Great pizza place- I love their white pizza and the service is fast and friendly. They've been here for a long time because of the consistency of the great food! read more

Stopped in for a slice to give the place a shot. Place was clean, move ahead to counter. Counter had pizza in a hot case. Grabbed a slice and took off. Crust seems like they press dough into a pan with a bit of lip to it. Gives a nice corner crunch on the dough. Which was a tad yeasty but not in an obnoxious way. Sauce was thick, flavorful and had a nice thick cheese layer that was topped with brown tips. Well cooked, decent slice. read more

Heavenly Pizza - The place. Pass it often decided to try a slice today. - Pizza Near Me - N Ft Myers, Florida

See all

Order a large pizza and hot wings with ranch and we got the large pizza and the wings had no sauce or ranch we got blue cheese dressing instead people need to ring things up right don't eat there read more

Heavenly Pizza is very close to where we live. We have wanted to try them out. We ordered a takeout pizza yesterday. My first impression when picking the pizza up was that their place needs a good cleaning. It was about 5:30p. Their small dining room was in desperate need of either a broom or vacuum. Underneath each table was paper, crumbs and who knows what. My 2nd impression was that every single employee looked unhappy. If I had been coming to eat in, I would have turned around and left. We ordered a Hawaiian pizza. The pizza was good, without anything being special. The crust was done well. The toppings were minimal compared to most pizzas we have gotten. And we eat a lot of pizza. My recommendation is that until cleanliness becomes a priority, look elsewhere. read more

Quite upset. Been ordering since they opened, this customer sat for two hours while driver after driver was assigned to deliver ours only for a supervisor at Door Dash said there was a mistake and my order has to be remade and will be delivered . So half hours later email says the order is canceled. I tried the next day to talk to Heavenly, was put on hold and after I am convinced my CALLER ID made them 'avoid a conversation ', I hung up after 9-10 minutes waiting. Will I try them again? Only if I sit in their lobby and take it home myself. Hiring outside help did not help this household. and if they are chronically busy to be forced to cancel orders....expand. I will remove this review if I get a call from them. read more

Heavenly Pizza 12-11-24 Arrived on Tuesday about 4:23. The place was neat and clean, but it seems so dark in there even the menu was black. They were dealing with a lot of take outs at the front counter, but Brianna sat us quickly. We ordered the special Pizza which is a 16-inch Cheese Pizza for 10.99 any Monday or Tuesday 2.00 for any extras on it. We got extra topping of Peperoni for on it. We also ordered a Salad, Garlic Bread, and Italian Sub. Our Salad came out with our Garlic Bread, and all was good. Garlic Bread was very tasty, and the Salad was fresh. Our Pizza and sub came out a short time later. The Pizza was good and hot. Crust was good and the bottom was brown not burnt. All ingredients were good on this Pizza and Brianna came back to check on us and refill drinks a bunch of times. Our friend stated the Sub was good and all was fresh on it. You can't beat the special price for this Pizza. If your hungry for Pizza stop by on Monday or Tuesday for the special or the rest of the week for their other specials. They do sell Beer their so its great to have a Pizza and brew. I give this place 4 stars out of 5. Follow Me for More Reviews Gulf Coast Terry read more

See all

Been doing Heavenly pizza for 11 years. Always loved and recommend it. Loved the delivery. Lately it don't seem the same..I'll have to see then and ask why. I still like it but not as well as in the past. Delivery was good.pizza hot but the amount of stuff on the pizza is not the same. Next time instead of the heavenly I will order the great eight . Now that I can't get out I have it delivered. I looked at a older pizza picture andī now and see a big difference. The picture today was the same Heavenly but a slice and does not look to be the same pizza. read more

See all

On our recent visit to Cape Coral it was recommended we visit Heavenly Pizza, so one week night we made our way over to give them a try! A little small pizza spot in a strip mall that was definitely worth the visit, but could be easily missed if you're not looking for it! We were seated within a few minutes of arriving on what seemed to be a busy weeknight. We started with an order of the Pepperoni poppers and Jalapeño Poppers. These both were soooooo good! Flaky dough balls with cheese and pepperoni and cheese and jalapeños with a side of marinara to dip! I think a third option of these would be great with a combination of jalapeños and pepperoni all in one! For my main, I chose the Fantastic Five 8" pizza. A combination of Pepperoni, Sausage, Hamburger, Ham, and Bacon. This was the perfect personal sized pizza as we all ordered this size! The pizza itself was pretty good, a nice crispy crust with the perfect amount of sauce and cheese and toppings! The service was a little on the slow side as I think we waited close to 20 minutes for the apps and another 30 or so for the pizzas, but it wasn't enough to ruin the meal. Would come back if in town again! read more

Heavenly Pizza - Pepperoni Poppers - Pizza Near Me - N Ft Myers, Florida

See all

A friend told me about this place. Great pizza. I will be a regular. Thin crust with excellent quality.

