As I was enjoying my chili and the smiling service my dining companion asked quizzically "I don't understand why this place isn't packed. If I lived here I'd be eating here almost every day!" And, there's the question because the homemade soups are delicious and this chili is OH SO GOOD!!!! Their sandwich menu is creative, and those sandwiches don't need fries to take over from their flavor (Served with a small bag of chips.). They also have dinners on the menu although we have always gone the soup/sandwich route. While we were eating a very happy man picked up four trays of food so clearly, they do well with their catering as well. Yes, I miss the pre-COVID "pickle barrel" but I don't think we are going back to a time when many hands and fingers were collecting pickles and peppers from the barrel to add to their meals. If I had one complaint it would be that there should be more pickle options on the menu or a choice of pickles/peppers as a condiment side to the sandwiches. Great service ... delicious soups ... fantastic sandwiches all at a very reasonable price certainly deserves a round of applause or at the very least 5 stars. read more

In A Pickle - Chili ... mmmmm CHILI - Sandwiches Near Me - West Deptford, New Jersey

See all

Very good! Will order again! Food was fresh and delicious! Fried pickles were tasty!

Food was fresh and delicious. Got Italian roast pork sandwich, chicken tenders, turkey club, reuben, and sausage pepper onion sandwich. My family really enjoyed, we shared so got to taste everything. Prices weren't bad at all. Impressed. read more

I have to admit, I really only come here for 2 things. 1 are their Homemade Soups that they have every day and so many to choose from. I also enjoy their BLT. Not something I normally even order, but when I have a craving.... It's of to "IN A PICKLE" I go! The service is always great too. The lady working the register and answering the phone and taking orders at the tables has her hands full, but does a great job read more

We were driving home from river winds and this sign caught my eye! Anyone who knows me knows I am IN LOVE with pickles. So, naturally, I had to order from here. We ordered the southern style fried pickles and the normal fried pickles. I also ordered roast beef on a panini... Overall, the service was great and timely. All COVID precautions were followed. My panini was nothing more then bread that was toasted and the roast beef was a tad dry. It still tasted good but it could have been better. I was most excited for the pickles but was unimpressed.. they, too, tasted dry? I am not sure how exactly to explain it but the bread to pickle ratio was just.. not ideal. All in all, its a cute place with a lot of options. My boyfriend really enjoyed his sub, although I do not remember exactly what he ordered. It is decently priced lunch spot in the area, nothing over the top though. read more

Stopped in as my go to spot was closed and looking forward to a corned beef special. Then I decided to add a soup my CB sandwich which was OK but I was disappointed in the white bean and ham soup They had a nice selection of soups and I am not sure if they are from scratch but mine was a bit vinegar flavored. Small pickle bar with several tables in this quaint, clean sandwich shop. read more

In A Pickle - You pick it you eat it - Sandwiches Near Me - West Deptford, New Jersey

See all

What more could you want then a buffet of pickles. This deli offers a unique dining experience with delicious food. The owners are also super friendly. The homemade soups make you think you are going to catch your grandmom cooking in the back. On sunny beach days there is nothing better then enjoying your delicious sandwich al fresco allowing you to get your vitamin d. One of my favorite lunch spots. read more

Just ordered from here for the first time. Was told it would be ready in 20 minutes, an hour later it still wasn't ready. Disappointed... my chicken parm was possibly the worse I've ever had. I would have rather had chicken nuggets on a hotdog roll covered in ketchup. It was burnt and I didn't finish half of it. The only thing I could enjoy was the lobster bisque. Having an actual job and a limited lunch break made for an awful experience. I don't think I'll be going again. read more

Since I just came from playing Pickleball at the Riverwinds Community Center this was the perfect spot to catch a quick bite. Because I was definitely In The Pickle. The service was friendly and welcomed me and my friend to sit wherever we liked. We always order water because we are calorie conscious and know that the food we order will be enough. The sausage with peppers and onions was very satisfying and exactly what I expected. Yum. My friend said his crab cake sandwich was also delicious. We are definitely coming back and recommending it to the folks who play Pickleball at Riverwinds. Haha pun intended. read more

OK, so I'm in this little town with hardly a spot to eat after 8PM, and I bring up Yelp reviews for the couple of possibilities. This place comes up with about a 4.5 and some nice reviews. So, Nick and I decide to give it a shot. Walked into a deserted place, not a sole (they close at 9PM, we got there at 8). The waitress was very friendly, but as she was new did not know a lot about each sandwich. To start, I asked if they would be willing to give me a mix of traditional and jalepeno deep fried pickles, not just one or the other. They said not a problem. OMG, they were fabulous with the ranch dipping sauce. So, Nick ordered the Italian Pulled Pork and I tried to order the Shrimp and Crab Cake Sandwich, which they were out of, so instead ordered the Sausage with Fried Onions and Peppers. So great to find a place that actually takes their product serious. The bread was perfect. Fresh lightly toasted hoagy, DEEEElicious. The sausage was sliced lengthwise before being put in the bun, which makes it so much easier to eat. The onions and peppers were done perfectly. They have a pickle bar, and let's just say of you like pickles, and who doesn't, you will love it. Sweet, Bread n Butter, Hot, Garlic Dill and more. I was so thrilled to find a place, especially a small sandwich shop, that gets it. Go here for sure. read more

