Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    NY Craft Beer

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed Closed

    NY Craft Beer Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - NY Craft Beer

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - NY Craft Beer

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Beer, Wine & Spirits 3,312 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Barrels & Stills

    Barrels & Stills

    4.1
    (19 reviews)
    2.2 mi
    $$

    I just love these guys and this is my go to liquor store!…read more I'm an avid tequila connoisseur so I'm always on the hunt for a quality tequila selection and this place has it. And when they haven't, they have happily ordered what I've asked for and have kept it on hand. The guys are also very knowledgable about the newer liquors on the market and always stock the harder to find vodkas like Figenza. One fun little gem is when they have tasting events in the store and if you give them your email, they let you know about their events that are coming up. I've walked in on a few tastings and as a result have walked out with new spirits to add to my home bar collection. Great wine selection too!

    This has been my liquor/wine spot of choice since many other places have either been closed, or not…read morehad great service in picking up spirits. During Coronavirus time, they have created an intricate system of helping customers get what they need. This included a wooden barrier with a hole to speak into, a rotating wooden delivery system that you can put payment into, and after they process will give it back to you with the items you choose. They are in good spirits, and will help you choose what you need. They wear gloves and masks, and speak to you over the speaker system they have created. I found my High West Campfire here, as well as the other wines we needed to stock. However, a few more times after coming in, the service has been rude to me, and scolded me for lingering too long, and also I have found other places with better prices around the area.

    Photos
    Barrels & Stills
    Did you know Sangiovese from Emilia Romagna is better than from Tuscany? I think so and this bottle did it for me. It's a must try.
    Did you know Sangiovese from Emilia Romagna is better than from Tuscany? I think so and this bottle did it for me. It's a must try.
    Barrels & Stills

    See all

    Superstar Beverage

    Superstar Beverage

    1.7
    (6 reviews)
    2.5 mi

    Great location on Rt110/Walt Whitman rd in Melville. They have a wide variety of domestic and…read moreInternational beers...and yes that means IPAs too folks! I have particularlly utilized this location to get local Long Island beers [Goose Island last year and Great South Bay this year - personally love that GSB Blood Orange :) ] for the two local Melville, LI Shave-off events that I have coordinated/hosted for my company. Yeah Movember for Mens Healthcare Awareness month. Yes fellas that's right I care about your health and your tastebuds too! You grew it out and handled the the itch for a whole month (hopefully with some aid from our fabulous prestige products ;) and I'm smart enough to know a nice cold IPA on the way in before you face the blade is welcomed. This location has wonderful staff that are quick efficient and very helpful to any query you might have from: beer selection/location in store, ice quantities needed, cooler bucket rentals, waters and more. The fellas always willing to give you a hand to bring your purchased items to your car, which is a nice personal touch too. Especially when you are making sure to have enough for your event (personal or private). I highly recommend a stop at this location whether it's for something big or small for that night. Thanks to all the Superstars at this beverage center.

    I walked in with three large bags that were already separated--one for bottles, one for cans, and…read moreone for plastic containers. I had five children with me because we were trying to teach them the importance of recycling and taking care of the environment. Instead of a simple recycling experience, we spent about 25 minutes going through everything. The employee told us that they only accept containers they sell and kept throwing items he wouldn't take into a separate bin. When I asked whether they were required to accept all eligible deposit containers under New York State law, he told me, "No. What am I supposed to do, go to Uncle Giuseppe's? If you bought the bottle from Uncle Giuseppe's, take it there." I found his attitude extremely rude, dismissive, and unhelpful. What should have been a positive learning experience for the children turned into a frustrating and disappointing one. I ended up going to Giuseppe's...took plastic, glass and cans in one machine, way easier & which five minutes!!

    Photos
    Superstar Beverage
    Superstar Beverage

    See all

    Superstar Beverage

    Superstar Beverage

    4.5
    (15 reviews)
    3.1 mi
    $$

    Owner was knowledgeable and offered assistance in a pinch. Has a great selection of beer and…read moreminiature kegs which is exactly what I was after.

    Awful customer service. I will never buy anything from this store again. The store manager, Chris,…read morewas rude and unprofessional. We ordered a keg from the Huntington store for our Oktoberfest party and it unfortunately did not work properly, not sure if the tap or the keg itself was to blame. Chris blamed us, even though a number of people at our party tried various approaches to get the keg to dispense beer throughout the night, and a few of us also tried again the next day before returning it. Mostly sputtering foam came out, so we ended up having to return a keg that was more than half full, which was disappointing and expensive, considering we paid full price for a keg we barely used and had to supplement with additional bottles and cans. When I notified Chris of this he gave me an attitude and said he would check the keg and get back to me with an update, but he didn't do so. I called him to follow up so we could close the loop, but he kept putting me off and then dodged my calls. I'm pretty sure he answered the phone and pretended to be someone else one of the times I called to find out what the status was too. Ridiculous. Mistakes happen. I thought maybe he could give me a credit or a discount on a future purchase since our keg purchase was mostly useless, but I didn't count on that. I wasn't sure what he would offer to do, if anything. I did at least expect him to address the situation with me, a paying customer, instead of ignoring and avoiding me. We've hosted this party for the past 9 years and we've never had an issue with kegs we got from other vendors. I've also bought beer at this Huntington store and their Melville location many times in the past. There are plenty of distributors with good beer selections, though, so I'll be patronizing them in the future. Superstar has lost this customer for good.

    Photos
    Superstar Beverage
    Superstar Beverage
    Superstar Beverage

    See all

    NY Craft Beer - beer_and_wine - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...