1. Emmalee's Second Time Around

0

Newbury, OH

Cancel

Open app

Search

Emmalee's Second Time Around

4.0 (7 reviews)
Open • 10:00 am - 3:30 pm

Emmalee's Second Time Around Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Emmalee's Second Time Around

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

4 years ago

I love Emmalee's! Always some great finds and the owner is lovely. Found some great Waterford pieces there.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

I have been here many times and can usually find a unique piece for myself or a gift. Worth the visit.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Emmalee's Second Time Around

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Thrift Stores 1,325 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Burton Antiques Market

Burton Antiques Market

1.5(2 reviews)
2.8 mi

2026. Still $10 entrance fee. Kinda of a rip off. If you go at 2p it's $5. Go then. My problem with…read morepaying to get into these types of shows is that you don't know if you're gonna buy. And if you do buy your already $10 in the hole. Not sure it's worth it. Lots of vendors inside the buildings and outside set up. Vintage for sure. Everything from baseball cards, signs, lamps, buttons, Christmas, fall, furniture, and all priced vastly differently. Also have some crafts. Large variety of stuff. Some did smell old. Lots of jewelry. The vendors are informative and know their stuff. But some the prices are way outta hand. They had a crock for $495, very crazy. Those tend to be pricey but that's ridiculous. Who's buying that? Vintage desk type lamps for $450. Maybe I'm wrong and that inline but wow! Easy to navigate. Good bathrooms. Food trucks. Parking is everywhere. I heard it used to be larger. Taking your time to walk through you can do it in about an hour and a half.

After last year's dismal failure we went back in 2025 hoping for an improvement. The weather was…read morebeautiful. The nearby town is quaint. The event charges $10 for admission to a mostly empty fairgrounds. We're not sure what the problem is. Years ago it was packed with vendors. Is it competition from the internet? Too expensive for vendors? Or, is it just bad marketing and organizing? Anyway, we don't plan on going again to this sparse and disappointing event.

Pier & Co Llc Liquidators-Appraisers

Pier & Co Llc Liquidators-Appraisers

2.4(12 reviews)
31.5 mi

When I got to the store there was an older gentleman at the counter working. He immediately seemed…read moreirritated that I was there. He Talked over me every time I tried to talk, not letting me complete one sentence. The best way I can put it is the definition of condescending in its truest form: Behavior or language showing a patronizing, superior attitude, where someone acts as if they are better, more intelligent, or more important than others.

Full disclosure - I grew up around the corner from Michael Press. But while we've known each other…read morefor decades, that only matters because its the reason I went to Mike for an engagement ring in the first place. However, it does not, for a moment, affect this review. Sometime a while back, I knew I was going to propose to my lovely fiance (spoilers! she said yes), and started shopping for a ring. Researched the important factors and started looking around, and while i found a lot of nice rings, nothing that really called to me. It was a frustrating process, culminating in buying what I thought would be the perfect ring online, only to return it. That was probably the lowest moment, and so I took a break in my ring shopping. Fast forward some months later, and I saw someone else from my hometown post photos on social media of a beautiful designer engagement ring from Mike Press, and so I reached out to Mike. I had no idea what I wanted, even after all that shopping, and couldn't have been more nervous. I didn't want to design a custom ring, because I have the imagination of a piece of wood, so I relied on Mike to ask the right questions and pick out a number of options. He was patient, detailed in his explanations of various rings and options, and came up with a number of beautiful suggestions. Nevertheless, I still could not make a decision. I was scared of completely screwing this up. I asked a million questions, then disappeared for weeks while I thought about it, only to come back and ask more questions. Mike never brushed me off or decided I wasn't going to be a sale - he just kept helping me along. In the end, not only did Mike find a beautiful diamond but he held it for me in spite of having other interested parties. Sent me photos, videos, descriptions, etc until I was finally able to pull the trigger. With the perfect diamond, he then suggested what ended up being the perfect setting to go with it. I was so trilled with what he put together that I wasn't even worried about whether or not Melissa would like it. Again, it was perfect. I wish I could find more good things to say. This was an incredibly stressful and nerve wracking process but Mike made it easy in the end. I was glad to give the business to someone I've known my whole life, but even still, was not expecting the kindness, patience, and helpfulness to the degree Mike provided. He bent over backwards to make this easy.

Photos
Pier & Co Llc Liquidators-Appraisers - Mike Press did an amazing job with this ring.

Mike Press did an amazing job with this ring.

Pier & Co Llc Liquidators-Appraisers - Beautiful gate-leg table.

Beautiful gate-leg table.

Pier & Co Llc Liquidators-Appraisers - Antique platform rocker.

See all

Antique platform rocker.

The Marketplace Mall - Inside

The Marketplace Mall

3.6(9 reviews)
5.9 mi

I was out shopping and thrifting in Middlefield so I figured I would check out the Marketplace…read moreMall. Located on Kinsman Road in a former drugstore building you will find an 'antique mall' filled with individual booths. The Mall is overall very clean and bright, most of the booths are well organized and easy to check out. On the downside I found that less then half of the items were antiques or vintage, instead it is a mix of all sorts of items. For me I only saw a couple of items that interested me. Overall the prices seemed high for what was being offered; prices do vary depending on the booth. The vendors and volunteers that were in the Mall were nice and friendly and clearly the vendors care about their booths. I was primarily looking for wood carvings, especially masks so it is always a longshot whether I will find anything, but usually I can find some items that are worth checking out; here the pickings were very slim. Of course your experience can and will vary.

Marketplace Mall is antique hunter's dream located in the Amish Country. The shop combines locally…read moremade goods and antique finds. There are 70 different vendors in this space. I was so impressed with the selection and spent way more time here than historically at other vintage shops. AMBIANCE/INVENTORY: Each vendor essentially has their own themed booth in this space. To be very honest, the amount of inventory is overwhelming. As you navigate through the space, you'll find everything from local jams, furniture, Viking attire, toys, decor, clothing, and seasonal merchandise (Christmas). I would especially visit this space if you're looking to entertain and need plates, tea cups, and so on. Also, if you're looking for a fancy brooch or necklace for your next social event, look no further. I visited for just browsing. I walked out with gorgeous Matryoshka (Russian Doll), a hand-painted Russian egg with a church on it, and crystal-ish egg holder. I paid very reasonable price for these items considering that souvenirs from Russia are scarce right now. This space really offers very unique finds. VALUE: The prices vary. Each seller sets their own prices so they are all over the board. I would say that you can find items within any budget. Most items are well priced for antiques. SERVICE: The vendors work at the shop to help out. Several people approached me to offer help, share stories about the space, and socialize. I found this to be a very friendly environment. I look forward to returning here. If you visit, I recommend allotting extra time for browsing the store and every corner. There are so many hidden gems. The shopkeepers told me that the inventory continuously rotates and expands, so you'll always find something new.

Photos
The Marketplace Mall
The Marketplace Mall
The Marketplace Mall

See all

Emmalee's Second Time Around - thrift_stores - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...