First bed and breakfast. Gary was an excellent host and the perfect amount of helpful but not intrusive. Would recommend to everyone.

A unique historic home conveniently located in downtown Indy, with an owner as gracious, welcoming & interesting. Skip the hotel room u can secure anywhere and have an adventure. A stay at the Old Northside B&B will b memorable. read more

I loved our stay at the Old Northside Bed & Breakfast this weekend. I somehow missed it was Indy 500 weekend and the inn rates were not increased, so it was a fun surprise to get to meet a lot of folks going to the race from all over the world! We stayed in the Dewenter room which was cozy. It all felt like stepping back in time in a good way - the old house mixed with lots or VHS tapes to borrow!! Breakfast and snacks were aplenty. Gary was easy to communicate with and our late arrival was okay. I had never been to a B&B and look forward to doing it again soon. Thanks, Gary! read more

Old Northside Bed & Breakfast Inc - Dewenter Room - Hotels Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This was our first experience at a Bed and Breakfast, and because of this trip it will not be our last! I decided that for my birthday, I wanted to get a themed room. Something just fun to get away from the house for one night. Our budget isn't exactly the highest, but a splurge for a birthday is doable. I had originally planned to go to a different hotel for the evening, but I'm REALLY glad I didn't. Booking the room was so easy. The gentlemen who helped my husband were kind, easygoing, down to earth... very easy to work with. The B&B has multiple themed rooms (including a movies room that I'm very interested in for the next getaway), but I have an obsession with Tiffanys and that's CLEARLY the room for me. And WOW. The room. Is. AMAZING. From the decor to the bed to the robes to the bathtub, I was in heaven. HEAVEN. I was literally begging my husband to see if there was a BOGO deal at all. I told him I would offer dance lessons. Anything. JUST LET ME LIVE HERE. After the initial wave of heaven set in, we got settled. The room has a remote control fireplace and it's SO nice to be able to relax near it. Snacks and sodas were offered as soon we arrived, and we definitely took advantage! The amazing collection of VHS and DVDs had us in awe (and I'm a musical theatre nerd, so all the movie-musicals had me SO excited). We decided after checking in to take a walk to see what we could find for lunch. Don't let maps fool you: on gorgeous days (and even slightly chilly days), it's not very far at all from great food! The neighborhood is safe and quiet and people are very friendly. There are lots of dogs. Love it. After we were done with t he says activities, we were able to take a relaxing bubble bath. There's a Kroger within walking distance, so we picked up some wine and bubble bath to enjoy. We picked out two movies from their MASSIVE collection (Breakfast at Tiffany's and O Brother Where Art Thou) and relaxed in the gorgeous tub. We had reservations about the bed (it felt really soft), but that may have been one of the best nights of sleep I've ever gotten. Danny was the BEST host in the world and kept in contact with us via text. He made himself available at any time and was happy to answer all questions we had. Since we were the only ones in the house, he offered flexible check in and out, was more than capable in his breakfast making skills... his hospitality was unparalleled. After taxes, we spent less than $200 for two of us to stay in a room with gorgeous stained glass, a huge tub, a massive shower, a private bathroom, access to HUNDREDS of movies (in reality we combed maybe an eighth of what they had), the ability to enjoy breakfast made just for us, around the holidays, in a GORGEOUS neighborhood... We will be returning when possible. And I will be suggesting the Old Northside to EVERY person looking for an overnight getaway or a weekend stay. read more

See all

Non-white visitors beware! If you don't look Caucasian, the owner Gary will ask you where you are from. If you happen to come from a country he doesn't like, he will try to 'educate' you about the terrible things your home country did and call it 'a country of slaves'. I did not say anything back to argue. I just went back to my room quickly afterwards and cried and left at 7 am next morning without breakfast. I just wanted to have a relaxed weekend with my husband. I don't think I deserved to be called one of the 'slaves'. I called my credit card company (where I booked this trip) to make a complaint and demand a refund. The owner refused a refund. All in all, this has not been an ideal weekend getaway. read more

Old Northside Bed & Breakfast Inc - Hotels Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

In a word, FABULOUS! By far, one of the best places that me and my husband have ever stayed. Gary is the ultimate host: warm, welcoming, thoughtful and very experienced. The beautiful historic home is nestled in the Old Northside neighborhood. The rooms are elegantly decorated and very inviting. They draw you in to relax and nestle. Gary went above and beyond all our expectations. From the home baked cookies to the array of snacks and beverages available (all gratis) and the hundreds of movies available, and the plush towels and soft sheets, Wi-Fi boosters and premium channels on the tv, and the option of having your full breakfast served at a time of YOUR choosing, and the million little ways you are made to feel "right at home," a stay at the Old Northside Bed and Breakfast will draw you back again and again. Thank you for making our visit SO special. This place is a treasure! read more

I stayed here last week. It is in a great location for walking. Downtown is an easy drive. Gary was very helpful and has interesting stories to tell. The omelette he made one morning was delicious. Highly recommend! read more

