Ordered delivery. Served a completely undercooked stromboli - 3/4 inches thick of solid raw dough. Literally spat the first bite I took out. See photo - that's not cheese, it's RAW DOUGH! Stay away - God forbid they also only cook raw chicken for 2 minutes. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Raw uncooked pizza dough - I can't believe this was actually sent out of their kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

Please is disgusting. Had a bad experience last time I ordered thought I would try again what they sent me was rotten I couldn't even feed it to my dog. Stay away. read more

Best Grandma Pie south of Staten Island. Always have a great meal here. The entire menu is wonderful. Great lunch Specials during the week as well. Thanks Goodfellas! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

Better than expected pizza. Received delivery on time and even got an extra appetizer that we didn't order. Pasta alla vodka was average (better than expected for a quick service restaurant). Pizza is thin and tasty. Calzone was decent as well. Not as good as Al Forno but close to it and a little bit cheaper. I have a friend who saw an employee recently making a pizza with no mask on and with gloves on and then handling money at the cash register, pens, and then going back to making pizza without changing gloves. So I can't speak to the cleanliness of the restaurant or COVID protocol since we got delivery. read more

I cannot say anything about in person dining but I've been uber eating this place since the pandemic started and it is fantastic. The pizza is great, the garlic knots are great and both the chicken parm and meatball subs are great. Love this place! read more

Picked up order of large pie and 10 wings, I couldn't get over how light the pizza was,that should have been an indicator of what I was getting. It was very skimpy at best,the wings tasted like they were hours old,very disappointed I won't be going back there again for sure .it was really bad for 28$save your money go somewhere else. read more

Ordered food on Uber eats 45 minutes prior to close, the order was accepted and the food never arrived. Drivers attempted to pick it up and we waited for an hour to find they must have decided to just not make it. Very disappointing. read more

The Sicilian square pizza for $20 is the best deal around, feeds me and the family, and have some for lunch the next couple days. The pizza is even better being heated up a second time! Highly recommend as one of the better and reasonably priced pizza places in Jupiter area read more

Delicious! We were on a hunt good quality thin crust pizza. This gem nailed it and satisfied my craving. Had a large thin crust Hawaiian with white sauce. The staff was awesome, very kind and helpful. Delivered my expectations! read more

When this place is on it's great however lately it's been completely off. A few weeks ago we ordered three large pies and they arrived luke warm at best about 30 minutes late. I called back to let the manager know and they offered to replace them however everybody had already microwaved their pizza and it eaten so I didn't see the point. He thanked us for understanding and said he would note our account and the next time we called back and they will make it up to us. Fast forward two weeks and we order a calzone and a pizza. They tell us it's going to take in about an hour. No mention of the previous experience but my wife wasn't aware of those details. Guess we never got any notes on our account. OK I get it busy Saturday night during season. We order the pizza at 6 PM, at 7:45 it's not been delivered so we call and were told they're taking our pizza out of the oven. Assuming you get every single light it's still only takes you about five minutes to get to the place from our house. At 8:10 a delivery driver pulls up. Sorry for the delay "we got our but licked tonight" Unfortunately given that it was a school night my kids had already had leftovers and snacks and gone to bed. I voiced my frustration and was offered half off next time. Really? Ugh. read more

Extremely rude and wont be back. Pizza was "fair" nothing to write home about. $5.00 for a slice and i only ate half of it. Suggest you try Sals instead read more

Gloomy, negative atmosphere. Not friendly at all. You walk in, they look upset you are there. Once or twice, ok. But every time? The worst is the short Latin jock. So negative and unwelcoming. Over priced, average pizza. Done with them. read more

Perfect for big parties pizza Small homestyle but large commercial ovens perfect for catering or serving the latgest pizzas love the location sits close to water & bridge but sits in a small shopping plaza super hipster vibe read more

The meal was very low quality. We ordered a 16" cheese pizza, small Greek salad and 6 piece boneless wings (I wanted regular wings but may have chosen wrong online ordering). The pizza had a large circle about 8" diameter in the middle with virtually no cheese. The crust was like cardboard (seemed like it may have been a pre-made crust or at least tasted like one). The boneless wings were just round nuggets very literally less appetizing than the garbage nuggets you get at McDonalds. The Greek salad was just mediocre according to my wife. I rarely bother with a review (especially negative) unless something is clearly good or bad. In this case the meal was simply sub-par and generally unappetizing. read more

Pizza tasted like a frozen pizza. Salad was missing all of the meats and cheeses. Salad dressing was left out. Don't waste your money!

