Food and service always excellent Especially their veal cutlet subsand their steak fries All of their subs are great. read more

Always a pleasure to go there I've been going there for years. The pizzas are great. The sandwiches are excellent. Give the meatball a try. He makes them himself this parking in the rear. read more

Excellent food, service and price. Great menu and fresh ingredients. Give them a try you won't regret it.

There's no better for sure been going just about every week for 50yearsawesome steak subs their meatball and veal parm ( real veal ) and there pizza is the best around lower price than other pizza shops read more

Nickey's is back and better than ever!! Pepperoni Pizza and the various subs are terrific!! A great family run business with great and fresh ingredients and everything is done the right way!! The best in Lynn and around!! read more

I was literally standing by the corner and saw so many people coming out of this place with boxes of pizza. My curiosity got me to taste a delicious plain pizza. Soooooo Good !!! Definitely coming back.. read more

Nickey's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lynn, Massachusetts

Nice folks own the place, it's kind of strange like stepping back in time. There's probably about 10 people behind the counter, they all look related. The inside probably has never been updated since they first opened. It was clean though and all the many people working there were very friendly. Sadly the pizza was pretty crummy. The crust was tough, and had much too much sauce. The sausage topping was pretty horrid too. Tasted like a cafeteria... I'm so sorry to be unkind, but I must be honest and this place wasn't for me. Maybe someone else would love it? Different strokes right???? read more

Mom and Pop shop with pre-COVID pricing. Pizza and steak and cheese subs are good. Sub was about $8. Can't beat that with a bat.

This is an old school sub shop with a good menu, from the fries to the subs are good. My favorite is the double dough pizza with toppings. The prices are fair for what you get and I definitely recommend trying this place. read more

Nickey's Pizza - Double dough pizza / mushrooms & pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Lynn, Massachusetts

See all

Awesome Steak & Cheese subs! I just wish they were a bit larger (I'd definitely pay more!)

Nickys been closed for at least 3 weeks and i am having withdrawals for a steak and cheese or a pizza tell me guys are taken a long over due trip back to the old country ! read more

Best pizza in Lynn, I've been going here since I was a kid. They also have excellent subs. The veal cutlet is real veal and meatballs are home made. Not like Fauci's pizza. I once asked if the meatballs were made there and was told yes. But they were the small frozen type you can get at Walmart. read more

Miss Nick and his family so much. Great pizza, cheese steak with provolone. Family run business and very accommodating. Great staff. Closed during pandemic. Hopefully, opening soon. read more

Great pizza, great prices, very polite staff, they kept it original and feels very homey. Wayyy better than faucis pizza down the street. They do not deliver and only accept cash. There is an atm inside. They pizza and subs are cheap and big in size and flavor read more

See all

I've always loved Nickeys's pizza, I grew up on it so did my family and friends. Subs are great too even as a vegetarian!

Been coming here for over 40 years. Best pizza in New England as far as I'm concerned. Quality has been consistent for decades. Nicky still works making the pizzas after all these years. I never realized how addicted I was until they burned down a few years back and I had cravings specifically for their unique blend of flavors. They still prep the ingredients and don't use the bagged frozen crap that a lot of places have switched to. That goes a long way with me. Their subs, particularly the steak bomb, are great too. read more

If you're looking for the best steak & cheese sub....you found it. I used to live in town 40 years ago and their subs are exactly as I remember. The same owners. WTG Nickey I hope you have many more successful years to come. Cya next I'm in town. read more

The best pizza and french fries in the city!! Very basic menu of pizza, subs, fries, and chicken fingers. The pizza is super cheap (under $10 for a large), but so fresh and delicious. Posting this review though because of the great staff/owner. I brought my son in one day to pick up our food (no delivery, cash only) and the nice lady behind the counter gave my son some free cookies because he was being so good. There are many pizza places in the city, but this is by far the best. read more

Only had the pizza but it is one of the best on North shore. Good crust, mild sauce and traditional toppings. Prices are unbeatable (13.50 for large three topping pizza). Family run operation. Thoroughly recommend. Reminder that it is cash only. read more