This was a fun and interesting place to stay - the rooms were decorated way beyond what you might expect. If you like pictures and knick knack decorations this is the secret and the price is right $150/night. Overall the beds and baths are ok. Older house and older accommodations - don't expect great shower heads or fancy beds. Breakfast and food looked to be great and there is a wonderful dinning area. The host, Gary, is very responsive and will work out most needs. I wanted to check out at 1 pm but he would not help here so I took a little away from rating. The real reason for lower rating is that the owner is very much a political person who supports Trump and Pence. While it is his place and his right to support who he wants it probably is not best to mix politics and business. If that is ok with you then I'd recommend going there. One negative is the closest eating establishment is about 8 blocks away and 1.5 miles to walk to downtown. read more

See all

Wow, one cannot find a better bed and breakfast around town. The hospitality is superb and the surroundings are elegant. Blessings to Gary for opening his home! read more

We had such a great time at Old Northside! Away from the hustle and bustle of downtown Indianapolis (I assume it's hustling and bustling anyway; we didn't really go there during the day), this B&B puts you right into a real, residential neighborhood - as a tourist, it was nice not to feel so, well, touristy. With a private parking lot and an electronic code to get in, it was also easy to come and go as we pleased. Gary and JoAnne were quite accommodating and friendly. I especially liked the endless supplies of snacks they had available 24 hours a day! We would definitely go back. read more

Old Northside Bed & Breakfast Inc - Hotels Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Our stay (8/26-28) was pretty uneventful and I found the inn to be charming, unique, and quaint. We arrived late (11:30pm) and the host, Tressa, was there to greet us and show us around. I didn't find it that cozy, however, but the uniqueness made up for it. The first impression walking in brought us into a kitchen cluttered with a huge selection VHS and DVD's spanning back decades. The second room featured a piano and a microphone, but wasn't used during our stay (I would have sang away if i knew someone that could tickle the ivories). To the right was the dining room, set for breakfast the next morning and then another sitting room next to that. If you want to not leave the B&B and watch movies all day, this is for you. If you love to watch movie musicals, this place is totally for you. Our room was upstairs, the Hollywood room. Check out the pictures. It's something to write home about. It comes complete with a sitting couch a vaudeville makeup table, and a directors chair. The walls were adorned with faces and playbills from Hollywood and Broadway past. We were saddened that we didn't find one black person on any of the walls.. But I guess that was Hollywood, eh? The bed could use an upgrade (creaky and not soft.. My boyfriend liked it though.. But he prefers to sleep on planks anyway). The two pillows were also embarrassingly worn and not plush... (reason for the missing star). I suggest brining your own pillow (s). I could do without the carpet in the bathroom (which was also decorated with music, playbills, and books on musical theatre by the toilet). The breakfast was filling and tasty, especially the sausage egg casserole on the final day. They had delicious coffee and a gracious host that made sure we were taken care of. The other guest rooms were pretty nifty, too, but none, I think, as advent garde as our room. Check out Foundery Coffee up the street for yummy coffee and bagels. Check this place out. It's different and unique with a great host. read more

See all

Such a charming and beautiful historic house. Our room was so comfortable. The owner was very warm and welcoming. The homemade cookies were delicious and such a nice touch. Tons of great classic movies to choose from. The location was perfect and very walkable. Very dog friendly. I highly recommend staying here. read more

From the moment we first called Gary about a room the warmth in his voice brought a comfort. We are on our Honeymoon "road trip" and I turned a few things around.So I was a bit anxious when I called. When we walked through the front door it was like we had time traveled. It felt like we had stepped into the past. The videos and cds helped bring you back into that bygone era. Our room "the tiffany" was beautiful! The stained glass window, the pictures and the Jacuzzi made it so very romantic! Gary was the best host, it was like going to your uncle's house, if he was a world traveler with a very interesting life to share. Breakfast was delicious. We had an amazing stay, our only complaint...we were only here one night! read more

See all

Really enjoyed my stay! ONBB has great character, is quiet and has a very good innkeeper. Breakfast was good and I enjoyed my conversations with Gary and the other guests. I stayed in the Hollywood room and though I'm not that much of a movie buff I really enjoyed looking at all the pictures. It is a walkable neighborhood, I walked over and toured the Benjamin Harrison Home two blocks away. There are other sites nearby as well. Wi-Fi was good and I was able to get some work done in my room. Again, I want to say my room was very quiet, comfortable and homelike and I slept very well. That is the most important thing about a place to stay yet! Look forward to staying there again when I am "Back Home Again in Indiana" read more

This is an extraordinary property with hosts who provide an astounding experience! The building itself is a Territorial home with a stunning, fully-restored Victorian interior. The home is full of history!! Not only is it beautiful to look at, but innkeepers Mr. And Mrs. Hofmeister make it a joy to be a guest. The Inn is homey, comfortable and located in The Old Northside Neighborhood. This makes it a very nice walk to the downtown area of Indianapolis! Honestly, I could not have asked for a better honeymoon! Oh, and I did I mention the food? The breakfast that is part of your stay is inventive and delicious. We totally enjoyed our stay and will most definitely be back! Our children are older and we are planning a Christmas trip for us as a family. I know both or sons and daughters will want the Hollywood room! If we put our youngest daughter in the Literary Room she will never leave! Again, the two of us will be back for a short getaway! It is so nice that I am even thinking of purchasing a gift certificate as a Christmas gift to my parents! You will love it! Steve & Mary Kay Keith (Chicago, Il) read more

