We selected Mar Del Caribe from internet reviews for a Tuesday evening dinner as we were heading back to the Isla Verde area after visiting Old San Juan. My wish that night was to find a place offering fried whole snapper and it was on their menu - and I even called ahead to be sure it was available that night. So I was hyped to try their snapper version, and it didn't disappoint. The vibe of the restaurant was that of a friendly neighborhood joint, possibly a bit retro time-wise. Service was prompt and informative. We both had cocktails, and Paige said it was one of the best whisky sours she's had. With the snapper - which was HUGE - I had an order of mamposeao, a rice and bean stew that was amazing. My wife's chicken parm also got a great review from her. We parked in the small lot directly in front of the restaurant, and there was an attendant to help with parking. read more

Mar Del Caribe - Chicken parm and the rice & beans side - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

See all

I love the patio atmosphere at this cafe style restaurant... Perfect for people watching in Old Town San Juan. Also the chicken mofongo with the creamy garlic sauce... perfection read more

Four stars is being very generous. But to be fair, some things were very good and other things had a lot to be desired. As others have mentioned, it looks like a hole in the wall from the outside and parking is a bit difficult but there is parking across the street near what looks like a park. The seafood options are very tasty and nicely presented . So-called avocado salad is just a bunch of slices of avocado on a plate, no salad. The steak was very salty, and even though it was requested to be well done, it came back as a rare to medium. The servers were friendly, but the service itself was a bit slow . It was good overall for most people except the one that ordered the steak. The Mofongo is a Puerto Rican side dish and it was really tasty. I would not repeat read more

See all

Ambiance setting match the quality of the food that was served, simply outstanding! Staff were helpful and attentive. If you are seeking for fresh flavorful food this is your spot. Recommend going early for dinner for the place gets full fast. read more

Mar Del Caribe - Tortellini de queso salsa rosada - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

The Snapper was the highlight of this place! Beautiful ambiance. Great service. They let you know the size beforehand too like it's gonna be huge or smaller. The food was nice for a birthday dinner. read more

I'd love to be able to write a review about the food & ambience. The only thing I can honestly write about is the service, which was NON-EXISTENT for us. We walked into the restaurant & headed to the bar. The hostess gave us 2 dinner menus, & our menus didn't match. Oh, well. Then, we looked at the drink menu. The bartender NEVER even looked at us. After several minutes of waiting for the bartender to notice us, to no avail, we counted to "3" & walked out. This is NO way to treat a customer. We actually walked 24 blocks from our hotel to the restaurant, just to be ignored. Not good. read more

This little hole in the hell yeah! will leaving you feeling like island royalty. In the mood for super fresh, well-prepared seafood? Want a little white tablecloth treatment? Do you enjoy being waited on with the utmost care and attention to detail? This is the spot!! The service here is impeccable! I mean I have never seen food and drinks come so seamlessly while plates and silverware were cleared by the invisible man. The ceviche was an abundant pile of gloriously fresh fish. I asked for more bread to finish it off. I also had the Lobster Thermidor. It was as big as my head and delicious down to the last bite. My margaretes were strong and tasty. Treat yourself to this adorable, authentic place. read more

See all

This place was okay. The only saving grace to this place was the salmon being perfectly cooked and the pear sauce being really good. Everything else was meh. The paella was slapped onto this plate the original dish looked better without the waiter just plopping it onto this plate. Also all seafood except the squid was overcooked on the paella. read more

Mar Del Caribe - Paella - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

This is the easiest review ever: Elevated dining with classic Caribbean comfort food recipes. The service, ambiance and representation of the island was present from the moment you walked in. The food itself was worthy of spending all afternoon tasting and enjoying dishes. But I only had an hour and enjoyed every bite! I will be back! read more

Mar Del Caribe - Beautiful main dining room in an old house. - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

We were searching for a restaurant nearby the Airbnb we were staying at, and we found Mar Del Caribe. The reviews and pictures looked promising, and I could never turn down seafood! The restaurant was clean, and we were luckily able to get seated immediately with 7 people. The service was amazing and so attentive- never had an empty wine or water glass! As for food, 4 of us shared Paella de Mariscos It was seasoned and cooked well with plenty of seafood, including prawns, lobster, squid, mussels, fish. It came out in a large hot pan, and they plated table side- It was such a big portion! Tostones and Chorizo Al Vino were good starters. read more

