I can never figure out what will stick in San Francisco. I know what won't work almost immediately,…read moreas do most people I speak to, but the City goes ahead with ridiculously expensive public plans anyway, and many of those plans attract the same grime, dirt, graffiti, and destruction that everyone predicted they would, except now the taxpayers have to pay for maintaining things that are unprotected and falling apart.
I really used to like the fountain. Yes, it was disgusting, and way too many people bathed and peed and laundered in it, but it felt like approachable, if run down, art. They turned it off, fenced it off, and now it just waits and collects more and more debris.
Some places in the City are just destined to fail as public spaces, like Hallidie Plaza. (I like Hallidie Plaza and believe it could succeed, but it would require a great deal of public assistance to get businesses to open in and around it, money the city should probably spend on other things.) UN Plaza wasn't destined to fail, but once its failure began, the City didn't do enough to save it, and that's really a shame, because there are plenty of cultural institutions nearby that could (in theory) hold so many events here that the people who just want to set up their lives here wouldn't have a chance because of all the taking-their-stuff-down they'd have to do constantly.
The farmers' market is wonderful. I really like the foosball tables, although there needs to be a go-to place to buy ping-pong balls nearby. The chessboards and the fitness stations? Meh. We'll see how those work out. Chessboards would work better near the cable-car turnaround on Powell Street, but not in Hallidie Plaza. I like the dog park, and on the few occasions since COVID that I've walked through UN Plaza, I've seen way more people walking their dogs here than I ever expected to see.
There are very nice sight lines from Market Street through UN, Fulton, and Civic Center Plazas to city hall. Especially on a night when city hall is lit up in colors celebrating whatever team or cause, it's just gorgeous. And I love the Bolivar statue, as out of place as it can seem at times.
But at night. I haven't been here at night since some sort of protest or rally or whatever years and years ago. It's really a perfect place for a protest, both visually and spatially, plus it's close to BART and a bunch of bus and train lines, and it's a pedestrian plaza, so you can cram thousands of protesters in here without anyone being endangered by cars.
But at night again. Too shady. Too scary. Like a lot of Civic Center and the TL, it's probably more depressing than it is dangerous. There's also a way in which it serves no purpose at night as a pedestrian thoroughfare. Even if you're walking from the Bill Graham Civic Auditorium to BART, there's an entrance on Market Street before UN Plaza. There's just no reason to venture that far north when Market cuts down your walking-in-a-shady-area time because it's diagonal. I do like the shortcut from Market Street to Leavenworth, but again, unless you're a UC Law SF --what an atrocious name!--student, why would you be walking north on Leavenworth through Civic Center and/or the TL at night?
It has so much potential, so I'm sticking with three stars.