Best pizza in the area very good prices. The entire staff is very nice. Have not had a chance to eat other menu items but they all look very good. Very highly recommend this place. read more

Great food each and every visit!! Give them a try they won't disappoint you. The pricing is great as well!

New place for me Was craving 'Za while driving south to Fort Myers, so did search and found this joint located in a strip mall on US 41. Bottom line: Craving *satisfied* Very good dressing in the Caesar salad. Tomato?! The pizza--I got a large with pepperoni, mushrooms, and fresh garlic, was very good at scratching that pan pizza itch: decent crust, excellent sauce, cheese dripping off the slice. I'd order it again, not as a first choice, maybe, but good enough for everyday! Excellent service, too. Kristi and crew were attentive, friendly and extremely polite. The atmosphere was loud and full of regular Florida folks. (Kind of what I've come to expect around here. ) read more

Heavenly Pizza - Large pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, and fresh garlic. - Pizza Near Me - N Ft Myers, Florida

See all

I was recommended this place while in town and it definitely lived up to the recommendation! It was a small local place and because it was small and packed we did have to wait a few minutes for a table. Once seated we ordered drinks and appetizers. The appetizers were definitely a hit with my family! The jalapeño poppers were pretty spicy but very good. The poppers were cheese jalapeño and bread with marina sauce for dipping. I preferred the pepperoni poppers which were the same but with pepperoni. I'd definitely recommend getting these if you come in. They were perfectly cheese and delicious. For my entree I got an 8" great eight pizza but without olives. It was cooked perfectly with a crispy crust and lots of yummy toppings. The marina sauce they used tasted good and fresh so that took things up a notch. read more

See all

Heavenly Pizza is the best! Everything we have tried is amazing, from their salads, subs, soups, to their pizzas. You can not go wrong in whatever you choose! While the food is incredible, the staff is always friendly and accommodating. . . Whether you eat there or order take out, it's great! read more

Pizza was good. My daughter still can eat a whole pizza by herself. This is one of the better pizza places in the area. I haven't been here for a couple of years. Really I forgot about it. But I will be back! read more

Heavenly Pizza - Yummy pizza - Pizza Near Me - N Ft Myers, Florida

See all

There idea of buffalo wings is nothing I have ever seen before and to add to insult the wings had feathers on it. I couldnt. Customer service was great the girls were wonderful but food was so disappointing. read more

Love their Pizza! And you can't go wrong with the burger! I have had it numerous times and its always grea!

Always have good service and pizza when I come here. It's a little hole in the wall pizza joint but is some of the best pizza around. It's like a hallway lined with benches. Always packed it's so good ! read more

Delicious pizza, great service and reasonable prices! What's not to like? Love their Hawaiian pizza!

Had a slice, and it had to be the worst pizza ever. Pizz was dry and hard. It's gas station pizza without the gas station. Floor and tables were also a mess. read more

Food here isn't good at all . Just another disappointing restaurant here in Florida wings were raw . Greek salad with no olives. To much feta cheese, and Italian dressing. Pizza is American garbage. At best meatballs and calzones would have been better of if it was cooked by a six year old child! Service was good. Ambiance is old and cheap . read more

Food is good but I've always had to wait longer than seems reasonable. Not sure I'll return. I think I've given it my last attempt.

Horrible! Everyone is rude manager included. we came to order salads and garlic bread. The usual that me and my mom get when I'm in town. We decided to try this place. Customer service was horrible. They overcharged us $30 for two salads and a garlic bread each topping they charge an additional charge got toppings that they did not add we asked them if we could have the toppings we paid for they told me they told us no. I spoke to one manager everyone was rude and she asked me to try again tomorrow. . as well as adding toppings in our salad that we didn't ask for like mushrooms, tomatoes carrots Etc; after all we didn't even enjoy the food. if I could do 0 stars I would. read more

Heavenly Pizza - Pizza Near Me - N Ft Myers, Florida

Server was nasty and rude because we decided to switch seats due to family banging into us in their uncomfortable seats! Pizza is average, too, so I wont go back when there's a million other better pizza joints read more

Our pizza was hot delicious and ready fairly quickly, even on a busy Friday night. Service was friendly and price was very reasonable. Cheese bread was great, too! We will definitely be back. read more

