We just moved to Watertown a month ago and have been trying different pizza places in the area. We…read moreare on a quest to find a truly thin crust pizza so I was excited when I called and they said they could make one. I explained what I was looking for in great detail and the woman taking my order seemed really enthusiastic that it could be done. We ordered a large thin crust pizza and a large calzone. The thin crust wasn't that thin, but was definitely still tasty. The calzone was almost perfect. The crust was soft and flavorful, sprinkled with a light coating of parmesan cheese. You can request the sauce on the side, which I did. The sauce didn't really taste like much of anything, but the calzone didn't need it anyway. A little on the expensive side, but I would definitely eat here again.

The pizza here is amazing. The staff is as well. I'm visiting from Florida - and finally had a…read moregreat experience with a Watertown restaurant. I've been back 3 times.

Stopped by Papa Tino's and had a great meal. The pizza was cooked perfectly with a crispy crust,…read moreplenty of toppings, and great flavor in every bite. The wings were just as good -- juicy, well seasoned, and cooked just right. The antipasto salad was fresh and loaded with meats, cheese, and veggies, making it a perfect start to the meal. Everything tasted fresh and the portions were generous. Great spot for pizza night if you're craving good wings and a solid salad to go with it. Definitely worth a visit!

burnt pizza overcooked wings sad had better there before for take out…read morewings would have tasted good if not overcooked wut the fuk I give up this was the last time. i hate pulling a Karen sht but this wasn't cheap 2 times now from 2022 talk the wife to give them another shot,wish the ladies were back in charge.

Wings are large and well seasoned. I like my wings on the crispy side and these are perfectly…read morecrispy!!! The pizzas are very good as well. I haven't tried any of the other goodies but they all sound amazing!!! We have ordered a few times and they have always been consistent. Highly recommend!!

We ordered 2 pizzas and wings to give Creekside a try recently. The pizzas were decent, but we were…read moredisappointed to not be able to order 1 with garlic as is our custom. The wings were a bit on the small side, but were well sauced and full of flavor. Everything was ready on time as advised for a hassle-free time at pick up. Overall they seem to have the basics right, and now just need to work at perfecting what they have on offer.

Menu stated $4.25 a slice with a drink but yet charged us for it for EACH slice. I think it's a bit…read morewild we spent $18 for all this. Definitely a bit expensive. The restaurant itself was super clean and decorated with cute things. Pizza was great and barley any grease. Would come back with more money to spend.

Ordered 3 calzones, ended up being $50! with no cheese or ricotta. When it was brought to the…read moreassistant managers attention, she would only offer to remake them or give store credit. We didn't want to drive all the way back to Great Bend! No supper tonight and will never order from either Stefanos again. BE SURE TO TELL THEM YOU WANT CHEESE AND RICOTTA IN YOUR CALZONE or check before you head home.

My husband and I are unable to drive at this point in time. My husband is recovering from…read moreesophageal cancer and his goal to have a wonderful meatball sub. We've tried, and most of them in Watertown .stink! No Italian roll, no sauce. We have had a pizza from Nonna Dina before and it's very good. But this time we tried the subs. I got a mixed sub, which was great. My only wish was there was roast beef on it. My husband had a meatball sub. His comment was. " that's a real submarine sandwich!" We loved it and said this was like meatball subs should be. Thank you so much and we will be ordering from you again. If we could give you more than five stars or 10 stars we would!! Lin and Pat in Watertown

Nonna Dina's was amazing! Very clean establishment, very friendly staff, and fresh, homemade food…read more REAL pizza! Don't mind the picture of the garlic knots, we did order six and devoured two before I took a picture I live out of state, and can't wait until I'm in the area again to go back to Nonna Dina's!

First time ordering from this place. Just did online take out. Pizza was delicious! Just wish it…read moredidn't take almost 2 hours to get two smedium pizzas.... Employees seem nice though

I've been here many times. In the eighties it was my parents go-to and for pizza takeout. The…read morelady bartender who I've seen many times has absolutely no hospitality skills at all. She actually scolded me a few times. I will never ever ever sit with her at the bar again I paid and didn't even eat the food I ordered. A very hostile environment if you were not one of the regular customers. Shame on Arts Jug. I dont care how good or consistent the food is,,,,hospitality is far more important.

I LOVE Alteri's!! They are so accommodating, their breads and meats are fresh, their antipasto and…read moresausage breads are to die for, and their pastas and sauces outrageous!! And their meat cutter, Don Cornaire, is so wonderful!!

We've always loved the Italian Bread! Alteri's is one of our first stops when visiting from Palm…read moreBeach. We stock up on pizza, dinners, salads, and pastries before heading up to our summer home in Redwood. It saves me so much time when entertaining guests from out of town. Best Italian food ever!

The food is great and the customer service is phenomena! We were in and out in under an hour. Our…read morefood was delicious. Our waitress and the staff (especially Krissy P) were on top of everything and so sweet. 10/10 recommend!

I lived in Carthage a long time ago. I was at the original location across the street that burned…read moredown over 20 years ago. This place was still pretty good. Attentive service. I was alone and I was seated immediately. The restaurant was clean. Nice decorations. I do love pizza, but I've been eating a lot of pizza on this trip so I got a pasta dish. The manicotti. It was a little heavy on the cheese on top for sure. It was good but in the end, I guess I wish I would've got a pizza. Standard selection of National and some regional beer. I got a bottle of Yuengling. Street parking out front, parking lot in the back. There's a rear entrance as well.