This was a very interesting and relaxing two hour cruise…read more I surprised my wife with a sunset cruise hosted by Bedell Winery. The cruise had 3 offerings of their specialty wines, a nice red, white and sparkling wine along with all you can each shrimp and freshly shucked oysters. If you couldn't consume shellfish, they offered a charcuterie box from Mamma Lombardis. Pretty nice offerings Bedell! Parking was easy peasy, the train station lot had plenty of available parking. Once we boarded, we each grabbed a wine glass and headed to the upper deck. My wife, looking so elegant in her summer dress, it was just a perfect night for a romantic cruise on Long Island. You don't have to call me late for dinner, I saw the crew carrying the oyster aft (that's the back of the boat for you non sailing Yelpers) I grabbed a plate and loaded up with a nice amount of shrimp with cocktail sauce as well as oysters. Ever try sail while trying to keep cocktail sauce off my white silk Tommy Bahama shirt? I did it because I have mad skill. I noticed the couple next to me, I made small talk with the guy. This woman, she must of eaten 2 dozen oysters! And I dig that! Enjoy yourself, don't hold back. I had about 6 oysters, a good amount of shrimp and a quite a few glasses of Bedell wines. The captain of the boat did something very cool. He brought the ship very close to lighthouse for a perfect picture spot. Could this night get any better? Here's where and I hope Bedell reads this review. You have the perfect opportunity to talk to all the guests and sell your winery! There should of been bottles of the wine we tasted for sale as well as baskets filled with wines & cheeses, raffles to come back to the vineyard for a tasting, shirts, glasses, Bedell things for sale. It sounds like you need me to take over this area of responsibility. ABC, always be closing. Wine is for closers! The guy pouring the wine was swamped with everyone at once saying: Gimme! A back up sales person, a closer would have sealed the deal. Other than that, if you see The Peconic Star offering sunset cruises, it's something I highly recommend.

My first time fishing in years. Had a great time. It's nice that they only take one half capacity…read more Captain and crew knew their stuff. Coming back soon. I wish they would add some 1/2 day trips. They wore this old timer out.

Fantastic! Wonderful captain and crew! Relaxing and inviting. I highly recommend and will…read moredefinitely sail again.

I had the most amazing birthday celebration aboard My Reality Charters! The crew was so gracious…read moreand generous. The yacht is in tip-top shape and our guests had an amazing time cruising around the Hamptons. If you want a memorable and fabulous day on the water My Reality is the adventure of a lifetime!

Great charter, Superb hospitality and a sure thing return when next heading out on the water in…read moreDelray/Boca.

An amazing experience with staff that's willing to cater your boating experience to whatever you…read morewant. We brought food and the stew kindly assmbled beautiful platters for us to enjoy and quietly folded all towels and clothes every moment possible. They run a tight ship, keep things clean, and operate with a "yes, and" mentality. Would recommend for any occasion and ask for a dock and dine!

My husband and I are somewhat experienced sailors looking to get our ASA certification, and we…read morechose Sag Harbor Sailing. I'm so glad we did! From hands on instruction, to two beautiful days of sailing on an Ensign, we simply had a great time. Mark was extremely knowledgeable and capable and we felt totally secure with him, even with Hurricane Lee threatening to cut our time short! We'd do it the same all over again. Thank you for an amazing experience!

We booked a very last minute sail with Eric. He was so flexible and easy going! We arrived with our…read moregroup of 10 which included 6 children of various ages. Eric's boat was clean and comfortable. Big basket of snacks for everyone and a cooler with drinks too. Eric was patient and kind with the kids and let them steer too! He also played the role of lifeguard after we stopped to swim near Shelter Island. Take your family out on a charter with Eric while you're in the Hamptons. It was so so nice!!

Awesome Captain, awesome boat! We have enjoyed Captain…read moreEric's sails since last year and we are real excited to take a sail on the new vessel "Sea Escapes" this season.

Booked a cruise with Captain Steven with my husband for our wedding anniversary. We had such a…read moregreat time and learned so much about growing oysters! The Half Shell is a beautiful classic wooden boat that was a dream to be on the water in. We cruised around Peconic Bay and were able to see the Founder's Oyster Farm and a tall ship that was in Greenport. We had tons of delicious fresh oysters along with homemade mignonette, hot sauce, and cocktail sauce. I could have stayed on for a few more hours. We can't wait to go again soon!

Rob was great as always. His understanding of the tides and weather always puts you on the fish…read more He timed the day perfectly for black sea bass in the morning and fluke in the afternoon. He even provided me with a new ceviche recipe to try that evening that certainly didn't disappoint me or my family. I will absolutely be booking another trip with him soon.

This was the best charter I've ever taken. Caught the biggest doormat ever 6lbs! Captain Rob really…read morebrings your hook to the fish.

Might be the best thing to do on shelter island. Captain John knows the island like the back of his…read morehand and every trip is a boat ride and a history lesson of the island all wrapped into one.

Captain John is wonderful, he knows Shelter Island and Sag Harbor so well, and has so many…read moreinteresting stories to tell about the famous artists, musicians and politicians that live in these McMansions. His large boat is extremely comfortable and takes around six people, I cannot think of a better way to spend a couple of hours, in the luxury of a beautiful boat enjoying the magnificent waters of the East End. My friend and I booked the charter for a two hour trip, Captain John was very accommodating and took us at the last minute, and it was the highlight of our stay on Shelter Island. I highly recommend booking Tubby's charters, you won't be sorry! We are already planning a repeat trip with a group of friends as soon as Captain John has space to take us as he is very fully booked as many people go back for return trips year after year. Thank you, Captain John , you rock!