My experience with Five Valleys Urology was very positive. After the initial consultation and review of my condition, I felt the Doctor was thorough in his diagnosis and on explaining my options. I choose to postpone surgery initially and had a follow-up exam four months later. At that appointment I decided to have the procedure scheduled. Thankfully I was able to have the surgery done within a week! I was very pleased with my surgeon, Dr. Wicher, who explained everything to me and answered all my questions. I would not hesitate to recommend Five Valleys based on my experience. read more

I am a retired attorney wit 30 years of experience. I have been Amicus Curiae in the Supreme Court on One of The major civil rights case in the United States Supreme Court, . FARMER v. BRENNAN, 1993 U.S. S. Ct. Briefs LEXIS 506, Counsel JEFFREY T. RENZ, Acting Director, Montana Defender Project, School of Law, University of Montana, Missoula, Montana 59812, (406) 243-4823, Of Counsel: Elizabeth Honaker, Kirk Krutilla I have also won cases in the Montana Supreme Court. Recently I went to Five Valley Urology in Missoula. I was set up for radiation. I had to figure details out for myself but that was okay. I needed a PSA as a follow up. Because I did not want to rely totally on Five Valleys I asked my physician for a PSA. She told me I could not get one because I was in the care of Five Valley. I said okay and followed their directions to get my PSA with Five Valley. When I followed their instructions those involved said they had never heard of me, checked their hospital records and said nothing existed. I called them and asked them "What the Fuck is going on". The person who I talked to was very offended that I said "Fuck". At that time I felt if people dying of cancer was not a priority and saying the word "Fuck" was a priority, I wanted to go through somewhere I could get a PSA so I told them to cancel all appointments and got a new primary physician so I could get a PSA. Later I got a notice that I had an appointment June 25th. I responded I cancelled all appointments and was perusing my own PSA. They responded that I could not do that because I was "under their care" I responded I did not want to be under their care and to cease this as I wanted a PSA. They sent me to John Conner their CEO. I tried to explain the problem but he talked over me. I put down the phone. He said I know you are there. I told him I would talk to him if he did not talk over me. He would not let me terminate care. He said something was wrong with me because I was angry. I told him "you would be angry too if you had cancer and people were sabotaging your ability to get care. He said there was something wrong with me because I would not discuss it with him. I told him to cut the bullshit and hang up. As I research I find this kind of behavior just might be habitual. (I will work on verifying this some more.) This violates The Right of Individual Privacy (Article II, Section 10, Montana's 1972 Constitution contains an explicit, standalone privacy clause: "The right of individual privacy is essential to the well-being of a free society and shall not be infringed without the showing of a compelling state interest." The Montana Supreme Court has consistently interpreted this text as a sweeping protection of personal and bodily autonomy. Under Montana case law, this clause shields an individual's right to make fundamental medical decisions, control their own body, and protect their physical integrity from government intrusion. I will be going to go through court to get an injunction against them so they cannot deprive me of getting a PSA. Talking to them does not seem to work. I do notknow if this type of behavoir bothers you. read more

I was seen by Dr Westenfelder yesterday and I found him to be kind, explaining everything to me very well and laid out his plan for diagnosing my problem. Even though it was earlier in the day I never felt rushed and he answered all of my questions. I feel fortunate to have him available. read more

What an amazing office of skilled and dedicated people. The office runs like clockwork from the minute you walk through the front door till you leave. EVERYONE has been helpful, kind and informative. Dr. Reynolds was our initial Physician from an ER visit. Nicole saw us through our first office visit. Melissa, mostly, and Shelby when she was out scheduled surgeries, supplied us with information and LISTENED. Calling with concerns were answered with "we can see you in an hour." I apologize for not knowing the employees from that visit but they answered our concerns and we left the office feeling "taken care of." Dr. Redshaw performed surgeries and like clockwork called me to let me know surgery was complete and the outcome. We couldn't ask for better medical care! If you are wavering on this office, DON'T!!! Schedule your appointment. My husband's day surgeries were performed at St Pats. The RNs and CNAs were there for whatever he needed. read more

My husband was treated very well and everyone treated us kindly. Hard to tell yet if the treatment will work but it was worth trying and we appreciated the positivity and honesty they showed us. read more

