This was an amazing experience I really like this place. It was really cool. The service here is…read moreawesome.

Perfecto! Such wonder flavors and you can try before committing. All the staff is full of smiles…read moreand very friendly. How could you not be when you are surrounded by delicious gelato. Word of warning, the smpace inside is very small. You are better waiting outside until it's your turn.

Beautiful store. Lovely cards. They sell Jellycat stuffed toys! Cool cards. Great choice of quality…read moregifts. The proprietors are helpful and kind. I look forward to returning. Thanks for a great experience.

Window shopping in Sayville today and glad to see the former Sayville General Store is now occupied…read moreand open again. Good Things is very similar to the General Store, but has more items I personally would purchase. I particularly love their children's section, the selection of clothes books and toys is superb. I was very glad to see they sell some of the glass baubles the General Store used to sell. A much smaller selection, but I hope it's something they continue to stock. Staff was polite and I enjoyed they weren't overly pushing a sale.

Awesome steaks! Epic craft beer can selection- several Other Half choices and other solid local…read morebeers

We booked this restaurant for catering for my sister's wedding and everything was confirmed well in…read moreadvance. The menu, pricing, and logistics were all agreed upon, and we were relying on them for a major part of the event. Very last minute--close enough to the wedding that it left us scrambling--they backed out without a real solution or adequate support to help us replace the service. For an event of this size and importance, that level of unreliability is unacceptable. There was no sense of accountability or urgency in helping us fix the situation they created. It put a lot of unnecessary stress on what should have been a special day. I would not recommend them for any event where dependability actually matters.

Such a wonderful weekly market. Selling everything from amazing sweets to freshly made Neapolitan…read morestyle pizza to even fresh made pasta! Of course the market essentials like fresh locally grown fruits & veggies are available for purchase as well. Located at The Islip Grange in Sayville. Plenty of free parking available. Stands that stick out to me- 1. Hester & Pearl: they have amazing sweets!!! 2. Pickle Packin Papa: selling delicious pickled goodies. 3. Until The Dough Runs Out: cooking up amazing Neapolitan Pizza's Come on down to Sayville and check it out Every Saturday 9am-2pm

Great local farmers market! Everything you need each Sat 9am-2pm. Fresh local produce and vendors…read morefrom Long Island.

After being a long time instagram follower, I finally made my way to this artisanal cheese shop. I…read morewasn't sure what to expect when walking inside- if they'd have premade platters, if they'd make platters on request, if cheese was pre sliced or more like a deli counter. The two staff members walked me through their store like a breeze. I asked for their top recommendation each, and they came through beautifully. One was a triple crème and the other was a balsamic cheese. Both delicious. After a sample I got a small portion of each to take home. They sell all the bits to make a board if you wanted, I picked up some gluten free crackers as well. I was very happy with my experience and will return for a board or more cheeses for parties going forward

Quality artisan Italian fare , very high prices and a little bit of an attitude. This place would…read morebe perfect in East Hampton or Manhasset but most Sayvillians are priced out of this market. If I hit the lottery, I would shop here every day, but until then I must say goodbye after years as a loyal customer. Guys behind the counter seem to make up the prices as they go; poor customer service. Farewell my friend, I will miss your your crab cakes most. Very clean store and perfect for high end catering. Minus 3 stars for unreasonably high price points.

With the change in ownership, their food is absolutely amazing, service has changed for the better,…read moresome notable changes inside and so much more organized! good Pizza right next door too!

It's a really cute spot with fresh flowers and fresh fruit. I love stopping by & picking up some…read moreplants as gifts ect. The parking situation is a pain though because there is hardly any space ect

excellent assortment of various plants and flowers. Some of the best tomatoes and corn I have ever…read moregotten anywhere, good cheeses and baked goods. Always friendly and helpful service.

I have been going to Cornucopia for 30 plus years. Their selection is really good and their sales…read moreare truly sales !! Their staff is helpful and knowledgeable. The feel of community is apparent. Love this store !

I hear a lot of people talking about this coconut cult, yogurt, so I tried some and I do like it…read moreand do feel like it may be helping my tummy feel better. It might be also due to the lack of lactose in this particular brand. It is hard to find, but always in stock here Cornucopia. That is what initially drew me here. The store is has an organic earthy tone, layered wood displays with mute tones. It feels like shopping in a cozy enchanted forest. With fresh things growing everywhere. They seem to have a little bit of everything. I enjoy the FRESH goodies at the counter as you check out, they are all amazing. Something else to check out is the app called to " TooGoodToGo" it has $10.00 surprise bags for here so you can also add a great deal to the trip and wait for your exciting surprise. So even though it was the coconut colt that brought me into the store, I find myself coming back more and more. I enjoy the shopping experience and excellent customer service.

Not too often I see a store so well stocked, clean and bright. Not recommended to go when your…read morereally hungry and cash is low right before payday! Exemplary!

Wow! I visited the…read morebrand-new Uncle Giuseppe's in Bohemia today (11/14/25), not realizing it was actually their grand opening; and what a fantastic surprise! The moment I walked through the doors, I could tell this location is something special. The entire store was incredibly well stocked, from the produce and deli to the specialty items and bakery. Everything looked fresh, organized, and thoughtfully displayed. The smells throughout the store were absolutely amazing!! The kind of inviting, comforting aromas that make you want to explore every aisle. You could immediately tell how much care went into preparing the fresh foods and baked goods. But the biggest highlight was the staff. Every single employee I came across was welcoming, friendly, and genuinely happy to help. Even though it was their opening day and likely very busy behind the scenes, they all carried themselves with such professionalism and warmth. It created a really enjoyable shopping atmosphere and made the experience feel personal. Overall, this new location exceeded all my expectations. It's refreshing to see a store open with such attention to detail, amazing customer service, and a truly inviting environment. I'm excited to make this one of my regular stops! Very happy to have it closer to home! Welcome to the community!

I love the oils and vinegars here. You can taste the different varieties in small cups or dip bread…read morein them. I wish they had plain gluten free crackers to sample the flavors. My favorite oil is the white truffle. It's expensive but worth every penny. I enjoy it on grilled vegetables. Some of the sweet vinegars are nice over berries or ice cream. Go in around the holidays for their lovely gift baskets.

The Crushed Olive is the newest addition to Sayville and a welcome addition to Long Island's…read moregourmet food scene. This new location on Main Street is in addition to their two existing Long Island locations in Huntington and Stony Brook. Offering an unmatched variety of premium olive oil and balsamic vinegar you will be sure to find the perfect fit for your family's taste. The Crushed Olive offers everything from your basic Extra Virgin Olive Oil to more complex infused oils, bursting with flavors from Tuscan Herb and Persian Lime to Wild Mushroom & Sage and Herbs de Provence. I was also pleasantly surprised to find that many of their oils are certified organic! Not sure where to begin on your mission to find the perfect oil or vinegar? Fear not! The warm, Tuscan appointed décor invites you in to sample each and every oil and vinegar there is to offer. Feel free to peruse the many offerings, reading about each product and pouring yourself samples until you find and old favorite or an existing new selection. Besides, who doesn't love dipping pieces of crusty bread into the perfect olive oil or vinegar?