Best New York Style pizza in town. Crispy crust and great toppings! The owners are amazing and remember us each time we order! Pizza doesn't take long read more

Worst experience ever Ask to put pizza back in the oven for few extra minutes and the worker gives me grief "this is how we make it" politely respond I like mine extra crispy. He keeps running his mouth. When he doesnt offer refund for being rude Tell him to keep the pizza and eat it himself. No respect for customer request at this establishment. Now I know why the place was empty at 1pm read more

Great food and great owners. Funny sense of humor and was very friendly with all of the guests! They were the only ones open during the freeze and we were so thankful to find them. If you are in the NRH/Watauga area come give it a try. We really enjoyed our food and our draft beers. Thanks for everything! We had hot lemon pepper wings (they made custom for us) and pepperoni pizza that was all fresh and cooked perfect. Looking forward to coming back!! (Couldn't wait to eat the pizza before we took a picture ) read more

My New York Pizza - Hot lemon pepper wings - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

See all

Best Pizza I have ever eaten in my life, and an Amazing owner! Give this place a visit, you won't regret it. read more

My New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

Great pizza and great atmosphere anchored by a new FULL bar! This is one of my favorite pizza spots. Don't let the surly man behind the counter scare you away. His pizza is awesome! This last visit we also had Lasagna, tasty, but too soupy for my taste. I'll probably stick to pizza. read more

My New York Pizza - Bar - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

Blew in because our usual pizza spot closer to home was closed Mondays, so we thought we'd give 'em a try. And they're really good! So I suppose we have another pizza option for the nearby rotation. We got a calzone and a stromboli and shared each other's. They were huge, and made well, and came out quick enough for "made to order". Of the two, we liked the stromboli a bit more. A fun side thing, I'm a nut for all things 80s, and this couple had the kickin'est deep cut music playin', and I mean italo-disco, Modern Talking, Sandra, Bad Boys Blue... I was VERY impressed! And when I mentioned it, I suppose they appreciated their taste to be recognized! I assured them I thought the food was good too! Haa!!! Anyway, meant a lot to me! Another aside, I notice some of the harsh reviews here make a stink about being unable to customize pizza-by-the-slice. I encourage anyone reading those reviews to realize that's not how pizza-by-the-slice works, the ability to make one huge POPULAR choice pizza and selling it to multiple customers. To ask them for a slice of pizza with a weird request (like no marinara) that nobody else would want, those customers are asking them to throw out out 80% of the remainder of pizza. If a customer wants something nobody else would want, get a whole pizza and don't blame them for not understanding the principle of pizza-by-the-slice. Anyway, just had to throw that in. Anyway, great place! read more

My New York Pizza - Stromboli & Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

See all

Convinced that not a single person in there has ever been to New York because that tastes worse than Little Cesar's. We came in to get "pizza by the slice" as advertised and they scammed us saying that they don't do that because they weren't going to make a pizza just for individual slices. Our only option was to spend $12 on their smallest pizza. They tried to sell us bottled water and when we refused and asked for water cups and they charged us $1.50 per cup with no ice (which was definitely tap water) and the cups were dirty inside. Pizza itself was disgusting. The crust was hard but the cheese was rubbery and just slid of the pizza like it wasn't even cooked with it. They took forever to get us our order and it was a bad experience overall. We come to this strip mall all the time and NEVER see anyone in there and now we know why. Such a shame cause it could be so good. I wouldn't come back here even if someone paid me to. read more

See all

I've tried a lot of pizza places, this is by far the best one. Excellent pizza and subs. Owners are dedicated and work very hard, 7 days a week. read more

Nice, authentic New York-style pizza reminds me of my days growing up in Brooklyn. This is one of the few places that actually makes NY pizza. If you really want to experience how Brooklyn Pizza is supposed to taste, from the ability to fold a slice to the amount of oil, definitely give them a try. read more

I try & try with this place. I try with different names and number because I've had to complain before, but keep trying because there a small business that's close to home. They're just like, lazy acting... my food always feels & tastes old. I ordered a fresh, new, large pizza. It came out burnt like it's been there all day and they rewarmed it or like they just over did it. Looked at it & didn't like it, but still tried it & no. It tastes burnt. The Asian lady owner is so rude when I call, I don't even want to call and let them know. Just don't waste your time here, there's better. read more