Being from NY we are very picky about our pizza. Stopping in for lunch proved a good idea. The two gentleman behind the counter were quick to point out the menus and specialty slices. We had spinach rolls, meatball and cheese slices. All of the slices were big and tasty. Tge pizza roll and sauce was also delicious. While we waited for everything to warm up we took in the great b/w photos of Little Italy, Coney Island, Italy and NYC. There are board specials too. A good place to get a close to home experience. Enjot! read more

First time trying new York style pizza and wow was it different and it was really good me and my family came here thinking it was a regular pizzeria so I ordered the two meat lovers pizza and have to say those are some big slices we thought it was going to be a small pizza but we're we shock to see what was at our table but man how good they were with one slice of those pizzas you could fill up two people but they were sooo good one of the meat lovers was spicy like crazy but good while the other was perfect and the place was nice and modern overall everything was great I give this place a. 11/10 would totally recommend. read more

Great pizza, great wings, good service. I would be giving them 5 stars if they hadn't failed to mention I could have gotten 10 free wings with the purchase of my first 16" one topping pizza order. Otherwise, they are a simple yet authentic pizza joint unlike your typical Pizza Hut or Dominos, all for a reasonable price. read more

I don't know what he's going to say I just came in for a slice had no idea about this place and had a pepperoni calzone stuffed pizza in a Pepsi and the sauce was to die for it most incredible sauce I had to get a double bowl of it and get my calzone in it there's not one drop left I'm going to show you a picture of my plate when you know sauce is good this is what you do don't miss this place read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

Very frustrated with Joe (would not give me his last name) at this restaurant. He acknowledged making the wrong calzone after I told them I already cut a piece out of this calzone and he wanted to pick it up (which he said he threw away anyway). It took them over 25 minutes to deliver a new one and didn't deliver a new sauce when they delivered the correct calzone. I called back for a fresh new sauce and he then said I was being a Jack_ss (had the audacity to charge me $2.50 for a new sauce because of their mistake). I was flabbergasted when he called a customer a jack_ss. Not sure who owns this restaurant but Joe is lacking in Customer service skills. He then hung up on me. Regretfully written!! read more

Every city has their own 'Best pizzeria' and I feel like this has to be the best pizza here in Jupiter. Ordered a late night order for an 18' cheese pizza (with extra cheese) and a dozen garlic knots online from their website at 9:55 pm and it was ready to be picked up around 10:20 - 10:30 (forgot the exact time). If you don't want to dine out you can always dine-in also. The best part about this pizzeria is that they open until 11 pm. The only flaw is that they don't partner with local delivery services, they rely on their own drivers which may result in longer wait times until you get your food. read more

So tasty!!!! The food is good and the prices are great! I love the Stromboli and calzone! Must try the Mac and cheese pizza!!! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Small Stromboli and slice of mac and cheese pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

So amazing!!, The pizza was so fresh and hot! Great service with very friendly workers. Great food and service would definitely go back again read more

Delivery of Philly Cheese Sub - sub was cold, hardly any meat and the cheese wasn't even melted. Onion Ringed were cold and over done. Salad was ok - Very disappointed for my first order. read more

Just relocated to Jupiter from CT...which is a Pizza Haven...with great NY style pizza every where... When I stopped in for a slice at Goodfellas and Joe Bomps the owner ... he couldn't have been a nicer guy...and the pizza is spectacular... I thought I was in little Italy or coney island!!! Try Grandma's sicilian or my favorite...a pizza with Shrimp, Sausage and carmelized onion...OMG good... Eat in casual or get delivery...their driver Bernardo, was such a professional, which is rare for pizza drivers... either way...this is my new go to pizza joint in jupiter... read more

I've had several pizzas from here since the first not awesome encounter and I'm changing my review!!!! It is great!!!

