We were in Fairfield for the weekend visiting cousins. Nobody wanted to cook, so we ordered delivery through DoorDash on Sunday night. We got an extra-large cheese pizza, a Vegetarian Special, a Meat Lovers and 12 hot wings. That gave us something for everyone. The veggie fans and the meat lovers were both happy. Everything was yummy. The order arrived about 30 minutes after we placed it. That's quick for a Sunday dinner rush. read more

Had to try this pizza place & am NOT disappointed. I ordered the large vegetarian adding jalapeños & artichoke hearts. Pizza was covered with fresh toppings and crust on point. Definitely will be back to try more. Take out only though with three chairs to wait inside. The young lady who took my order was pleasant giving an precise wait time of 20 minutes. I went at 5pm on a Tuesday night. I'll have to remember to take a pic for round 2. read more

This is a dam good pizza quick and friendly service. This is takeout only spot, they use quality toppings and their crust is delicious. What really impressed me the most, is that this is affordable!!! A two topping large pizza cost me just over $16, I really appreciate that especially in these messed up times we live in where everyone is out to gouge people for more money. Keep up the great work! Won't be getting pizza from anywhere else in Fairfield... unless it's from Heretic, those pies are next level! read more

The pizza is perfect and affordable i mean a really great quality pizza for a great price, and the ladies in the front are very polite.

Location and ambiance are super sketch, and service is alright, but the pizza is BOMB. We get the Calm Casino and Bianca pizzas every time. Freaking delicious. We once placed a large order for 20+ extra-large pizzas for a birthday party and the staff was easy to work with. Everything came out fine and on time. But seriously though, just get the pizza. Hella good. read more

For a takeout pizza place this is the spot where you're gonna get more bang for your buck. The pizzas are super delicious and budget friendly . every time I've ordered in the girls are super nice. The guys are too. The only reason why I give them four stars is cause they do not offer packets of Parmesan and peppers. I don't even believe they have napkins and plates. . read more

I went there when we first moved here 4 years ago and it was awful! This year I gave it a second chance and it is now my go to pizza in Fairfield. They don't skimp on the toppings and the pizza is hot when you pick it up. It's not the best pizza ever, but nothing in Fairfield is. When you add price to the equation, and you're looking for an affordable reliable pizza this is your spot. read more

Best pizza in town, my family loves this place, it's the only place we'll order pizza from now.

This is a great pizza place! Pizza is always piping hot, perfectly prepared and soul satisfying! Our go to pizza is Veggie with added jalapeños for a kick! read more

The pizza is great! Please fix your online ordering it says 11pm instead of 11am on Wednesdays so I can't place an order or it has to be through DoorDash which hikes the price up $7 read more

Yes for the value. No for as other people have said the customer service. Very rude, no smiles, straight forward. I also don't like a kitchen when it's blocked by a two way mirror. Never a good sign. With that said eaten here while at work a few times and we've all said it taste good, crust is good, cheese/sauce taste good. Very good value Just wish the mirror would come down, so can see how clean and what's going on. read more

I've been here a couple of times and it's always unpleasant from ordering to eating. Might as well just get little caesar's and save some money. Very salty one of my pizzas were undercooked. The service is poor and rushed. read more

Best pizza in Fairfield!!! Hands down. No joke! This place is awesome! I'm not going to lie a little sketch walking up at night, the inside reminds me of an old cannabis club iykyk lol but overall the pizza is great! No indoor dining, tried the other items on the menu, they were meh but when it comes down to pizza these guys know their stuff! Did I mention the price was cheap af! Large for a little over $17 crazy! Trust me this spot is a must try if you are in the area and if you want to switch up the norm round mush table or soggy Pizza Hut definitely give NYP a shot! You won't regret it! read more

I was in the area for a work trip. I had a lot of pizza during the week lol. This place was by far the best tasting pizza around. I had the meat lovers and it was loaded with meat, tons of cheese, it was saucy, and the crust was crispy. Mind you I ate this at the hotel about 20 minutes after it was made. The location is a bit sketchy but what place isn't in that area. Do yourself a favor and try this place out! read more

Ordered the XL New York Special ... felt like the XL was a bit disappointing in size but the flavors were all there. Friendly service over the phone and when picking up the pizza order. No inside dining. Ample parking. Pizza was on time. Will definitely have to come back to try the other pizza options and calzones. 3.50 for a small condiment container for anchovies if you are an anchovy fan. read more

The Clams Casino was excellent. I do not see this pizza at many establishments. They did an outstanding job on this including the seasoning and the dough was cooked just right. The price was amazing for a pizza of this caliber and with these kind of toppings. read more

Haven't had their pizza, but their calzones are...not worth the price, to put it nicely. I was nearby for a job and was looking forward to some NY pizza, but very, very disappointing. Way too cheesy and not enough toppings (pepperoni and jalapeño) to balance it out. It was pretty good warm, but when I took a bite on my drive home from work, it was bleh. Cold pizza is supposed to taste good still. At least the good ones are! Also, what kinda NY pizza doesn't have slices?! Why 3 stars? Cuz the calzone was not the worst and maybe if I try their pizza, I may change my mind. Next time, don't put too much cheese. It's like y'all made a pizza and folded it in half. I'm sure that's how you make a calzone, but don't put the same amount of cheese. Cheese-us Crust! read more

