The pizza and food is so good here, my wife and I are willing to drive 45 minutes to eat here. The pizza here is the closest to New York quality pizza we have found since moving to Central Pa. from NYC/ N.J. The dishes are excellent and very generous. We always have leftovers to bring home and enjoy a second time. Prices are reasonable and the service is fast and friendly, as well as being well staffed. The dining area is spacious offering booths and table. Each table and booth can sit anywhere from 4-6 people. There is also a small bar offering wines and beer. The dining area and restrooms are clean. I highly recommend this restaurant for pizza lovers as well for delicious Italian dishes. read more

See all

This is our third visit here. The pizza has been consistently good. The staff if friendly.

The food is always so so good with excellent portions. We have never had bad service there. It's a calm atmosphere where you can actually put your phones down and have a conversation. The manager/owner Sal is an amazing person and literally treats his guests like family. We will be going there more often! Love love love this place! read more

I usually go to Kings in Hedgesville, but Ive been to Falling Waters, Inwood locations. These folks serve LARGE portions and the quality of the food, altho slightly different in each location, rivals neighborhood Italian restaurants in the DC area. Prices have risen lately but not bad. Great NY style pizza. Mostly friendly staff, highly recommended! read more

Consistency is ALWAYS the main ingredient at this Kings NY Pizza location! It is evident not just in the foods but with a waiter like seasoned waiter Panji you'll enjoy first class attentiveness and service. As to the ambiance, the entire restaurant has a great atmosphere that is not just a beautiful and artfully decorated dining experience, but is super clean that can be attributed to the leadership experience of owner manager Sal. If you're looking for a great authentic Italian cuisine, you must include Kings NY Pizza! Simple delicious! Simple perfect! read more

Kings New York Pizza - Falling Waters - Italian Near Me - Falling Waters, West Virginia

This is one of my favorite establishments to stop and grab a bite to eat when traveling from NYC heading down South and vice versa. It's like a treat on the road for a slice of pizza as well as dining at Kings New York Pizza after several hours on the road. The food here does not disappoint. Taken food on the run/go. Pizza fresh and hot. Ordered and picked up food from the hotel. Food was piping hot and delicious. Dined at the restaurant. Wait staff was friendly, polite as well as checks in on you. Good service. They out of coffee. Made fresh pot for us. We came one hour before closing. Prices are reasonable and entrees can be shared. My all time favorite items Margherita Pizza Sausage Pizza White Pizza Sausage Roll Saltimbocca All Romana Veal Marsala Kings New York Pizza has an extensive menu. Look forward to trying other items. Don't forget the deserts Cannoli Homemade Tiramisu- we got 2 to go Restaurant very convenient to get to and not far off the highway I-81. read more

See all

We live nearby and love this place. They always give us a big enough serving for two meals. Their garlic bows are the best.

So far, this restaurant serves up the best New York-style pizza in the area, and it's a truly authentic Italian spot that I definitely recommend. We've enjoyed everything from their salads to five different pasta dishes, and each dish has rated at least 8.5 out of 10. The portions are generous--filling yet full of flavor--and the staff are friendly. This place is great for families or for dates, as it's welcoming for all kinds of gatherings. read more

This pizza was very good! I got a cheese slice, they put a lot of cheese on their pizza which is totally fine by me. My husband got the pepperoni roll which he loved and said there was a lot of cheese on it as well. We also got the garlic bows as they were called which were loaded with garlic but pretty good. This place is pretty expensive but tasted really good. The service was very fast too! We got it to go so we didn't really pay attention to the inside of the place. If we are ever in West Virginia again we will stop by again! read more

Kings New York Pizza - Falling Waters - Slice of Cheese Puzza - Italian Near Me - Falling Waters, West Virginia

See all

We were traveling through and staying one night so decided takeout pizza would be the easiest. The pizza was good and we tried a few sides also which were all tasty. The only critique was the girl answering the phone and at the pickup counter correcting me on how to pronounce my name twice. I literally stayed a pickup for Lana and she replied back a pickup for Layna. My family and I laughed about it but it was enough that the second time passed through Fallingwaters, we didn't order from Kings. read more

Terrible, jar sauce would be better, never saw sausage sliced in a sauce before. Won't be back read more

Kings New York Pizza - Falling Waters - Spaghetti -with sausage - Italian Near Me - Falling Waters, West Virginia

Although I only picked up subs once, the steak and cheese was the best I've had in the area!

