This place is absolutely amazing. Everything is homemade even the waffle cones. The ice cream is so yummy!!! My favorite classic is their cookies and cream or the toasted coconut chunk, but I love trying something from their flavor lab almost every time. My husband's favorite is cookie dough and then anything with peanut butter from their flavor lab. The staff is super friendly and helpful. read more

Outside the Cone is an awesome local spot, the staff were very sweet and kind! The whole place feels so welcoming and very clean. Four of us tried a mix of vegan salty s'mores, vegan chocolate, banana pudding, Buttah Finger, melted brownie, and banana chunk ice creams, and every single flavor was rich, and absolutely delicious. I loved that they have so many quality vegan options, too. I'm bringing my family and I highly recommend stopping here if you're anywhere near Forest and Lynchburg!! read more

See all

Yummiest ice cream in Lynchburg. I would know. I highly recommend. Friendly staff, thanks

This is probably my most favorite place to come for dairy free ice cream!! Their vegan Cookie Monster flavor and the vegan pumpkin spice one were the two flavors I had today and they were so amazing. I'd had the Cookie Monster flavor before and loved it, but this new to me fall pumpkin one was just incredible too! The people are always so nice here. I love the calm setting too--great place for an ice cream date or family outing for ice cream. read more

Outside the Cone - Vegan pumpkin spice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

What a great little ice cream shop! Since I've moved to a low carb/keto lifestyle, I haven't had a lot of ice cream. But we had some family events in town, and someone suggested Outside the Cone. "Best in town," they said. And I would bet they are probably right. We passed 3 or 4 different ice cream shops to get to this one. And it was still hoppin' right up until close. Since I'm on vacation, I allowed myself to indulge in one of their waffle cones that they make in-house. (The place smells delicious from their handmade cones!) But I did try the keto butter pecan. Sweet sassy molassy! Butter pecan is my favorite flavor and this keto version was ON POINT! Absolutely delicious. A great treat if you're doing low carb or keto. Just get it in a cup (unlike me!) We sat outside as it was a little crowded inside. But there are several tables to choose from and 3 or 4 outside. I was also impressed they had a full baby changing table in the restroom. I don't have babies, anymore. But I remembered the hassle (especially for men!) of finding a changing station. So, that was a helpful addition for families. read more

Upon entering this ice cream place, I was greeted with what appeared to be an official resolution from the Virginia State House declaring that this place is really really good. It is. Indeed, I don't know of a place like this in the Richmond area, but this location in a Lynchburg shopping center has everything you'd want in a premium ice cream place. The aroma of cones was difficult to resist and they had the option to get one coated with chocolate on the inside. I used this to make my mint chocolate chunk more chocolate-y, which was a good decision, and yet one that did not overwhelm the robust herbal mint flavor. Alternatives were many, including vegan flavors, local fruits, and even supposedly a keto flavor without sugar, which I'm skeptical of but good for them for trying I guess. Most people will just be seeking a regular ice cream cone, and they will likely find a better one than they expect. read more

Outside the Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

Outside the Cone in Lynchburg is without a doubt one of the city's best kept secrets. Not just for the ice cream, but for the people behind the counter. I'm not even a big "ice cream guy" but let me tell you... the flavors here are exceptional. The honeycomb ice cream alone could convert just about anyone. It's rich, unique, and absolutely unforgettable, just like many of the other obscure and creative flavors we got to try. But what truly made the experience memorable were Merriel and Ashley, two absolute gems of human beings who made us feel welcome from the moment we walked in. Their patience, kindness, and genuine warmth during our (admittedly indecisive) flavor selection made all the difference. We especially had the pleasure of talking more with Merriel, and wow, what a shining star. She was thoughtful, attentive, and carried herself with the kind of care and professionalism you rarely see anymore, especially at an ice cream joint. She's special in many ways! You can tell she truly takes pride in all she does, and it really lifts the entire experience. Ashley was equally sweet and helpful, and together they are part of what makes this place award winning in every way. Thank you Merriel and Ashley for turning a simple ice cream stop into one of the highlights of our trip. We'll definitely be back when we return to VA read more

Really good ice cream and cute place! The staff is nice and the flavors are always changing.

