Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Gobbler's Knob Golf

    4.0 (2 reviews)

    Gobbler's Knob Golf Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Gobbler's Knob Golf

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Matt W.
    171
    1110
    668

    13 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Gobbler's Knob Golf

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Island Green Resort and Golf Club - The Clubhouse

    Island Green Resort and Golf Club

    4.2(11 reviews)
    27.4 mi

    My husband and I were in the Catskills for a midweek getaway for his birthday and we decided to go…read moreplay a few rounds of golf the day of his birthday. I had researched a few golf resorts in the area beforehand and it was between Island Green and one other place. The deciding factor was price and the fact that Island Green had a tee time that better aligned with our schedule. To be honest, my husband and I are golf novices and everyone at the resort was so friendly and helpful, on and off the course! We didn't have time to finish all of the holes due to a dinner reservation but we had such a great time. The condition of the curse was very well maintained and it wasn't too crowded for a Tuesday afternoon!

    1/5 7 minutes ago on Google…read moreSo for those of you planning a wedding nearby... we had the most horrific experience here. Wedding across the street and with few places to stay in the area we rented out the Island Green for family guests. I had visited the place prior to the wedding to meet with the owner and check things out. He showed me a couple of rooms. I did not go deep into the rooms but peeked in ( except for the clubhouse "suites" which only had an outdoor entrance and it was necessary to walk through one bedroom to get to the next. There were 4 double beds in each rooms and each had one bath.) Clear this establishment is not meant for any but male golfers. The owner made a big deal about their restaurant chef and I was introduced to him during my visit. They both talked about how talented the chef was and how delicious the food was. I asked about their hours and was told they would extend their dining hours for our guests if we brought in enough people. The wedding was held in the fall. The guests staying there stayed in rooms that had scraps lumber in the closets, some closets unfinished, no hangers, one guests sink faucet was hanging loose. One guest said the cabinets were dirty as well as the refrigerator. One guest room had no heat. One room's only tv was in a hallway with no room to sit and required you stand in the hallway to view the screen. I am sure there were more issues but we were spared so we could enjoy the reason we were all there. The wonderful food they advertised was nonexistent. They were getting ready to close for the season so the food supply was negligible. I believe they had told guests they were going to bring in some pork to make barbecue but they did not follow through with that promise. When the manager was approached he got very defensive and claimed I had approved every room during my visit which was untrue as I had viewed three total rooms and had only looked into the clubhouse suites because I was trying to figure out who would be comfortable staying there with their rooms wide open and the front bedroom used as an entrance to the second room. He was dismissive to the guests who approached him over the issues I was aware of. The guests staying there described it as similar to a motel featured in the tv show Schitt's Creek if you are familiar. I understand most people who stay there are men and play golf there in the warmer months. The rooms are laid out to accommodate many people in each room. They may not have the same expectations. This is not a RESORT!!!! A resort is a self-contained commercial establishment--such as a hotel, beach, or ski destination--that provides lodging, food, entertainment, and recreation for vacationers It was definitely a rip off for the guests and humiliating for us to have promoted their accommodations. If you are planning a wedding nearby just food for thought. Maybe they'll clean things up but this was a nightmare for us.

    Photos
    Island Green Resort and Golf Club
    Island Green Resort and Golf Club
    Island Green Resort and Golf Club

    See all

    Gobbler's Knob Golf - golf - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...