We ordered takeout from King's off the highway when driving home after traveling for the weekend. The restaurant was clean, and the staff was friendly. Within 20 minutes or ordering, we had a very large hot and ready pizza to go. The pizza was tasty and pretty cheesy (a little too cheesy). We had to wait for a bit to let the cheese set on the pizza. It wasn't the most flavorful pizza we've ever had but was still a great option for some off the highway pizza. read more

See all

Great Italian restaurant! Portions so big you almost have to take left overs home! Absolutely delicious! read more

Kings New York Pizza - Falling Waters - Cream of Crab soup - Italian Near Me - Falling Waters, West Virginia

My last time coming here!! Ordered 3- slices to go, cook put pizza in the oven, put it in the box on the counter, the cashier was so worried about feeding her face, she ignored the box sitting on the counter top for at least 15- minutes, as she eating, when she finally opened the box and saw the pizza , I was looking right at me, her eyes got big she knew I was pissed, like I said I've had 3- bad experiences here and I'll never come back read more

The food is good. I get food here every few weeks. Normally the staff is very friendly, but not today. The cashier was absolutely rude, multiple times. I ask for the manager to explain how I was treated. I told the manager if I ever see this cashier again, I'll leave and won't ever come back. In retrospect I wish I had ask for a refund and never visiting there again. I probably won't. There are lots of good pizza restaurants in the area. I recommend Tony's New York Pizza. read more

Very much enjoyed the meal. Only thing I would say is the food is heavy and tasty. A lot of cream and cheese in almost everything which made it heavy, but it was very tasty. Nice and clean little spot so when driving for a longer time. This was a nice little cozy spot to stop. read more

Food and service are very good! Prices are reasonable for the quality of food. Very casual decor.

Food ok. Waiter good. They penalized me for using a credit card. Sorry ....your surcharge fee not welcome. There are too many other restaurants without. Won't be back read more

We are traveling and decided to give this restaurant a try. We are sure glad we did! The food was delicious and the service was fantastic. My sister had a salad and the stuffed shells, I had a "small" pepperoni stromboli (it was huge) we both enjoyed our meal. Our server Bryana was friendly and very attentive. The ambiance was relaxing and the owner stopped by our table to ensure everything was to our liking. There was something on the menu to accomadate anyone's budget. read more

More like 3.5 stars. Don't use the Yelp directions (a feature I love, BTW) - the GPS took us to a dead end street in a residential neighborhood. Once we plugged the address to the Food Lion in, we got there easily. First impression - it's a beautiful space. Very clean and decorated well. It was a bit of a roller coaster after that. Hubby ordered a beer - domestic, simple. Server advised "we don't have that, we're out. I know it's on the picture, but we don't have any." Ok, no worries he ordered a different one. The kid orders an orange slice. She looks at us like we've lost it. So I repeated it and showed her on the menu. Her reply? "I don't know why that's on the menu, we've never had that." Ok. Sprite it is. We ordered our meals - the menu is standard Italian fare and we ordered a slice of cheese pizza to go along, because hey, how else can you evaluate a place like this? Hubby was thrilled they had French dressing for the salads and the server commented to ask if it was hard to find. I only mention this conversation, because sure enough, she brought ranch. Oh well. He ate the ranch. The bread is phenomenal. I read that they make their own. Crusty on the outside, soft on the inside - awesome. The olive oil dipping sauce was lovely. The salads were good and super fresh. You would think that a place that makes its own bread would attempt to make salad dressings as well, but alas, Ken's packets came to the table. You know, the take out kind. My manicotti and Hubby's stuffed shells were done well. Nicely stuffed with ricotta (they don't cheap out and under fill their pasta like some places do), covered in a flavorful sauce and melted mozzarella. The kid's spaghetti with meat sauce (adult size, because we've sadly outgrown kid's menu portions) was ok, though a little watery. The pizza slice was good - the crust nice and chewy and the sauce was slightly sweet, the way I like it. It would definitely be worth ordering a whole pie on another visit. All in all, despite the small hiccups, we would come here again when in the area. It's a nice alternative to the chains. read more

See all

I used to love ordering from here but they have priced themselves down to two stars. $20 for calamari? $16 for a cheeseburger sub? For those prices to be justified the food needs to be outstanding and unfortunately Kings food just doesn't match the pricing any more. They've lost a customer due to their pricing increases. read more

Great pizza and good prices name of game here. Been here couple times for pizza and never let's us down. Best pizza place in Hagerstown area. read more