I felt a little rushed towards the end of my appointment, did not get clear answers to all of my questions and felt too uncomfortable to ask every question that I had. I received conflicting information between lab results, the urologist's assessment of those results, and my own (and my primary care doctor's) findings. The urologist seemed reluctant to physically inspect that specific issue, instead relying solely on the lab results, despite my concern that my own experience conflicted with those results (this ultimately went unresolved). The urologist was mostly nice, but left me feeling cold (like I did something wrong?) at the end as she was clearly trying to wrap up my appointment and get me out of there. I ended up having to make another appointment with a different urologist in the same building for a separate issue. I left feeling confused and still a little concerned. I was unfortunately not very satisfied with my visit, to be completely honest. I don't know if I will go back for my future appointment or just cancel it now. (This is an alternate/anonymous account as I do not feel comfortable leaving a dissatisfied review under my real name, in case I need/decide to return. This is however genuine feedback from a real, recent patient.) read more

Was seen by Dr Simmons, Feb 24th. Dr told me he would schedule an MRI the following week. It's now March 22nd No MRI scheduled, no following up from Dr Simmions. After I left a complaint, reception called and blamed the MRI company.. Still no Doctor follow up.. I have a very high PSA.. Very unprofessional.. Seeking care elsewhere.. Notice all the poor reviews below.. Terry read more

Westenfelder was rude, belligerent, and condescending. Rather than answer my questions regarding urinary retention, he spent the whole appointment berating me for having chosen a treatment (TULSA) over the ones he is selling! (surgery, chemo and radiation) He blamed my urinary retention (UR) on the TULSA procedure even though I had documented verbally and in writing that the UR had begun two years prior to said procedure and had become acute two months prior to the TULSA. Rather than being interested in my health Westenfelder clearly came to the appointment with his own egotistical agenda. I wouldn't let him treat me if he was the last urologist on the planet. Save yourself the waste of time and go elsewhere. read more

I'd give zero stars if I could. Went to set up a payment months ago and they drew the process out to the point where it was too late to set up said payment plan. Told me it was my fault and now they're sending my family to collections. It's a shame what people do to get paid. read more

They convinced me that prostate implants were my best option for BPH. Having them implanted was excruciating and the results were very minimal improvement. There has to be something better. read more

Originally made an appointment in July of 2023 because of a high PSA test. It is now March of 2024 and I only recently received a diagnosis of prostate cancer. After much waiting between test times and appointments , I only received my diagnosis after calling three times and being left to wait and worry over a weekend. Now they're wanting to change my appointment from March 21st to April 11th. This is the appointment to establish my treatment plan and all the testing will be done by the 21st I don't want special treatment but I do think that when an appointment is made you shouldn't have to wait 20 days for the next one. And this is not the first time I feel like I've just been kind of shoved aside, I'm very concerned and can't seem to get answers without calling multiple times and it's very frightening and frustrating​​​ read more

Dr Karl Westenfelder recently did a procedure for me, and I would like to say that my experience there was outstanding. Dr Westenfelder was instrumental in explaining everything to me at the pre-op, and I felt very comfortable with him doing the procedure. He was very compassionate, and I could tell he wanted to relieve any fears I had of the procedure. I joke around quite a bit, especially to relieve my fears, and it may be hard to read me sometimes, but Dr Wetenfelder is a very good communicator, and he seemed to sense my fear about the upcoming procedure, and that helped to calm me. Dr Karl Westenfelder gets 5 Stars from me, and I highly recommend him as a top notch surgeon. Billy Hower read more

I am a very satisfied patient. The skills and professionalism of my doctor and staff at Five Valleys Urology have successfully cared for me the last few years, and have made it so I can continue a healthy quality life because of them. I am forever grateful. read more