New York Pizza Express - Inside the calzone. - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, California

Called and ordered a large pepperoni with extra cheese and extra pepperoni and they put so much cheese on the pizza my daughter could not even enjoy it , I hope they were not being sarcastic by putting so much cheese it was not even edible , doesn't seem like the type of business that would care or fix the issue so I didn't even take it back , but wanted to write a review so other people could see how they do business. The price of their pizzas have constantly been raised at a ridiculous rate , used to be the cheapest pizza in town now they have raised prices and the quality is not as good as it used to be read more

NYPE is the spot! It's tucked away in a janky looking plaza, home to a smoke shop and some other random places I haven't really noticed. There's always a lot of ransoms hanging around outside so just a heads up. It's an unassuming little hole in the wall, but you find treasures where you least expect it sometimes! Their pizza specials are really good! A large combo is $11, and a single topping large is only $6! That's a steal, considering the pizza is pretty damn good. I did order a pesto pizza and added chicken and that came out to be about $22ish so don't expect all their pizzas to be cheap. I would advise going for the specials if you're watching your budget. This place is different because they don't put their toppings on top, ironic right?! The toppings are layered between the sauce and cheese. So, crust, sauce, toppings, then cheese on top! They use a lot of cheese too!! So extra brownie points for that! My dad was super skeptical about getting pizza from this spot. He's a little bougie about things sometimes but after one slice, he was a believer! Check this place out the next time you want some pizza! read more

Not really New York style pizzas, but good for their price. Vicini's is the only place in town I see that's really New York style. But this place is fine read more

Pizza is a food item that we all can rejoice over. It brings people together and its' purpose is to be shared. Luckily, NY Pizza Express is within our reach for a small gathering with my family. We ordered one 3 Meat Combo pizza and one Veggie pizza (both large) and they were good for a party of six. (We also had other food.) The toppings were plentiful and they did not skimp out unlike other spots that I've experienced. FYI, the pizza is a bit greasy (via Yelpers and my Dad can agree) but pizza is something we don't indulge in often, so it was fine with us for this occasion. I'd recommend coming here if you are in need of some last minute dinner/party plans. They don't allow orders ahead of time, so just call 20 minutes before your anticipated pick-up time. read more

By far the best pizza in Fairfield. To-go only, all their energy goes into making a great pizza

Order a med clam pizza. The pizza I received was more like a cheese pizza. The pizza hardly had any clams in it, if any at all each slice must had only one clam each. Probably would of received more stars. read more

Best pizza ever always fresh and on time my kids love it 100% recommend I always order for parties

Oh man I ordered from this place so many times in one week. I found this place because believe it or not, most of these so-called pizza places do not serve anchovies anymore. These guys did. In fact they have a pizza that has anchovies in it. There Napoli pizza has artichoke hearts, garlic, anchovies, and mozzarella. Damn its so good and so tasty mmhmmmmmmmmmhmmm. A shame I don't have a picture because the times I've ordered it I inhale the entire pizza. Oh, and I always order via DooDash and my pizza is always nice hot n perfect. read more

Stromboli was a greasy mess. Nasty part of town. Had better Stromboli and pizza down the street

Good pizza and chicken wings. A small to go pizza place not too bad. I recommend the place to get fast food.

I've passed this place many a times and didn't think to stop and try them out. My family normally chooses to eat pizza at least once a week. I was tired of the "major" chains and during this pandemic, I was wanting to support my local small businesses. My bestie suggested I try the pizza and I was quite pleased! My family isn't too over the top with their pizza selection; they have the basic menu items and some extras that would suite those with a more advanced pizza palette than my household's. Their pizza crust is quite good. It doesn't taste like cardboard and the texture is very much to my liking, a little thick, but fluffy! The sauce isn't overwhelming and their aren't stingy with their toppings. I will say they aren't in the greatest area, but they are definitely a hidden gem. The staff is friendly; they are quick to serve you. There isn't really a space to wait, so it's definitely suggested to call in your order in advance. The pricing for their pizza is very affordable in comparison to the major chains. It's certainly a place where you get your money's worth. read more

See all

Nothing fancy, hole it wall type spot. No thrills or frills. Go in.. Very bare inside, order what you like off the menu... And you will sink your teeth into one tasty pie. 7.99 for a large 3 meat?!! Count me in! Plus an Xtra buck for extra cheese.... And man, was it cheesy lol. I'm use to places skimping on the cheese.. Even after I ask for extra. But man this tasted like I got the whole bag. I got well worth my 9.xx I paid. Will return in the near future, may not get extra cheese, seems they are very generous with a regular amount. So all in all.... I recommend it! Thx Yelp for leading me here, I was going to hit pizza Hut like I usually do.. Glad I didn't. read more

