Delicious cookies and ice cream options/combos. Service gets a little overwhelmed, as it's a small facility and they can get very busy with both in-store patrons and online orders. Very much appreciated the efforts they went to ensuring that cross contamination regarding gluten was appropriately handled. Separate utensils, gloves changed, etc. Love the late hours. It's a bit of a whole in the wall, but given that it doesn't pretend to be a dine-in facility, it's perfectly adequate for a take-out/delivery location. I did not experience any of the service issues that others mentioned in their reviews. read more

Yummy, late night fresh cookies and ice cream! What more can you ask for? Five stars!

Just had a dozen delivered - (Used GrubHub since that is my go-to for delivery to places I am not familiar with. They have an easy ordering system so I go with what I know): Excellent service - Was delivered via the Insomnia store vehicle. Instructions followed to a "t". Very quick - Delivered within the commitment time provided Great product - The receiver was very pleased. Will order from them again! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Special dozen - 5 regular and 1 specialty cookie - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Vegan Birthday Cake, HECK YEAH Vegan Double Chocolate Chunk, ^not the favorite. Vegan Chocolate Chunk,couldn't tell the difference with the non vegan chocolate chunkYUM Chocolate Chunk, almost gone, loves it White Chocolate Macadamia, helz yeah Oatmeal Raisinate that quicker than u can say yum read more

Insomnia Cookies - Vegan Birthday Cake Vegan Double Chocolate Chunk Vegan Chocolate Chunk Chocolate Chunk White Chocolate Macadamia Oatmeal Raisinate - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

I had an issue with my order I placed via insomnia's Instagram which was transferred to DoorDash delivery. Upon receiving my order late , I received the wrong milk flavor, boxes unsealed, and missing icing. The purpose of this DoorDash order was to save me a trip to the store however I still had to drive to the store to get a refund and to have my order corrected to only come home to another issue - I took a bite into my cookie and almost swallowed an unknown thin transparent material that was different than the wrapping paper placed at the bottom of the boxes as shown below BEWARE! read more

See all

Love Insomnia Cookies! They are always fresh and delicious, rarely ever a wait and the staff is always super nice. I tried the new double chocolate peanut butter and it was just OKAY. My favorites are the regular peanut butter and M&M cookies. Snicker doodle is also a crowd pleaser. I usually stick to the original cookies. Hooked and Pocket Points always have a BOGO deal. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Peanut Butter Choco-Lantern! - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Went here on our college visit in Tallahassee. Waiting outside in the line at 10pm at night.... gotta say I thought we were crazy but these cookies were deliciously warm and satisfying and well worth the wait! I loved the double chocolate chunk. They were even delicious the next morning! Definitely going again on our next trip! read more

Sweet tooth addiction...this place has you covered. The best cookies I have ever had. Warm, chewy, freshly baked and they deliver too. You want milk they got it, you want ice cream they got it. Chocolate chunk is my favorite but they have other flavors just as good too. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Cookies... - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I ordered a 6 pack for my daughter and roommates to be delivered Feb 14tLreturned she returned their call to set up delivery. it's now Feb 28th. My card has been charged and she has no cookies. What a disappointment. Order number is 2006750608 if anyone at the company monitors this site. and, I tried to edit this post to make sense of the above. I wasn't able to make the edit. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Order confirmation - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

These cookies turned me into the cookie monster! My family and I devoured these after we went to dinner. The cookies were great the perfect ratio of chocolate! You need to try these cookies! The line is always out the door for a reason. The vegan ones were great tasted just like regular chocolate! LOVED IT read more

Insomnia Cookies - White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie, Vegan Birthday Cake, Peanut Butter Chip Cookie, Vegan Chocolate Chunk - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

To start the prices where way higher then local competitors. Then I order a 2 scoops of ice cream with a deluxe cookie for 9.75$ and I get home to eat it and they did not give me a cookie. I called the location and they said I could come and get the cookie.... not driving 15 minutes to go get a mid cookie when I can go to better places for cheaper. read more

Ridiculously good cookies and icecream. Very bad for my diet. I'd go here every day if I could.

