Kellyo's Pizza

(2 reviews)

0.3 mi

This place was a great place to watch college football! The food was excellent and the service was…read morereally good. They set up our group in the back room and we had plenty of room and tv's to watch the game. If and when we go back we will definitely be visiting again.

Really good pizza! Definitely the best pizza in town! The cheese doesn't fall off as your eating…read moreit. The double dough pizza is my favorite.

See all

Little Italy's Pizza

Great place to stop by while visiting famiky while in town. We had the ribs and the Italian beef…read moresandwich... yummy! More power to you, guys!

Great delivery. If you're in town for the night, you could do a lot worse. Their cheese is great,…read moregreasy but that's part of the attraction

My daughters first time trying little Italy's she loves it

See all

Bobe's Pizza

1.0

(1 review)

0.5 mi

I have been a Bobes pizza lover for years. I have only tried this location twice and both times I…read morewas disappointed . The first time I figured they may have had an off day, but this second time was 100% worse. My pizza was so cold it felt like it had been sitting in a refrigerator instead of made when I ordered it. Thumbs down Bobes pizza!

Pizza Hut

Went in at lunch to get the buffet. They had no salad bar out and only a single pizza, after…read morewaiting several minutes they brought out a couple of single topping pizzas. I asked about the salad bar and was told that they would make me a salad and bring it out but by the end of my meal I never got it and the server never came back to the table. Very disappointing and not worth the money spent.

Service was very well but the food and place is so rundown and so bad. Food was horrible, forks…read morewere dirty, cups smelled like cleanser and pizza smelled and tasted like plastic even the server told me it tasted werid. This Pizza Hut needs better cooks and better people to clean their things.

Pee on the seats and toilet was not clean

Fork was dirty

See all

Sink looked like someone wipped their a** on it

Dimaggio's Pizza

So lucky to have this family owned restaurant! Nice varied…read moremenu, a longtime favorite for over 50 years! Fresh made pizza dough with delicious toppings.

Always and forever, a Carmi standard! We love everything about Dimaggio's! Don't hesitate-- just…read moreorder and enjoy!!

Hamburger, mushroom, ham. Oh my!

Large super deluxe

See all

Raw bacon on pizza? Eww.

Casey's

(1 review)

0.4 mi

Great crew of people working their always friendly and are willing to help out if neededread more

Susan Bobe's Pizza

Pizza very good! Service very good. Pizza is best at the restaurant but delivered items are good.read more

I just ate and wasn't offered a knife or fork. I asked if I got a knife or folk or ate with my…read morehands. He said it was up to me. Didn't get a refill on my water the guy never came back to my table, as he was too busy talking to his friend. I paid cash and thought there was a 4 percent discount, but not. I had to tell him how much I got back in coin. The food was good but ruined the experience. No napkins on the table I had to get my own. The lady that works there in the evenings is really nice, but I didn't see here there this afternoon.

See all

Roscoe & Sons' Pizza

11.4 mi

Great pizza, fantastic customer service. They have a variety of pizza, sandwiches and pasta. Give…read morethem a call "You've had worse" great slogan!!!

Customer service is top notch! Everything they offer is amazing. I love that they go outside the…read morebox when thinking of new flavors to pair together. Always adding to the menu but not taking away from the quality. Favorite pizza place in Gibson county!

See all

Robear's Pizza

(6 reviews)

44.6 mi

My first time here. Ask for white base sauce ! The crust is very nice. The cheese is really good…read more The toppings were fresh and flavorful. I can't wait to go back and try many more things ! I don't know if the name changed to GG's or if it's always been ?

Pizza is great plenty of toppings. The staff has been really nice every time I have been in. They…read morealso are pretty quick with getting your order prepared and ready for you on walk in orders.

Margherita pizza with white base sauce. DELICIOUS!

See all

Big Jon's Lunch Box

was visiting from outta town/state, and settled on lunch here (after rabbit-holeing) the night…read morebefore. their prices are UNBEATABLE, it's a simple space, that's CLEAN, and inviting. we got the catfish special, and a kids meal, to split and try. EVERYTHING was amazing, tastes like grandmas, and definitely made in house. the catfish and nuggets were perfect! onion rings, coleslaw, and mac salad were top tier

Stop in last year when I was in town for bring a group of kids to tour the local college. It was so…read moregood I knew I would have to come back when I got the chance to do the same trip. My omelette was delicious and filled with lots of fresh veggies and meat. The waitress was very kind and friendly and checked on us several times. Choice of table or booth for sitting and nicely decorated with kitchen hummer posters and the like.

Deliciousness. catfish special and catfish nugget kids meal

Decor, that's true!

See all

Rueben sandwhich and dbl cheeseburger. Dbl cheese was more than enough to fill up a grown man.

Kellyo's Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Kellyo's Pizza also viewed

Susan Bobe's Pizza

4.0

(25 reviews)

•$$

Pizza very good! Service very good. Pizza is best at the restaurant but delivered items are good.read more

Roscoe & Sons' Pizza

Great pizza, fantastic customer service. They have a variety of pizza, sandwiches and pasta. Give…read morethem a call "You've had worse" great slogan!!!

Kyle's Una Pizza

3.3

(4 reviews)

Pizza was hot and had a crispy crust. Sauce has a strong oregano flavor and lacked tomato flavor…read more Needs to be a little sweeter. Try somewhere else if they're open. Only reason I gave this high of a score is the delivery girl was very nice.

We ordered a half pepperoni half deluxe pizza from here to be delivered. It was dark outside so I…read moredidn't have a chance to see it till I got inside. When we opened the box it was all deluxe. When my wife called to tell them their mistake he tried telling us we ordered pepperoni on half of the deluxe. Which is not true. We have ordered several half an half pizzas from here. After she explained we couldn't wait on another pizza do to her being diabetic and already taken her medication they just hung up on her. Very rude. I don't care if this is the last place on earth that serves pizza I will NEVER order from Kyle's again!!!

Taco Tierra of Mt. Carmel

4.0

(33 reviews)

•$

It's a local favorite and has been around many years. The staff is always friendly with quick…read moreservice, and the restaurant is always clean.

Hard work and passion goes into every order making sure each is better than the next.read more

Shelly's Pizza

3.5

(2 reviews)

•$$

The pizza was pretty good, but the owner is too cheap to run the air conditioner. It's worth the…read moretrip to Ft. Branch or Princeton to eat.

Had the 18" thin crust pepperoni, mushroom & extra cheese pizza. My family was in a hurry and…read morehungry. We'd never been here before so we took a chance. The service and pizza were both great! We were very pleased, we'll definitely be back for more.

American Table - Princeton

4.0

Had breakfast this morning. Fast and hot when delivered to the table. Service was great. Prices are…read morebetter than most Evansville restaurants. Coffee was good too.

Small, family friendly diner! Breakfast, lunch, or dinner -it is all good. Great prices & specials…read moreeach day! The portions are so large I usually eat on them for 3 days Service is always fast and friendly.

P J's Pizza

4.7