Not sure how long Michelli's has been around, but for some reason it's gone completely under our radar, at least until we got the flyer in the mail (hey- it worked!). There are very few pizza places in Brevard that I think are worth going back to again -- all are no less than 25 minutes from our home in south West Melbourne -- and I thought we'd exhausted them all. Side note, we're originally from Indiana and while you wouldn't think of it as some sort of pizza Mecca, it kind of is... think Arni's, Bazbeaux, Pizza King, Noble Romans-- and of course close access to some of the best Chicago pizza around. Anyway, we've been jonesing for something close to some of the kinds I just listed and we always come up short. At the very least, we'd love for a chain like Jets to come closer bc we grew up on the deep dish style (which reminds me... I miss Garcia's!) but Brevard doesn't seem to care about that style. Too many east coast folks, I guess. Back to Michelli's. I'm was excited to see Sicilian style in the menu and more than willing to give it a shot. I was also excited to see some toppings and styles reminiscent of Bazbeaux, like artichokes, broccoli, Quattro formaggio, etc. I ordered a Sicilian with a bunch of weird toppings. Maybe not a "typical" Sicilian but it still worked. The flavor was good. It tasted fresh and the sauce was delicious. It was also one huge pizza! For $40, I suppose I would expect it to be (I did order a bunch of toppings, of which at least half were premium, and that's really what shot up the price). My only complaint -- and it's kind of a big one, but bc it was good otherwise I'm more than willing to overlook as a one-time thing -- is that the crust was overcooked to the point of being black in many spots on the bottom. The result was a super chewy and somewhat dry crust. Next time I order I will point this out -- based on everything else being so good, I expect that this is not the norm. read more

Just tried this place last weekend. The margarita pizza and garlic knots are delicious! The service was great as well. We will definitely be going back to try another pizza! read more

Great people and good food and service. Need to try. When I'm up in Melbourne I always plan to eat there

Honestly they have the besttttttttt calzone in town hands down!! The little dust that they sprinkle on top gets me every time

Nothing beats authentic Italian food and that's exactly what you get at Michelle's. Friendly workers who are eager to please. A+++

Stopped by here tonight to share a pizza with my family. This is a very nice pizzeria and the staff here is friendly and great at making sure your drink cup is full. Ordered their meat lovers pizza and garlic knots. The garlic knots were fresh, with a soft center, and a light crispy crust. The knotd were covered with oil, butter, garlic, and cheese Tasty! The pizza was a nice size and covered with a generous amount of meat toppings. Combined with a good sauce and quality cheese made for a tasty combination. We will be back. read more

Michelli's Pizzeria - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

I've been here enough times recently and in the past to say that the food is okay/average. The pizza is tough to eat; I feel like I'm really trying to pull with my teeth with each bite. I got the Family Meal Deal, which comes with a 16" pizza, wings, and garlic knots for $20.95, but my family and I weren't satisfied with the quality. I chose garlic parmesan for the wings and expected the wings to be a lot saucier but they were kind of dry. The garlic knots didn't taste that fresh either. I don't think I would purchase this deal or any non-pizza item again. What I would come back for, though, is the lunch special: 2 slices of cheese and a fountain drink for $6. When I want pizza right away and for an affordable price, the lunch special does the trick. read more

See all

Excellent food Great service , friendly staff . Walgreens store 3090 W. New Haven , W. Melbourne 32904 . MGMT staff and Customer Associates we love you all read more

Busy or not how you treat a customer is what it's all about. You misquoting from an hour to hour and half is a big difference. The person taking my order didn't have my name down right either. The main cook who I presume is a manager or owner was super rude saying they misquoted and there's nothing I can do but wait. He was yelling profanities the whole time in the back. Nice attitude and great customer service there....I'll be sure not to take my business back here ever again. read more

I love this place. The pizza is always good and fresh and the slices are huge. Definitely recommend it read more

The best items that we had there is the garlic knots and salad. Pizza lacks flavor and is mediocre, the sauce is scarce and the pizza is to thin. when I picked up the slices everything fell off. Also, the bottom is burnt with a lot of black, which is to be expected from an oven but it shouldn't overtake. The taste of the pizza did not have a good taste. After eating it, the whole pizza is just lacking flavor and have had better in town. Surprised there is more than one or two stars. in my opinion I wouldn't return. Probably not the best prices in my opinion. Prices are high and pizza is lacking quality and good taste. read more

Cute place, nice staff. Pizza was ok. Crust needed to be a bit crisper. It lacked flavor. I asked for broccoli well it might have had 12 pieces on a large. If I'm paying $2,00 for every extra there should have been covering my pizza. No garlic slices and I paid for that too. When you order the specialty pizzas they were packed. We ate from the north. I paid $70 for two mediums and a large. I was going to stay home and make homemade, I seriously regret my decision. It would have cost me a total of $11.00 for 3 pizzas. Never again read more

poor service. not very friendly people. i Also overheard some of the employees complaining about a guest and they weren't being discreet. Atleast wait until there's no one in the building to do so. read more