The first time I went I got a smaller cookie and I said "meh" I don't understand the hype. I went a 2nd time the same week and I got the bigger size and a box of the minis for my boyfriends family and can now understand. I got the chocolate chunk and my boyfriend got the chocolate and peanut butter and both were so good. His family loved the minis so much they went back for more later that week. read more

The staff failed to give us 1/4 of our order. I was on the phone with their customer service for 20 minutes before they hung up on me after I asked for prooof of permission to pick up my missing food tomorrow morning. The food was good, but their service was disappointing. read more

Insomnia Cookies - All Vegan Birthday Cake Vegan Double Chocolate Chunk Vegan Chocolate Chunk - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I stopped in one late night as I had a craving for something sweet. They were doing a buy 4/get 2 free deal. I got (2) Mint Chocolate chip, (2) Chocolate chip, and (2) Peanut Butter. The service was fast, the cookies were warm and the price wasn't bad. I found the quality of the cookies to be good and the taste was appealing. The cookies had a nice crunch on the outside and they were extremely soft on the inside. The Mint Chocolate Chip was my favorite and it appears to be a big seller. I didn't eat all of the cookies at once and found that they were still fresh (and soft) a couple of days later. This place is definitely worth a visit. Pros: Late night, delivery service, quality and taste Cons: The menu is somewhat limited and the parking lot is small. read more

If you love a warm fresh baked cookie, this is the place for you. Cookies are definitely my favorite dessert. Between the cookie boxes and ice cream cookie sandwiches, they have something for everyone's cravings! The cookies are warm and taste super fresh every time i have had them. Let me tell you, i LOVE chocolate. Like LOVE it. Nothing beats a perfect chocolate chip cookie. But insomnia's sugar cookie just might. Their sugar cookies are game changing!!! The only reason I'm not giving Insomnia 5 stars is because I typically get it delivered and it always seems to take a lil longer then expected. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

OMG....cookies are amazing!!! They keep them warmed, so it's like eating them straight out of the oven! The only downside is later in the evening they may run out of some of the popular flavors. Def hit this place up. read more

Really great late night crew and of course amazing cookies at this insomnia outpost in Tallahassee. Came in about 11 and of course the place smells amazing. Bought 4 chocolate chunk cookies to bring home for the kids and these guys even had a cooler full of milk to go with it. Awesome that they also do delivery I think until about 3 AM. Familiar with these guys in New York but this location doesn't disappoint. Definitely worth a visit. read more

Insomnia Cookies is my favorite cookie delivery in town. Opened late for those sleepless "insomnia" nights, you can always satisfy your sweet tooth. Their cookies are perfectly baked, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Even with delivery it seems that they are always at the perfect warm temperature. On my birthday my sister had a surprise cookie cake delivered to me. It was one delicious surprise, and what started my love for Insomnia! The cake was basically one giant thick cookie. The frosting they use on it compliments the cookie perfectly. Definitely recommend for a special event! Insomnia has all sorts of cookies and sweet treats that can be delivered to your door step or picked up. The Smores and M&M cookies are my two favorites. In addition to cookies they also have brownies (which I have not tried) and ice cream, so there is something for every craving! My most recent delivery was the cookiewiches. Ice cream sandwiches delivered to your doorstep? Count me in! You can customize your sandwich to the max. Choosing your ice cream flavor, and which two cookies you want on the outside. My creation was the Rocky Road ice cream with two M&M cookies on the outside. This sandwich was melt in your mouth delicious! Literally! Before its arrival I was a little hesitant if the sandwich would be all melted before getting to me, but the way they deliver is with the scoop of ice cream in a separate container than the cookies. Once it gets there you scoop the ice cream onto the cookie, smush the cookies together, and enjoy! Its easier than it sounds because they put the perfect amount of ice cream for the sandwich. After this new cookiewich revelation I definitely see myself ordering from Insomnia even more. So good! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Cookiewich! - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