My New York Pizza - Burnt - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

See all

Absolutely amazing family owned and operated small business! The food is amazing, the entire menu, but that's not what makes this place a 5/5. During the recent snow/ice storm of 2k26. this place continued to stay open and serve and host whole entire family's who where either not prepaid for the town to shut down or just wanted to get out of the house. I personally don't have enough positive words for local small businesses that help out and welcome in their neighborhood during times of need. I love you guys and I will be stopping by on all my future Dallas/DFW trips. Check them out. read more

This place is an insult to the community. They are rude, 0 customer service etiquette, and insulting. I wish they would leave Keller and open up shop far away. I was driving and called to order a pizza. They wouldn't take my order without giving them a credit card. I said I am driving, the man said no credit card, no pizza. Honestly, what is the risk? I have never paid for an order over the phone prior to picking up the food, especially pizza. It's not like I can walk out with it without paying. There's something wrong with this place, the owners, and the way they treat customers. Avoid at all costs!! read more

We got a meat lovers and Alfredo pizza. Both were so soggy in the middle. The pizza boxes were soaked with grease. The meat lovers pizza had so much ham you couldn't taste anything else. read more

I don't have enough great things to say about My New York Pizza. They're the best pizza in the immediate area. The Husband and wife owners take pride in their business and it shows. I have to say one thing you might want to try is their Mediterranean offerings. The Husband happens to be from Turkey and that lesser known side of the menu is fantastic. read more

Always good, friendly and they have a wide variety of food from wings, to pizza, to Mediterranean. read more

My New York Pizza - Hot and lemon pepper - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

Worker was not friendly Pizza was not fresh Will not be returning not worth the money read more

Some nights there is a bar full of customers, and about 8 beers on tap, and some vino. Thankfully there is also a few tables and booths to sit at. read more

My New York Pizza - Bar full of customer eating, drinking, and being merry. - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

See all

I'm not sure why I've come back here for a second time when the pizza is mediocre. The customer service was so abhorrent I will DEFINITELY never return. I'm not sure if it's the owner but he was extremely rude and seemed like he didn't care for the business at all. Eye rolls and sarcastic remarks and snooty comments for no reason at all. I would be surprised if he didn't respond here with some unprofessional response as well. Just felt the need to warn others to take your business elsewhere to someone who appreciates there customers especially when they have done nothing wrong to begin with. Cheese bread has no flavor and the pizza is just okay. read more

Got recommended by a friend, came to stop by at lunch and the atmosphere was comforting and the music playing in the background was awesome! Had a slice of cheese pizza and I can say this is the best NY style pizza in the area. We tried the chicken parm as well and it was big portions and the chicken was cooked beautifully. The owner was very nice and accommodating. read more

We have never had a bad meal here. I spent 10 years living in the NYC area. This is the best crust around bar none. The owners make inventive and delicious pizza and meals. If you really want to have something new try the kebab plate. Birol shows off his roots read more

Great pizza! Great crust, nicely crispy with just enough chew to it. Awesome ambience and music as well. Just a great local pizza joint.

Overall good experience. We had the baked ziti and toasted ravioli and it was all tasty. Will try the pizza next time.

Sat at the bar for 10 minutes before we were acknowledged (there were only 4 other people here). Bartender/cook/hired help acted annoyed that he had to wait on us. We ordered 2 beers and he walked away. Never came back to take a food order. We eventually left a $10 on the counter and walked out FYI, I'm not sure this is "health code" legal: read more

My New York Pizza - a blender and a bottle of soda - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

Says their open and OPEN sign is lit up and everything but doors are locked, notices in doorway, not sure what they say... no one answers the phone and no one is inside. read more

Who ever is the owner , isn't from NY. The cheese he uses sucks and not fully melted. Looks like string cheese. Also he's not 2A friendly with his sign in window, but that didn't stop me. Hell this is Texas. Wont be going there again. Save yourself the trouble and head down road to Kabylos. read more

Excellent pizza! Crust in perfect non flop texture! The pizza sauoiss superior to all other pizza I've had here in north texas!

