Decent assortment of ice cream flavors but it's incredibly slow to try and get anything in there…read more Only one person was working in there on a summer Saturday afternoon/evening, and it took close to half an hour to get 3 people some ice cream. The shop is very large and would seat a number of people comfortably, but looks a little spare right now. There were some annoying people in there discussing politics very loudly, acting like they were defending their own honor or something. They took up a lot of the counter time trying to engage the young server with their political discussion (I guess trying to get him to agree) and I think a more experienced customer service person would have been better able to deflect their questions and move things along. A manager probably should have been on site to make that happen. My daughter had Muddy Boots and liked it, my husband had Maine Blueberry and loved it, and I had chocolate, which was very good. The ice cream is good.

Truly a gem of a shop along the small strip of Carthage. My fiancé and I would walk past the store…read moredaily on our way to the gym until finally we decided to try it out. We brought our service dog along with us. Upon entering the shop, you are blanketed by a feeling of warmth and adorable sweet treat decorations that have a hint of country. The menu is visible on the wall and as we waited, because there was a line, we were able to pick out what we wanted: a root beer float, cookies and cream milkshake, and a small cup of vanilla ice cream for our SD. The cashier whom I'm assuming is the owner/wife was extremely kind and did not even take a second glance at our SD. She took our orders and we patiently waited at a table as the other owner/husband prepared our desserts. We realized they had opened their store in memory of their deceased daughter. Our ice creams were ready and my god, when I tell you it was some of the best ice cream I've ever had, I mean it! So creamy, so flavorful. My cookies and cream milkshake was packed with bursts of cookie cream and cookie bits. It was thick but not too thick to the point where I would have to eat it with a fork. Everything was wonderful. My fiancé enjoyed his root beer float, and I did too! We shared just about everything, even taking a bite out of our SD's ice cream cup, which he inhaled. We will be returning soon for a multitude of reasons.

Great service and product offered on a busy evening. Visit family each summer and this business is…read morealways a stop or two while in town.

Friendly service and very good ice cream with tons of variety…read more We are thinking of going to try more flavors.

We've stopped at this ice cream shop for years. They serve Hershey's ice cream and they have soft…read moreserve too. Their employees are always wonderful, customer service is A+. Their servings are notoriously very big. The small is 2 scoops that are so big they stick out of a pint container. I had almond coconut chocolate and a bourbon caramel. Both delicious.

This is one of those places that, if you're not looking, you'll miss it!…read more It's a small ice cream shop that's doing all the things. While the ice cream isn't house-made--it's Hershey's--they have a huge selection of flavors, and they clearly list what they have along with the sizes. And let me tell you, even the "baby" size is BIG! The staff was pleasant and friendly, and honestly, if you can't find a flavor you like here, you have an issue. Parking is on the street, but if you're in the area, give this little spot a whirl!

Staff is Very good service and very nice and friendly The…read moreice cream is amazing and very tasty

I love fall I ate pumpkin ice cream in the summer Yay!…read moreI love water You can eat ice cream while near the lake

nice place to stop and get ice cream. I do wish they took credit cards. place pretty busy in summer…read moreweekends. wide assortment of ice cream. I wish they served coffee drinks and coffee

Friendly service, delicious ice cream, good prices and large servings. Comfortable outdoor seating.read more

Biggest servings, tastiest choices, and best selection of ice cream in the North Country! It's a…read morefamily tradition to visit Good Ol'wishy's that we all look forward to every summer.

If you're in Croghan this is a must stop!!! So many flavors of ice cream to choose from, and the…read moresizes are unbelievable!

Delicious local cheese! I love the selection of goat cheese they offer and it's better to buy localread more

This farm is on route 12 and has a self serve farm store. Look for the farm sign on the left…read moreheading north on route 12 between Boonville and Lowville. When you see it turn into the farm. The self serve store has many ways they process goat milk but the gelato is our favorite. The mint flavor is bright and the gelato is not green because they don't die it green. It is great to be able to buy the products on the farm that produced them. They sell other local food products as well. Stop in today.

Absolutely wonderful place, our family were in Watertown for a day out with our toddlers, zoo,…read morelunch, playground, ice cream kind of day, well when we yelped to see what's around for ice cream shops this place came up. We love to try out new places so we chose it. No regrets here - first of the product, ice cream was the best I have had to date, really yummy, second very kid friendly place - toys, kid books, little tool set, small picnic table for littles. Owner very pleasant and friendly. Tried to accommodate our picky toddlers and provided them with a ball to play. Such a relaxed environment, it was very easy to enjoy icecream, while our kids played and went back and forth between grabbing a mouthful of icecream and going back to play. Place radiated with positive atmosphere and relaxed demeanor, just loved everything about it. No stress just icecream and fun! If you are in the area give this place a chance. Oh and they offer other treats like chocolate covered strawberries and pretzels, rice crispies and thos place has a promise of smoothies, I am personally looking forward to that too. I had full intention of taking photos of my ice cream and kids having fun but I was too busy enjoying both. I'll have to co.e back with my real camera next time and take photos. You will not regret trying this place out - it's a little gem.

This place is dangerouslyyyyy good! I got some truffles the other day that didn't even make it…read morehome! The owner is really friendly and great. Plus they are open through most of winter so highly recommend checking this place out!!

I like big scoops and I cannot lie. Other ice cream shops can't deny…read more.. Great flavor selection, a few spots to sit outside and enjoy your ice cream. However the real star here is the portion sizes. You definitely get your money's worth and if you leave hungry, that's on you.

We stopped in for ice cream, because we heard the portions were huge. My wife ordered a baby baby…read morecone, which was two scoops, I went for a baby cone, which was three. Many flavors of Hershey's hard ice cream, they also have soft ice cream. FYI, all serving sizes can be served in a bowl rather than a cone. I'd opt for the bowl if anything bigger than a baby!

A must in old forge! The ice cream was good. It is in a cool area next to nutty putty. We enjoyed…read moreour ice cream.

We stopped here after seeing Leon Entienne, an illusionist at The Strand. It was a great way to…read morefinish the evening. The service was quick and the ice cream delicious!