Best Sicilian pie in town--none come close. The fried chicken tenders are real tenderloins.

Just driving North from the beach and found this place on Yelp. GLAD I DID! The slices here are FANTASTIC! Hot with a crispy crust. Delicious, sauce, cheese, crust ratio spot on! My only concern is that it's 95 outside and NONE of your 3 air conditioners are on, only 3 ceiling fans blowing around the hot air. Why?? read more

Micchelli's Pizza - Slices - Pizza Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Micchellis Never disappoints! Every one is ALWAYS so nice from ordering to delivery! There panzarottis Are THE BEST! Love their chicken salad sandwiches as well. Great place:) read more

Have been driving past this Resteraunt for years. It takes 20 mins for us to get there & was told what great wings they have. I must say, that lastnight New Years Eve - I called, ordered and was told it would be ready in 30 mins. When I entered I was immediately greeted with a sweet hello and can I help you? That is important to me, to be received by the staff. That is wonderful customer service. My food was ready and was absolutely scrumptious! I highly recommend this quaint establishment and will be back to try more items on the menu. read more

I have been coming here for years and not a doubt this is one of the best local pizza spots. I get the same pizza every time and it just gets better without fail. Prices are great compared to Primos. read more

No consistency in food..pizza is very bad in somers point..not good service..don't know if we would try it again..so many good pizza places that are better read more

I got a Margherita pizza. Not even close. I couldn't even finish 1 slice. I've had better read more

Micchelli's Pizza - This is their version of "Margherita" pizza. So disappointed - Pizza Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Bad service. When you order a chicken club sandwich and it says it comes with fries, you won't actually get the fries unless u ask? Doesn't make sense at all. read more

Micchelli's Pizza - No fries even though menu says it comes with fries - Pizza Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Surprisingly excellent pizza, with crispy crust and plentiful toppings. I enjoyed my quickly delivered small meat lovers pizza and mild wings. Another time I got a cheeseburger and curly fries. The best thing I ate was the pizza. They were not stingy with toppings and there isn't anything to complain about. The wings were big and fairly juicy, but the buffalo sauce was a bit sour. Should I order them again, I would try a different sauce, maybe BBQ or even plain. The burger was well done, but not dry. It takes a lot to mess a burger up, and I would rate this as average. Definitely plenty good for late night delivery, but I wouldn't go out of my way for it. The curly fries were very good. Little is as satisfying as a good curly fry. In short, pizza and curly fries were my two must haves. read more

Micchelli's Pizza - Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

See all

Best entrées, Pizza, and salads to be found in the entire area. Staff is up to par and the weight is never too long small restaurant with great big taste. read more

Micchelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Inconsistent quality - pizza dough was stale. Been there in the past was decent- not so much now.

I have tried this place a few times. Delivery drivers are great however the people who take the orders are hit or miss. The last three times I have ordered, the order taker forgot items! And by the time they get to your house they turned the ovens off so you can't get the items you ordered. As I said the food is good. But they need to work on the people who take the orders. Very bad customer service when it comes to delivery orders. read more

best local pizza spot, I've been living nearby my whole life and Micchelis has been our go to for 20 years try the buffalo fries! can't go wrong with anything on the menu read more

It's not bad. It's not good. It's what my dad would say mezza mezza. Unbelievable how many average pizza places there are in this area. Comparing this pizza to places in NY is like like calling Steak-Um a cheesesteak. The sauce kills this pizza. They use quality ingredients for toppings. The cheese is quality and not greasy. The crust is a little doughy but not bad. The sauce is not good. They either use a prepared sauce that is cooked which is a no no or they add sugar to a fresh sauce that is cooked. It lacks freshness that comes from quality San Marzano tomatoes that are ground up and seasoned with a little sea salt maybe some fresh basil and possibly garlic. The sauce on great pizza is so simple. It costs money for good quality canned whole tomatoes and it takes time to run them through a food mill but if you just did that and added a few ingredients or not. You would have a great pizza sauce. read more

Micchelli's Pizza - Over 1/2 the pizza left over. Rare in my family. - Pizza Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Very good pizza. I love that the don't add sugar or oils and they grate their own cheese. We got a large cheese, meat lovers, and white pizza, plus a spring salad and calzone. The meat lovers was very good. The white pizza was good, but not great. I've had better. The calzone was my favorite. It was perfect in every way. The salad was excellent too. read more

