Stopped in for an everything bagel with cream cheese and it did not disappoint. Bagel tasted fresh…read moreand very good! Place looked clean the people working there friendly.

Stopped by this bagel shop that got decent reviews. Let's start...the inside is old and dingy…read more Looks a little dirty and unkept. The selection of bagels is limited and when asked what cheese they had, they only had American despite the sign listing several types of cheese. We ordered an everything bagel and a salt bagel, both with butter and tomato and a small coffee. There is an up charge for the everything bagel due to it being an "egg everything bagel". The everything bagel was hard. (And anyone who knows bagels knows egg bagels are the softest bagels). It didn't taste fresh even though it was 830 am. The salt bagel was softer, better and decent. The coffee was hot but taken from a carafe- not freshly brewed, so it also tasted old and flat. The servers were friendly enough and the prices were decent (despite the up charge) , $9.25 dollars for the 2 bagels and coffee. Probably not coming here again, going to look further around for a better bagel shop, I know they're hard to find in this area.

What can we not say about this place! The sandwiches are to die for, the coffee is off the hook…read more(they serve 2 Queens coffee!!!), the brownie bars make you want to hide in the closet and eat the whole damn plate full. The staff are polite, helpful, and hard workers. A local legend works there, Kathy. If you're lucky you'll get the "Kathy treatment." Umpy's offers catering too! We got theit gigantic sub for our son's graduation and mini bagels for my daughter's class party. Always a pleasure eating here. Highly recommend! A+++++

Awful. I got tuna fish on an everything bagel and it was disgusting. Not even an everything bagel…read more Tuna fish was still wet so the bread was wet. No flavor. Worst thing ever. I don't know how this places has this many stars.

Called to order breakfast, and was asked to hold. As shown I was on hold for 7 minutes. During that…read moretime I heard the employee take 3 orders, and in between banter with customers, having full conversations. I stated saying "Hello?", "Hello?" loudly thinking that the woman forgot about me, and immediately after she hung up on me. I thought it was a mistake (seen in the photo) I called back twice, I and was hung up on immediately.

The women who took our orders were really sweet and friendly. Sadly, the bagel with cream cheese…read morewas inedible--the bread tasted stale and dry, with no density or pillowy texture. I took 3 bites and threw the rest out. Additionally, we ordered two hoagies. The bread was thick, dry, and impossible to swallow. The sandwich toppings and dressing were unevenly distributed throughout. I had to fully abandon the bread and eat the inside alone. It was a sad, sad meal.

A definitive 5-Stars for Beyond Bagels - Greentown, PA…read more We had a Monte Cristo sandwich, a burger, fries, a BLT, and a chicken Caesar -- everything was excellent! The food was fresh, flavorful, and served hot. Service was friendly and welcoming, making for a great experience all around. Highly recommend! Quick and easy and alot of desserts but I was too full to partake

Been here several times. Food is usually good. Today, the eggs were so overcooked that the whites…read morewere hard & crispy & there wasn't even a 1/8tsp of yolk. The plate of eggs & toast sat at the edge of the table as 2 waitresses walked to the table about a coffee refill with no word about the food sitting there uneaten. The waitress finally asked about it when we were ready to leave... No, I didn't want them redone, we're leaving. She took my uneaten food back & took 10% off our bill. It wasn't even 1/2 what I paid for my meal. Oh & she threw in 2 bagels. I've never had anyone not take a meal off the bill when it was untouched & still make the customer pay for most of it when they cook it wrong.

Food is top notch, the service is warm and welcoming, the wait time is low, if any, overall we…read moreloved this spot. It's right next to the GWL, we left daily to come here for the awesome bagel sandwiches.

Smells so good when you walk in! This is the kind of bagel place that rocks - no nonsense, get in…read moreline, place your order, and get out - very simple space, a counter a couple coolers and staff that do their best to get you back out the door. We loved our sandwiches! Caution - the paper cups for the tea and coffee are not the strongest and both of our lids popped off in the car. Not a deal breaker, we had extra napkins, but definitely a bummer. We would still go back for more bagels!!!

