Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Good Neighbor

    4.6 (13 reviews)
    Open • 11:00 am - 7:00 pm

    Good Neighbor Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Good Neighbor

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Sheree M.

    Went into this shop today just to check it out. Fell in love. Super cute Boutique with all sorts of new fashions of various sizes. It's rather small but it has just the amount of clothes that you need both men and women. You can even buy really nice plants if you would like! They are a bit on the pricier side, however, you can tell they are quality items. I didn't buy anything but tried on 4 different jumpsuits and a dress but didn't fall in love with any of them once I tried them on, not because they weren't cute but they just didn't fit me like I needed them to! Definitely check them out if you are on the area. They are directly across from The Garage.

    Kevin L.

    We stopped by here on our Indy trip to see what the shop was. And boy, it was a cute shop. It had a lot of ethical clothes and even had some nice plants in the corner for sale! The clothes were of high quality, not too sure how sustainable they are though. The price seems fair for quality and the staff was friendly. I believe they update their clothing catalog often as well, so it's nice to see new styles.

    Main entrance is on Edison located between Mass Avenue and 9th Street, just north of the hotel entrance
    Ken N.

    This store has a bright and cheerful vibe filled with a small but diverse collection of well made items (per my wife's observation.) It's easy to find if you go to the Coca Cola Bottleworks and see the signs for the Hotel, this store is just north of the hotel on the same side of the street. Metered parking is available on Mass Ave or there are pay lots across the street and behind the "Garage". I am not aware of any validating of your parking stub for this store. You would have to ask. Once you find it, the store feels fresh and new, is well lit, and seems to mirror the title "Good Neighbor" with quality items and friendly staff. Since it was a cold weekday just before lunch, there weren't any other customers, but the young lady who was working didn't hover over us but engaged us in conversation offering to help find anything we were looking for. Basically, women's clothing is to the left as you enter and men's to the right. They did have quite a bit of denim clothing, and lots of warm wear for getting us through the winter. You can shop and then head over to the Garage Food Hall (located north of 9th street only) across Edison. Or if you are curious, look into the lobby of the new Bottleworks Hotel which preserved much of the art deco facade. It is a beautiful area to shop with everything clean and new, but paying homage to the past. Check out Good Neighbor while in the area! Review #3845

    Indoor, plants
    Sha C.

    I love this place so much! The staff is so nice and they make conversation and truly make you feel at home. The store carries plus size which is very important to me and it also has A wide array of clothing and styles. I always make sure to stop by just in case they have something new in stock! It's very clean inside and has a beautiful aesthetic. Pricewise I think it is on par with most boutiques in the area and the quality of clothing is worth the price!

    Matthias Y.

    Cool store to check out. Very friendly staff (5 stars in that area). I feel like prices are a tad high (that might be the cost of supporting local, though). Would definitely come back. I was surprised to see the very nice selection of house plants they have.

    Card

    See all

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 0
    Love this 7
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Taylor C.
    359
    34
    39

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ken N.
    668
    3984
    21554

    6 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jill B.
    0
    33
    82

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Good Neighbor

    Review Highlights - Good Neighbor

    “I wanted to try on a pair of Good American jeans and haven't really been able to find them around the Indy area until here.”

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Women's Clothing 1,918 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Newman & - Los Raiders

    Newman &

    3.8(45 reviews)
    6.6 mi•Broad Ripple
    •$$

    If you are looking for nicer men's apparel like a suit for a wedding, this is an excellent place to…read moreshop. The store feels luxurious when you walk in but also approachable. It isn't huge but has the wide array of items from suits and toes to hats and shoes. Keep in mind it is a consignment shop so nothing is returnable. So I recommend either being certain or trying it on to guarantee satisfaction. I loved the suit I picked for my husband but sadly the measurements we had were off and it doesn't fit. It was disappointing as we need a suit for an upcoming wedding. But I understand the policy. This the warning to try it on in the store! I'd go back (with him this time) and look again as they did have nice items. I was told I could also consign the item with them but that seems like a lot of extra work. I'll wait to see if maybe he can fit it down the road...or someone might need it more than us. But a nice spot for men's formal attire and nice dress shirts.

    My experience is that there are a lot of consignment shops around Indianapolis that have women's…read moreclothing, but not as many that have men's clothing. Newman & Company exclusively sells men's clothing. You'll find formal wear, street wear, sweaters and hoodies, t-shirts, jackets and coats, jeans and pants and slacks, shoes, belts and accessories here. The shop is well curated, and all you'll see on the racks are straight-up hits. I visited with hoodies in mind. I was shopping for my teenage son. I really didn't know what to expect from this consignment store, but I found way more than I imagined! My son wears a man's size in sweatshirts, so I found a large variety of hoodies and sweatshirts that he might like. Keep in mind that this is a store for adults, so sizes start at adult small, which is actually pretty big. There are no children's clothing sizes here. I walked away with three hoodies, and because they were gifts, I obviously didn't try them on. Although, if I wanted to, there are changing rooms in the store. Be aware that all purchases are final. No returns! The service is top-notch. The people who work here are friendly and ready to help, but will also hang back and let you do your thing if you don't need them. When it came time to check out, they neatly folded my clothing as if it was their own. They have a no-bag policy, so be prepared to carry your clothing out sans bag. One thing to note: Newman & Company is affiliated with Amanda's Exchange, so if you have a rewards account with one, it is honored at the other.