Mar Del Caribe - Chorizo Al Vino, Tostones - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

See all

The food was amazing, the services was good. We enjoyed the food so much we went back a 2nd time while on vacation. You can't go wrong if you enjoy seafood and Authentic Puerto Rican cuisine. read more

Mar Del Caribe - Lobster tail. - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

Great little spot in Isla Verde. Formal dining area with excellent service. They bring out a bottle of their homemade hot sauce which was great. Their cocktails left something to be desired, I would stick with a bottle or glass of wine. They served complimentary bread and the soups were divine. We had both the lentil and seafood soup. Give this spot a try! read more

So good! Tucked away from the business our tourist, this place was amazing. We got there on the later side but they sat us with open arms. Serving staff and host were all very welcoming. Food was amazing and reasonably priced. Drinks were good as well! Was difficult to tell the atmosphere from the pictures but more upscale. Will be coming back! read more

Mar Del Caribe - Surf and Turf - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

See all

We love this restaurant because it is consistently good! We like the seating outdoors and the service is excellent. We went with another couple. They loved it too The appetizer grilled octopus and the tuna salad with seaweed was delicious. For main course i had the salmon & shrimp with creole sauce. It was delicious. Tacos and whole fish snapper was to die for. This is our second time in this restaurant and we really enjoy it! Hope they continue same so we can enjoy more read more

Go check out the video...EVERY SINGLE PERSON enjoyed every entree. Every drink. Beautiful ambiance read more

Mar Del Caribe - Amazing!!! - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

See all

Excellent neighborhood upscale Puerto Rican restaurant which feels like a family business. Service is excellent from the valet parker, to the entrance host to the very attentive waiters. Prepare to be amazed by this fine dining experience in a spaciously intimate restaurant setting. Would highly recommend the food as being among the best restaurants I frequent on a regular basis. Very highly recommended. read more

My friend and I had dinner at this restaurant last night. We were not disappointed! The food was delicious and the atmosphere was lovely. The white table cloths and quartet of waiters in black suits working as a team gave this place a formal and elegant feel. It was pricey but worth it for a fun and special dinner out in San Juan! read more

Mar Del Caribe - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

See all

Had a fantastic dinner experience @ this fine dining restaurant. Hubby and I kicked off the night with house sangrias ... the crab appetizer was good. We had the cod, lamb chops and seafood soup. Desserts were guava tart and papaya dessert. Will certainly dine again read more

Mar Del Caribe - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

See all

Great food and service. Spanish octopus appetizer one of the stars of the trip. Lobster thermador was huge too

Muy mala comida la paella muy mala el arroz crudo los camarones muy secos y la pasta fettuccine con pollo la peor pasta k Hemos comido sabía a leche batida con queso arriba es el primer día k llegamos a conocer puerto rico primera mala esperiencia read more

Food was decent, but fish and shrimp a bit overcooked. As others have noted, get and review an itemized bill! We were overcharged for cocktails and found we were charged $12 for water which was never requested. Felt scammed in the end. read more

This is a great place to have an authentic Puerto Rican meal. They have several varieties of rice and they are all very good. We had chicken, steak, and pork and they were all excellent in quality and taste. The guava dessert was so good. Our server, Felix was the best server we had while on the entire island. He was attentive and gave really good recommendations for not only what food we should order but other things we should do on the island. The restaurant was very clean and family friendly. We can't wait to go back! read more

We are from the U.S. visiting PR. The service and food were amazing! This was our favorite place! We had the tuna, grouper, snapper, and shrimp dishes amongst the four of us. Highly recommend the guava tart with ice cream for dessert! read more

Went here on a whim and glad we did. The food was amazing and the service was great. It was around 6pm on a Friday and it wasn't busy. I had the lamp chops and it was cooked to perfection. Really wish I remembered to take pics! read more

Everything was delicious. Todo es delicioso! We had lobster, mixed seafood dish with rice and beans. Que bueno! Then we had the cream brûlée. The service was great as well. And the people there were caring. The place from the outside does not describe what they contain on the in. read more

See all

Ordered delivery from here over the weekend- so can't speak to the ambiance- though we have passed it and it is a "hole in the wall". Don't let this stop you- everything we had here was AMAZING. I got the Mofongo with steak, chicken and chorizo and a cheese sauce- it was lick the plate good. But the portions are large- so saved a lot for the next day. read more