GREAT PLACE WITH ONE CAVEAT - This is a place I send people for food when they are looking for good pizzas and subs while in Ocean City, haha. It is better than most if not all the quick pizza and sandwich spots over there, so worth the short trip off the island into SP. And it is not even in Ocean City. My only gripe is a big one for me, but I realize for most customers this won't be an issue, other than maybe the lack of transparency. For months or maybe even a year, they had an ingredient list hanging on their front counter for their cauliflower pizza crusts. The note said the ingredients were cauliflower, parmesan cheese, oregano, basil, nutritional yeast, garlic and egg. All keto-friendly stuff, which is a big deal to people who are dedicated to that diet. Turns out the cauliflower crusts they use do not match that list at all and are not keto friendly crusts, but actually loaded with various high carb ingredients. I was really disappointed to find this out and frankly, it was only my curiosity about the nutrition facts for diet logging that unearthed this. Anyway, the regular pies are great, and when I ate that stuff, I liked the cheesesteaks, too. The owner is super friendly. All in all, this is a solid spot and has been for a long time. read more

Best in the area in my humble opinion! Their pizza is the perfect blend between crispy and chewy, sauce is tangy but not too tangy. Their everyday special is 2 16-inch pies for $20, can't beat it. Plus, a terrific caesar salad. I and many others from Ocean City will gladly travel to "the mainland" for Micchelli's, it is that much better than anything "on the island". Enjoy! read more

Micchelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Really nice people, Really Great Food but the fast delivery was awesome. I highly recommend this place. Thanks so much for great service read more

Great pizza and wings! Make sure to get the homemade desserts. Both this location in Somers Point and the one in EHT get 5 stars! read more

We found this place when we moved to SPt about 3 years ago.. the food is great.. tasty... the people are great too... I am vegan and they have always been helpful with that... we will continue to eat here... if you have not tried it maybe you should .. you might like it as much as we do! read more

See all

I give this place 2 stars only because of the fact I have never eaten food/pizza that literally has no flavor what's so ever. I was kind of in shock. And the "garlic knots", I honestly couldn't talk even garlic. Don't mean to bash on the place but not only did I give it one try, I've been there 4 different times. Final thoughts, if you like eating bland no taste pizza paste then this, IS your place. read more

Really good cheesesteak & pizza. We stopped & ate in based on Yelp reviews. The lady at the register was super nice & we were really impressed with the food. I'll definitely be back!! Got take out from here last week and it was just as good as when we ate in. Will be on steady rotation for take out, especially since we're in OC all summer and it's hard to get good food on the island. read more

Excellent food excellent service we ordered takeout I had 2 slices of pizza and a chicken parm sandwich both were excellent and for dessert I had the carrot cake which was creamy and delicious I rate this experience five stars because the food was amazing and we will be coming back to our spot known as Micchelli's read more

See all

I have to agree with Bob O...there was absolutely no taste to the dough...guy said it was cheese and sauce on cardboard and the man was right. People giving this place 5 stars, where have you been eating? Had to doctor it up with every bit of garlic powder, grated cheese, chili pepper, oregano, etc. to get any flavor out whatsoever. The cheese was generous and the service was friendly...but wow, that was not a 5 star pizza. read more

I went there last night and got the fried shrimp and fries. It was soooo good that I had to come again today. This time I ordered shrimp linguini. I was so upset when I saw my pasta. My pasta was dry and had no seasoning what's so ever. The noodles tasted like boiled plain noodles in noddle water. The shrimps were huge and tasted really good. There wasnt any garlic or oil or anything to the pasta at all. Just noodles and shrimp. read more

There's NOTHING bad to say about this place! I love it! I work at the hospital. Next to it and we ordered pizza and salads. I love how they have different sizes to their salads. We ordered a large to share between both of us and it was a MASSIVE salad. Fresh ingredients. Crisp lettuce and the dressings were great as well. I don't eat white bread/dough. So it's extremely hard to find a pizza/restaurant that has wheat dough as an option. I was elated when I found out Michellis had wheat/multigrain dough and rolls. We ordered the garden pie and we fought for the last slice. It was amazing in every sense of the word. Michellis is our new take out spot when we have Take Out Tuesdays. Not to mention they delivered quickly as well! read more

Micchelli's Pizza - Garden Pie on Whole Wheat Crust. - Pizza Near Me - Somers Point, New Jersey

Always arrives hot best pizza in south jersey. Just as good as New York pizza. If you don't order here you're missing out.

