We stopped on our way on 219. Restaurant was neat, clean. Waiter was excellent. And food was…read moredelicious. Ordered chicken ala cover, gnocchi with piccata, and ravioli. All were excellent. Very tasty. Portions were perfect.

Really cute local place with very fair prices. I went twice for lunch last week. The service was…read morevery friendly and very attentive. Never had to wait for anything. The food was decent, better than national chains and priced competitively. The ambiance really did it for me. Reminded me of going to an Italian restaurant in the 1990s with my grandparents. Loved the kitschy walls, the tablecloths, the bread on the table. Seemed to be a local institution.

I almost never write negative reviews, but I get the feeling a lot of people pass through this area…read moretraveling and would want to know, so here goes. We got there somewhere around 7 o'clock, were seated within 10 minutes. I was super excited because the atmosphere in this place is outstanding. I mean really great looking restaurant. Old school Italian is the only way I can describe it. We ordered mozzarella sticks as an appetizer and they were fantastic, as well as the salad and wedding soup we ordered. Bread was also really good. However, the main course was not very good at all. My eight-year-old ordered mac & cheese, which I was shocked to learn was Kraft. (as an authentic Italian place, that was kind of weird) I ordered the chicken Romano and the waitress suggested I change the side of pasta to capavelli with a sun-dried vodka sauce... I think that's what it was, but it was a different sauce than on the menu, am my daughter ordered angel hair with basil Alfredo sauce and chicken. First thing, my son said was his mac & cheese tasted funny, I took a bite and it was extremely overcooked. The noodles were mush, and there was no sauce or flavor. My daughter's Alfredo was already separated when it came to the table, and the bottom of the plate was filled with a ton of oil and the noodles were extremely dry. If you bet me money that was an Alfredo sauce, I would've lost that bet. I didn't taste Alfredo at all. We ended up asking for an extra side of Alfredo, and that came out separated as well, and no amount of stirring would put it back together. I'm guessing all of this was microwaved, except maybe the noodles. My chicken Romano was OK. The pasta suggestion from the waitress was absolutely delicious, but the chicken was definitely not panfried long enough, and there was so much butter or Whirl, on it and on the plate that I tried to use my napkin to sop it up. (i'm thinking it was a butter substitute like Whirl based on the taste) Everything was reasonably priced, but we took almost all of the food home accept the mac & cheese, we tossed that. I'm gonna try to fix the pasta with a trick when Alfredo sauce is overcooked and separated, and hopefully I can save it. I think I'm gonna set my chicken breast on a piece of bread to try to soak out the stick of butter (Whirl?) that's on it. Usually I love a great chicken Romano with a well-prepared butter-lemon-caper sauce, but there was no lemon, no caper, just A pool of butter/Whirl. If I can't fix this it's $80 in the trash. I don't make it through this area often, but I will try this place again and order other items because maybe they're way better at something else.

Food was tasty, service was fantastic!…read more We got the Gorgonzola steak Alfredo pasta dish and it was exactly as expected - rich and tasty. The steak was cooked as requested and had a very good flavor. I've heard the saying, "you come for the food, but you come back for the service", and that is 100% true for Casali's. Our server gave us by far the best service I'd had in a long time. She was warm and friendly, and genuine, while also really knowledgeable about the specials and drink list. Thank you for making my mom and I feel so welcome and cared for as we were passing through town on a road trip.

Great atmosphere. Not too loud and not too quiet. Staff was very friendly very helpful, and very…read moreoffering. Was my first time in Saint Mary's and a lot of of the places I ate were bland. The food here had flavor and taste great.

My friend and I stumbled in here while in Jamestown and not knowing where to go. Lucky for us!…read moreThe service was friendly and attentive. The food was way BETTER than expected and I would recommend this establishment! The only minor criticism I can make is what ever they use to clean the place sorta lingers in the air - so you get a great smell of tomato sauce and the scent of Fabulosa cleaner. All being said- I'd go back!

The food is good here but the service a couple times has been a challenge. We ordered pastas and…read moreask for bread and then we found out we were charged for the bread. Another time we came in with a large group of 12 of us and our server was just horrible. We had mostly adults but we did have a kid with chicken fingers and it was the last thing brought out had to wait almost an hour. Very disappointing. There are many choices for restaurants and I hope this place improves with staffing.

First of all, this place is busy. Don't even think about going without a reservation. It is not…read morefancy. We had a party of five, and we're seated pretty promptly. They were a little slow getting to our drink and food orders, but it was to be expected because of how busy the place was. All of our meals included bread and salad, and some included additional sides. They have a huge menu, and their portions are huge. For example, a serving a spaghetti looks like half a pound. Everybody takes leftovers home. We had a wonderful server, Tammy? And a nice family night out.

Amazing sauce and pasta options on the platter . Lasagna was the best. Great salad as a pre cursorread more

We offer a variety of dishes on our menu sure to create a…read morelong lasting dinning experience.We offer numerous appetizers to please your appetite. Enjoy our sizzling steaks off the grill along with a variety of Italian dishes and succulent fish made to perfection. Come and enjoy a great dining experience with us. .

We cannot say enough about our first visit to Mama Lucerzia's. We have food allergies and emailed…read moreback and forth with Maria before coming. When we walked in she remembered right away. The food was absolutely amazing. When the food came out you could tell it was made to order. The bolognese was to die for. My daughter who's away as a college student was in heaven! Maria was very attentive to our food allergies. You can tell Maria puts her heart and soul into her restaurant and food. We can't wait to go back!

Thank you, Maria for the ultimate service! This is a favorite restaurant of a special friend and a…read morebirthday dinner was decided to be spent here! Thank you for your help to make it a special moment - remember that call from CA! I appreciate it. I know the food is good because they boys love it.

Excellent Pizza and toppings! You definitely get your moneys worth. I highly recommend the cheese…read moresticks and the big daddy!

Absolutely delicious! On our way home to Virginia from Canada. Went thru the drive through ordered…read morea small pepperoni sausage & mushroom. My husband & I loved it! Delicious & very affordable! Must stop when you are in Ridgway PA on Erie Street. You will not be disappointed! Cheers to Fox's Pizza! Thank you! The Yearys!

Excellent service , great Italian selections , fair prices , very good selection of drinks , pizza…read morewas very good , grilled chicken salad was outstanding , will definitely return

Visiting my daughter at PSU and wanted some Italian and pizza and found this place via yelp. Not…read morefar from campus, parking is a bit tight, be sure to only park in spots for restaurant and not surrounding place. Now, down to the food and service! Service, great. Quickly seated and our waitress was then very attentive and food also came out timely. We shared a pizza and chicken parm with egg fettuccine noodles. They definitely cook their pasta al dente, it was a nice chew vs being soft and mushy. Chicken was cooked perfectly. Pizza was tasty with some of the best crust, light and airy. Nice inside with booths, tables and fun pizza decorations.

Very good selection of Italian foods. Pleasant atmosphere. Friendly workers too. Convenient place…read moreto shop.

Found this place traveling through the area. Had the sausage sandwich of the day and the lobster…read morebisque. Both were great. Good place to pick up your Italian grocery and deli items.