New York Pizza Express - Large, 3 meat (pepperoni, sausage and bacon) +Xtra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, California

Just moved to Fairfield from Chicago & was looking for a good pizza spot that wasn't mainstream. Found this spot via google and decided to try them out. The location was kind of sketchy so we drove around in hopes of finding something else. After 15 mins of no luck, we decided to order from here. When we got home & tried it, we were VERY surprised. This pizza was AMAZING & was only $10.99 for a Large. Mindless to say, we've been coming back ever since haha. Try them out, it's pretty tasty for the price and location read more

Have tried many places around and have tried this place twice so far and been delicious. The sauce to cheese to crust ratio is spot on and its been great both times. Finding consistency in pizza especially when getting it delivered is always a challenge but so far they have been spot on. The wings were delicious also. Looking forward to ordering it again tonight. read more

Okay, I've been a resident of Fairfield since 1986 and it wasn't until this year did I try New York Pizza Express, good lord am I glad I did. I literally could eat pizza 3 times a week, especially from here. The crust is light and fluffy and airy and has a good chew not to mention it crisps nicely on the edges. The sauce ratio is on point, it's hearty, has a good acidic balance. Cheesy goodness with a fantastic "cheese pull" (my 12yr old). Now for toppings. They have so many options but we kinda stick to the same things. Again I have little kids and a husband who's picky so one thing we all agree on is BACON. Let that sink in. Crispy. Tasty. Salty. Savory bacon in all of its glory. I don't know what kind of voodoo they do on the bacon but Jesus! Its on another level. No other place here in town has bacon remotely close to the gold they sprinkle atop my pie. Affordable as all hell. A large will feed 4, 3 slices each (sometimes I double cut to give the illusion of more ha ha (I have little kids man). In my book they check all the boxes. Did I mention it's like a 20 min pick up time? Insane. So if your looking for a pie, give 'em a try! read more

This place need to up their prices. They are too cheap. The pizza is great. I used to love round table pizza, But I love this pizza because they have extra layers of cheese and veggies and meat on there Pizza without changing. They need to move and price their pizza like Mikes Mountain Pizza. Mikes pizza suck. Bad customer service and the pizza taste terrible. They don't even know how to make a great pizza. They should follow New York Pizza in Fairfield. I wish they had tables to sit at and a bathroom. But Mikes does have tables and bathrooms but they are tiny and I went to wash my hands and no soap and they are bad at having toilet paper. I had the runs after eating at Mikes. Round table sucks too. The bathroom are just full of pee. But not New York Pizza. If you are looking for great pizza this is the best pizza in Fairfield and Suisun City California. New York has the perfect pizza but no bathroom and no tables. They are great I guess because they have no overhead. Go to this Pizza place, oh yah Cesar Caesars needs to close down because they have the worst customer service and the best shitty pizza on this planet!!!! NEW YORK PIZZA IS THE BEST PIZZA!!!! A little hint if they can leave the salt off the Pizza would make it the best thing to happen to pizza But New York is the best pizza overall!!!! read more

Pizza is ok, but the staff are rude!!!! Girl on the phone took my order, interrupting me several times to speak with a co-worker. Had to repeat my order many times. Ordered a pesto pizza with mushrooms. Got home and opened the box to see a cheese pizza. Called the store only to get rude remarks from the original girl who took my order. She stated I never ordered mushrooms, so it was my fault.. she said if I bring my pizza back, she will give me a refund. Never said anything about correcting the mistake. I also asked he why the prices were higher than posted on their online menu and she said it wasn't updated yet. New York pizza express needs new employees that are polite AND educated, but from reading other reviews the owner is the same way. I will never go back!! read more

A perfect hole in the wall. Best pizza in Fairfield! Period. My coworker turned me on to the hot freshly made pizza joint and yes it is good pricing and good pizza! I love it read more

New York Pizza Express - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, California

This is our family's favorite pizza place in town. When you call they're always ready in 20 minutes. The crust is tasty, good amount of toppings. They're pineapple and Canadian bacon has a great lately smoky flavor to the meat. The price is also very good. Is it the absolute best pizza I've ever had... Probably not, but it's pretty darn good pizza! Every time we try somewhere else, it cost twice as much and it's only half as good. This place is the best one in Fairfield! read more

Haven't been here in forever but it use to be good and reasonably priced considering portion sizes. Staff was friendly order was prepared quickly read more

This pizza is fire. I'm from east coast and have always been disappointed with pizza in Fairfield until now. This will be my go-to place from now on. I had a somewhat complicated order (I wanted half n half) and with the doordash order system that wasn't possible. A simple phone call to them helped me sort it out and give them a headsup. The order came perfect as requested via leaving a message on the order item. I've never had better pizza in California and I've been here for 10 years. The wings were bomb af too, some of the best I've had. This my definitely my new favorite pizza place. Thank you! read more

The best HOLE ON THE WALL pizza!!! Never buying commercial pizza.. theirs is big and a lot of toppings

They have really.great.pizza. it's hot, fresh and very.inexpensive. it's in a great area.next to.Goodwill.