DO NOT USE THIS SHOP! HE IS A LIAR AND WON'T FIX THE THINGS HE BREAKS!
Sometime around the beginning of the February 2019, my 2011 Ford F-250 Superduty began to leak a very small amount of oil. We took it to our local mechanic shop (Jerry Potts Auto) who have worked on it many times for a diagnosis. They found the problem to be the upper oil pan gasket failure which is a common problem for these truck but this particular shop didn't handle jobs of that size. My husband then reached out to James Dodson Service Center LLC in his hometown Sparta, Tennessee for an estimate. James Dodson said that he would be happy to fix and quoted us the price of $1000.
We dropped my truck off to James Dodson Service Center LLC Thursday February 7, 2019 and was told the job would take roughly a week, that we should be able to pick it up on Wednesday February 13th. James called my husband later that day to tell him our problem was not the Upper Oil Pan Gasket but that he knew with certainty that it was actually the Valve Cover Gasket that was leaking the oil. By Tuesday (2/12) we had still not heard from James and we had left multiple messages that went unanswered. Not knowing what was going on with my truck, Saturday (2/16) I went to James' business Facebook and messaged him hoping to get an update. His cell phone number was listed on his Facebook page so I text messaged him as well. Finally, I got a response text followed immediately by a phone call. He informed me that my truck wasn't finished and that he had broken a major bolt off in the cylinder head while he was taking out my injectors. He said that it was now leaking oil and coolant. I asked him for an update date that he thought my truck would be finished and ready for me to pick it up. James responded with "I don't know why you're rushing me, I will put the valve cover back on and you can come get your **** truck right now." I told him I was not trying to rush him but at this point I was just wanting an update as we were days over the original pick up date. He said that he would need my truck for at least an additional week. I asked him what he was going to do about my cylinder head bolt that he had broken and he said that he was going to fix it, but that the bolt breaking was not his fault whatsoever. He "Fixed the bolt, put my injectors back in and started the truck. Wednesday (2/20) he called my husband to let him know it was still leaking oil. He said that he was incorrect in the diagnosis of the Valve Cover Gasket failure and that our problem was the Upper Oil Pan Gasket that we had brought the truck to him to fix to begin with. He said that he would need at least an additional week to fix the Upper Oil Pan Gasket problem. At this point, my husband and I agreed to go get the truck and not let James work on anything else. We went to the shop and picked up my truck. James said that since he didn't fix our problem that he wasn't charging us due to the fact that he misdiagnosed it but that our valve caver gasket still held the 12 month 12,000-mile warranty.
Wednesday February 27, 2019, we took my truck to Full Force Diesel in Murfreesboro, TN to get the Upper Oil Pan Gasket fixed. While in their shop, they found that the bottom half of the bolt James Dodson's shop had broken was now in my oil pan. Paid $1487.51 and have had no issues at all to date from the Upper Oil Pan Gasket.
On April 14, 2019 my truck started to make a knocking noise. We took it back to Full Force Diesel and when they did the diagnosis they found that when repairing the bolt they had broken, James Dodson's shop drilled the bolt crooked which caused the cylinder head to crack and led to my injector backing out of the engine. So as of today April 23, 2019 my repair bill just to fix the things that James Dodson Service Center LLC broke is a little over $3700. This includes two new injectors, two new injector line kits, a new cylinder head, 18 head gasket bolts, one new head gasket, four new glow plugs, one new valve cover gasket, one new manifold gasket, one new turbo pedestal gasket and of course the labor hours charged by Full Force Diesel. read more