I am a retired aerospace/physician researcher. I have been seeing Dr. Redshaw since 2020, both for what was exceedingly large number of bladder stones and a 300 gm prostate. The stones combined with the prostate were causing severe urinary retention, resulting in surgery. I have followed up with Dr. Redshaw since that time a for the treatment of recurring bladder stones. Five stars are not sufficient to represent the quality of care that I have received from Dr. Redshaw and virtually everyone I have had contact with at the practice. Dr. Redshaw is an outstanding surgeon/physician and I cannot recommend him enough for anyone needing the finest urologist I have ever been too. Before I 'found' Dr. Redshaw I had the unpleasant experience of encountering several other urologists both in Montana and in eastern Idaho. Dr. Redshaw approach to my case was done not only with expertise but also with genuine care and concern. I have never had an issue scheduling an appointment and anytime I have needed to get in touch with either Dr. Redshaw or his assistant Jodet I have always been able to do so. Of note, I had, prior to coming to Five Valley's another cystolotholapaxy done by another urologist. The following morning I was experiencing bladder spasms. I contacted the surgeon who informed me that he was eating breakfast and for me to "please" hurry up before "my food gets cold." Let me say that anytime I have needed to contact a physician after hours I have done so reluctantly as I know how valuable those after hours are, even when one is on call. After the open bladder procedure I had with Dr. Redshaw, the cath plugged up that weekend. I called the doc on call. Within five minutes of contacting the answering service I received a call from Dr. Simmons. It was 0130. He simply could not have been more empathic and caring of the situation I was describing. Again, let me reiterate,EVERYONE I have dealt with at 5Vs has been outstanding. You simply will not find a better surgeon/physician than Jeffrey Redshaw. Both Dr. Redshaw and the 5V group have my highest recommendation. "Thank you." read more

In the room, the dr is great. Once you leave, you will not receive follow up care, even if you literally are in pain and begging for it. The front desk and phone duty nurses do this practice and their patients a serious disservice read more

I have no complaints with the doctors, they were great and thorough with consultations. It's the office staff I have an issue with from being disorganized, rude, not following up with paperwork and leaving out details of which location they set up various procedures. My best suggestion for patients is to follow up yourself and make phones calls to make sure paperwork has been submitted for procedures. read more

The front office staff goes from acting okay to straight out rude in no time flat, and then they make comments about patients behind their back if the patient had any questions/concerns. ​I've never felt so unwelcome in a clinic before in my life as I have here. They also make you come in for extra unnecessary visits if you want something done, because that way they can make more $$$. The doctor was okay, but considering how much you have to deal with the rude front office staff, I'd rather drive down to Bitterroot Health than deal with them again. They also made us "put down/hold" on a credit card 3x what our actual payment will be when it goes through insurance, I've never seen that kind of nonsense before in my personal life or as a medical professional, and then the receptionist was like "you should be prepared to pay the full almost $1k amount up front" in the snottiest tone I've ever heard from an adult. Both me and my husband were floored with that encounter (I checked with him to make sure it wasn't just me). read more

Too much for a single post. Suffice it to say I simply wish there was any "urological" alternatives anywhere within the greater Missoulian area... read more

I have going here for about a year in half the staff I find is great and the nurse Chystal is fantastic And Dr Martain I totally Recommend her. My Daughter was seen by another urologist in the office he treated her in the hospital due to Emergency he was another fantastic doctor I'm sorry I don't know his name he took the time out to talk to my grandson who is also a doctor about his mom my daughter thank you so much five Valley urology read more

My experience with Five Valleys Urology wasn't positive. The front desk employees are very rude and unhelpful. I wasn't able to see a doctor but rather a PA who didn't show any interest or concern with my problem. The assistant over the phone and also the PA were both incredibly unpleasant when it comes to providing medical care. read more

I love this group! They are so kind and professional and respectful. From the check in to the exam to the billing, everyone is so great to work with. Thank you Dr Kronner and crew for all the care! Best place in western Montana for this type of healthcare! Thank you read more

Worst experience with a health care provider in Montana. I was referred to Five Valleys Urology by my principal care physician Dr Elena Furrow due to an enlarged prostate and a high psa level.Humana Gold Plus member in good standing.Have a "updated Medicare Health Insurance card with a Medicare number instead of having SS # on front of card.SS administration has done this to eliminate fraud and identity theft. Have used this card numerous times in network approved health care providers in Montana without any problems.On checking in at front desk i was asked to provide my SS # and pay $ 100.00 prior to being seen by any medical personal.This is illegal and fraudulent on 2 levels. My Humana Gold Card clearly states on front of card,$45.00 co pay for this in network provider referred by my principal care physician who is in network also.Verified this by Humana 1-800-457-4708.SS administration also verified that my card with updated member # was valid and i was not required to provide any additional information. Despite trying to explain this to office personal the illegal extortion attempt continued,The "Office manager who is the rudest,most incompetent,unprofessional person I have ever dealt with in the Medical Industry,explained 5 Valleys Urology was a small business and was not guaranteed payment by Humana, Have had extensive contact with Humana customer service.Humana is unaware of not paying in network approved health care providers.Office manager then stated "I would never receive treatment at 5 Valleys Urology.66 years old,have never received treatment like this.Are patients allowed to question bogus and incorrect billing policies by incompetent Staff ?Does an office manager decide who is to receive medical treatment at this facility,Blatant and illegal Discrimination ! Kevin Kona read more

