First Priority Payroll

5.0 (1 review)

Accountants, Payroll Services, Tax Services

Closed • 8:00 am - 11:30 AM, 12:30 pm - 5:00 PM

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Services - First Priority Payroll

Accountants

Payroll services

Audit and conflict resolution support

First Priority Payroll Photos

First Priority Payroll - Accountants Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Add Photo

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - First Priority Payroll

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Cecile V.

13 years ago

Working with First Priority this past year has been an excellent experience. Payroll has always been done quickly, with reports that are clear and accurate. Anytime I had a request or question, I got a response right away. Everyone that I have worked with was amazing, kind, and helpful. I highly recommend them! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about First Priority Payroll

4730 S College Ave
Fort Collins, CO 80526
Directions
(970) 204-9449
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.firstprioritypayroll.com

From the Business

Specialties

We specialize in confidential, timely, custom payrolls that fit your needs and the needs of your business. We are more than happy to adapt to your schedule and work with you to maximize your payroll, as well as make sure your tax payments are paid correctly and on time. We also offer accounting and tax services if you need them.

History

Established in 2001.

FPP was started in 2001 after a payroll company in town sold it's clients and closed. Our associate business received many complaints about ADP, the payroll company most of the clients were sold to. In response, the associate business decided it needed to start a payroll company to satisfy their customers. Thus FPP was created.

Meet the Manager: Debbie S.

Debbie was one of the founders of FPP and has worked in office since the beginning. Before that, she worked for a large bank as a Manager. Now she is available to talk about your payroll needs anytime our office is open.

More Info

Hours

Ask the Community - First Priority Payroll

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Accountants 123 times last month within 20 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Payroll Vault

(1 review)

First time business owner here with a newer company. I needed help moving a 1099 to a W2 and…read moregetting payroll processing set the right way. Payroll Vault delivered. Ashley, Amber, and Lindsey answered every question (and the ones that keep coming up), walked me through setup, withholdings, and pay schedules, and kept me on track with compliance basics. Pricing is reasonable for small businesses. I could not ask for a better first experience. The knowledge and customer experience is amazing. Highly recommend!

From the owner: Local Colorado & Wyoming: You can now focus on your business while our local dedicated expert…read moremanages your human resources, payroll, timekeeping, background checking, worker's compensation, labor law posters & business compliance. What makes us stand out from the rest is our determination to help you succeed combined with our second-to-none customer support & low prices.

Unify Payroll

(1 review)

We've been using Unify for a few years now and have loved the relationship. They are always on top…read moreof things and incredibly responsive. It's great having a relationship for something as critical as payroll just down the street!

From the owner: Unify Payroll is a Colorado payroll service providing small to medium sized businesses with…read moreprofessional and affordable payroll, timekeeping, and human resource services. Locally owned, with our headquarters in the heart of Old Town Fort Collins, we are looking for good, long term partnerships and we are committed to being the best payroll option in Colorado.

Cherry Street Accountants

(8 reviews)

Meredith is a very savvy, easy to work with accountant. We had a sort of emergent issue, she…read moredropped everything and got the situation figured out, which I'm sure took away time from other things she needed to do. We've worked with other accountants; they talked over our head, Meredith makes the entire tax process and as painless as it can be! I would highly recommend Meredith for any complicated return.

We have very complicated tax returns which I used to do myself, until it got way too complicated…read morefor me. Multiple LLC's and K1 partner returns, self employment income and multiple rental properties, are just some of our complexities. Meredith refiled our taxes after one of my mistakes in 2015 and has been doing them ever since. She has given us great advice on how to better handle our accounting and our experience with communication has been very good, she always returns our calls and questions promptly.

Eger CPA

(1 review)

Eger CPA and associates have been with us on our business journey for the past 10 years. They have…read morebeen incredibly responsive, personable and provide high quality professional advice on taxes and accounting.I have also used them for personal financial planning as well. Everyone in the office is very competent and they are easy to communicate with. They treat you as a valued customer and I would highly recommend Eger CPA to businesses as well as individuals!! You will be happy you choose this company to work with you thru the maze of taxes and financial mazes we must navigate.

From the owner: Eger CPA is a full-service accounting firm located in Fort Collins, CO. We specialize in meeting…read morethe financial and business needs of our clients, from entrepreneurs to small businesses. We are dedicated to providing our clients with professional and personalized services. Our goal is to work directly with our clients to decrease their tax obligations, and increase their net worth. We specialize in working with small businesses with their tax planning, bookkeeping, payroll, and financial services. We work with our clients to plan, monitor, and advise throughout the year in order to take advantage of opportunities and avoid costly mistakes.

