I just order from here today and let me tell you! The woman who I think owns the cute coffee shop goes above and beyond! I reached out via Facebook with some question regarding sugar free options and she replied right away answering all of my questions I had. Then when I placed my order on door dash something I ordered had sugar in it she called me right away to call and fix it. Way above and beyond. Very heartfelt human! Recommend this place 10 times over! If you're looking to get a yummy drink or cute dessert and or delicious food head on over and check this place out! Thank you for the food experience! I truly love kind people! read more

Excellent coffee! Friendly staff! One of my favorite coffee shops! I highly recommend the Americano!

Mission: "At Highwheeler Coffee, we intend to create community around an appreciation for hand crafted coffee and tea beverages in a comfortable and inviting space. We see coffee as a craft beverage, and hold an interest in its production along every stage of its life cycle. We focus very heavily on the skill of each individual, from farmer to barista, to produce a quality beverage." Had coffee and lunch here after shopping at the Plain Foods Coop a few doors away. The cafe interior is well planned, attractive, spacious, and super clean. We sat by the window with the high roller bicycle etched on it looking out onto the street. We ordered two of the paninis so we could share halves; the large turkey and the grilled vegetable paninis were grilled perfectly, oozing with quality cheeses, and flavorful. The sweet potato soup had a engaging low key hot kick. I could enjoy that soup every week if I lived closer to the cafe. The owner I think served us and she could not have been more pleasant. --Welcoming and knowledgeable. We got several cookies to bring home. There were several varieties available including S'mores and Sugar. The huge Oatmeal Raisin ones were freshly made, chewy, and yet crispy. I could not resist and ate one on the hour long car ride home. We could not believe they were only $.75 cents each -- a give a way. Pastries were also available to eat in or take out. There was an attractive display of coffee and teas for sale. Pleased to see that a custom decaf blend was available, bought a half pound bag. It is probable the most flavorful coffee I have ever had. I have brewed some each morning since as a treat to myself. (See photo I posted of the coffee bag for details of the blend.) Also, many quality Harney tea blends are available for purchase or can be enjoyed in house. Added perks: We purchased 6 used like new quality hardbacks for $2.00 each before departing. Our purchase included two cookbooks. The rest room was immaculate. We plan on returning to this cafe on out next visit to Fort Plain. read more

See all

i ordered a hot chai latte, which was a little sweet to my liking but still good. menu had a nice selection of extra flavors and bakery/food items. service was fast and friendly. was able to sit and read, though most people were taking orders to go. mostly country music playing, but not overpowering. nice natural light from the front windows read more

Highwheeler Coffee - bar area and menu - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fort Plain, New York

Good, service and ambiance is wonderful. Paninis are delicious. Arts to be sold and a lovely variety of such.

So many coffee choices!!!! This place is so cool because it's not what you'd expect to find in a small town. They have so many different options of coffee brews they really care about coffee and the quality of the brews. I had always wanted to try Chemex Pour Over and finally got the chance. It was a robust flavor and really delicious! The bonus was the sweet potato toast. I had never heard of something like this before but I'm so glad I tried it. It was the perfect mix of savory and sweet. I want to try and make it at home. Check this place out if you happen to be in town! read more

See all

Always good, always accurate. Easy in and easy out, on street parking right out front. There always seems to be a steady stream of traffic but never so busy that service gets slow. Ill like a caramel latte or just a coffee with a little cream. Sometimes add one of the baked goods or overnight oats. read more

Stopped here for a mid-morning coffee while riding the Erie Canal Trail. It's not too far off the trail and easy to reach by bike from the trail. The coffee was delicious, but I didn't sample the baked goods. read more

I met with the owners in advance to set up a tea party baby shower. They were extremely accomodating and affordable. The spread that they prepared was amazing, the ladies that worked the party were very friendly, and the place has a great atmosphere. Fort Plain is lucky to have this great coffee shop right in the heart of the village. The food was excellent, the coffee/tea were delicious, it was very affordable and the staff was friendly. What more can you ask for?! read more

Highwheeler Coffee - a long table of food - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fort Plain, New York

What a fabulous addition to Fort Plain. Bravo to the owners for bringing this cafe to the community. The interior is airy and bright with plenty of seating. The coffee menu is impressive and more upscale than I expected and the service was friendly enough. They do close at 3pm which is a little early. My boyfriend had a Kyoto cold brew and I had a matcha latte, both of which were delicious. The ham and gruyere paninis were savory with an oh-so-satisfying cheese pull. They also sell home goods such as Chemex coffee makers and other gadgets. Worth a stop if you're in the area and looking for something different. read more

Highwheeler Coffee - Amazing matcha - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fort Plain, New York

See all

This coffee spot is awesome!! Their matcha is spot on and golden milk lattes really hit the spot. Great community vibes and it's a sweet lil spot to do work in or just grab a drink from. Fairly priced, super friendly staff, and lots of great art covering the walls. I look forward to returning!! read more

Pretty hipster compared to the rest of the stuff in the area. Probably normal (or comfortable) place for some Californians. The person who took the order was very helpful with the coffee beans we wanted to purchase. Gender neutral bathroom. read more

Highwheeler Coffee - a woman sitting at the bar - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fort Plain, New York

We were traveling through the area and remembered finding this little gem last fall on a bike ride. So glad we made a second visit - it was great! As it was lunchtime and we were starved we each got a different sandwich. The flavor combos were awesome and they were cooked to perfection. We also got a few pastries for breakfast the next day - can also recommend those. Can't comment on the coffee or tea as we were coffee'd out at that time. Lots of selection, though. Tables were socially distant and each had little a sign that identified that it had been sanitized - you turned it over when you left to indicate that it needed cleaning. Staff was very nice and masked. If you are in the area, treat yourself! read more

Really good food but very expensive food is amazing I'll tell you that for sure but for a cookie and a milk is 7 dollors

Great Coffee, Great Specials and I love the panini's! A variety of coffees and teas to choose from that is hard to find around the area.

Every time I go, the service is great and the employees are friendly. The drinks and pastries are always amazing.

Love this coffee shop and the staff! Friendly service great atmosphere and wonderful coffee and daily specials.

I love this place omg!! FINALLY we have an outstanding coffee cafe! (better than Starbucks imo), zen, modern atmosphere, pristine white & clean, healthy options! (vegan & gf!), super friendly staff, unusual snacks and creative, modern desserts! yayayay! They even have live music and support local artists. I love this new addition to the area and look forward to creative growth and prosperity for them :) read more

Great place for a perfect drip coffee and a snack! Little gem in fort plain. Free WiFi and clean and relaxing.

A gem. Passing through town from Cooperstown, Googled coffee shop and easily found. Comfortable, friendly and coffee & teas are top notch. Stop by and try! read more

There are several good reasons to come to Fort Plain but this is the best. It's little hidden gems like this that deserve more patronage. Everything here is done right, See 4 yourselves. read more