Thank you michelle's You're being the best pizzeria around these parts. The food is always fantastic, And a service is impeccable. It's always nice to go into the store and feel like they actually want you there.. The store is always clean. Thank you for all that you do!! read more

BEWARE! I don't know about you... but 18 bucks for a medium pepperoni pizza is way crazy. It better be perfect and mine looked like a misshaped football about the size of a paper plate. When I complained all they could say was I don't make the prices... They didn't offer to remake it and when I asked for some parmigiana cheese, the woman at the counter hands me what amounted to ketchup packets. That is the last time I order from there. It is price gouging at its finest. One of the cooks tried to tell me it is like that all over... Sorry but a one topping LARGE is 7.99. When he tried to tell me about the ingredients, I mentioned the packets and he shut up! And they refuse to deliver. And when I went to the desk, I said be honest, does that look like an 18 dollar pizza, and even she had to get the cook cause she didn't think it was right either. read more

I....don't know where to begin. Had high hopes for this place but I was sorely disappointed. I ordered the bolognese spaghetti and my gf ordered the baked ziti with meatballs. The bolognese could stand to be something else besides a meat and sauce. There was no kind of cheese or any "oomph". The ziti had a weird taste, like it was off. She took two bites and it went in the trash. I ate around the meat on mine and dumped the rest. $42 in the trash. The garlic rolls were passable. I spent the next two days with my stomach upset. I just moved here from south Florida so maybe I'm used to food being a little bit higher standard in some ways given the variety of places. Needless to say, won't be eating here again. read more

Great place with traditional style pizza and dinner's and Calzones. Always better when you pick it up. P read more

The pizza is always good at Michelli's!! They are so popular that delivery times can get a bit long especially on Friday or Saturday night. Just order an hour or two early and you will be fine. I usually call around 2 and schedule my pizza to be delivered at dinner time that way I don't have to worry. read more

Pizza is really good, the issue is that I always order delivery from them, and I recently called and all of a sudden I'm out of there delivery range . I haven't moved houses and the building hasn't moved either. The girl was very rude and didn't even try to offer an explanation. They definitely have lost a life long customer! read more

Came here yesterday for lunch and ordered 2 slices of cheese pizza. Pretty good pizza and great customer service. Very nice workers.

Great pizza and staff, Very accommodating, You can BYOB, Would highly recommend this place if traveling. read more

What ....how did I NOT find this sooner. Carrabbas who ?? This place is like the best little dive I have ever ever found. Their calzones are so so FRESH and GOOD and better than Wagon Wheel and Bizzarros and Bizzarros has a killer calzone. I cant explain it, but like their dough and lightly dusted with maybe olive oil and Parmesan cheese I think -is like the best best FLAVOR ever. Its not greasy and didnt hurt my stomach in an hour or two, SIMPLY AMAZING !! If you have not tried this hidden little Italian Restaurant YOU ARE SO MISSING OUT !! Ive only had the Calzones with meat, mushroom and cheese and Stuffed shells which are amazing too and the garlic knots and salad and I AM SO SOLD! I wont be going to Carrabbas anymore after Church that is for sure and I have being doing that for 10 years every Sunday, but with all the changes in Carrabbas sauces and cutting corners, I refuse to pay $20+ for a dish and be unhappy! Especially, when I can come here and pay $10-13 and it is so FRESH and DELICIOUS and I leave HAPPY -not regretting the money I just dished out!!!!! A+ A++++++++++++ read more

WOW i am so glad we stumbled across this place . Pizza is great , hand tossed , premium cheese , ! I had the vegetarian sub, made with eggplant peppers onions and mushrooms! If your vegan just get it without the cheese, AMAZING , and flavorful. I'm glad i dont live close or id be broke and gain 50# in a month lol . Hard working and friendly staff . We went at 5:30 on a Tuesday pm , they were busy busy busy with carryouts and delivery but we ate in and got our food in a timely manner! Great Job ! read more

Michelli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Called in take out at 6 pm, 2 cheese steaks and garlic knots. I was told 35-40 minutes. Arrived at 6:40 to pick up, they told me they haven't even started on the order yet! I took a seat to wait. Informed my guests at home who had the movie 'on pause' to wait for me to return. While waiting, I could hear them tell other callers to give them about 35 minutes for pick up. That's clearly not accurate at all. After an hour the order came out. They said sorry for the wait, at least you know it's fresh right? Really? It would have been just as fresh 25 minutes ago right? Garlic knots were cold. The cheesesteaks are awesome however read more

