Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Moonlight Bay Resort

    5.0 (1 review)

    Moonlight Bay Resort Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Moonlight Bay Resort

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    12 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Resorts 103 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Stone Hill Resort - The pier

    Stone Hill Resort

    5.0(1 review)
    25.9 mi

    I am writing this review as I sit here overlooking the lake from the living room of the cabin…read morethrough the wall to wall row of windows. Every visit to Stone Hill just gets better and better! Since my last review my family has grown and now my toddlers (2 and 3 years older) are along for the week. We have spent each day fishing, going down to the beach, visiting with Helen - the amazing lady that owns Stone Hill Resort - and playing on the playground with the children. The beach and sandy entry to the lake is AWESOME for the kids and the shape and turn of the dock makes a natural swimming area that has a max depth of about 16" making it a PERFECT way to introduce the toddlers to the lake and swimming in it (while you can keep them in an area that is fairly controlled for safety). Stone Hill has a pontoon boat that you can rent for the week (well worth it and SIGNIFICANTLY cheaper than the in-town rental options). Each cabin unit comes with an aluminum fishing boat. Since I last reviewed Stone Hill they have added direct tv and wifi. It is done in a nice way with nothing rustic being taken away but instead supplemented with these additions. This is the singe BEST vacation rental option in northern Wisconsin, still a slice of old Hayward, WI Resort history and an amazing 5 star experience every time I come.

    Photos
    Stone Hill Resort - Loon on the lake at Stone Hill Resort

    Loon on the lake at Stone Hill Resort

    Stone Hill Resort - First cast small mouth bass at Stone Hill Resort in Hayward WI

    First cast small mouth bass at Stone Hill Resort in Hayward WI

    Stone Hill Resort - Stone Hill Resort

    See all

    Stone Hill Resort

    Fred Thomas Resort

    Fred Thomas Resort

    5.0(2 reviews)
    28.5 mi

    Great place with updated, super clean cottages and well maintained grounds. Plenty of activities…read morefor everyone including volleyball, pickle ball, a playground, kayaks, wake boards and a rec room. You can rent pontoons and fishing boats directly from the resort and prices are comparable to other local suppliers. The fact that they're onsite and convenient just adds to the value. You can even buy live bait onsite if you need it. We enjoyed seeing some of the wildlife in the area as well. Pheasants stroll the grounds and eagles are common along the southwest side of the lake. The flower garden is beautiful and has a path going through it so you can get a better view. Prices for cottage rental were either comparable or better than the other resorts nearby. And the staff is really friendly and helpful. An all around great experience and we already plan on coming back next year.

    This is a family run resort with a great vibe. We've visited with the 2nd generation for a couple…read moreyears and they're great. The 3rd generation is setting up themselves to succeed already, they know the business from various angles. Their tag "perpetually new" is true, they update the cabins, boats, and grounds regularly. It's more expensive than other places perhaps, but worth every single penny. And it's worth getting on the waiting list for these cabins. We've been to many WI resorts in many decades and this is the one we can't wait to re-visit.

    Photos
    Fred Thomas Resort
    Fred Thomas Resort
    Fred Thomas Resort - Fun at the beach! Sandy area is great for young kids.

    See all

    Fun at the beach! Sandy area is great for young kids.

    Tall Pines Resort - Inside Cabin 5

    Tall Pines Resort

    4.0(3 reviews)
    29.2 mi

    This is specifically related to the rental cabins. We did not eat at the lodge but have heard good…read morethings. As far as the cabins, it's hard to give a sub par review because I really wanted to give it the benefit of the doubt but in the end, it really just wasn't what we were expecting and hope others can learn from it. I will start with the pros: clean cabins, close lake access with docks for boats to pull in, great area to walk in, safe and quiet, close to downtown Hayward, cabin 5 had a great screened in porch, AC is a plus, had fun fishing on the lake but had to get out of the bay. Cons: resort term used loosely as there are minimal amenities, no swimming beach, lodge closed Sun-Tues, boat rental not available on site (although brochure says it is), many missing kitchen tools in cabins, was told all cabins came with bedding but there were only sheets - you'll need to bring your own pillows and blankets, you're kind of on your own once you check in as as property managers did not seem be accessible/available for questions or help after hours, don't expect cell service. We made the most of it and it was an overall decent place to stay but felt a little mislead and wish we'd have asked more questions/had more info about what we were really getting.

    Best. Ribs. Ever. It is their special on Saturday nights. Been twice to make sure it wasn't a…read morefluke. Not at all....soooooo amazing. Melt-in-your-mouth, fall-off-the-bone ribs. Great side salad and perfectly baked potato. Super friendly staff and cute little lodge on the lake atmosphere. Also- pretty amazing fried chicken. I believe they serve this any time. So happy I discovered this little gem on Nelson Lake. Have been wanting to try their Friday fish fry, maybe next time I am in the area. Go try this place.......now! Kitchen open Wednesday through Sunday. And they have Happy Hour (3-6). That's all.

    Photos
    Tall Pines Resort - No for pit and view of other cabins.

    No for pit and view of other cabins.

    Tall Pines Resort - View from cabins into bay

    View from cabins into bay

    Tall Pines Resort - Dining room

    See all

    Dining room

    Moonlight Bay Resort - resorts - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...