    Photos
    Newman & - Shoes

    Shoes

    Newman & - This guy

    This guy

    Newman & - Shoes

    See all

    Shoes

    Toolbox Men's Supply Company - Interior

    Toolbox Men's Supply Company

    4.7(26 reviews)
    0.1 mi•Chatham Arch
    •$$

    beautiful store and people that work there, great selection of clothes and underwear.read more

    If you are like me, and good customer service is important to you, skip this hole in the wall and…read morejust order online. I literally just walked out of that place, having spent more than $60, and the old guy behind the counter was as rude as can be. I walked in, and I get that he had customers (a trendy, older couple, who seemed to have some change in their collective pocket), but my initial issue was that he barely even acknowledged my presence, and when he did, his tone went from pleasant to seemingly annoyed (not an exaggeration). So, I'm looking around the store, and I see a couple of things I liked, and the store clerk is just fully engaged with the couple and they're having what sounds like a nice conversation. As this is going on, I move to the other part of the store, and in doing so I walked past the clerk who was posted behind the register. As I passed him, in a very different tone, "let me know if you need any help." I immediately thought to myself, "wtf is this guy's problem?" Brushing it off, I continued shopping. Once ready to check out, I approached the counter where the clerk was just chatting it up with this couple, who had all ready made their purchase, so i am kept waiting while this conversation concludes. After they finally left, I then laid my items on the counter and you could have heard a pin drop.. not a word from the clerk. And then when he finally does speak, he's got that same tone again. Now, I know that I did not come in this store, causing anything or doing anything that would merit being treated like that. I'm guessing he assumed I didn't have money or something. I don't know, I speculate, of course, as I have no idea what goes on in the minds of crazy people. Even after spending more than sixty dollars, I didn't even get a thank you, he dropped my receipt in the bag as though were a piece of trash. Sorry to be so long about this, but things like this really irritate me. Who knows what his problem is? But if he treats people like that that are spending money at his store, then you all should avoid it, i know, I certainly won't be back, and I will be spreading the word.

    Photos
    Toolbox Men's Supply Company - Interior

    Interior

    Toolbox Men's Supply Company - Me

    Me

    Toolbox Men's Supply Company

    See all

    A.Mina Fine Clothier & Tailors - Mina's did a great job on our wedding order. We had the sharpest french blue suits. Credit: Danielle Harris Photography

    A.Mina Fine Clothier & Tailors

    4.7(31 reviews)
    1.0 mi•Mile Square
    •$$

    Anthony and his team are the best!…read more I've been going to Anthony to get my suits for as long as I can remember. He always treats me like family and provides an excellent product and service. A. Mina has a wide arrange of options for any price. I always walk out of the store knowing that I have excellent fitting pieces. If you are looking for a suit or blazer and you're in the Indy area, don't waste your time with the other guys, go see Anthony.

    I haven't worn a tux since high school, so when I had to get one for a work black tie event, I was…read morenervous about what to do. I had a vague idea that I wanted something a little non-traditional but besides that I had no clue what I was after. Anthony was quick to make a great recommendation for a navy blue tux with a great cut for a slimmer guy, shawl collar, and black silk and satten accents. He was also patient. I thought I wanted a vest and when it came in I didn't like it and went with a cumberbun. I thought I wanted a certain shirt and he got it for me, but it turns out it didn't work and he had a plan B ordered for me just in case that happened. Everything was far more affordable than I anticipated, also. Anyway, I looked great last night. I snapped a few photos that I've attached (it's hard to capture a navy blue suit with black accents in dim light!), and I had a flood of compliments from everyone. Go see Anthony and he'll take care of you.

    Photos
    A.Mina Fine Clothier & Tailors
    A.Mina Fine Clothier & Tailors
    A.Mina Fine Clothier & Tailors

    See all

    The Shop - Roselyn Bakery cookies were part of my childhood. I love this tee! It is a thicker material, so it feels like it will wear well over time.

    The Shop

    4.2(29 reviews)
    6.3 mi•Broad Ripple
    •$$

    Biiiggg fan of The Shop and have been for years. They're usually a stop if I need Indiana merch to…read morehaul back with me to AZ- I love all of their designs (especially anything not in black/gold colors) and they offer more than your standard screen print on a cheap cotton Gildan tee (used to work in merchandise dev). For many years the colors, designs were not "official team" apparel which kept prices fairly low. Now that they've gotten into licensed team apparel, I've noticed some prices have gone up.. but it's the price of business. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ At any moment you'll see IU, Xurdue, Butler, Colts, Pacers and Indy 500 brands all over the store and online, with occasional touches into OSU, ISU (#LarryLegend), and retro brand fandom. The only less Hoosier Hopsitality thing about them is their staff - the guy working when I most recently stopped in did not appear approachable nor care to talk... but hello-- that is part of your job. The hipster Broad Ripple "I could care less" vibe he gave off left a sour taste in my mouth.

    Stopped here during a trip to Indianapolis for the Taylor Swift Eras Tour. We heard from someone…read morethey were carrying some TS merch and we decided to check it out and so glad we did. They had 2-3 shirts that were Taylor themed and a cute sticker. The prices were affordable and I paid $24 for a shirt and $3 for a sticker. I wish they had a larger selection of designs on different types of shirts. For example, the design I really wanted was only available on a very think cotton shirt and I would have preferred a lighter and softer material.

    Photos
    The Shop - This Indy tee is soft and comfy. This is exactly what I wanted in a shirt to represent my home.

    This Indy tee is soft and comfy. This is exactly what I wanted in a shirt to represent my home.

    The Shop
    The Shop

    See all

    Good Neighbor - womenscloth - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...