Accounting Matters

(1 review)

Angela, has helped my above and beyond over the past 3 years. Payroll, PPP loans and more…read more Highest possible review!

From the owner: Located in the heart of the Fort Collins, Accounting Matters is the small business resource for all…read moreindustries and sizes. Our exceptional staff is responsive to provide timely deliverables, allowing you to continue to grow your business and generate revenue vs. doing what we do best...Accounting. SERVICES Accounting Bookkeeping Payroll Tax Financial Reporting Business Registration QuickBooks Support

Sheryl Dryer, CPA

(1 review)

Sheryl is amazing. She saved me over a thousand dollars more than H and R block quoted me on my…read moretaxes. I would definitely recommend using her for all of your tax needs!

From the owner: Tax return preparation, individuals and businesses…read more Certified business valuations, business appraisals for buy sell transactions, divorce, mergers and acquisitions, disputes

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Karen T.

13 years ago

First Priority payroll is a class act organization. They worked to accommodate my needs and are always there to answer my questions when they arise. No more worries about taxes and tax payments. They have made my life so much easier. At tax time all I have to do is to take my reports that I receive from FPP and hand them to my accountant.....so easy. Thanks for doing such a great job taking care of me and my payroll needs. read more

Steve F.

13 years ago

I own Maya Cove Restaurant in Ft.Collins and have used/been approached my most every other payroll service in town. None of them compare to the value and customer service that First Priority provides. They are prompt, friendly,accurate but most of all, easy to work with. They handle EVERYTHING ! I wish all my vendors were as thorough as First Priority Payroll. read more

Meli Z.

13 years ago

I love this payroll company! They are very smart and helpful ladies! I would recommend any small or large business to do their payroll and bookkeeping with them, I think their prices and rates are very reasonable compared to others in town! read more

Noah W.

10 years ago

Great payroll company. I've been using them for many years and they're always accurate and on time with very reasonable fees. Highly recommend! read more

First Priority Payroll - accountants - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Fort Collins, Colorado Things to Do near First Priority Payroll

BEST of Fort Collins, Colorado Coffee near First Priority Payroll

BEST of Fort Collins, Colorado Restaurants near First Priority Payroll

BEST of Fort Collins, Colorado Cpa near First Priority Payroll

BEST of Fort Collins, Colorado Bookkeepers near First Priority Payroll

BEST of Fort Collins, Colorado Payroll Services near First Priority Payroll

BEST of Fort Collins, Colorado Gyms near First Priority Payroll

BEST of Fort Collins, Colorado Delivery near First Priority Payroll

BEST of Fort Collins, Colorado Florists near First Priority Payroll

People found First Priority Payroll by searching for…

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed First Priority Payroll also viewed

Quick Cash and Tax

5.0

(1 review)

Now I don't usually do this but this couple were the nicest and most welcoming people I've come…read moreacross in a while. After having a pretty bad day, I was already dreading having to spend a couple hours after work to go file my taxes. As soon as I got there, the wife kindly welcomed me in to the office where the husband was. They started asking questions about my day, my life, and my background to get a better perspective on how I was going to file. Not even 10 minutes had passed when I already knew my refund amount and estimate on how much it would cost me. The wife was sitting behind the husband (and vice versa) to make sure they would input everything correctly. I was out in less than 45 minutes and couldn't be more thankful. If you're looking for a helpful and stress-free family-owned business (support local) there is no better place!

Soukup Bush & Associates Cpapc

5.0

(1 review)

Amazing, professional, honest and with an incredible personality (and that's the entire staff, not…read morejust the CPA's!!) Keeping up with business tax laws is a challenge and they exceed my expectations. My previous CPA's (and the subsequent ones I interviewed, were lacking integrity and professional approach.) Soukup Bush has been handling our tax needs for the past six years and have done a superior job!

NoCo CPAs

3.7

(3 reviews)

I've been using Leasa's accounting services for the past three years for my small business. She is…read morefriendly, honest, helpful, very knowledgeable and reasonable in fees. Leasa is always timely in completing the filings. I've been disappointed with some CPA's in the past regarding exorbitant charges, dishonest hourly billing and bad tax advice. Not so with Leasa. I trust her completely and I highly recommend her services.

Leasa has been my business and personal accountant for 7 years. She works closely with me to make…read moresure that all my finances are properly tracked and organized and that I am maximizing all available tax breaks. She easy to get a hold of and always has the answers. I have worked with several other accountants in the past and have always had issues. 7 years and so far things have been great! Highly recommend!

InK Tax Service

5.0

(5 reviews)

Have used Irene Day for over 20 years. She and her team are extremely reliable, accurate and fair…read more I cannot say enough good things about them and their services! Highly recommend them!

