OK. I know what you're thinking, that this place looks crazy and like it isn't even open if you…read morewere to walk up to it on the street. But don't be fooled! It's a hidden treasure chest for all gamers! If you can look past the ongoing clutter, dust, and random items thrown about, you're in for a treat. I consider myself to be a big vintage gamer. So, I like hunting for anything that is hard to find and that will bring a nostalgia from my childhood. When I was visiting Celina, I didn't know what to expect but just wanted to check this place out to see what they had. They had more than any other gaming store I've seen for SNES, NES; there were even Sega Genesis games strewn about. Controllers, memory cards, old consoles, games that you thought you'd never see again. Honestly, I will look here again for anything that I am searching for in the future. The owner was very helpful. Normally, I have to look online for old games and hope that they work by the time they reach me in the mail. But now, I will call this place first to see if they have a game in stock...even if it means traveling a couple of hours. Apart from video games, the store carries retro board games, toys, and DVDs/VHSes. So, if you're looking for that old holiday Barbie from 1992 that your parents never got you, chances are that it could be here. Or if you want to watch the entire "Friends" series on VHS, look no further.

We used to check this place out quite a bit but once the board game guys moved out we realized they…read morewere the super friendly employees we had mentioned before. They have a cool selection of pinball machines to play but you can easily go through money faster than you'd hope.

We were in Lima for a cross country meet. After we "dined" at, naturally, Kewpee's, I, naturally,…read moresearched yelp for "arcade." Cartridge Gaming was a fantastic and unexpected find. This business started out by selling old and used cartridges for almost every (major) gaming console ever made. The owner has an enormous, almost unbelievable, selection of games you played, games you wish you had played, and some games that you've probably never heard of. What a trip down memory lane. Yeah, the owner had a nice little business selling game an outstanding variety of game console cartridges...and then he got bit by the pinball bug. So, in his store, he has 24 pinball machines, three cabaret style machines (Galaga, Centipede, Ms.Pac Man), two multigame machines (an iCade 60 gamer, and another that features about 100? vertical scrolling Japanese "maniac shooters..." if those are your thing. There's a Crazy Taxi game, too). The pins range in price from 12.5 cents per play (two credits for a quarter, arithmetic wiz), to a buck per play. Here's the key...every game that I played was in good or excellent condition! What an cool variety of games, he has. Newest game? Jurassic Park (2019) by Stern. Flagship game? Dialed In (2017) Limited Edition by Jersey Jack; that's a $9000 dollar machine. Mike P's favorite game? FirePower (1980) by Williams...25 cents per play...just like the machine at Little Cesar's Pizza on Suder Avenue...back in 1980. For an added bonus, ask him to see the collection of video game consoles and microcomputer stuff that he has in his back room. Another trip down memory lane. When in Lima, stop by...after Kewpee's.

I love the two main guys that work here. They are so nice & respectful I don't feel safe in Muncie…read morein many places. But here I do, I can relax and just look through film. It's always so chill. I don't like how they have had to shove everything together now. I know movies compared to games is not where they make their money. Now it takes a little longer cause I try to go twice a week. To check for anything new. So I could look fast & then head out if needed. But I get it it's not a big deal. Love this place and the employees!

Dave's Video Exchange was recommended to us by a family member. Some parts of the selection were…read moredeep, others a bit scattered. A solid store for your retro needs. Video selection looked expansive, though we weren't there for that. We will return when in the area.

If a teenage boy declares that this is his "favorite shop in Indianapolis," that means a lot. If he…read morealso says that he could spend all day in your shop and not get bored, you probably have something good going. It's hard to impress teenage boys. I'm not a teenage boy (as far as you know), but I also think Disc Replay is quite neat. It has an amazing collection of used video games for a variety of platforms, like Xbox, Playstation, Nintendo Switch, Nintendo DS, Gameboy, Wii, and even games for systems that old heads like me were brought up on, like the original Nintendo, Super Nintendo and Sega Genesis. The prices for these used games are suuuuuper good. Like, I was seeing price tags with $1.99 and $3.99 on them. We picked up a Plants vs. Zombies Nintendo DS game for $14.99, which according to my kid was a good price for a game he really wanted. They sell everything from refurbished Meta Quest VR headsets to Tamagotchi, which I didn't even know kids played still! Wow! A blast from the past. That's another thing: If you're a person of a certain age and you want to wax nostalgic about your middle school/high school years to the teenager you brought with you, visit Disc Replay. In the back of the store are aisles and aisles of used DVDs and Blu-Ray movies. My teenager asked me if this is what Blockbuster used to look like. Bless his heart. I said no and patiently described the wonder that was Blockbuster. Kids today just won't ever know; it's a dang shame. But thankfully, physical media is still a thing, and if you want to pick up a DVD copy of You Don't Mess with the Zohan, you can do that here. The people who work at Disc Replay are friendly and know their stuff. They answered our questions, and you can tell they don't only sell video games and movies, but they partake in this culture, too.

This place sucks! I would never go back. Went to trade in some old controllers told me wait time…read morewould be 3 hrs so I left them. When they call me saying my items are ready tell me that if I can't make it there before close, I forfeit the items. This should've been made clear before I dropped the items off. Once I arrive, they tell me we can't take these controllers because of XYZ. Something that very easily could've been communicated over the phone and would've held no issue picking up at a later time. Very poor managed with very poor communication. I've also had friends experience similar issues at the store would not recommend to anyone.

Good prices and great staff. Spencer helped me out with my order and gave some of the best customer…read moreservice out there. 10/10

Cool atmosphere with great prices. Wide selection of all generations of games. Great attentive…read moreservice and helpful staff. My family can't wait to come back here!