I had Nicky's for the first time when I officially became an adult and quickly realized that the first 18 years of my life were wasted. You know, as far as pizza is concerned. Nicky's has delicious pizza, awesome fat fries, and great subs. I'm personally all about the pizza, but there's something there for everyone if pizza isn't your thing. (And if pizza's not your thing, I should Yelp you, you weirdo.) Since you may not trust my taste buds, let's go through a list of important criteria in judging any pizza place and see how Nicky's holds up, shall we? Taste: Delicious Speed: Super fast Prize: Amazingly cheap Staff: Very nice Accuracy: Always cooked to specifications Nicky's is superior in almost every category. The only thing I can even think to list as a con is that they don't deliver. Of course, it's right down the street so that really doesn't mean anything to me. I just really wanted to find a single con so I could show that my Nicky's love isn't biased. If you're in the area and you want pizza, go to Nicky's. It's way better, cheaper, and fresher than the pizzas you'll find anywhere else in the area. And unlike some other pizza places around here, these people really deserve your business. read more

I don't get back to Lynn very often anymore, but whenever I do, a stop at Nicky's is mandatory. I've been eating here since I was a little kid and it's as good as it ever was. The pizza is always fantastic and most days you still see Nicky standing there making them and directing traffic in the shop. This trip I got a steak bomb for the ride home, and it was awesome, steak, cheese peppers, onion and salami delicious. I also got my standard small Italian no pickle, and again it was perfect. if you're in the area do yourself a favor, stop in for a sub or pizza you won't regret it. read more

Small joint, we came here after a training at MGH with a few coworkers and was not disappointed. My coworker grew up in the area and said they make one hell of a steak and cheese and I was not disappointed. Three subs with french fries for only 20 bucks is a steal. Family owned place that has been in operation for well over 40 years. Would absolutely come back, super friendly staff and great food at a great price! read more

I'm a little ashamed to admit this, but being a life-long Lynn Girl, I have never eaten at Nicky's until very recently. What the heck was I thinking!?!??!? This place is awesome!!! Everything is cooked to perfection, exactly the way you order it. You know a place is good when it's been around for so long and doesn't do delivery and is cash only. Will be going back again and again. Give it a try....you won't be disappointed. read more

Better than Faucy's. That isn't saying much though. There aren't many quick and decent pizza places in the area so you may as well stop here. read more

Usually get my pizza here once a week. I almost always come and pick it up myself that way it's nice and hot by the time I get it home. The pizza is very tasty and cooked well and a large cheese pizza cost $10, a great deal nowadays. I have always got the cheese pizza so I cannot give any other recommendations At this time. They have a parking lot behind the shop and I recommend this pizza place highly. read more

Great pizza. Man who answered the phone was super pleasant. I will be ordering again soon.

I came across a suggestion for Nickey's while searching for a place to grab a pizza while staying in Boston for a few weeks. I wasn't let down, the pizza is just like the pizza I grew up on in New Jersey. Thin crust, just enough crispyness eat by hand without flopping all over or breaking when you fold it. I think it was 8.50 for a large cheese pizza, a real large, not one of those 12 or 16 inch large pizza's. I would recommend this small corner pizza shop to anyone staying north or east of boston. ::They only take cash so plan ahead:: read more

I'm giving it one star because it smelled good when I walked in, so their pizza is probably as good as people say. Customer service is horrible,though! After waiting a half hour, I went to pick up my pizza, and THEN they told me it's cash only. No mention of it anywhere online, and they didn't say anything about it when I ordered. When traveling, as I was tonight, I eat on per diem and pay with a company credit card. There's nothing wrong with running a "cash only" business, I get that. But there IS something wrong with not telling people that when they order! You'd think after throwing a zillion pizzas in the trash, they would wise up, but evidently not.... read more

I am very picky . I can say with out a doubt I have never been disappointed. They always use quality ingredients that don't cost a fortune. they r a true gem! read more

We've been ordering pizza and subs from Nicky's for at least the last few years and have always found the food to be really good. Pizza is always hot and fresh and the subs are never disappointing. Have gotten the steak bomb, chicken parm sub, chicken finger sub, meatball, turkey, italian, etc. ---all delicious! Plus the guys who work here are always so nice! Definitely recommend going here if you live in the area or are passing through. read more