I love these ice creams, they are creamy, with a rich flavor, my favorite is the coconut and chocolate one, I love that they make the cookies there for the cones, highly recommended, the staff is very friendly. read more

The flavors and freshness of the ice cream here are fantastic. It is a hole in the wall, but it is so good. You cannot go wrong with ice cream. The service was good, and it was a cute little place near many other restaurants in the Burg. read more

I can literally taste why so many of this shop's flavors are national award winners! Delicious, fresh ice cream with both traditional and unique flavors that will knock your socks off. I've never had ice cream so full of flavor! Another must try if you're in the area. read more

Outside the Cone is hands down one of my favorite ice cream spot in Lynchburg! They offer such creative and delicious flavors -- my absolute favorite is the blueberry goat cheese (when they have it, don't miss it!). On top of that, they provide gluten-free waffle cones, which is a huge win. It's not easy to find gluten-free cones, let alone ones that taste this good. Great quality, friendly service, and awesome options for everyone. Highly recommend! read more

Lovely ice cream store with a variety of ice cream flavors. The kindest workers ever. Came with a large group but the workers accommodated all of us quickly with lots of tips and samples. I ended up getting a single scoop with half cotton candy and banana chunk. So delicious!! Left very happy. Cotton Candy [5/5] Very light, not overpowering artificial flavor which I like. Banana Chunk [5/5] Tasted similar to a banana split dippin dots. Love it. Not an artificial taste, very yummy. Waffles are all made in house on the day of. Whole store smelled like waffle heaven. I would def recommend you stop by here and get your tummy filled with some cheap amazing icecream. I love what they have but I'd love to see them grow and add possibly sherbets to the list? I'm a huge sucker for sherbet. Lol. Will be back next time I'm in Lynchburg :) read more

Outside the Cone - Marshmallow single cup (1/2 scoop of banana chunk at the bottom) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

This is one of the greatest ice cream places I've ever ate at. Staff is kind, ice cream is good, and very welcoming. They also have fun unique flavors they try and switch out every once in a while, however unless human hair is an ice cream flavor I don't know why it's ending up in my bowl. This hasn't happened any of my past times but today I found 3 pieces of hair in my ice cream. Other than that it's great but that is gross to find. Maybe hair nets? read more

We had Outside the Cone cater our wedding, and it was a HUGE hit with our guests! The staff was incredibly friendly, and they were absolutely game with using our custom ice cream cups (mini baseball helmets, like at the games!). We got Vanilla, Chocolate, and Cookies and Cream, which, again, were all HUGE hits with our guests. We've been to the in-person store a few times as well, and it was just as good there as it was at our wedding. This is one of Lynchburg's best ice cream shops, and we highly recommend them to anyone looking for either a sweet treat, or a catered event! read more

I try to come here every time I come to Lynchburg and this is the best ice cream anywhere around. Had the blueberry goat cheese and hippo tracks today. Both are excellent! The staff was friendly and helpful. Sat outside today which was lovely. Always worth a stop and I'm never disappointed. read more

Nice little ice cream place with some unique flavors. Not much in the way of ambiance or a cool hip vibe, but decent ice cream at reasonable prices. read more

Not pictured me with the outstanding "It's all Greek to me" ice cream with Greek honey, cream, baklava, a caramel swirl. I could eat this at least three times a week. Rich without overwhelming you. I'm currently crushing on this ice cream. This was our second visit and both times have left me wanting more. You can bet our next trip to Lynchburg will include a pop by this ice cream shoppe! This is locally owned business. Flavors are amazing feted on a seasonal basis. They are all hand crafted with love, imagination, and incredible taste. This spot is a must add to your list of things to do when you are in the area. read more

See all

The first thing you notice when you walk in the door is the blast of waffle smells. They clearly make their cones in house. Phenomenal ice cream. Well priced and the quality of the ice cream is second to none. I liked how the waffle cone was somewhat bendable, a callback to the origins of the waffle cone being... an actual waffle. Nothing is sadder when you bite into your cone and it shatters like a poorly tempered car window. Definitely will be coming here again! Pictured here is butter pecan and peanut butter chocolate with graham cracker. Both great flavors! Highly suggest you come down and get yourself a cone. read more

See all

Great service, AMAZING ICE CREAM!!!! Hands down, the best ice cream in town!!!!!!!! read more

100% you should go here to get your ice cream fix. I wanted the real stuff and got convinced to get a Vegan type ice cream...it was that good. So, needless to say that if the lite version of the ice cream is that good, you can bet the real stuff is superb. The staff behind the counter are the sprinkles. They are nice, willing to help and knowledgeable about the flavors. So, just go and you are welcome! read more

The best homemade ice cream & service in town! We've never had a bad experience and love the outside seating #livinggratefully read more