Good lunch spot, food is good but it does take awhile for it to be made during the lunch hour

Sigh. I wanted to like this place.. I really really did. The pickle bar is disappointing. There are a few options, but nothing special. I ordered the pulled pork sandwich, buffalo chicken soup, and two paninis. I ordered on the phone, they said ten-fifteen minutes. After driving there, it was about twenty minutes. I waited an additional ten to fifteen minutes. The pulled pork sandwich was mediocre. Way too much tangy sauce- the pork was a radiant red. The paninis were average. The buffalo chicken soup was a huge let down. It was watery with no buffalo flavor at all. Not to mention the veggies in it were still hard. I had to make my own the next week for redemption on my stomach. I thought it was kind of steep in price too. However, the general atmosphere and the staff was really nice. read more

Great lunch spot. We had the crab soup was it was very good. The server worked really hard, but it seemed that they were short on staff. Our Triple P sandwich took a while to come out, but it was great. The bread was the highlight. The pickle bar is great, we totally eat a bunch of pickled peppers, dill pickle and regular pickles. Just one thing, that is my personal pet peeve, why stairofoam cups? They are bad for you (http://www.drweil.com/drw/u/QAA401095/Is-Styrofoam-Safe.html) and bad for the environment (http://greenliving.lovetoknow.com/How_Styrofoam_is_Bad_for_the_Environment). read more

Nice place for lunch. In an area with few choices, we come here 1 or 2 times a week. Sandwiches and soups are really good and consistent but after going thru almost everything in the menu, they could stand to change the menu up a bit once in a while or add some specials. They've had fish and chips as a special every day since Lent. Had it 4 times...not that special anymore! :) Pretty regular crowd. Same faces every day. Staff is super super super nice but service can be a little slow at times. Watching the wait staff crash into each other on busy days is part of the entertainment. Highly recommended. read more

I ate there recently, while traveling for business. And honestly, the place had an oder of vomit, which I later discovered was caused from the Louisiana BBQ pulled pork, as that is what I ordered, and it not only smelled like vomit, but it mildly tasted like it as well! When I queried the hostess as to what the sauce was, she looked confused and said, barbecue....I have had hundreds of BBQs in my lifetime, and can tell you, if I had to guess what this sauce was made from, I would venture to say ketchup, sour vinegar, and horseradish sauce, now picture that on your sandwich, served as barbecue sauce?! It was AWFUL!! The pickle chips were fine, and my partners food looked ok, but, they need the revamp, or REMOVE that pulled pork (so called) Lous. BBQ sandwich!!! read more

Every time I have ordered the service is terrible. The food is good but not worth the experience. Always forgetting orders, incorrect orders and too long of a wait. read more

Average. "Pickle bar" is depressing. Husband ordered corned beef Reuben, corned beef was a bunch of thinly sliced 2in squares with some sauerkraut and slice of Swiss on top. Weird. Plain. Average taste. My Italian pulled pork sandwich was lackluster. Both came with "chips and pickles" meaning 2 slices of a pickle and a small bag of chips. Definitely leaves something to be craved. Not from here, unfortunately. Gave it a try, not for us. read more

Love stopping by in a pickle for lunch during the work week. There aren't too many places to go in the nearby area so I'm really glad we found pickles. It's a place that's priced right and you don't leave smelling like food which is the case with so many other local lunch stops. It's usually pretty crowded if you don't get here before the noon rush. I always get the mozzarella and tomato panini but have also enjoyed their turkey club. If you're looking for spicy wing sauce their wing dishes have some zip. I left off a star because they haven't found a way to heat the place appropriately. In the winter time I keep my jacket on during our visit which isn't really that comfortable. But in the summer the outdoor tables are perfect. read more

In a Pickle has a cozy, unique atmosphere (once you see their decor you'll understand). For those who enjoy pickles, their pickle bar is a nice touch. Overall, their sandwiches are good and they seem to abide by an oft-overlooked principle in the food industry: K.I.S.S. (Keep It Simple, Stupid). They don't try to be something they're not; in other words, they stick to being a solid sandwich shop with simple selections, yet also have a nice variety to choose from. My two issues are: their rolls can be too thick and disproportional to the contents of the sandwich, which can overwhelm not only the taste of the ingredients with bread but also makes you fill up faster than you'd like; and none of their buffalo chicken selections are any good. I don't know why they insist on using such a tame-flavored, almost barbecue sauce-like texture for their buffalo chicken sauce. I recommend avoiding the buff-chick meals. read more

In A Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - West Deptford, New Jersey

Honestly I don't know how you mess up on making a triple decker turkey club, but the only things that takes to make one it's turkey, lettuce, bacon, tomatoes and maybe mayonnaise. I legit only asked for the tomatoes and mayonnaise to be taken off, yet you guys made it so there's legit only turkey and bacon on my sandwich.. I also don't understand why you would ask what kind of cheese my fiancé wanted when you legit tucked the paper you wrapped the sandwich into the cheese... so all the cheese pulled off when he removed the sandwich.. like why ? Definitely not worth ordering 65$ dollars worth of food... read more