After being away from the East Coast for a number of years I was dying for a true veal cutlet sub. This place has Italian food that is second to none. read more

Nickey's is an old fashioned local gem with thin NY style pizza. I like my pizza cooked well done and my pizza is always cooked to specification. 10 bucks for the pizza- and I'm never disappointed. Closed on Sundays. No delivery- no credit cards- and 100% take out. read more

I grew up on Lynnfield St about half way between Nicky's and it's competitor. We always got pizza at the competitor (for reasons I don't know) and steak bombs at Nicky's. Well, when I got old enough to decide for myself, I switched to Nicky's. I'm almost 50 now and Nicky's is still going strong. Nicky's has excellent, thin crust pizza. Generous toppings, perfectly cooked, always fresh hot and delicious. I love that they have Salami, a lot of places don't nowadays and it's excellent on pizza. They also have steak fries instead of shoestrings, my favorite, they actually stay hot till you get them home and are crispy and perfectly cooked as well. The subs are delicious too, bread really fresh and generous with the fillings. They make the best (though, admittedly not the largest), steak bomb in the area. Props also for their homemade veal parm sub......Delicious!! Thank you Nicky (who is there frequently) for all these years of excellent food!!! One note, Nicky's does not accept credit or debit cards but has an atm on the premises, they do not deliver, and they are closed on Sundays. read more

The Best!!! Here's how I can put it most easliy. They don't deliver and it's cash only and yes this a review written in the year 2011 and yet their consistency for awesomeness mitigates the inconvenience because to me there is no other. The prices can't be beaten but the quality and quantity of ingredients have never suffered in the 27 years I've gone there read more

Best Pizza on the North Shore- Have been getting his awesome pizza since he first opened- I only wish I could get his pizza in Dallas, Texas :( read more

It's hard, if not impossible, to find a good pizza place in Lynn but Nicky's was a nice surprise! Great crust and really nice sauce - not too sweet and not too spicy. Crust is thin and crisp and chewy! They have off street parking, the place is clean, the people are friendly, the food is good and very reasonably priced! Try it! read more

Another great pizza. Hand cut pepperoni with a good amount of sauce. Not dry! Steak fries are good (they salt them). I was not impressed with their chicken parm sub. Thought they would have real chicken cutlets but they seemed frozen. I'll stick to the pizza. Cash only place! read more

Nickey's Pizza - Awesome hand sliced pepperoni pizza. Good amount of sauce, not dry! - Pizza Near Me - Lynn, Massachusetts

Another lifelong Lynner that waited way too long. I've heard raves about Nicky's my whole life but probably dismissed them because they don't deliver. Then a couple of days ago, I got a hold of their menu and couldn't believe how inexpensive they were. So I figured I wouldn't be losing much if I didn't like it. My wife picked up the pizza for me; a large bacon pizza. I opened it up and at first I was disappointed. It appeared they had really skimped out on the bacon, but appearances can be deceptive; most of the bacon was buried beneath the cheese. In fact, toppings turned out to be quite generous. The sauce and crust were both excellent and noticeably homemade. Definitely not a Greek (frozen crust) pizza. I'd give it 5 stars but it was my first time there and I would only give that rating if I've seen consistency. I will be going back often, so maybe an upgrade later. Highly recommended. read more

Haven't had Nickeys in well over 10 years. Got a pepperoni pizza the other day and it was delicious. Mad at myself for missing out on this gem for so long. This will def be my go to the next time I want a roni pizza. Would have been 5 stars but they don't deliver and only take cash. read more

It's my favorite pizza place in the area - and there's lots of good ones. Good, cheap, fresh, basic pizza - made right by people who have made thousands of them before. They don't use typical pepperoni in their pizza... it's way better. If I'm in the mood for pepperoni, this is where I always get it, 100% of the time. I usually get take out, but there's some tables inside. I think they deliver, but I'm not 100% sure. One caveat: this is an old fashioned, family place - they're closed on Sundays. read more