Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Lighthouse Antique Mall

    5.0 (1 review)

    Lighthouse Antique Mall Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Lighthouse Antique Mall

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Antiques 476 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Strawtown Pottery & Antiques - Inside antique area

    Strawtown Pottery & Antiques

    5.0(1 review)
    7.5 mi

    It's rare that I get excited about writing a review but this is one of those times. The business…read moreowners are the reason. Background is my wife and I have been wanting to start collecting pottery for some time (serving bowls and other dinnerware mostly). Long story short was I found them thru a display at Logan Mall in Noblesville and they suggested I come by for a visit after calling them. The store looks like an extension of the house they reside in...when you walk in it's mainly the antique area. I'm not an antiques guy so I can't speak to what they have on that. My daughter and I wandered around a bit looking for pottery in this area and we found a surface finish that we both liked for a serving bowl. Eventually I struck up a conversation with Diane (one of the owners) asking how she could help, etc. We told her what we were looking for and she very graciously showed us their pottery shop. I met her husband Matt (the other owner) and he took about 20 minutes of his time to explain how they make the pottery (everything by hand...no molds), how they got started, family, etc. They were such nice people and gracious with their time to put up with my rookie inquiries. My daughter found a few old 45s she wanted as well. Diane said it would be a couple of weeks for the bowl. Fast forward a couple of weeks and I went to pick it up. It was exactly how we wanted. They informed me the finish/glaze was difficult and took a couple of tries but they got it. It is absolutely perfect and will hopefully be in our family for a very long time. The location is right at the corner of IN37 and Strawtown Avenue. If you are looking for handmade pottery with two business owners that have a passion for what they do then swing by and tell them Chris sent you :-). This is a type of business that you want to support and I'm looking forward to doing more business with them in the future.

    Photos
    Strawtown Pottery & Antiques - Matt making pottery...all done by hand.  No molds.

    Matt making pottery...all done by hand. No molds.

    Strawtown Pottery & Antiques
    Strawtown Pottery & Antiques

    See all

    Caldwell Antique Mall & Flea Market

    Caldwell Antique Mall & Flea Market

    4.1(12 reviews)
    32.2 mi
    $$

    Great place for browsing. Nice people at check out. Home decor is worth checking. Thxread more

    I've found my new favorite place. We have recently purchased a house in the area and I am trying to…read morefurnish it. I have been looking for places where dealers have individual booths. Finally, I found this place. The store has great parking out front. The aisles are large and easy to navigate. There are so many different types of dealers that everyone is sure to find a treasure. I was looking for furniture. Not only did I find exactly what I was looking for, but the prices were extremely affordable for the quality represented. I found several accent tables and nightstands. I even found a lovely small sideboard that was solid wood. I also found a great set of nesting tables for $59.99. I was amazed since I have bought a set at wholesale price in the past and paid close to $150 for them. Darion was super knowledgeable and incredibly helpful. As said, I purchased a number of larger pieces and wanted to fit them all into my vehicle. Darion took the time to help me load them and reload them in my car until we were able to fit most of them in. She was willing to keep trying different ways to get it all in. She definitely went above and beyond. Without her help I would have had to get someone to come help me load my car since the pieces were too bulky and heavy to do it alone. She was AMAZING!!!!!! I look forward to coming in on a regular basis since these types of stores have constantly revolving stock. If you see something you like, buy it, because it will be gone the next time you come in.

    Photos
    Caldwell Antique Mall & Flea Market
    Caldwell Antique Mall & Flea Market
    Caldwell Antique Mall & Flea Market

    See all

    Kaye's Antique Barn - Kaye's Antique Barn just steps from Gilley's front door. Park in same lot.

    Kaye's Antique Barn

    4.5(4 reviews)
    41.6 mi
    $$

    Maybe it was just having left Gilley's that affected my perception of this place. Or maybe it's…read morethe lack of accessibility that this place has that keeps it from getting a higher rating. They have some nice stuff here, including a lot more furniture than I expected. They have more room upstairs for browsing too. But the barn seems small compared to the antique mall next door, so unless there is something here that screams "Buy me!", it's kind of hard to rate it higher. Be aware that this is an old barn and has a raised center aisle to walk on. That means low head clearance for air ducts, so watch out. Also, if you are rubber-necking and not looking down, the step down into the rooms/booths on the first floor is large (maybe a 10" drop!) and it would be easy to stumble if you aren't paying attention. Fortunately, the owner did mark the steps in yellow and write "Step" on the ground, but who looks down when you are surrounded by stuff at eye level? I guess I should have. On the positive side, there were some beautiful furniture pieces and a really cool store counter that had shelves that extend all the way through the counter, having a display window on the outside of the piece. This allowed you to see what was in the drawer as a purchaser. Not sure what you would do with this at home, but it was an ingenious piece of Americana. Review #1959

    Cute place lots of nice big furniture. Ended up just buying a set of glass door knobs at a great…read moreprice. Head space in a few areas is very low so if you are tall watch your noggin.

    Photos
    Kaye's Antique Barn - Exterior

    Exterior

    Kaye's Antique Barn - Entrance on the south side

    Entrance on the south side

    Kaye's Antique Barn - Watch your step...it's a doozie if you aren't paying attention

    See all

    Watch your step...it's a doozie if you aren't paying attention

    Lighthouse Antique Mall - antiques - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...