See all

Wonderful hospitality and charm. Jacuzzi tub in the honeymoon suite. Home baked cookies and breakfast with classic movie collection. What a wonderful experience. read more

This place has a funny smell. As we entered into the small kitchen, we could hear snoring from the room adjacent the hall entry. The whole place seemed really outdated and cluttered from all the VHS movies in cabinets throughout the house. They put us in a dark room in the attic which is not pictured on the website, it must be an overflow room because of the random personal hygiene items stored there. The room features unsanitary carpet in the bathroom. This is not the elegant getaway we had envisioned based on the website and the prices. read more

This is a lovely old house with an fascinating host. We stayed in the Dewenter Room, and our bedroom seemed private for old house. It had a regular sized jacuzzi tub, although I just took a shower. We loved that we could have a nice walk downtown (nice for us as walkers at least). The neighborhood was beautiful. read more

A wonderful, old place! The innkeeper is such a nice man, who welcomed me warmly. He showed me around the house and then brought me to my room. I slept very peacefully that night, with out any disruptions. The next morning a delicious breakfast was waiting for me down stairs. I was sad when I had to go, but as I walked out the door I couldn't help but notice it was very scenic and close to the down town. Old Northside has truly made my visit to Indianapolis worth while and I hope to go back soon! read more

This place was charming and really fun to stay in. Gary, the tenant, bakes and stocked the first floor of the house with all kinds of sweets, there are about 1000 movies to chose from and it is located right in town, but has a small town feel, which is a bonus. The one downside was that the room smelled a little funny, but that's probably just a price you pay to stay in an old Victorian home! read more

Gary knocked on our door and asked if we were overflowing the tub. I told him I would get a rob on and he could come in and look. He said, "No I believe you. OH and by the way your dog barked the entire time you were gone." Little did he know I had a pet camera set up and watched her the entire time and she slept! Not one peep from her. My boyfriend and I packed up our stuff and left. As we were leaving Gary said, "It's not my fault your dog barked." I think he was bad about his tub. We did not over flow it, we offered for him to come in and check. He was abrasive and not helpful. The place is not well care for. DO NOT RECOMMEND. read more

8-13-2016 Exactly two weeks prior to my wedding I was searching for a nice B&B to spend my wedding night with my new husband. I easily found Old Northside Bed and Breakfast online along with a list of other B&B's and their reviews. Old Northside was the only place with consistent great reviews so I decided to give them a call. Gary answered my call and I knew immediately that this was the place that I wanted to stay. His voice was kind and he didn't seem to mind answering my questions. On Saturday evening when we arrived we were greeted by a friendly, down to earth, kind man ready to ensure that our stay would be great. He showed us to our room, the Tiffany Room, that was classically decorated and gave the feeling of being in another era. After showing us to our room he gave us the grand tour of his beautiful B&B that included a snack area loaded with four types of homemade cookies, cold drinks, and yes....microwave popcorn for snacking while watching one of the hundreds of movies that Gary has available for his guests to borrow. After enjoying a nice hot bath in the jacuzzi tub and a restful nights sleep, we were pleased to awaken to the wonderful smells of a homemade breakfast. We were able to choose our breakfast dining time and graciously feasted on homemade ham and cheese quiche, banana walnut bread, also homemade with extra walnuts, hot coffee, teas, orange juice, cold cereals, fresh fruit, breads for toasting, and memorable ambience. I may have forgotten a food item or two, but I think you catch the drift. After eating until we could barely move, we were offered banana bread for the road. We gladly accepted and after packing up our belongings, Gary walked us to the door and I couldn't resist giving him a thankful hug and we were on our way. If you're looking for an experience that will surely give you the urge to return and try out each of his themed rooms, be treated like a good friend, and enjoy peace, quiet and good food, then this is definitely your place. If you want a so-so run of the mill stay I'm sure that you can find something different. Thank you, Gary Hofmeister for giving me and my new husband a night and morning we will always remember. read more

Room was not very clean and in need of repair. There was what appeared to be cat hair on the bedspread and cloudy spots. The carpet in the room did not look swept. The curtains were coming off the wall next to water damage seen on both corner walls. The carpet in the bathroom was pieced with bath rugs around the sink and toilet. Some sort of pipe coupling is visible in the bathroom wall - for an "historic" renovation it was done at low cost and not for the period. Bath linens had stains and holes. We stayed on a night when there had been snowfall earlier in the day and the parking lot had not been plowed/shoveled nor had the access alley. Made getting into the lot and into the building a messy, slippery problem. You enter the building through the kitchen, which also looked in need of upgrade. This was overpriced, and we won't come again and won't recommend this bnb. read more