I highly recommend InK Tax Service. They are thorough, thoughtful, accurate and a pleasure to work…read morewith. I've tried a number of different bookkeeping and accounting services over the years and Kita and Irene are the best!

Grey CPAs

5.0

(2 reviews)

Best accountants I've worked with! Personable, fast, thorough. Taxes can be stressful and Grey CPA…read morehelped to reduce my stress tremendously!!

I've been very pleased working with Forrest at Grey CPAs over the last 6 months for my small…read morebusiness and couldn't be happier with the service. Forrest has been very patient and understanding from the start up phase of the business through the operational phase. He's handling all of my accounting and tax preparation needs and more. He's very knowledgeable, detail orientated and really easy to work with. I'd highly recommend Grey CPAs to anyone.

The Spencer Group

4.8

(5 reviews)

Amy has been so kind and so helpful! She has been fair and full of great ideas to help us. She…read morewants her clients to do well and she wants to protect and help them. I love that she goes out of her way and is passionate about her work. We will hire her again!

Amy is fantastic and very helpful on saving me money wherever possible. Her fees are very…read morereasonable. I will definitely be back next year. Thank you

Squires Insurance Solutions

5.0

(2 reviews)

I been using their services over a year now and I can't not say enough how amazing this company…read moreit's to me. They shop the market for you and this is a great commercial insurance. If you ever have any questions, I'll definitely my to go person it's Chris!

I had a meeting with Chloe yesterday about my car insurance. I have been unhappy with my previous…read moreinsurance plan and price and wanted to switch things up. She was extremely helpful and walked me through the entire process, making sure I was getting the best rates without compromising coverage! I ended up leaving the office with a lower monthly rate, more coverage, and a feeling of relief. Chloe was so friendly and didn't make me feel rushed. I would recommend Squires Insurance Solutions to anyone I know!

Front Range Insurance and Financial

5.0

(1 review)

I was having issues with my homeowners insurance. I was referred to Leo by a friend who is in the…read morehome repair business. He told me Leo handles all his personal and business needs. One of best referrals I ever received. I gave Leo my information and he was off to the races. I will never randomly select any insurance again. Leo does all the research for you in a timely manner and gives you the results. Top Notch!

Harmony Insurance Advisors

5.0

(2 reviews)

We have never worked with a broker and just continued through 800 numbers. We recently decided to…read morework with Harmony. Tania helped us understand our policy and purchase better coverage for less money. We also had an issue with mortgage escrow not paying. She helped us get it all fixed with no lapse or issues. Honestly I am so tired of going through phone banks and menus; it is refreshing to get expert assistance and true customer service. It us so refreshing to have someone who represents the customer not the just the insurance company. My last comment is that she actually helped us after hours and on weekends.

Combed through my policies and not only gave me better coverage but saved me $340 on my annual…read morepremium.

Riverside Insurance

5.0

(1 review)

I have had the pleasure of being in a business group with Julius Luciano, of Riverside Insurance!…read more There have been multiple business partners of mine who have done business with this company, and everyone has been completely satisfied! Listening to Julius speak about his business, one can easily see his integrity and passion with his clients and company! I highly recommend Julius Luciano and Riverside Insurance for all your insurance needs!

First Priority Payroll

Services - First Priority Payroll

First Priority Payroll Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - First Priority Payroll

More info about First Priority Payroll

Ask the Community - First Priority Payroll

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

First Priority Payroll - accountants - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

People found First Priority Payroll by searching for…

Related Searches in Fort Collins, CO

Trending Searches in Fort Collins, CO

Related Cost Guides

Browse Brands

Browse Articles

People who viewed First Priority Payroll also viewed

Quick Cash and Tax

Soukup Bush & Associates Cpapc

NoCo CPAs

InK Tax Service

Grey CPAs

The Spencer Group

Squires Insurance Solutions

Front Range Insurance and Financial

Harmony Insurance Advisors

Riverside Insurance

First Priority Payroll

Services - First Priority Payroll

First Priority Payroll Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - First Priority Payroll

More info about First Priority Payroll

Ask the Community - First Priority Payroll

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

More businesses like First Priority Payroll

4 First Priority Payroll reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

First Priority Payroll - accountants - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

People found First Priority Payroll by searching for…

Related Searches in Fort Collins, CO

Trending Searches in Fort Collins, CO

Related Cost Guides

Browse Brands

Browse Articles

People who viewed First Priority Payroll also viewed

Quick Cash and Tax

Soukup Bush & Associates Cpapc

NoCo CPAs

InK Tax Service

Grey CPAs

The Spencer Group

Squires Insurance Solutions

Front Range Insurance and Financial

Harmony Insurance Advisors

Riverside Insurance