They should change the name of this place to "Incredibly Awesome and Delicious Insomnia Cookies" as they really are outstanding. I can not believe how good these freshly baked cookies taste and I ordered a box of 6 and pretty much ate them all very quickly. Overall, they are all incredible and I could not decide on what was my favorite, so I guess the next time I am in Tallahassee, I will order some more to try them all. read more

I ordered cookies for delivery and they were here 10 minutes later! The driver followed my instructions exactly!

Insomnia is great if you're craving something sweet after midnight. I have tried many flavors and the cookies never fail to disappoint. The fact that they have take out & delivery is really convenient!! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Box1: Red velvet, double chocolate, sugar, chocolate chip, sugar, peanut butter Box2: Brownie & Triple chocolate Deluxe - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Amazing service! We went there to for some cookies and our cashier was so nice. She gave us 2 extra cookies. I would definitely recommend. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Just like mom used to make! They were delicious, moist, and soft. Everything you could want from a tasty cookie. They got a great mix of deserts and a wide variety for the whole family. I love them and could eat them every day. Staff are usually helpful and have treated me respectfully. They also serve ice cream which I will get time to time. I've had some recent issues with the delivery, so I think I'll stick to going to the store from now on. Hopefully they improve in the future. They truly have the best flavor in this area. read more

In town to see our daughter. Made a late night run to try what the kids rave about. I will say pretty good warm cookies hit the spot. Chocolate chip was good but the Snickerdoodle was better. read more

The cookies are absolutely delicious!! With that being said, this is only my second trip there in the past few months so my five star rating is based off the variety of the cookies, the taste, and the good customer service that I've had on my two trips there. My son loves them! There are two different sizes for different varieties of cookies. They also have brownies, ice cream and milk. I know that they deliver but I can't speak on the delivery as I usually just drop in for a cookie or two if I'm in the area. They are open until 3 a.m. in the morning, so if you're in the area I would definitely drop in to try a cookie or two. By the way, they serve all the cookies warm! read more

See all

I'm not a huge fan of desserts and I love this place! They're cookies are baked to perfect: crispy on the outside, warm and gooey on the inside. The bonus is that they're open late and they deliver! If you're looking for dessert to appease those late night cravings at an affordable price, this is the place to go. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Heavenly cookies - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I got insomnia cookies delivered for the first time ever and was extremely disappointed. First, I asked for my cookies to be delivered at 7:45pm and did not receive my cookies until 8:10pm. I do not live far away but I figured I'd order them to get delivered so I didn't have to leave my apartment. I wouldn't have done so if I knew it would take that long. Once I got the cookies and looked at them, I was also pretty disappointed. They were broken up and were not even warm. The jumbo Peanut butter cup one that was over $3 had a giant cup in the middle...not how I've seen it as others post it. All in all, I wish I at least gotten an apology from the delivery girl for being late. Now I know that insomnia cookies is not all that it's hyped up to be unfortunately. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Had to come by during FSU Orientation with my daughter. It was a nice sweet surprise. We pretty much ordered all of the cookies available. I like that they deliver as well. I am sure that it will be a nice treat to receive these cookies while trying to pull an all nighter . read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Great cookies and service. We took our kids there for dessert. Cookies were warm, chewy and just like homemade. My husband and I shared a cookiewich (a generous scoop of Rocky Road between two double chocolate chip cookies). We will definitely be back! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Cookiewich (rocky road and double chocolate chip cookies) - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I ordered two cookie'wiches. What arrived was just the ice cream, no cookies. I called and let them know that we didn't get what we ordered. They told us that they were going to send us the rest of the order (our cookies)! No one came. I don't know what happened. Either way, ordering from them is a disaster and a waste of money. read more

