Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Handsome Hollow

    4.9 (7 reviews)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Handsome Hollow Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Handsome Hollow

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Renae K.
    543
    53
    347

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Handsome Hollow

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    The Old Schoolhouse Inn & Restaurant - Molten chocolate cake

    The Old Schoolhouse Inn & Restaurant

    (58 reviews)

    $$

    This is one of the most amazing experiences I've had in upstate New York. It really is an…read moreold-school house that they converted into a restaurant. It was kind of nice that they had three separate areas. The bar had a game area connected to it kinda loud then they had another dining room which I'm glad we didn't eat at although it was really kitschy with all the stuffed animals around. The people who worked there said it was all from family members that donated them. My mom and I I feel got a great deal. It was hamburgers, fries, and unlimited salad bar with unlimited shrimp all for under 20 bucks per person. The burger was amazing done perfectly and it's from the cattle behind the restaurant. The fries were fresh cut, and were from her uncle's farm. They were cooked to perfection nice and crispy. The salad bar was really amazing. It had lots of choices and lots of toppings. It seemed that they kept up with messes from that dressings that might've spilt over. The shrimp is on ice not in ice. They even had a bit of dessert of ambrosia on the salad bar. It was an overall great experience. I wish I lived in the area to go back and enjoy a great hamburger. Also, you know that I'm a water snob and their water was great.

    It's nice to see historic building still in use to this day. this historic hotel is still in use…read moreand adds a bit of charm to an already charming community. The architectural detail is wonderful and the landscape gardens are floral and well maintained. great little spot to stop at if your in the Catskills. ****Great collection of taxidermy inside. If you love it you love it. I if you don't well ... you don't. ***

    Callicoon Hills

    Callicoon Hills

    (7 reviews)

    Went here for a mid week summer getaway with my husband and we had an amazing time. We went in the…read moremiddle of the week so there weren't a lot of people at the resort. The resort is nestled in the Catskills surrounded by lush greenery and the smell of nature. The property is beautiful, very clean, and has that cozy modern woodsy aesthetic. It's perfect for a weekend getaway or if you just want to escape in nature for a couple of days. On the map the property looks huge, but everything is pretty quick to walk to. Our room was so lovely, and there is no TV which really gets you to be disconnected. There is a huge pool, with floaties and a truck side bar which was closed but is open on the weekends. There's also a sauna and gym which is overlooking the views of green hills. There is a nice lounge/communal area next to the cafe/reception where you can hangout and play all sorts of board games and have a nice drink. Outside there is also a covered area with a ping pong table, giant jenga, and connect 4. Each night they have a fire pit, weather permitting with smores. One of the nights it was raining so sadly no fire pits for smores, one of the staff members was so kind to heat up some smores for us and some other guests and it was nice to just have that little treat to make up for the weather. You can explore the beautiful grounds, where on a short walk across the road is their barn where they host weddings, a large pond, and if you walk further down you'll find yourself next to a stream. All the staff were so friendly and accomodating. I imagine it's more busy on the weekends especially when their pool bar and on site restaurant is open. It was a magical place. Can't wait to come back again.

    Callicoon Hills is a property that appears to have been designed for Instagram before it was…read moredesigned for guests. And frankly, once you get there, the instagram photos just look like dupes. We booked a stay expecting an elevated Catskills getaway based on the property's marketing, pricing, and branding. Instead, we arrived at what felt like a hotel that was not ready to be operating at the level it advertises. Our room showed visible signs of unfinished renovation, including unpainted wall patches where fixtures had been removed, remnants of painter's tape, damaged paint on the door, and a bathroom barn door that would slide open on its own. The room was aesthetically minimalist to the point of being impractical (but not even that cute), with very little surface space and a surprising lack of outlets. The larger problem was the number of amenities and experiences that were unavailable or poorly executed. We were informed after check-in that dining service would be significantly limited due to a soft opening. The pool was not operating. Weekend yoga was unavailable despite being marketed. Parts of the property contained boxes and visible signs that preparations for the season were still underway. None of this was communicated before arrival. The food experience was equally disappointing. There was no vegetarian dinner option during our stay, which is difficult to understand at a hotel catering to a NYC weekend crowd. Breakfast was slow, and bad to the point of almost inedible. Even small guest-facing details reflected a lack of attention. For example, the s'mores were oddly restrictive, short on supplies, and featured marshmallows that were so hard they were difficult to roast. What made the experience particularly frustrating was that many of these issues seemed entirely avoidable. Weather is outside a hotel's control. Failing to communicate unavailable amenities, opening before operations are fully ready, and charging premium prices for an incomplete experience are not. The entire stay felt like a triumph of branding over hospitality. While the property photographs well from the right angle and with much moved out of the frame, far fewer aspects of it function well.

    Stonehouse Gardens - Stonehouse Gardens, event venue near New Paltz, NY. Grounds and barn available for weddings, parties, photographs.

    Stonehouse Gardens

    (7 reviews)

    My fiancé and I toured Stonehouse Gardens when we were looking for wedding reception spaces in the…read moreHudson Valley area. Deb and Steve were so welcoming and helpful in answering all of our questions, and their property is absolutely gorgeous. You can see the years of love and care that have gone into maintaining their house and its surrounding land over generations. One of their adorable cats even hopped along with us on our tour! While we ended up going with a different event space, closer to our ceremony site, I would recommend Stonehouse Gardens to anyone looking for a unique and rustic place to host an event, particularly if you are looking to be in the natural beauty of the outdoors. There were so many areas of the property that would have been lovely for photos, it would have been almost impossible to choose!

    We had our wedding at Stonehouse Gardens last fall. Deb and Steve were wonderful. Their property…read moreis your canvas where you can have the DIY wedding of your dreams. We had a food truck and food stall, created our own outdoor cocktail hour area with strands of lights and a photo booth, and transformed the barn into an 80s disco. If you can dream it, Deb and Steve can help you make it happen. The venue itself is gorgeous! We had a perfect fall day and the lighting was wonderful for photos. Our guests still talk about how great Stonehouse Gardens was for a wedding. We highly recommend Stonehouse Gardens.

    Handsome Hollow - venues - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...