This good will is typical to most other stores. The donation center does not take furniture donations, whereas the store in Manitowoc does.

it is very rare that I find what im looking for but when i find a gem its very exciting! prices have definetly raised a lot, so i dont love that, but the employees here are always very friendly :) alex is an absolutely darling! read more

The prices have become outrageous! They stopped the 1/2 price weekly color tag sales. The stopped the Military Discount day. They stopped the Senior discount day. I used to shop for families that need help every Wednesday and looked for things 1/2 price to get more. I paid for everything from my own pocket. I spent at least $35-$65 each week. Haven't been there since they changed all the above me things.maybe my purchases don't matter to them. Sad......now I drive to Plymouth to Neat Repeats and St. Vincent (also the one in Sheboygan). Their prices are much more reasonable and they also have color tag and weekly specials. Hope their big salaried executives see a decline in the sales. I'm sure I'm not the only one who is upset. Only thing GOOD about this Goodwill is that most of the employees are very nice! And I know they didn't make these foolish changes read more

I've been going to this Goodwill for over 30 years and I've almost always found some good deals. But now. Wow, what a turn around. Discounts are all gone, sky high prices. I saw a used polo shirt with a hole in the front of it for 7.99. Why? Because it was a J Crew? It has a hole in it! I go to Goodwills all over Wisconsin because I travel a lot. Sheboygan Goodwill is the highest priced store in the state. I was recently in Madison and even the state capital was cheaper then Sheboygan. You're greedy Sheboygan. read more

I have an online vintage store. I spend a LOT of time in thrift stores. I live closest to the Sheboygan, WI location. It is my least favorite. I'm always disappointed. It's been over 8 months since I stopped. I went today since I was in the area & had some extra time. The store is filthy and disorganized compared to West Bend, Fondi, Manitowoc, Grafton, and Menasha. The other thing that is really annoying is that there are lamps that have the original shades. Instead of keeping them together, they price them separately. Also, all other GW stores have set prices on dish sets over 10-12 pieces. They do not. For a chipped plate they wanted $3.99!! read more

Not a great thrift store, if you are a regular at thrifting. Pluses: it's clean, and the staff is always friendly. Minuses: It's crazy overpriced. I'm not paying $6.99 for a worn, used shirt at a thrift store. That's asinine. It's one thing if items are marked higher because they're new, but that's not the case here. I pretty much come here for books- that's about it. There's a lot of new stuff. That sounds good, but it's not really the point of a thrift store. There's piles of stuff that didn't sell at one store or another and now is available for barely cheaper here. It's an okay place, but I've certainly been to better GoodWills (apparently they're not all the same- the one in my hometown is cheaper than this!) and there's no shortage of better stores in the area. read more

I attempted to drop off a very nice piece of oak furniture (a buffet table) and was greeted by an extremely rude man who said "that's not going in there" and proceeded to point to the tiny sign with tiny writing placed behind the car that stated they don't take furniture at this location any more. Sorry, I don't come here to shop since most things are egregiously overpriced so I wasn't aware of every new policy. No need to be so completely rude about it. I will never bother coming here again and will recommend the same to others. Guess the dumpster got a new table. Nice mission statement. read more

Shopped there multiple times, and always came out with a great find. Reasonably priced and pretty well organized. Furniture section is tiny, but clothes and trinkets were in good supply. Will be back. read more

Its a hit or miss kind of store. Either you find something worth buying or you rummage through garbage. When you do find something its always extremely cheap. read more

Goodwill Store and Donation Center - Thrift Stores Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Most things are seriously over priced! The reason they get so much clutter. These days, they try to get top price for everything. They profit for charity so they claim. At the same time should you not sell cheap to help out needy? I have seen things priced here higher than you pay new. They have also started selling on ebay if it will bring higher price. It's the greed factor! read more

Great, helpful staff in a very clean Goodwill. Every area of the store was clutter free and very organized. The staff was very helpful and made sure that the dressing rooms were kept orderly. There were no piles of clothes jammed inside. A young woman was there to both open the dressing room doors and constantly re-hang items as they came out and were put on the rack. This store is making a difference by providing a great environment to shop in..KEEP IT UP! read more

ILove the clothes however even though they're sorted by color and sizes and are neat and in the row most thrift stores are in the point of a Goodwill store as for the people who can't afford top price and goodwill in Sheboygan Wisconsin charges top dollar I just think their prices should be cut just a little read more

It's newer & clean. Serves it's grand purpose for recycling items through out the community. Hue is a great employee. read more

Goodwill Store and Donation Center - Stuff. - Thrift Stores Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Customers FORCED to wear masks at this store at all times, without adequate air conditioning support. Will not shop there again. My health matters to me. read more

If you are someone who truly loves to have fun and go thrifting, avoid this store. Any donated items of value are separated out of their inventory and sold online or shipped to their higher-end "Retique" stores in Milwaukee and Manitowoc. This leaves behind nothing but worthless odds and ends. They pre-scan all the books, sifting out the newer, valuable books and selling them online, which means that the remaining books are all outdated, worthless, and sit on the shelves for months. They put up a sign that states they put thousands of new items out that day, but an employee told me it was just a made-up number. Their "Thank-you for supporting the Goodwill mission, please take our survey" statement at the end sounds formulaic and disingenuous. It's old. Get a new slogan. This Goodwill needs to realize that if you want people to return regularly, you have to put out desirable inventory at a good price. They get all of their inventory for free, so no matter what they sell it for, they're making a profit. St. Vinnie's is much cheaper and does not "pre-sort" their merchandise. Everything you donate there stays in the community, and the money supports our community. St. Vinnie's (and Salvation Army and Bethesda) also takes the time to make sure electronic items work properly before selliing them, Goodwill does not. St. Vinnie's also has multiple racks of clothes prices at just $1 or 49 cents- Goodwill does not. read more

Loved this Goodwill. Found some fantastic bargains. Prices on clothing seemed high to me but other things were really good We bought a vintage Singer 401 sewing machine for $7 and a great end table that had a lamp attached for $7 for our travel Trailer They had so much stuff and employees were very nice and kept putting stuff out even on Friday evening at 6pm. Great store. Address wrong on Yelp as store is in the other thrift store read more