I have tried In A Pickle three different times and I really wanted to like this place because I have heard great things but they can never get a simple order correct and they have been extremely rude every time I have gone to get my food. I understand these are stressful times but I have only order once here during Covid the other two times where when life was normal, so I just don't think they are then nicest staff. read more

It was my first time eating here. I had heard good things but never took the time to try it. I was not disappointed! Although it's a small place, the service was timely and friendly. The food was delicious and very wallet friendly!! read more

This place is very nice and has very good food but the amount of plastic they use crazy. Styrofoam cups for drinks when you sit down it would be cheaper and cleaner for the environment to use glass cups. read more

What, What, What....A bad A$$ deli in West Deptford. People, it's real turkey not deli slices, all homemade in house. House brine corn-beef, fresh roles, homemade soup. I got the homemade Italian pulled pork with sharp provolone, and it was banging...Down falls, sammy's are not that big, and the location is tucked away in a shanty strip mall. Staff is awesome, personable, and accommodating. Its near Riverwinds golf course. Highly recommended.. Family owned + Homemade food = Repeat costumers like myself. read more

I love this place. The pickle bar is a nice attraction if you like pickles. I've tried a few different items and never disappointed. The only negative i might say is when it's crowded food takes a little longer to arrive. But service is friendly and accomodating so not that big a deal read more

Nice place. Got a sandwich, small soup, and soda. Came to about $17.00. A little pricey for me, but that's just my opinion. Food was OK, just OK. Nothing really stood out to me. Would I eat here again? Yeah probably, not much in the area besides wawa and Wendy's. read more

Great little place for a good sandwich. Had the tuna melt. Very tasty.

Best wraps, best service, and one of my favorite places to grab lunch in NJ! Pickle bar is an awesome touch!

Cute place for quick lunch. The pickle bar is a fun idea. The sandwiches can be a little on the pricey side, $7+ is a little expensive for a Panini. Also, more vegetarian options would be a nice addition. Everything is fresh and the servers are very friendly. read more

Was looking to try a new place out n decided to order out from here...I ordered the shrimp and crab cake sandwich, Reuben and started with the fried jalapeño style pickles...I'm giving this 3.5 stars with the potential for 4..I picked up the order 5 minutesater than when they said I should get there an by the time I got home everything was barely warm...the crab cake shrimp sandwich would of been better for sure if it was eaten there nice n hot...good sauce...the Reuben even Luke warm was nice n moist and had good flavor...the fried pickles were good but def need to be hot...I also ordered the buffalo soup which was ok...if I get the chance ill have to post follow up review which I'm sure will be better if eaten there...quaint spot n for those who care the girl who took the order was cute... read more

Really good service and food. Great sandwiches with a pickle bar. Generous portions. Soups sound great. May be next time. Had a great sandwich on sour dough bread and it was excellent. Even the wife bragged about her BLT. Excellent fries and drinks that are like a half gallon. Only complaint is that it's not closer to home. Some traditional items like corn beef and pastrami would be great but otherwise a great spot for a good sandwich or soup. We'll be back. read more

Great place to get fresh food and friendly service!! You can sit down or order ahead and take out. My whole family loves this place! We've never had anything we didn't like! read more

Like others said, this place is surprisingly expensive for lunch. I don't mind paying $9-$10 for a wrap if it's worth it but that's not the case here. Food is just okay. My biggest issue as other reviewers have said is the wait time. It takes forever to get your food here. Like mind bogglingly long. I keep giving this place more chances because their is a serious lack of lunch options in the area, but they keep disappointing. read more

Food is usually delicious but sometimes you order your favorite meal and it's just ehh. There seems to be 2 different groups that make the food- 1 awesome- 1- not delicious- smaller servings, food a bit soggy on the take out. Can't figure out who works when. People are always friendly. read more

We went there today and called ahead. Waitress was the rudest I have ever experienced. As we were leaving, she announced they shouldn't do call aheads anymore. We were polite and easy. She had an awful attitude and was slow and rude. Will not be returning. read more

In a Pickle is a go to for a great lunch. Their buffalo chicken soup is amazing and just the right amount of spicy flavor. I had the pulled pork sandwich during my last visit and it was so delicious my boyfriend couldn't resist stealing the other half! The pickle bar is cute and fun, just like the decor. The staff and owner are friendly as well. Overall, it's a nice locally owned place. read more

Good food! Italian pulled pork is very yummy. BLT was delicious! :) I wish they had more of a selection on chips and drinks like most deli's but I guess that's only a minor complaint anyway. People are really nice and food was ready in 15mins which is what they told me. read more

You really can't go wrong here. I've been using In a Pickle to impress business contacts for months. Always a good place for a satisfying business lunch. read more

Excellent sandwiches...very friendly staff, bright and cheery decor (nice clean bathroom), convenient to 295!

Solid place, solid wrap, server nice, close to my house, full when I left, and good pickles..... People are too picky about restaurants... Shut up and eat read more