Outside the Cone - Red white & blueberry for one scoop in a cup #livinggratefully - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Tasty, refreshing, homemade and GOOD! I'm always in search of a good, chunky cookies and cream ice cream...they have one of the best I've had. I devoured it and even found myself scraping the bowl. I also got Mango Tango which was also really tasty. I actually plan to go back today after dinner... read more

Outside the Cone - Cookies and Cream & Mango Tango - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

It is dangerous that this place is only a few minutes walk from me. I'm here all the time for the best hard ice cream in town! I love that they have new flavors every time I go! This place just opened and they started out with quality ice cream that has not failed to impress me since. I always try a few flavors and it's so hard to choose what to get. They're also super friendly there, and they have a great seating area with the cutest decor. Would recommend to anyone! read more

Outside the Cone - Hazelnut and chocolate ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Outside the Cone has quickly become my favorite ice cream shop in all of Lynchburg and that's saying something in a town with endless ice cream shops. Outside the Cone offers the most creative and delicious assortment of flavors and the BEST waffle cones. They have a weekly flavor lab where they experiment with different flavor choices. Sometimes these choices are only there for the week and sometimes they bring back fan favorites. Apart from the flavor lab, there are classic flavors that are offered continuously. The staff members always greet customers upon entry and they are polite at the service bar. They offer samples of flavors so customers can narrow down their favorite choice. The inside of the store is cute with a variety of cows and ice cream paintings on the walls. There are different sized tables indoors and they have outdoor-seating as well. If you are visiting Lynchburg or a local, you have to stop by! It's definitely worth the visit!! read more

Right around Wyndhurst's food eatery, this little ice cream shop is also tucked on the side, but their ice cream sign sticks out. I LOVED honeycomb, I never had honeycomb in my ice cream, wasn't bad at all though. I could tell they were going for a healthy twist to it, it was very light, especially the cookies and cream flavor. I got cotton candy and mint choco chip. Gave a four star review cause it didn't stick out to me as spectacular, it's a locals ice cream shop, or more of a summers evening to go to spot. It fulfilled my sweet tooth/craving in 30° though so I'll give em that! read more

Outside the Cone - Cookies and cream two scoops for medium. One scoop of mint choco y cotton candy. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Went in for the coffee oreo, and came out with an ice cream flight! Yes, they do flights!! To go!! I can't even pick a favorite because they were all so so good! The Oatmeal chocolate chip cookie surprised me with such a wonderful combination...but the Vegan thin mint shocked me at the amazing flavor they were able to achieve. Butter pecan, a classic, was so so yummy. Now, don't get me wrong, the coffee Oreo was incredibly delicious, my second favorite ice cream combination ever, and they delivered on making my tastebuds happy. Stop in here and try all the flavors!! Love this place and can't wait until Summer when my pup can enjoy it too! read more

I went right before I moved away in November and I literally drove back today to get ice cream. It's the best and creamiest homemade ice cream in Lynchburg. They also make 99% of their own syrups and toppings. The prices are also great. You cannot go wrong here. I've tried all of the homemade places in town. The only other one I liked that is now closed is Halos Heavenly Creamery. read more

Outside the Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

This ice cream is freaking bomb ! They make everything from scratch from the ice cream to the waffle cones ! You can try a sample any ice cream you want before you make your final decision and the staff never gets annoyed even if you are like me and you want to try like half of the flavors lol! The staff is super kind ! They have keto flavors , vegan flavors , and then of course the real deal ! I like it because every time I go in there the flavors are usually different with a few that are always the same ! Did I mention I am not even really an ice cream person ? My husband LOVES ice cream and this is his favorite place , but every time we go I usually end up getting some because it is just THAT good. Next time you are wanting to go get ice cream ... seriously your only option is this place !!!! read more

The staff was extremely welcoming and explained everything very well to us for our first time there! It was a super cute place with fun paintings and artwork on the walls! All of the flavors we tried were really good and I love that they have a Flavor Lab for new rotating flavors! Eco friendly restaurant, homemade ice cream, and a great staff!! read more

Came in on a Sunday night for a double-scoop on a waffle cone. The gals working that night were polite and gave good recommendations for ice cream. Out of the two flavors I got (I forgot the name, but it's the one with potato chips, lol) and the cotton candy flavor, cotton candy was a clear winner! The waffle cone was tasty too. I'm big on food textures, and the waffle cone had a mix of crunchy, and the tiniest bit of chewy (my guess is they are made in-house?). It was delish! Loved it and will be back! :) read more