I never write reviews because I have never been so unsatisfied with a meal before. I ordered 24 wings and a chicken parm sandwich. The wings were ok very large but not the best. The chicken parm was chewy and bland couldn't even eat it, ended up giving it to my dog. I have tried micchellis numerous times and always left unhappy. read more

Finally threw the menu away!!! We tried to give it a chance for the third time but ended up feeding it to the dogs. We talked about how bad the food was for two days! read more

Could've been 4 star. We order once a weekend food always consistent. There's always that one employee who wants to be more then what they really are a person answering phone and taken orders. If next time will order online if available and put her out of work. On fri aug 16 at 8:28 I called and ordered cheese steak Stromboli pepper of side with marinara. 8:30 called back my son said buffalo cheese steak BUT no one else wanted it so before hanging up I said to girl keep same order cheese steak Stromboli. She said ok. 45 min later chicken cheese steak shows up with marinara on side,,, really!!! I called back asked what happened for says you changed order. Asked to speak to manager or owner. None there and she said your problem and hung up. Called back to ask her name. She said not giving it. Good employee read more

Orders the chicken parm. Sauce wasn't very good. Vegetable pizza also had the same funny tasting sauce which wasn't very tasteful tasty two stars. read more

Alittle disappointed. On my way home, I called for a small cheese pizza. There're small pizza is a personal pizza. Only for one person. I have ordered pizza my whole life. When I order a small cheese pizza from any pizzeria, it has never come out as a personal pizza. I should have been told. I didn't want to wait for another, do I just tipped & left. Please tell your phone people to explain that your version of a small pizza is a personal pizza, enough for one. read more

Ordered delivery: burgers & pizza. It was delicious. so glad for the other Yelp reviews. Prices were fair; we will order from here much more frequently in the future. FYI orders took a long time to be ready (50 mins); worth the wait. Thanks! read more

I ordered a simple cobb salad with black olives and chicken. It was delivered with crumbled cheese on it. I called and complained that cheese was on it and did not want cheese on my salad. I was told they would send me another salad so I waited another 45 minutes on top of the original 45 minutes only to receive another salad with crumble cheese on it. No where on the menu is blue cheese crumbles stated in the salad. I called again to complain and the woman who answered the phone said we don't always write everything we put in our food on the menu. You're kidding right?! The driver didn't even leave my driveway and I returned the salad to them. When I called to complain and asked for my money back I had to argue with woman on the other end about how much I paid and that I wanted my money back. I was promised another salad tomorrow morning because it took them 90 minutes to get my dinner and now they were closed. I told them that won't be necessary since I did not want to eat my dinner for breakfast. So I ended up eating cereal because this establishment could not deliver a simple salad. read more

Order from here often and I've never been disappointed. Food is amazing, especially the grandma's pie. Really been loving the cauliflower pizza too! read more

We absolutely love this place. The pizza is yummy and the service is great. The owners really care for their customers. You definitely get a bang for your buck here. They have super yummy calzones and their calamari is so good and fresh. read more

Great food is status quo, I live on the island and Micchelli's is always my go to. Excellent staff and service. I recommend their wings over most of my previous favorites and local staples. I spread the word and have converted many locals to their wings.. (I prefer them dry with sauce on the side when ordering delivery) give them a try and you won't be disappointed! read more

I love there cheesesteaks they are always seasoned perfectly , stuffed with meat , delicious caramelized onions , fresh lettuce , plump tomatoes every time !!! read more

Stopped in for a quick slice based solely on Yelp reviews. Was not disappointed!!! Cheese jumbo slice was only $2.50 and tasty awesome! I'm a Jersey Native who can't find good pizza at home (Philly) so this was a great treat! And the service was quick and friendly. read more

Very friendly customer service and good food. Got the "Lite Pizza" (wheat dough, skim mozzarella cheese, and two veggie toppings of choice) which was great. The side of jumbo buffalo wings were above average. The menu prices on yelp are outdated everything is about $.50-$1.00 more expensive but overall prices are still pretty fair.. pretty slow service about 50-60mins later, even for pickup. read more