If you're craving some sweets at 1am after a hard day of midterms and classes, this place seems like a godsend with the close location and delivery options. However after seeing that delivery can take upwards of an hour, you'll want to stop by their store. Except when you arrive, service is kinda crappy. But then again it's 1am. Cookies were good and warm! Ice cream was yummy too. Kind of worth it, kind of not. You decide depending on how bad your day was. read more

I Ordered a few days prior for a 7:15pm surprise delivery last night. I Was finally able to get through on the phone when the order was very late after calling many times over 2 hours later. They said they would try to deliver the cookies by 10:15. The excuse was they were short staffed and only had one delivery driver. If that's the case then don't take on so many orders and communicate to your patrons about the delays!! I had to cancel the order. Very bad first impression. read more

I ordered delivery for my daughter and her roomate and they never received the cookies. Tracking number says it was delivered and of course my credit card was charged, however there was no text or phone call, and no cookies in sight. Customer service is non existent, I've been on hold for 30 minutes without talking to a real person yet. read more

The cashier that served/packed the cookies and took payments was eating ice cream until we approached to make our order. She was not consistently wearing gloves while serving. Very disappointed with the lack professionalism during my first visit. Cookies were good but would worry about sanitation. read more

Fast service, I have both gone there and had cookies delivered. They were out of snickerdoodle cookies the second time I ordered from them. Cookies were delicious, mouthwatering. Would definitely go there again read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

There's nothing better than having freshly baked cookies delivered to your house at 2 in the morning after a night out on the town. Even if I'm staying in that night, Insomnia only ever sounds like a good idea late at night when I'm couch "potatoing" some Netflix! With such a large assortment of cookies, brownies, and cakes, there truly is something for everyone! What's better is they even have Milk and Ice Cream to go along with your order if you so please! I have a huge sweet tooth and Insomnia really satisfies my cravings and then some every time. The only reason I'm not giving Insomnia 5 stars is because they are often very backed up and can sometimes take an hour or longer to deliver your cookies. BUT on the plus side, the cookies always arrive warm and gooey so I can't really complain too much! Give it a shot if you haven't, I promise you won't regret it! read more

Never let's me down! Always perfect. If you haven't tried it I would highly recommend. Sometimes they are really busy but normally the wait isn't too long! read more

I placed an order on a Sunday around 8:40 and waited almost 2 hours. I tried to just cancel on the app, but couldn't and by the time I got to talk someone at a call center it was out for delivery. Once the order got here, the ice cream was wrong. I ordered a Pint of birthday cake with no toppings and got a Cup with lots of toppings. Dispite all of that, the positives: the cookies were delicious and the driver was nice. I'm not saying the workers or drivers are to blame, I know it's tough. I'm just probably not going to order from here anymore. I've deleted the app since this. Attached is a time stamped pic of the receipt, the pic taken time and the ice cream received. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Receipt with time stamp on it and the pic then the Ice cream received - Desserts Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

My first experience with Insomnia was great. My cookies arrived warm and in a short period of time. My second experience, not so much. Apparently there was a system failure and the stores weren't getting any online orders. I called customer service (you cannot directly contact the store you ordered from) and the first woman I spoke to told me it would be about 30 more minutes (in addition to my original 20-25 minute ETA) due to the failure. I called back in about an hour and spoke to the same woman. Again, she told me 30 more minutes. After calling 4 different times, waiting for three hours, and speaking to two different people, I ended up just going to pick the cookies up. The second woman was much more helpful and honest, stating that there was no way to tell when my cookies would actually be delivered and sent me a coupon. She was apologetic and more professional. Upon arrival, one gentleman at the counter gave me extra cookies and apologized. Another joined in our conversation and was very unapologetic. I feel as though the stores or customer service could've contacted customers to let them know about the system failure. The cookies are great, I just wish they would've handled it better. read more