We popped in here for lunch today when Dulwich Picture Gallery couldn't find us a table. It was a…read morevey mixed experience and I wish I could give the place 3.5 stars instead of 4 - let me tell you why...
The building itself is gorgeous, lots of lovely stained glass, nooks, crannies, little rooms, big rooms, a circular bar in the middle and it has a really nice eclectic, not too cluttered, warm and cosy feel to it.
We sat in the restaurant, as it promised table service and we didn't feel like getting up to go to the bar every time we wanted a drink. We chose various starters, main courses and drinks and waited to be served. And waited. And waited... the only person not doing any waiting was the waitress herself. (boom boom!) I never got to the bottom of what the issue was, it wasn't that crowded, but we could never get her attention, she was super stressed, but I couldn't see what with and our food sat on the pass for a good 15 minutes before we got it. Everyone was really nice and friendly and apologetic, but that didn't make up for the wait!
However, and this is what makes this a 4, not a 3 star place for me... the food was very very good indeed. I was primed to send the whole thing (5 plates) back if it had been dry or cold in any way due to the wait, but I couldn't fault it much at all.
There were five of us, and between us we tried the crab paté, battered black pudding and soup of the day to start. They were all really nice - the battered black pudding especially so, and at £3.50 for a pretty big bowl of it (it's listed as a bar snack) was unbelievably good value.
For mains, two of us had the haddock and chips, while the others had the halloumi burger, the mushroom gnocchi and the sausages and mash. The fish was exceptionally good, with a light, yet very interesting and tasty batter, crushed peas (actually quite uninspiring) and tartare sauce from a jar. The chips were lovely and big and crispy. The sausages and mash looked amazing and were herby and creamy respectively. The halloumi burger was fine, but having been in the pass for so long the lettuce had not just wilted, but actually died on the plate, and the very thin fries had gone a little hard. If I had been eating that, I may not have been as forgiving as the person who did eat it all and really enjoyed it. The gnocchi looked amazing, but the verdict was that it was a little involved - it had spinach, sweet potato and beans as well as the mushrooms. However, that is exactly as it was billed and I think that it lived up to its description.
I have a dreadful cough at the moment, so to drink I tried the house hot buttered lemonade, which comes with a cinnamon stick - absolutely delicious and perfect for a froggy throat.
So, they lose at LEAST 1, if not 1.5 stars for the hopeless (yet perfectly pleasant) service, but the building, ambiance and food clawed it back for them!