After calling the urologist's office in Hamilton to inquire about a procedure and being told it was not done there but being advised to call Five Valleys Urology in Missoula, I did so. The person answering the phone demanded to know if I was a patient before I could even get my question out and when I said no, snapped that I would need a referral! She was so rude I thought she was going to hang up on me before I could tell her my question was about finding out first if the procedure was done there and if it was, I would get a referral from my primary doctor. Pause. She would let me talk to a nurse--voice mail. Three hours later, not having received the promised return call, I went through the exact same things again, this time with a return call. No. They did not do the procedure. I thanked the nurse but it was good manners on my part because she just hung up. What an unpleasant experience. I am very glad I do not have to go to Five Valley Urology. They staff I spoke to was rude and far from welcoming. Since then I have talked to others who have had the same experience. Competition would be good for them! read more

I had an emergency kidney stone removal surgery and it just happened to be a urologist from five valleys that was on call that night. I was given no information on the procedure itself that I was receiving, was sent home with no pain medication no antibiotics no instruction. I had a stent left inside me with a string hanging from it that I'm supposed to pull out of my body by myself. I have been in excruciating pain and unable to do anything but move from my bed to the bathroom. Extremely distended abdomen and horrendous burning and cramping. I have called multiple times and left messages and the office staff is extremely flippant as if I'm making up the extent of my pain. The lady who finally called me after I left messages over two days told me "if you absolutely have to, come in and we will pull it out for you." I asked her if they would numb me, she told me "no, we'll just pull it out". And she also told me "you know there's lots of people who even have two stents in, they're really not that bad." Really? How are you going to tell me, that they really aren't that bad, when I am in the most physical discomfort I have ever been in in my entire life and I've had two children naturally and several surgeries from a major motor vehicle accident. This has been the most disrespectful and dismissive experience I have ever had with a medical practice in my life. read more

I'll start with the good part. Doctor Kroner was great. My procedure was fast and easy. When I gave the office my short term disability paperwork to be filled out and returned that's when the difficulties started. I began calling when I hadn't heard anything back and the office staff initially told me they'd call me back when the paperwork was filled out. When I wasn't getting a call back I followed up and was told that all paperwork is done at the end of the day although it had already been more than a day at that time. They said they'd contact me when it was ready. I continued to get no call and began to realize as I was informed very clearly the next week this type of paperwork wasn't a priority for them. When I called the next round I was continually transferred to a nurses voicemail or given a bunch of different reasons why they hadn't completed the paperwork. This included "the doctors are very busy" and "this has to go through office processing before being completed." Basically always something different and clearly I was just getting the runaround. I decided after much of this to start pushing back and explaining that I need to get this paperwork in to get some replacement income coming back. When that didn't work I got angrier which only caused me to get more belligerent comments in return like "your paperwork will not be filled out today" and the like. I left an angry message for the administrator and of course got no response as this was mid day on a Friday. I finally got angry enough with them that they all of a sudden had completed said paperwork that was literally a few check boxes and a signature in record time. I was thankful to have it done so I could send it out and get the process started but as previously stated I got a return call from the administrator John O'Connor the following Monday. He was very nasty, telling me that my paperwork is "not a priority" and "they don't have to fill it out if they don't want." He also threatened not to treat me again in the future per my getting angry with the staff. I think he fails to remember that we are the customer, not them and it was their failures to care and take care of their customers needs within a reasonable amount of time that caused their customer to get pushy. The doctor was good but if you use Five Valleys Urology, fair warning, dealing with the office staff can be a huge headache. read more

I drove from Lakeside, MT to Five Valleys Urology, 220 miles. My appointment started at 2:15pm at the time of check-in I was told they didn't know where Dr. Kevin Kronner was currently, but should be on sight shortly. 3:00pm was passing, they still did not know Dr. Kronner's location, but I was put in exam room 10. About 4:00pm Dr. Karl R. Westenfelder entered exam room 10 and ask if he could fill in for Dr. Kronner. Passing through the reception area I asked if they had located Dr. Kronner, the receptionist said "they had not" read more

If you want an arrogant, condescending and rude doctor this is the place to go. What was worse was the miss-information (lies) told to us.