Food is authentic to NY. The pasta sauce is amazing. Service is always on point. Menu has many different types of choices. You'll love this place. read more

Came for dinner on a busy Saturday night. The service was prompt & friendly. Started with the Greek salad and some mozzarella sticks. The sticks were hot and the salad was fresh. We then had a medium cheese pizza and a calzone with spinach, broccoli and tomato. Everything was served hot. The pizza was classic New York style Pizza. Yummy crispy crust and the right amount of cheese. The calzone was stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella. The dipping sauce was delicious. We will definitely come back here again. read more

See all

Really friendly staff and Italian feel inside. Pizza was just average for my liking though.. veggies and meat were just a little too much on the size and amount. Also lacked sauce, which in my opinion is what makes up the majority of the flavor profile of a great pizza! Overall a solid made fresh pizza but with no memorable qualities. read more

Best pizza in town! The girls at the counter and on the phone are always super friendly. They practically know our order when we walk in! Highly recommend. read more

we have been getting to go from this restaurant for quite a while now. We're never disappointed our friends son is in the Navy in Key West. we introduced him to the pizza from here the next to the last time he was in town. he was in town this week and we had him over for pizza. He said it can't get any better than this pizza told him about the baked ziti that my husband loves. He thought about getting up to take back with him. My personal favorite is the chicken Marcella. I will tell you I highly suggest on a Friday and Sat evening order early if you don't you might have a wait. One more thing there garlic knots are delicious. read more

Been here and never been disappointed. Although I will say, proceed with caution if you order the wings. The "hot" is extremely hot and I like spicy food, but man. They put a hurting on me. LOL! But the pizza is awesome! It's always hot with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. The customer service is always great. One of these days, I'll stop long enough to take a picture. But it's so good I can't wait long to take a pic! Tuesdays/Wednesday they do a special with a large cheese pizza as well. Check them out! read more

Great Lunch Specials! Very friendly and helpful service. Nice clean place. What more can I say... read more

Came here because of the reviews and was not disappointed! We had a 20" pepperoni pizza with an order of 12 garlic knots. It was all very tasty! Will definitely recommend anyone to give this place a try. We came on a Saturday night and they were very busy but they got our food out quickly! read more

Michelli's Pizzeria - 20" Pepperoni Pizza, it didn't even fit in the box! Very yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

This is a return review and retracted previous review from to start a four-star customer service fantastic pizza this night out of this world. After talking to the owners, they explained someone NEW was making the pizzas was The result of a burnt crust and that taste overtaking the pizza they made right on it....our service tonight it was spot on !the way it should be done , the staff friendly all and all a nice visit with good pizza tonight and Everything was out of this world !so hats off to this establishment and their great customer service and pizza Thanks again staff and Eric and Michelle ! read more

After living in Palm Bay for the past 6 years or so, I have FINALLY found my pizza place!!! This is that REAL NY style pizza! SO MUCH BETTER than Bizarro's and more reasonably priced!!! Perfectly thin, crispy crunch with that slightly oily but not too oily (not much oil on the box, despite the way the pic appears) yummy kind I've been craving since I moved here and couldn't find! Quoted long wait time for pickup but that's cause it's really good, they're busy, and it SO worth it! The girls at the front were super friendly and efficient, I was in and out in no time. My whole family was impressed with the pizza, even my son who isn't a big pizza fan! We can't wait to try the wings next time! read more

Hands down, best pizza I've found in Melbourne. The crust is the perfect balance of crisp and chewy, the toppings are high quality (try the Bianco-- a simple concept executed to perfection) and the pizza is always piping hot and fresh. The meat feast is particularly excellent. I recommend this place to all my friends-- Bizzaro who? read more

When you move into a new neighborhood you hope there is a great local owned pizza place in it. Boom, we have a winner. We love the pizza! Garlic knots are sooooo good. Every one of the pastas we have tried have been amazing. And every time I go in even when they are slammed, the people are friendly and happy to see me. read more

My dad loves the spaghetti and meatballs! The staff is always so pleasant and welcoming! Love this place!

The food is good. Not good enough for the insane wait times. Never been ready when they say it will be so I end up waiting around getting hangry. The place is small and loud but again if you don't mind a long wait order here the food is good read more

We went for lunch the other day and the pizza was just ok- we all got 2 slices and a drink. The pizza certainly could have been cooked longer. It was hot but not crispy at all. Dough was very pale on the top and the bottom. read more

worst over priced pizza I have ever had. service was okay but the medium is like a small, and for a " supreme " medium pizza the total was 31.00 before tip. it got here and hour and half later, cold, tasteless and some of the toppings looked like they expired. Almost an entire pizza was thrown away because this was not edible. overpriced and garbage. will not eat here ever again. read more