First of all, the food was amazing! Fresh pizza, salad, etc. When they served us our pizza, they…read moreapologized for an only slightly wonky cut, then gave us ANOTHER pizza, for FREE! We didn't even ask them too. Best pizza place I've ever been too.

We ordered a custom pizza for pick up! The crust was great,…read morethe marinara very tasty, the toppings were sufficient & the cheese was generous! My husband, who picked it up, said the staff was friendly & the restaurant looked clean & tidy! Yummmy!

I hail from the east coast. We relo'd to Colorado 2 years ago. I have been on the hunt for genuine…read moreeast coast pizza, not thick crust, not greasy, just the New York style, thin crust so it flops when you pick it up and you have to fold it, well-seasoned tomato sauce and cheese. I had given up - hey I know I moved to a state that's not east coast and I just figured pizza was one of those things I'll have to miss. Not anymore - I found the genuine New York slices as this location today. We had great service and were served quickly, and the garlic knots were also legit. We will def be back and we were going to return and order an entire pie to go so I could stash it in our freezer - but we ended up having a family emergency and having to leave Manitou. But we will definitely, definitely be back!

This is a great stop for a quick slice if you're feeling the need for sustenance in the Manitou…read moredowntown area. You're not going to find a more filling option in the area for less than $10. I tried the spicy combo option - pizza with jalapenos + the hot knots. For a comical $6.66 it filled me up enough to fuel taking my son and niece to the penny arcade. Not a penny these days, by the way... This is a hole in the wall style restaurant, so seating is fairly limited. Not great for a group of 20, but fantastic for everything else. There was only one fella working the oven, front, and every other hat, but he knocked out order after order with efficiency. Worth a visit! My new go-to for quick eats in Manitou Springs.

Pizza was seriously so good. We were hesitant when we saw mostly teenagers but they were all very…read morehard working and kind. We love the cause behind this business. They missed part of our order and corrected it free of charge which was so sweet as well. The price was also great for how big of a slice you get!

Good selection of pizzas by the slice and good value for the amount you're getting per slice…read more Recommend the Mountain Man or Chicken Bacon Ranch. Skip the garlic knots. Free water cups.

Great pizza made fresh for your order. Tasty sauce and…read moredelicious toppings. Many pizza choices and I like supporting local businesses rather than a big box chain.

I always love the pizza, garlic knots are out of this word! Spinach artichoke dip has a little kick…read morewhich I love!!!! And staff is always amazing, so friendly and gets the food out super fast!

Everything at Pizzeria Rustica is both high quality and delicious but be warned that it is a bit…read morepricey. The two pizzas we had were the Rustica and the Verdure. The base of both of these pizzas are excellent, being the crust and the sauce. The crust is thin with some black char on the bottom. The char adds a lot of flavor that enhances the whole pizza. The crust edge is also well seasoned and has a nice chew to it. Additionally, we had some of the garlic truffle oil that we could dip our crust into and this was a must. The crust is good without it but with it is spectacular. The sauce is what you expect from a San Marzano tomato sauce, thin, light and sweet. It tastes so fresh. What was lacking the most for me was the toppings. They didn't really stand out or make the pizza so much better. On the Rustica the ricotta does make a big impact on those bites but the prosciutto didn't do much. I like the arugula but it's overwhelming especially texture wise. Nothing on the Verdure was that impressive either. The tiramisu is a heavy hitter with the amaretto soaked lady fingers really packing a punch in every bite. One of my favorite tiramisu's in the city. The pizzas and tiramisu are both delicious and I will be back, but with a price of $20 for a fairly small pizza, this will have to be somewhere I only come occasionally.

This place has a lovely patio with outside seating lit up with string lights. Really cute. I didn't…read morelove the metal chairs and table, but it was still nice. We got the antipasto that came with salami, prosciutto, cubed cheese, olives, cold grilled carrot and squash, a couple of pieces of pita and a couple of slices of polenta. It was okay. We also shared a Regina Margherita pie. It was soggy and The grated parm overpowered everything. I hardly tasted the sauce or the fire roasted tomatoes.

