome cheese balls and pizza!! The cheese balls didn't have the heavy, thick breading that so…read moremany have--they were wonderful! We built a pizza with alfredo, chicken, and bacon. It was delicious! Service was excellent as well. We will definitely be back!!

Place was empty when I stopped in for a beer and a pizza. Asked a couple questions about the…read moretoppings and the bartender didn't seem to know what I was asking. Ordered a "medium" pepperoni and Italian sausage pizza. Was tiny, seemed much closer to 8" than 10". Not too many toppings, not too much cheese. Not sure what New York style means, can't imagine this is it though.

Extremely RUDE. Find someplace else to go! Went for drinks and appetizers around 8:35 pm during…read moreRiverboat Days and had a 2 yr old with us. We were told not to bother sitting down because at 9pm the 2 yr old couldn't be there. However... On our way out a couple with 2 young children, 5 & 7, were going in to order a pizza "TO GO" so they could take it to the park to watch the fireworks. They, too, were turned away! The youngest was visibly upset, as were the parents considering it was a take-out order! Wheelchair accessibility: There is about a 6 inch step to the front door. Did not see any ADA accessible entrance.

Excellent pizza and beer. Delightful bartender and very friendly owner. Highly recommend.read more

When I got gas this AM the pump started at .43 cents before I started to pump gas. Told the people…read moreinside and they wouldn't do anything about it. Gas is high enough already don't need extra added on illegally.

AI holding system refused to connect us and no one at the store answered to help us cancel our…read moreorder which was mistakenly placed at the wrong location. Horrible service, Casey's is being run into the ground. Find another local shop to get food from.

Went in last night for pizza, phenomenal service from your employee. The food was delicious and…read morebathroom was very clean.

We ordered the thin crust pepperoni pizza and it was outstandingly delicious. We'll order it again…read morequite soon. The service was friendly and great also!!!

Great service every-time. Food is amazing, the cactus bread is the bomb. Very friendly atmosphere.read more

Always amazing never fails food and customer service especially Annie customized pizzas when there…read morewas a fire in the building next door Annie opened up for the firemen

I drove from Omaha, Nebraska, after seeing Tasty Treats featured on YouTube, so I was excited to…read morefinally try it. The restaurant definitely has a charming old-school, hometown vibe, and I can appreciate that. Unfortunately, the food just wasn't for me. I ordered the loose meat sandwich "with the works." What I received was seasoned ground beef and onions on a bun with a single pickle and a squirt of mustard. That's literally all it was. I took two bites and couldn't finish it. I understand it's a regional specialty, but it wasn't something I enjoyed at all. I also ordered a chocolate shake. It tasted more like vanilla ice cream with chocolate syrup added than a properly blended chocolate shake. The syrup wasn't mixed evenly, so most of what I tasted was chocolate syrup. The service was okay--I'd give it about a 3 out of 5. The food came out in a reasonable amount of time, and the staff was friendly enough. Overall, I'm glad I can say I experienced it, but I definitely wouldn't make the drive from Omaha again for it. In fact, even if I lived nearby, I don't think I'd come back. The old-school atmosphere was the highlight of the visit, but for me, the food didn't live up to the hype.

Would not recommend anything other than soft serve on a cone. The food is terrible, the fries…read morefresh, were both soggy and dry. The staff rushed us to take our order, and when I said we need a few minutes to decide she turned and walked away without saying a single word, and clearly annoyed. It's maybe a cute stop for ice cream but don't expect much. I would honestly recommend having a talk with your staff because it was not a welcoming vibe I got from either of the employees.