Honestly, one of the best jewelry stores out there - definitely my favorite in Milwaukee and maybe…read moreanywhere. I'm across the country and still keep coming back to them, which says a lot. The team is awesome: super friendly, professional, and they always make things easy. They've helped me track down pieces, handled everything from sales to service perfectly, and even check in afterward to make sure everything was great. Shipping's quick, communication's great, and they truly care about their customers. Just a fantastic experience all around.

My wife reached a huge milestone in her career and I had to find the perfect watch to celebrate…read more Normally, a watch like the one I was looking for takes months to a year of waiting. Karen was great, enthusiastic, and helped me to narrow to several watches. To my surprise, less than a week, she gave me the call. I went to pick up the watch with my son and she was so attentive and even offered him a soda on the rocks. Even though he is young he does enjoy quality watches. So after leaving the dealer my son appreciates watches even more now. Thank you Karen for the great experience!

Wonderful service. Very pleasant and so glad I found them. Recommend highly. Fixed a broken…read morewatch. Thank you so much and will return with all my repairs.

I have been dealing with Mikhail (Mixa Jewelers) since 2004 he customized my wife's wedding ring…read morealong with several rings for me, he's done change and zodiac medallions just the way I requested he puts his heart into it as if he's making them for himself he does a great job I'm happy!!!

My then husband purchased my engagement ring from Donnybrook and it was beautifully designed and…read morecost $3500. Several years later we split up and I gave the ring back to my husband. He went to 5 different jewelry stores to get it appraised and try to sell it and each one of them told him that the diamond was cut poorly and wasn't worth nearly what he paid for it. While I think Donnybrook has some nice pieces, you might want to get a couple appraisals before buying. We got ripped off.

Convenient, courteous, and helpful…read more Armando is awesome. Nice selection of watches.

I could not recommend this company more. I had a wonderful experience with Bret. He was so…read moreattentive and informative. He took time to assist me with my questions and was a total class act. My best take away from this experience was that I TRUST 100% that my jewelry is in good hands. Thanks again for your help.

I have an old watch I inherited from my grandfather. One day it stopped working. I went to C.C…read more Conrad in my neighborhood, hoping that they could fix this relic from 60 years ago. It took some doing but they were able to track down the needed parts. All good! Thank you Walter!

Went in to purchase my then girlfriend , now fiancé, an engagement ring. The owner was very…read moreknowledgeable and reasonable in his pricing. We were able to strike a deal within my budget, and my partner is thrilled with the ring! Beautiful 14K gold with tanzanite center stone surrounded by small diamonds. Thanks for making a special moment for us possible!

After visiting a few other jewelry store, I decided to see what Craig Husar's had. I worked with…read moreVivian Andrekopoulos and she was simply amazing. She responded to my online request for information on a particular style of ring. I had a specific style and diamond cut that I was looking for. She messaged back with some information and asked if I wanted to come in to discuss and look. I made an appointment, and Vivian followed up prior to my appointment. Vivian greeted me at the door upon my arrival. Vivian had all my information on the ring and led me to the station to show me. She went over the details, the quality, what it meant, showed me a few other stones but when she asked me if I wanted to look at any other style, I knew that was the one. I wasn't planning on purchasing a ring that day, but when you find that one ring that you know is the one, what else is there to do? After the purchase, Craig Husar came up to say hi and to chat. I thought that was really nice that he took the time to come up to congratulate me and to thank me for coming in. Then I came back in with my girlfriend as she wanted to get me sized. Vivian took the hint to not let her know that I've been working with her. She kept it a secret. Afterwards, my girlfriend bought the first ring she saw and expressed how wonderful Vivian was, still not knowing I bought her ring with Vivian's help. Vivian's knowledge, responsiveness, and care set her apart from other experiences I've had at jewelry stores.

Always a good experience here. I've bought a few watches from Peter and Dom. They also helped me…read morewith a trade in. Ramiah is always great to see here. She helped me pick out a diamond and setting for an engagement ring. Craig Husar does a great job here keeping everything fresh with the watch selection. Breitling was a great addition, looking forward to seeing this store grow!

I came in here for some appraisals and interest in gold dealings. Being new to the area, I was…read moremerely getting a feel for who to do business with now that I have relocated. I have found the owner to be knowledgeable, honest, and fair- qualities that tend to be difficult to find in the industry. I will be doing future business here.

Marc is so kind and very helpful! He always gives me competitive prices alongside a very enjoyable…read moreexperience! HIGHLY recommend and 10/10 will be back!!!

My wife has always loved opals and she wanted a ring for our anniversary. We drove up from Chicago…read moreand spent the afternoon looking at the most gorgeous stones we've ever seen. Dennis, The Opal man himself, even brought out a selection of unset stones for us to look through. The staff was incredibly helpful and knowledgeable and Dennis went above-and-beyond to make sure that my wife's ring was exactly what she wanted. She's been crying tears of joy every time she looks at her ring. If you have someone in your life who loves opals, I don't think you'll find a better experience elsewhere.

From the owner: Unique Opal Jewelry.read more

An extremely attractive display of lovely jewelry. The owner was more than gracious and is…read morededicated to her craft. I don't think I've ever felt so comfortable in a jewelry store. If you want someone that will work with you on what you want, I would strongly suggest this is the place to go. Yelp should note they are in a new location in Lake Geneva

I have fallen in love with Geneva Lakes Jewelry!! Lynn is a true gemologist, and really knows her…read morestuff! She is so creative and kind. I have bought jewelry from her, have had jewelry repaired and she has also redesigned jewelry for me and I have been super happy with everything! I recommend GLJ 100%!