HANDS DOWN the best ice cream in the area. I visit here often and the good thing is that it's always consistent. Always good ice cream, friendly staff! It's a cute little shop and the vibe is great. The chocolate is superb and I also recommend trying any of their seasonal flavors (most of them are amazing!) read more

Häagen- Dazs who ? One of best chocolate ice creams I've ever had. This is a must if you're in Lynchburg. Super friendly staff, Taylor was the best she let us sample everything and was super informative about all their options. read more

**YOU MONEY IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN YOUR SAFETY** Great ice cream! Great customer service!!!! But!!!!!!!!! During this pandemic, this establishment is not requiring patrons to wear mask. I came into this establishment and immediately walked out when I saw people packed against the walls running out the door. This establishment has a sign on the door requiring people to wear mask; however, they are not enforcing the rules. It's seems they care more about your money than they do your health and for that I will not support this business until they live up to guidelines. VDH should be notified about this as soon as possible. Our health is at risk. Governor Northam announced that Virginia enters Phase Three of the Forward Virginia reopening plan on Wednesday, July 1. VDH urges all Virginians to continue to limit exposure by staying 6 feet from others and wearing a cloth mask while in public settings. Governor Northam announced Executive Order 63, a mask mandate, which requires Virginians over 10 years old to wear face coverings in public settings and business establishments, effective May 29. THEY ARE NOT FOLLOWING THE RULES BY MAKING ALL CUSTOMERS TO WEAR A MASK!!!! RESPONSE FROM OWNER: Like many other businesses, we have chosen to not enforce the mask man date verbally and force customers to leave the store. One of the reasons we made this decision is because the majority of our staff is under the age of 18 and I do not feel it is appropriate or safe for them to confront adults regarding mask usage. As a small business we only have the staff on hand to sell ice cream and serve our customers. We have spoken to the health department regarding this and they said what we are doing is perfectly acceptable. Businesses are required to post signage regarding the mandate (which is posted on both of our entrances), but are not required to enforce the legislation. For those who do not feel it is safe to enter we do make exceptions and will bring an order out to your car if you call ahead and can pay in cash for your order. I would also recommend visiting between 12PM-5PM when we typically do not have many other customers in the store to avoid contact. I appreciate your patronage and hope that you don't think we are taking this pandemic lightly. It is just very difficult as a small business during these times when so many are not wearing masks even when they know that it has been ordered. ----------------------------------------------- ADD ON You are free to call the LYH Health Department and ask them if a business must make customers leave if they are not wearing a mask. I didn't take down anyone's name, but I had a few questions so I gave them a call several weeks ago. We have signs on the doors and free masks to those who need them. Even large corporations such as WalMart and Kroger stopped enforcing mask usage very soon after they started because it caused a threat to their workers. An Adult is inside the building, but they are not always in the lobby and can't keep an eye on both entrances. As I've stated for those who feel unsafe coming inside we accommodate them however we can. We also have GrubHub delivery service option. This will be my last response in this matter. I appreciate your patronage, and hope that you will still be a customer in the future. read more

The service was top notch. They were so friendly and pleasant. The ice cream was excellent.

This is a wonderful spot! I've been twice and have to get two flavors. So far I've tried butter pecan and cookies&cream!! The staff is friendly and I look forward to visiting again! The prices are reasonable also. read more

See all

A few basics but everything has a creative twist. A few vegan choices if that's your thing. Super friendly staff and real metal tasting spoons. Enjoy yourself! read more

One of the best places for hand scooped ice cream. They always have interesting flavors available. Sadly one of the worst for milkshakes as the selection is limited on what ice creams they will use. Which really stinks as that's what I like. As a customer that doesn't have a problem forking over $14 for a milkshake I'm confused as to why. It's their choice, we will drive past and will go to the new milkshake place nearby. read more

What a cozy and friendly little ice cream place! I went here with a date for a couple scoops and the selection is good and everything is reasonably priced. I highly recommend dropping in on a hot day or taking a date to get some ice cream here. Friendly folks too. read more

As a lover of good ice cream, I was more than thrilled to find this shoppe! WOW, the flavors burst in your mouth! And the sweet people who work there make it an adventure to make the almost 20 mile one way trip. As a lover of Butter Pecan I'm usually disappointed with how few pecans are in the ice cream. Not so here, it's loaded and bursting with delicious pecan flavor that blends with the butter ice cream! And the Espresso Chunk is almost addictive! This is the place to go for an after dinner treat!!! Or anytime you need something that takes you away from your troubles, even for a few minutes. read more