The best pizza in Colorado Springs. The best pizza in Colorado, perhaps. If you like an…read moreupper-midwestern pizza (Wisconsin, Ohio, and that other place that does good hand-tossed pies) & value good cheese then I'm sorry buuuuuut you're going to a hotel lobby & you won't regret it. Yeah you can carry it out but holy cats hot out of the oven is best. The small but comfortable bar has a surprisingly good selection of beer on draft, & the bartenders (Amanda & Katie) are complete gems. Salads are really good. I can't recommend too many pizzas because I just get a large cheese - extra cheese - every time. So get extra cheese or I can't really help you. You might be beyond Yelp, anyway.

Eric was great! He was super personable, the service was excellent. We came in around 3pm so it was…read moreempty - we ordered the artichoke dip (they make it, not store bought or pre frozen) it was so good and the little toasty guys it came with were a perfect pairing. The white pizza was freakin delicious - came out very quickly too. When we are back in Colorado Springs, def a must stop again

Legit slice! Felt like pizza and wanted to try some place I hadn't tried before. Opted for the hot…read morehoney pepperoni and was happy to see a variety of pepperoni, ample cheese, delicious sauce, NY style crust, cooked perfectly and finished with the hot honey which adds just the right bit of heat and sweet! It was delivered hot and fresh and though it took an hour to arrive it was worth it. I'll certainly try this place again.

Great pizza! Now this is what pizza should taste like. I…read moreordered thru door dash so I'm not sure about a lot of things but I can say our pizza was fresh, good quality & we all agree that we want to order from here from now on.

Best pizza I've had in Colorado. This guy is amazing at his craft. They use local clean…read moreingredients. Believe me when I say these pies are killer. I'm an paisan from Connecticut.

Best pizza I've had in this city, hands down! Sit down restaurant or food truck, still the best…read more They use premium, local and organic ingredients which is a huge consideration for me. They change the menu up every now and then and seem to have a special menu item each week. These guys make a really good pizza!

Went here on a Saturday for lunch. The indoor area had a great vibe, not as spacious as I'd hoped…read morebut still good. The server was awesome- such a kind-hearted young man. Now for the food. Wow! Just wow. It was everything I had hoped for and more. My partner and I shared a pizza with hot honey and a Caesar salad. The pizza tasted amazing/ a bit floppy but that's because it was thin/thin crust. The salad was epic! The crunchy crispy romaine with lots of delicious dressing and Parmesan cheese chips were delectable! I'd go back for that alone. Give this one a try.

Been here 2 times and both are good experiences. I didn't…read moreknow White Pie was so large. Ample seating inside and outside which is nice. Bench seats outside. On second visit decided to sit outside. We were approached quickly and our server was very polite and attentive. We ordered roasted brussel sprouts. Very good but wasn't large serving. I guess that's why it's an appetizer. Then ordered a White Pie and Three Meat Pie. I was surprised how good they were. Thin crust (needed to be cooked a little longer) with plenty of toppings. The WP was cheese with an egg on top. You will not be disappointed with White Pie. I'd visit again.

The service is fabulous considering how busy they were! The food was great loved the Bri dip. The…read morebeer and liquor was great as well. Coming from out of town it really was fabulous highly recommend. Angel our server was just amazing and was able to answer all our questions. Great night!

One of the best little gems we found in Manitou Springs! Everything about this spot was a win. It's…read moreset in a cozy house with warm wood details and a whimsical swirl of umbrellas hanging from the ceiling. The drinks were delicious - we had a lemon-lavender cocktail that was perfectly balanced. The highlight, though, was the cauliflower buffalo wings. So, so good! The buffalo sauce wasn't overly vinegary, and the blue cheese dip was creamy without that funky taste, making it the perfect balance. Service was also kind and came with solid recommendations. Would absolutely come back!