Pulled off interstate, just passing thru. Expected a quick pizza joint. Pleasantly surprised to walk into an awesome Italian Restaurant. Clean, sparkling, looked new. Full menu. Bread & 'dip'- delish. Cheese on baked ziti not quite melted. Anti pasta salad more anti than salad but fresh. Excellent service read more

Kings New York Pizza - Falling Waters - Store front - Italian Near Me - Falling Waters, West Virginia

Recently moved to the area and have been looking for good restaurants to order from, found one here, the food is delicious, fair prices and polite staff. Will definitely make it a regular! read more

My favorite go to for consistently great food. I haven't had one bad meal. I have been frequenting Kings in both Falling Waters and Hedgesville and they are amazing. read more

We stopped in here for dinner tonight for the first time and it definitely won't be our last. Portions were very generous and the food was great. read more

Kings New York Pizza - Falling Waters - Calamari - Italian Near Me - Falling Waters, West Virginia

See all

Great place to get an actual white pizza that isnt Alfredo. They make their white pizza so correctly, I wont go anywhere else for one. It is so consistent in flavor and presentation. I have never had a bad experience. read more

I just ordered an appetizer (Hot Antipasta) that the waiter said had never been ordered! It is phenomenal! It was not my norm, but I was trying to go go more Whole Foods with less carbs and his fit the bill. It was VERY tasty. It is more than just an app; but a full meal. It should really be main course instead an app. Service was great, wish they had more draft beer or wine selection but mine was great. read more

Kings New York Pizza - Falling Waters - Italian Near Me - Falling Waters, West Virginia

Amazing place. Food is it utmost quality and the owner is going the extra mile to care for you and your meal the best ever

Excellent and fast service, quality food for great price! Would definitely recommend, you won't be disappointed

Our favorite place for Italian style food! From the starter bread with olive oil dipping sauce, garlic knots, lasagna, and eggplant Parmesan to the sautéed broccoli or spinach, you get a home run every time...and the serving size? It's like getting 2 for 1 price! Try it, you'll like it! read more

The pizza at the falling waters location isn't as good as the location in Hedgesville. The pizza didn't have any flavor and not much cheese. The Hedgesville location the pizza tasted amazing and had lots of cheese read more

7 December 2013: Tony and I dined at King's Pizza for lunch. I was pleasantly surprised at the quality of the food. I guess I went in with "Kkay, shopping plaza restaurant food" but came out with WOW, wonderful NY style pizza!! The manager, Salvatore, stopped at our table to greet us and offered us some fresh baked bread. They sell loaves of bread at a very reasonable price, which I wish we had bought some. It was fabulous! The dipping sauce that came with the bread was flavorful. We always ask for fried eggplant on our pizza even though it's typically not on any menu. We also had sausage. We ordered the medium, which when it arrived, I thought it was a large!! It was huge! It was excellent, although a little too much cheese for me. The pizza was very good with a nice crust, and I could imagine an excellent eggplant parmesan. The egglant is cut thick with a nice batter. Prices are reasoanble and the menu is filled with standard Italian dishes. Our waiter was friendly and attentive. The other staff members seemed friendly too. This is a place I'd definitely return to. read more

See all

I always loved this restaurant, went there about twice a month till we went and were seated near front of window in dinning room. It was loaded with bugs, flying all around our heads into our food crawling in and out of our bread. I was so angry and told them about it, we paid for an expensive meal could not eat it or even able to eat bread and dip in olive oil with seasonings. I left in a huff. I will never go back To that restaurant again, I tell everyone about our experience there. It was just terrible. Why don't u get an exterminator in stead of putting up Bug zappers on the wall. Totally discussing. It was such a good restaurant at one time. You certainly have lost plenty of business. We now go to kings in Martinsburg, very good food there also. read more

Fantastic food and service every time. We eat at King's once a month when we are in the area. Portions are large! read more

Always a great and dependable meal. We visit them often for takeout food and the only thing I wish they had was delivery!

Great Italian food, friendly staff, would definitely recommend. They also deliver so that's what I've been doing for the last year instead of dining out. Pizza slices are huge, so are the portions of other items. I'll always get the small steak and chees hoagie, otherwise I will be eating it for a few days. Linguini with white sauce and the veal marsala are two favorites. I live in Martinsburg, WV....not sure or why its showing Californian?? read more

Driving through town stopped ordered food. All across the board stop and eat here if ur driving through

Food is decent, sometimes seems like they fry the heck out of everything. staff is rude. Prices are very pricy. Pizza is great.