I was craving pizza and decided to give them another chance. Whoever answered the phone was an asshole. Did not want to accommodate my food request (fine). He decided it was okay to give me his opinion of my pizza was order and said "pointless" because it was a cheese pizza. Weird, but okay. Also wanted to take my credit card information over the phone and I refused. I suggested I pay when I get there instead and apparently it's not an option. Why would I trust a stranger to take my information over the phone? I know some businesses may do so for large orders but I only had one pizza. I'm not going to give you my credit card information over the phone so you can write it down. Beware. read more

For a quick slice or two at lunch time this place can't be beat. While I think the 2 slices and drink deal for $5 is OK, there are plenty of new lunch specials now. I was told they are on the web site, but in looking at the menu, they don't really jump out at me. Basically I heard a lot of options around the $5 to $6 mark. Pizza still continues to be a solid performer, and I'm not getting any weird vibes (or odors) either. In fact the guy who told me about the specials was quite pleasant. read more

Best pizza I have ever had! Absolutely amazing. The owner was so friendly and the atmosphere was perfect. I can't wait to come back and try the fettuccine! read more

My New York Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Keller, Texas

See all

Word of mouth recommendation. Lived down the street since it opened but tried the first time last month. Should have gone years before. Excellent menu selections. The pizza was correctly cooked and the ingredients fresh. The crust was not over cooked and made the traditional folding possible. Magnificent. read more

Great pizza!!! Huge amount of toppings, and have a huge selection of food! The pizza does not bed from all the toppings! Crispy and chewy crust! From pizza, wings and even gyros! The best tiramisu around! You can bring your own bottle of wine! The owners are awesome and friendly! read more

See all

The best NY style pizza in the area. I lived there for 10 years and know. All of his food is delicious- calzones, pizzas and the addition of some beautiful Turkish tastes just make it harder to know what to order. He and his wife make you feel welcome and appreciated read more

Was on my way to a get together in Keller and hadn't eaten lunch. Was about to pull into a fast food place near here and decided to give this place a try. The day I came it very much was obvious they were having some air conditioning issues as it was hot as all get out and the door was propped open. Ordered a slice of pizza and a drink, not badly priced at about $5. Came out pretty quickly as well, but it was a pre-prepped slice that was reheated int the pizza oven. I think if I had a fresh made pizza then I would have enjoyed it more, but it was by far not the worst pizza I've had. I'm sure if I'm in the area again I'll give it another shot if I'm in the mood for pizza as now I know it is here but I don't know if I'll go out of my way for it. read more

Really good crust. Cheese pizza is good. Pretty classic Ny style flavor profile. I will return for the crust read more

I do not recommend giving this man your business. He treats customers terribly. Asked for a simple modification to a pizza because I cannot eat pizza sauce. He refused to make that because he says it's "not right" and that "customers don't get to make his menu". He couldn't have cared less about accommodating a customer with a food allergy and made a modification to change the sauce on my pizza. I prefer to support small businesses but this owner is condescending. I've heard him speak to the nice Asian woman bad before too. He treats people like a door mat. I will never return to this place and it's unfortunate that I have given him as much business as I have now knowing he refuses to accommodate a customer with a special request. read more

First time in and definitely will not be the last! The pizza is really good and the crust is amazing! The owners were very friendly.

There is a particular type of pie that you just won't find at many places.... this pizza is as close as I can find stateside as in Naples itself.. perfect crust, perfect sauce(perfect amount), perfect cheese and nothing fancy about it .. just pure pizza pie. Everyone has a particular type of pizza they enjoy and let me tell you if you want a crispy semi flop crust with the equal amount of flavor THIS IS IT! Bonus... the wings are also perfect.. You can't give this place enough stars.. Clean, great customer service, and ALWAYS consistent in taste and quality. read more

I ordered the vegetable pizza and added ground beef but asked them not to put the tomatoes on the pizza since it has sauce on the pizza. When I brought the pizza home my brother and husband told me there was no sauce on the pizza. When I called them and told them, the lady didn't know how take care of a complaint over the phone. She wanted to talk to the "chef". She came back on the phone and was trying to tell me that because it was a vegetable pizza they don't put much sauce on it. I am sorry but is pizza sauce not made of tomatoes? I just told her on the phone that she was just making up excuses. Also what I found strange when I finished with my order on the phone, the young guy who took my order wanted me to tell (confirm) the address of where I was placing my order with. How strange. Well, another restaurant bites the dust. read more

New to the area and had a craving for a good pizza. Found this pizzeria on Yelp and decided to give them a try and was not disappointed. A very tasty crust and the toppings, not too little and not too much. The sauce was not overly sweet and gave the whole pie a nice taste. I think I found my new local pizzeria. read more

Just went to this place for the first time and it was great. We did carry out pizzas and jalapeño poppers. Everything was excellent and on time. Also the owner was there making pizzas and very personable. Definitely will go back. (Note: they aren't currently doing delivery due to staffing shortages) read more