Heavenly Pizza - Stuffed heavenly pizza - Pizza Near Me - N Ft Myers, Florida

If you like microwave type pizza, then this is the place for you. Pizza was warm and doughy. The cheese was overwhelming and the sauce was just okay. Staff was not friendly and place was not clean. Not a place I would visit again. read more

Very good pizza and they have really good lunch specials. We had a large pizza for 6.99. Can't beat that and it's good pizza. The service was very good. Our waitress was very nice and attentive. There is seating inside and a couple of tables outside. Take out or dine in. Good food at good prices with nice people. What more do you need. read more

Highly satisfied! Didn't order pizza but we got a meatball sub, pizza sub and calzone. Meatballs, rolls and others homemade in house was a nice touch! $5.99 large subs on wednesdays, comes with a bag of chips too. Can't beat it read more

We got a pizza for lunch. It was ok. A bit greasey and the crust too crispy. I probably wouldn't eat here again. read more

Heavenly Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - N Ft Myers, Florida

Fantastic service, delicious food, and a place we will definitely be returning to. We ordered take out when we arrived at the restaurant and had two beers while we waited. Beer is on tap and wine is also available. Great daily specials!! read more

See all

Steak and cheese subs were delicious. Will definitely order again. Hard to find good subs down here, but we did.

I have never had such an unpleasant experience dining out ever... the waitress was extremely rude, not only toward my family and I, we also noticed how rude she was with the other customers as well... the food was mediocre and they didn't prepare our food the way we asked... I will never recommend this restaurant to anyone nor will I ever set a foot in there again... what was supposed to be a happy experience with my family only turned out to be a horrible one read more

Where can you and listen to the truth of scripture and eat great food,the truth will set you free.

Great food and service. It's go to pizza in the area. Easy carryout nice seating area.

Yum. The white pizza was very tasty. The garlic knots looked like little buns. Their taste was on point. Long way for pick up made them loose the one star. read more

Heavenly Pizza - White pizza / Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - N Ft Myers, Florida

I ordered a pizza at 4:30. At 6:30 they delivered a pizza completely different. The next one came totally burnt. It's now 8:30 and I'm still waiting... read more

We have enjoyed the pizza from Heavenly Pizza for 10 years. Tonight was an exception. The crust was burnt and the pizza overcooked. My wife picked up the pizza to go and stated that there were new people working and it was a busy night. Hopefully they will return to the great product they produced previously. read more

I have had all good experiences with Heavenly Pizza. Pizza is delicious and staff are very nice. I had a misunderstanding with something I ordered many years ago but have all good experiences since. Best pizza I have had in the Fort Myers area. They make amazing subs and their prices are very reasonable. read more

I placed a delivery order an hour and a half ago and still no food. I don't care if it is heavenly, I'm not waiting that long for any food delivery. read more

Gather round, citizens of the internet, while I tell the tale of my Sunday lunch experience at a dying restaurant. I stopped in to Heavenly Pizza with my parents, intending to have a quick lunch before catching a movie at the nearby theater. We ordered a medium pepperoni pizza, a meatball sub, and soft drinks. At the time we arrived, there were 3 tables being served. Our drinks were served quickly by our diligent server who was somehow (divine intervention perhaps?) supposed to work the service counter and all the house tables on her own. 4 more tables were seated after we arrived. 45 minutes in, the first of 2 nearby tables seated before us were served part of their order. The second table followed - again only receiving part of their order. Shortly thereafter, the second table seated after our arrival was served their order (medium pizza). At that point, I asked our server if we would be served by 2:10 (an hour and 15 min after we arrived) as we had pre-purchased movie tickets and our showtime was at 2:15. She said would check with the kitchen and apologized, and returned a few minutes later with part of our order (the sub). Promptly at 2:10, the 3rd table seated after our arrival was served another medium pizza. At that point, I followed the server back to the service counter to pay for what we were served and left. Clearly the kitchen had no grasp on what orders were completed and not, and they had no capacity to quickly resolve the problem. I worked in the hospitality industry for just shy of a decade, ending my career in guest experience management at a destination hotel with 2 full service restaurants. What I saw during my visit is indicative of owners/management who are out of touch with their own business and have no regard for their patrons or staff. That poor waitress was clearly stressed to her limit and (God bless her) was doing her best, but she was totally left to her own devices without any help. Any restaurateur who does this to their staff well deserves to be put out of business, and judging by the cadre of unhappy patrons I'm sure that is on the horizon. Unfortunate turn of events for what used to be a great mom-and-pop pizza joint. read more