Amazing pizza we found by accident! Best we've had in a long time. Suggest the cheese! 16" for $12 you can't beat. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

Pizza was just ok....tasted dry, not enough sauce or toppings. Other items were just ok.... delivery person didn't wear a mask. Not sure if I would go back to this place because after reading the reviews & reading that no masks worn while they cook, I question the cleanliness during Covid-19. read more

Best pizza south of New York! Great variety. The Parmesan sandwiches are amazing the pasta is incredible. Everything is fresh and delicious. I absolutely love the staff they are totally cool. My favorite Italian restaurant in all of Florida!!' read more

My husband and I have tried many pizza places here in Jupiter and Goodfella's Pizza is by far the best pizza we have had here in Jupiter . We dine in once a week it's that good read more

When they first opened the food was very good and we ordered often. I even told others about them. The last few months the food quality has diminished and the customer service is non existent. Tonight I ordered a delivery of the Chicken and Broccoli over pasta one of my favorites. Was told it would be delivered in 35 minutes, arrived 1 1/2 hrs later. The chicken was dry and chopped so small you needed to send a search party to find it. Heavy pepper flavor killed it for me which I did not expect, besides it being cold. Understanding the business has grown and they can be busy I had made excuses for the things that were wrong. I can now see this is the new normal. This was our last order from them. read more

The owner forgot to place the pepperoni on our pizza. When we called him he admitted to his error but insisted we had to go through Uber Eats to get reimbursed. When we also commented that we were not happy that it took over an hour and a half for our pizza to arrive he went into a rage about not using Uber and it was not his fault. He was very unprofessional, immature, loud and obnoxious. The pizza was soggy and we will never order from there again! read more

Love this place lots of unique artisan pizzas. I love the gluten free option. The staff is great! You can pretty much create any pizza your heart desires. I eat here pretty much every weekend love the food and the staff. Try the eggplant park pizza or any of their eggplant subs read more

Finally found somewhere I can get damn good delivery food. Ordered 3 times, and they're consistent. Order online, pay with a card, and they have no trouble finding my apartment--the location of which eludes any "deliver dudes" driver. Everything has always arrived hot and fresh, even the fried stuff on the Italian feast. They honor your requests in the comments part of online ordering. Pasta is good, sandwiches are good, salads are good, wings are good, pizza is good. The pizza is no Angelo's, but it beats the crap out of the local chain pizza places. The fried mushrooms with ranch are my favorite. Hopefully they will maintain this level of quality and service. read more

Came up from Jensen Beach. What a FIND Best CheeseSteak I've had in Years. Go with the Gangster Philly if you like a lil heat.

The pizza here is outstanding! The owner Joe is super engaged and friendly. Highly recommend!

Joe came into my business with menus when i managed the Palm Beach Sports Club on Indiantown and US-1 dropping off menus in the middle of summer door to door in my plaza. I went for lunch the day after with my newly hired sales rep. Pizza is BEST i've had in all of South Florida. Cheese pizza is made with true NY love. It consists of a thin crispy crust with a perfect cheese to sauce ratio. NO FLOP. Dave Portnoy from One Bite and Barstool Sports would give them a solid 8.5 if he'd visit. Yes, I am a great friend of Joe and the Goodfellas family now. Ive always appreciated a hustler when i met one. But this never would've happened if his food wasn't top notch. read more

This is a terrific place for great Italian food. Small place with great service and decor. We sampled the pizza and it was good. The entrees were fabulous and the portions generous. The house salads were a nice size and very fresh! The garlic knots are delicious, as is the clam sauce and eggplant parm. We will definitely be back! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Eggplant Parm - delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

See all

Ordered a Margherita pizza. Arrived for the pickup & they said no basil. What's a Margherita pizza with no basil? Not much! Terribly undercooked read more

No masks on any of the staff. Definitely are not taking precautions to keep staff or customers safe.