What a cute little Brooklyn coffee shop tucked away in the mountains, right? WRONG. Brooklyn would…read moreeat this place alive and leave no crumbs - a contrast to the small piles of crumbs all over the floor of this wanna-be hipster, waitfest of a coffee shop. After a long interaction with the well-intended but poorly trained cashier, we moved over to wait for our drinks, only to be told after 14 minutes that he had rung it in incorrectly so they cancelled our order. She said we were overcharged by a whopping 34 cents, so she refunded the order and made us do it all over again when we would've much preferred to not lose the stop for our drinks in this completely stationary line. It's now been over 30 minutes. It would take less time to drive to the IGA, buy coffee beans, grind them, invent the coffee machine, and make yourself a cup of coffee.

Such great coffee! Got the vanilla latte and it was so very creamy! Wish I had an appetite to try…read moreout their menu because it all sounded/looked so yummy. Super cozy spot inside. Tables and couches to sit at. Local artist artwork on the walls. Staff was very friendly and kind.

I am never disappointed by a bagel and iced coffee from the Bagel Bakery! My fave is egg salad on a…read moreplain bagel but their apple cinnamon cream cheese is also amazing.

I pass through Monticello a few times a year and Monticello Bagel has turned into my little road…read moretrip ritual. I pull off, stretch my legs, and you can smell the toasters working the second you open the door. Last time it was a rainy morning and the whole place had that warm bakery air. I ordered an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and a coffee. The bagel came out still warm in a brown paper bag. Good crust, proper chew, not bready. Seeds actually stick instead of shedding all over the car. Small thing, but it matters. The line can look long from the door, but it moves. I was back in my car in maybe ten minutes. Parking is straightforward. If I am trying to make time, the drive through is there and does what it should. The staff is focused and quick. Not chatty in a forced way. Just normal, which I appreciate before caffeine. This is not a fancy place and it does not try to be. No rainbow bagels, no dessert disguised as breakfast. It is a simple bagel shop that knows its lane. Price felt fair. Coffee was hot and not burnt. Cream cheese ratio was right. I am picky about that. Do I wish the menu had a little more going on. Yeah. A couple extra spreads, maybe a rotating special. If you want wild flavors, this is not that stop. But the classics are done properly, and that is why I keep coming back. If you are passing through town and need a quick breakfast that will not let you down, this is an easy yes. Park, grab a bag, get back on the road. Simple, reliable, and it hits the spot..

Love this place! It is worth braving the busy parking lot, jammed with Shabbat shoppers to get a…read morebagel, challah or other baked goods! Always a kind "Shabbat shalom" from the proprietress to me , a shiksa through and through!

I heard about this bakery, which is a Heimishe bakery, from What's Cookin' Sullivan County page on…read morefacebook. Really, I was so surprised that after the season, this bakery is still open. They are planning to close around Columbus Day. For those of you that don't know, Jewish businesses open up in the summer and close when the kids go back to school. Communities with many of these businesses are aflutter with activity and then.....nada. Ghost town. South Fallsburg, Woodridge, and Woodbourne are prime examples. Blink....and you might miss this bakery. Fallsburg seems to be this intersection-a Stewarts on one side, a body shop on the other, Dollar General up ahead, and on the one side, a few Jewish businesses. An ice cream shop, a pizza place, and this bakery. My GPS was trying to point me across the street to the Dollar General. Anyway, once inside, there is a quick sale rack in which I found what I was looking for at an incredible price! Russian babkas at $2 each. After the season, you cannot find a babka in Walmart or Shoprite and if you did, they are usually around $7 or $8. I went late in the day at 4pm, so the bakery was empty, but that's a good thing. Get your last minute things before he leaves!!! Freeze them!

Service is always spectacular. They are only open Sunday, Wednesday- Saturday until 3pm or until…read morethey are sold out, which is pretty often by 1:30pm. Bagels are delicious, I just brought a dozen for the weekend to make egg sandwiches and pizza bagels for the family. When I order a lunch from there, my go to is there tuna on a bagel. So delicious, and I'm very picky with my tuna. They treat everyone like they are family when they walk into their doors. I love giving back to the community.

The best bagels I've had on the East Coast. Very generous portions with an affordable price. The…read morestaff is amazingly friendly. This is the only place I've found where you can get a jalapeño everything bagel. A must try, it makes the perfect sandwich.