Our friends Karen y Eric Vera brought us to Mar del Caribe restaurant for a dinner date. Wonderful service, ambiance and the food was exquisite. We shared the Fried calamari, King crab pastelillos, a wonderful Spanish bottle of red wine and the main courses were to die for. My husband had Fricase of goat, I had ceviche of conch and octopus with a mash of root vegetables. My friend had lamb chops w the same mash and her husband had a wonderful fish filet. We had a blast. TY. read more

Don't let the outside fool you inside it's table cloth and great service and great food. This was our favorite restaurant in Puerto Rico. We ate there three times well worth the money! read more

Interesting vaulted room with a history no one could expalin..ex church maybe? The welcoming suited staff were somewhat stiff and hovered aimlessly, but were there in case of need. Ceviche was fresh, Octopus was grilled and tasty. Large portions. The large seafood Paella was dry and over cooked, eggplant crab was an unslightly dish and enough for a sports team Positioned as fine dining, the staff need training in savoir faire..when's glass of white wine was asked for , after some struggle a glass of Vista Point ($4 at CVS) was the sole undrinkable option from a otherwise bottle only list. Creme brulee was burnt. With just a tweek of finesse this could be a fine dining venue, but 10/10 for effort. read more

Honestly a great place to go! The inside is beautiful and the staff is great!! They are super attentive and I couldn't recommend this place more! The food was overall amazing (we got the seafood paella, surf and turf, chicken Parmesan, and the Alfredo pasta). Everything was reasonably priced and awesome! I could not recommend this enough to both locals and tourists! read more

Mar Del Caribe - Surf and Turf - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

Off the tourist path and very unassuming from the outside. Staff are very nice and the drinks are great. Lobster was excellent! Highly recommend this if you're in San Juan PR. read more

Mar Del Caribe - Lobster in butter and Garlic along with traditional Puerto Rican rice and beans. - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

Food was outstanding! Service was great.. this place is off the beaten path from San Juan but well worth the short drive. Everyone loved their dishes. read more

Elegant intimate setting; fantastic top shelf food choices amd wine list; special culinary creations (including PR traditions); attentive service (in English as well); efficient valet parking, no worries at all. Private room 20 plus. read more

Great seafood. Attentive service. Authentic flavors. A must visit if you are in Isla Verde. read more

Mar Del Caribe - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

What a wonderful experience. A gem in Isla Verde. The best seafood and people (service). Awesome, amazing, friendly. . . Gourmand! Lobster thermidor and arroz mamposteao (ask for it crispy and "a Caballos " with 2 ! Walk from the hotel and get a cocktail de Ostiones right in front! Have a Grey goose martini on Alicia! read more

The food and decor is excellent. The appetizer came out quick. It was small yet delicious. The meal came out slow yet was also delicious. My suggestion is if you see more than 10 patrons inside, check to see if these people have their meals in front of them of them. If they don't, you will likely have to wait far longer than what's reasonable for your meal. read more

Pretty darn good. The seafood soup was very tasty. The lobster was tough but the other seafood was good. Frosty tuna was very nice. Fish tacos with a side of beans and rice was great. I'd come back. read more

Great fine dining experience. My chicken breast stuffed with sweet plantain, mozzarella and mustard was outstanding. (That was my husband's first review ever so you know it's good) This charming little restaurant (that is very unpretentious from the outside) was recommended by the staff where we're staying nearby. We wanted to stretch out from flying and enjoyed the half mile walk to the restaurant,but we did not want to walk home in the dark considering the potholes. To my amazement the lovely owner manager offered us a ride home personally, And we accepted her gracious offer. I took her recommendation to get the scallops and shrimp in an incredible coconut honey sauce. It was amazing, and the tostones were great with it. read more

This doesn't look like much from the outside, but it is worth it for the food! The best ceviche I've ever had and I tried a new dish (to me) called shrimp asopao. My fiancé had the osso bucco with absolutely delicious tostones. read more

Mar Del Caribe - Tostones! - Caribbean Near Me - Isla Verde, Puerto Rico

See all

Good food, highly attentive staff. I had the skirt steak with plantain risotto and the root vegetable puree, wonderful meal.