love LOVED this place! A gem tucked away on main street, LOTS of goodies galore, SUPER nice quality…read moreitems/clothes and reasonable prices and the sweetest staff working there! I bought a shirt and a dress for FIVE bucks - cannot wait to wear my items to work this week. Also loved their stockpile of decorations and books!

From the owner: Nestled in the heart of Downtown Canandaigua, the Finger Lakes Treasure Trove is more than just a…read morethrift store – it’s a community hub that welcomes everyone with open arms. Since 2016, we’ve been dedicated to making a difference, offering a carefully curated collection of high-quality, pre-loved items at prices that won’t break the bank. Every purchase and donation directly supports our mission of giving back to those in need. Dedicated to serving our community, we extend assistance to families and individuals facing crises or in need through our new food pantry, complimentary clothing initiative, and by providing information on available local resources and programs. Shop sustainably, find unique treasures, and make a positive impact. Your next favorite find is waiting!

Stopped in here last night as part of the Wine Walk. They were pouring a prosecco/ riesling blend…read more This place has a lovely collection of art, furniture, housewares, and jewelry. It's a pretty large shop just filled with interesting things to look at. They also sell a small number of handmade non-antique items, like necklaces and headbands. I bought a few small items. Definitely worth a visit.

Great selection of quality items. Love the universal pricing for item categories (All Womens…read moreTShirts are the same price...) The store is very clean and the staff is friendly and helpful.

The store is decent, but not the best. It feels overpicked, and many items are being resold at…read moreextremely high prices. Honestly, I wish they had a larger selection of furniture; it seems like there are too many clothes instead. However, the place was clean, and the service was quite good. The only reason I'm giving it three stars is that I feel like it has been overpicked in 2025.

Avoid shopping Sunday's at all costs - Manager Melissa…read more I'm a weekly customer and avid comic collector who loves the treasure hunt here. For context, I stopped shopping on Sundays months ago due to prior issues involving Melissa (weekend manager) and another employee. After six months away, I tried again--same result. I also observed smoking within a few feet of the public entrance when I arrived. On 10/19/2025, I brought two early '70s Batman issues to the 5-items-or-fewer line with Melissa, who was visibly agitated and had just called for additional front-end help. She allowed a one-item customer to go ahead--no issue. During my checkout, she began picking at the price stickers, bending the books, and left nail marks on a cover. I politely asked her not to remove stickers--a routine request I've made many times here because it can damage older paper. She paused for ~30 seconds, then rolled her eyes and replied, "Suuuuuure" in a sarcastic tone as if to imply I was crazy. I declined the purchase and stepped away. She called after me that she would personally buy the books so "no one would lose out," then grabbed the phone, threatened to call the police, ordered me to leave, and banned me--in front of three cashiers and roughly 6-8 customers. I was also accused of "threatening/harassing," which was unfounded and embarrassing. I value this store, but the conduct today was unprofessional and needlessly escalatory--especially from a manager. I hope ownership reviews the footage, clarifies handling of collectibles (including sticker removal), and addresses customer communication and de-escalation.

This is still a great place to spend a couple hours searching the aisles looking for treasures, but…read moreI was disappointed to see they are allowing non antiques in. 3-D printed toys are not antique or vintage. I hope they are not going to be just another flea market that rents space to people selling anything. I hope the owner walks through and makes some changes.

Great shop for emergency grocery provisions or to get some gas without driving 20 min into town…read morefrom Seneca Point. A bit pricey but again it's for emergencies. Love their homemade large cookies and brownies! On Thursdays from 3-6 they have a farmers market which is nice too.

This shop is on Rte. 21 in the tiny hamlet of Cheshire, south of Canandaigua. The building is the…read moreold country school which is cool and unique. Typical gift shop selections with a fair representation of locally made foodstuffs. Also have antiques for sale and grocery items (at least they did the last time I was there!). I've had very good subs from their deli. A nice all-around place to spend a few hours poking around!

I was so happy to find a book store in Canandaigua and was excited to see that they were used…read morebooks! This store was quite well organized and had a good variety to choose from. The prices were good and I was happy to walk away with two books that have been on my list. My main negative for this shop was the placement of the children's books. They are in the back room which is a pretty far back there and a bit darker/more cluttered. I'd prefer to see the kids books in a spot that is more visible to adults and more welcoming.

New books were in pretty good order. The used books were a little bit more haphazard. Which I think…read moreit's actually a rule about used books. But everything was pretty clean, not too dusty. A lot of Harlequin romances, which is really cool. Large sections of used sci-fi and mystery. Nice lady at the front desk. I got several new books. There were a few dollars off the regular price. And I'm not sure they were actually new or if they were just newer, ya know? Because they weren't new, new. Lol. Anyway, I had a good time perusing the shelves and purchasing things I didn't need, including some little book earrings.