Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    McGrath Insurance

    3.0 (2 reviews)

    McGrath Insurance Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - McGrath Insurance

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Insurance 2,240 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Lennon Insurance Agency

    Lennon Insurance Agency

    (2 reviews)

    Do yourself a favor and just go somewhere else. Anytime I've gotten an auto policy through this…read moreagency it's been significantly higher than other competitors. Then when you get charged over $100 more unexpectedly, they wont give you the courtesy of giving you a heads up or explain why. Infact, they dont even bother to reach out to you period like other agencies do. I had to contact them several times and still dont have a clear answer. When I cancelled after the charge they say the other auto companies will "raise their rates" on me. That's ironic. I paid way less upfront for my new auto policy with a bigger name than the few hundred dollars that they require upfront. Not happy with my experience here and the customer service is lazy. My experience here was nothing but a hassle.

    This old-fashioned insurance agent is located in an easy-to-reach (well, easy to reach for Woburn)…read morespot on Main Street in a lovely old victorian house, bordering on mansion, which overlooks a perfectly manicured lawn. Not what you expect for your insurance agent, but after having had nothing but good relations with them over the phone, I was pleased to visit their office to pick up some paperwork, and find that they are just as nice in person as they are over the phone. Mary Jane Keane in particular is very nice to work with, though she's insanely busy all the time, and will take care of whatever issues you have just like that. ::snaps::. They'll compare policies, give you the right rate, and their old-school customer service is top shelf. Love these folks.

    Old Heritage Auto Insurance

    Old Heritage Auto Insurance

    (18 reviews)

    Maybe I live in Bizarro World but I've never had anything but great customer service from the folks…read moreat Old Heritage. Whenever I call them for anything (which is often, as I've had an auto policy with them for 4 years and a renter's policy for the last year), they are always extremely helpful and promptly return my calls. I can't remember ever waiting more than an hour or two for a callback. When I've shopped around for better rates at all of the usual insurance suspects (Geico, Liberty Mutual, MetLife, even Amica), Old Heritage still comes out as cheaper by a good margin. (Or rather, the insurance that Old Heritage sells -- Safety Insurance -- comes out being significantly cheaper.) I have to think that the abundance of negative reviews exemplifies the adage that the only people who write reviews on the internet are people with bad experiences. Or at least it seems that one is more likely to flock to the internets to write a negative review than to write a positive one. So consider this my attempt to strike a more fair balance.

    I will start this by saying I had successfully purchased business insurance from this company…read morewithout issue, and had auto insurance with them for about a year before rates went up without explanation. I ended up switching to Progressive.A year later I was approached by one of Old Heritage's representatives (one I had not dealt with previously named James) via email who wanted to regain my business and asked if I wanted an Auto quote. I send my info, I get a formal quote that is over 35% cheaper than my current policy $802/yr), and strangely its from the same carrier. I say it looks great, and that I want to add rental coverage but other than that everything looks great and I'm thrilled. Then a week goes by with no communication. I send a few emails, no response. I call the office, I'm told he's unavailable and to expect a call back. No call comes. Eventually he responds via email, asks who my current carrier is (we have already established this) and he then responds telling me I'm better off going direct and ends the conversation entirely thanking me for (nothing??) I'm upset, I reach back out via email, phone asking why all of a sudden the change nd demand explanation. Then he responds with a price (not a detailed quote) that's more than I am currently paying and almost double his original quote, $1488. I ask why the drastic change, and suggest maybe this is edging on the unprofessional. He denies this, offers no explanation, and still refuses to respond to my calls and voice mails seeking clarification on WHY this has changed.I finally reach out to the Office and asked to speak with someone else in charge, and they tell me after reviewing our email correspondence that in no uncertain terms it was unprofessional of James to treat me this way and that they will get me another quote. I then get another formal quote that is even more expensive, almost $1800. At this point I'm so fed up, I have wasted so much time dozens of emails, calls, time I could have spent shopping elsewhere. Never got a clear explanation, just a muted apology.I still have a business policy but after this debacle I cannot recommend this place to anyone, which is a shame.

    McGrath Insurance - insurance - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...